Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Henry VIII was an abusive physco

306 replies

Iwanttoslowdown · 16/12/2022 07:50

And should be taught in school as such.

One of mine is being taught about this tosser in Secondary school history and I was appalled that it was treated with such blasé that he literally was an abuser.

So I had to retell the story not as someone to be revered or remembered well, but that this abuser killed some of his wives including the mother of his daughter Elizabeth I, had serial mistresses, gorged his way through Court like some oversized pimple set to burst and generally Gould not be taught as a good person.

OP posts:
BMW6 · 16/12/2022 14:54

fifteenohfour · 16/12/2022 12:22

A lot of history is glossed over, took me visiting Liverpool slave museum to know that the UK (England) had a slave trade much like the USA's. Was never taught it in history. My pride for the motherland took a nose dive that day and it's never really recovered

Well you had a piss poor education and couldn't have read much off your own bat, watched any TV programmes or seen any films that covered this.

Plus the whole of the UK was involved in the slave trade, certainly NOT just England.

Educate yourself and do something about your bigotry.

DixonD · 16/12/2022 14:51

fifteenohfour · 16/12/2022 12:22

A lot of history is glossed over, took me visiting Liverpool slave museum to know that the UK (England) had a slave trade much like the USA's. Was never taught it in history. My pride for the motherland took a nose dive that day and it's never really recovered

How did you not know this? We were taught this at school in the 90s. It certainly wasn’t glossed over and I can very vividly recall the description of those horrible slave ships.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 14:48

LadyEloise1 · 16/12/2022 13:41

Elizabeth 1, though fondly remembered on this thread, is not held in the same esteem in Ireland.
Land taken forcibly from the people and given to the likes ofSir Walter Raleigh.
Plus the persecution of a Catholic majority population.

I don't "get" either her staying unmarried and without a direct heir.
Perhaps she knew she couldn't have children ?

How can you not get it?

Her father beheaded her mother. Liz 1 was only 3. Can you not imagine the trauma, the horror, the association of marriage with death?

She dodged marriage proposals before ascending to the crown as part of dodging all the plots that hatched around her, with or without her knowledge. Allying herself in marriage to a single noble house would have blown the protection that her single status gave her - she could claim total neutrality to all noble houses, & total loyalty to the crown.

Once on the throne, much the same reasoning applied. Nobody wanted her to marry a foreign prince, as this would have been seen as handing the crown to external powers. She didn't want to marry an english noble, because what would then stop her from accidentally falling downstairs, & him taking over - as all the men at court felt was 'natural'?

TL:DR - she remained single to preserve her life.

crosstalk · 16/12/2022 14:47

H8 was certainly opportunistic. He argued against the Protestant heresies in a well publicised pamphlet which gained him from the Pope the title of Defender of the Faith which is still used on our coins (Fid.Def). He then switches for the sake of a new chance at a male heir. To say nothing of the fabulous abbeys and monasteries which could be sacked. Some were definitely corrupt but a source of medicine, education, hospitality and work for local people.

As for previous kings and the odd queen not being as cruel? William 1 took a major expedition to harry the north setting major cities and towns back and causing starvation. The battle between Stephen and Matilda weakened the whole country. The crusades were a nightmare for the average family. To say nothing of the Wars of the Roses.

There were IMHO four Tudor Kings before H8 (if you don't count H4 as parts 1 and 2 - small joke). H4 effectively stole the state of England and Wales; H5 pursued successful wars which impoverished England; H6 didn't last long. The only savvy one appears to have been H7 who tried to restore the English treasury but no dount did so with connivance and repression.

TheGuv1982 · 16/12/2022 14:46

crumpet · 16/12/2022 07:53

There is a suggestion that a major accident during a jousting contest affected his personality/decision making

Yeah, leg ulcers so bad you could smell him before he entered a room.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/12/2022 14:45

I imagine they also glossed over her involvement in her (utter twat) husbands murder and then marrying the chief suspect .....🙄

Isn't her collaboration in Darnley's murder still a matter of debate? I know Antonia Fraser doesn't think she was involved but Fraser's a Catholic writer. I incline to the idea that Darnley was dangerously unstable politically and a few people would have liked him removed to get control of the Queen - notably Bothwell.

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 16/12/2022 14:42

BMW6 · 16/12/2022 14:33

Not to mention his paternal grandmother Margaret Beaufort who was married aged 12 and gave birth to Henry vii at only 13.

Funnily enough that was her only pregnancy despite 3 marriages.

Margaret Beaufort was considered small for a 13 year old and undoubtedly the birth left her with injuries so bad she was no longer able to carry a child.

I believe most deaths of teenage girls were due to childbirth at that time.

loislovesstewie · 16/12/2022 14:42

BTW I am astonished that some posters don't seem to know much history. Either the teaching of the subject has gone down hill or my school history teacher was particularly good. He was very good actually, but I can still recall being taught about the slave trade, the whole sorry mess of Ireland, the Civil War etc. He was indescribably strict, but I liked him.

BMW6 · 16/12/2022 14:42

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 16/12/2022 13:47

At my Catholic school, Mary, Queen of Scots was presented to us as a tragic heroine and Elizabeth, a bit of a cow.

Well yes, I imagine they did as Mary was a staunch Catholic and wanted to take "heretic" Elizabeth's throne even if she had to have her killed to get it!

I imimagine they also glossed over her involvement in her (utter twat) husbands murder and then marrying the chief suspect .....🙄

Testina · 16/12/2022 14:40

Chuckle94 · 16/12/2022 14:01

He also had an illegitimate son with a 14 or 15 year old girl when he was 23.
A paedophile by todays standards but was considered normal back then

Today’s standards?
People gleefully follow the Radfords today - and she was pregnant at 13 to him as an 18 year old.
Haven’t moved that far forward in 500 years.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/12/2022 14:39

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 16/12/2022 14:36

There’s a moment on The Last Leg when they’re discussing Weinstein and one of the guests says - “Who would have thought that notorious Hollywood shit Harvey Weinstein had a dark side?” and I do feel that this is where the OP seems to be on this subject - like it’s a revelation that Henry VIII was like this!

Indeed. Executed two wives, numerous courtiers, thousands of monks, dispossessed thousands more, burned religious opponents, overturned the national religion of the previous 1,500 years; instituted the greatest acts of cultural, religious and political vandalism this country has known - there is a bit of a pattern there.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/12/2022 14:36

Another monarch would have had her executed after the Northern Rebellion

The 16c had an ongoing debate about whether it was justified to remove an unjust and tyrannical ruler. I think one of the reasons Elizabeth was so unwilling to execute Mary was that Mary was not just her cousin and had come to Elizabeth for protection but was, like her, an anointed sovereign; and if she could justify executing Mary, someone else could justify executing Elizabeth. Something that was given extra resonance after the murder of William the Silent in 1584.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 16/12/2022 14:36

There’s a moment on The Last Leg when they’re discussing Weinstein and one of the guests says - “Who would have thought that notorious Hollywood shit Harvey Weinstein had a dark side?” and I do feel that this is where the OP seems to be on this subject - like it’s a revelation that Henry VIII was like this!

BMW6 · 16/12/2022 14:33

Chuckle94 · 16/12/2022 14:01

He also had an illegitimate son with a 14 or 15 year old girl when he was 23.
A paedophile by todays standards but was considered normal back then

Not to mention his paternal grandmother Margaret Beaufort who was married aged 12 and gave birth to Henry vii at only 13.

Funnily enough that was her only pregnancy despite 3 marriages.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/12/2022 14:31

Testina · 16/12/2022 14:22

OP didn’t bother coming back then?
Shame - I’d like to know where she ever saw him taught as a good man!

Lousy father, murderous husband...oh wait, the founder of the English Navy and father of Elizabeth I. I suspect the two latter points are why people gave him a pass for a few centuries. You can see what his children thought about him from the fact that none of them gave him the tomb he wanted (the one that Wolsey had designed for himself).

Dickens had it right - “The plain truth is, that [Henry VIII] was a most intolerable ruffian, a disgrace to human nature, and a blot of blood and grease upon the History of England.”

Nancydrawn · 16/12/2022 14:28

Hobbesmanc · 16/12/2022 08:13

The whole Tudor dynasty was brutal and cruel in a way that surpassed previous royal families. As an example aristocratic women no matter how badly behaved were never executed (occasionally starved to death secretly or poisoned). But with his execution of Ann Boleyn, Henry set a precedent. He went on the murder a teenager (Queen Catherine ), his elderly aunt for no reason other than her bloodline and changed the law on executing insane people to get revenge on a lady in waiting.

His children carried this on. Poor Jane Grey. And Mary of Scotland.

Mary Stuart repeatedly collaborated in plots to have Elizabeth be assassinated, including some where she signed documents by hand.

Another monarch would have had her executed after the Northern Rebellion, about which she probably knew little but Elizabeth, having been in a similar position during Wyatt's Rebellion, held back.

Elizabeth was no saint. She had little problem invading other countries, allowing her government to extract confessions from Jesuits, or throwing Katherine Grey into prison (who, by the way, should have known better).

That said, by the standards of the day, she was not only reasonable but actually reasonably tolerant. Very little torture was allowed in England (one of the reasons there were almost no executions for witchcraft, esp. when compared to the continent); she had a tendency to forgive, if not forget, after a little bit of punishment; and she tended to react to plots against her throne rather than murdering people just for fun. (I'm looking at you, Ivan.)

Testina · 16/12/2022 14:22

OP didn’t bother coming back then?
Shame - I’d like to know where she ever saw him taught as a good man!

TheRedLip · 16/12/2022 14:21

ShandaLear · 16/12/2022 07:55

He invented a whole new made up religion just because he wanted a divorce. And that religion is now the official religion of England. Bonkers.

Er, he really

2bazookas · 16/12/2022 14:21

Let's hope your childrens' school teaches them how to spell.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/12/2022 14:15

Plus the amount of miscarriages and early deaths poor Catherine of Aragon went through. Life must have been brutal

There is a theory that Catherine may have been anorexic due to her religious fasting, and that caused her not to be able to carry babies to term.

www.historyextra.com/period/tudor/queen-katherine-catherine-aragon-what-happened-henry-viii-wife-death-pregnancy-children-divorce-facts-spanish-princess-daughter/

Bellaboo01 · 16/12/2022 14:10

Iwanttoslowdown · 16/12/2022 07:50

And should be taught in school as such.

One of mine is being taught about this tosser in Secondary school history and I was appalled that it was treated with such blasé that he literally was an abuser.

So I had to retell the story not as someone to be revered or remembered well, but that this abuser killed some of his wives including the mother of his daughter Elizabeth I, had serial mistresses, gorged his way through Court like some oversized pimple set to burst and generally Gould not be taught as a good person.

Yes of course he was. Was this even a question?

BUT, it happened and history should be recognised and not 'glossed over' just because it is awful. He killed his wives etc etc so i dont think anyone would be saying he is a kind man but, dreadful things that have happened in the past need to still be spoken about!

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 16/12/2022 14:10

And the fact that Mary’s execution was botched must have been even more haunting for Elizabeth.

LizzieW1969 · 16/12/2022 14:08

lokss · 16/12/2022 13:56

Yeah, she put up with years of threats! And Mary had plenty of warning. Still persisted

She had to go.

She had to be pushed into executing Mary by Walsingham by all accounts. She really didn’t want to make that final decision. Because she knew that Philip of Spain would use it as his excuse to invade England. (Which he did, the Armada took place the following year.)

It wasn’t about her not wanting Mary to die, though. She wanted Sir Amyas Paulet, Mary’s jailer, to murder her secretly but he refused to do it. So she was forced into a public execution.

But Mary had plotted her death, too. One of them was always going to kill the other because they both considered themselves the rightful Queen of England.

SizzlestheSausageDog · 16/12/2022 14:07

Well this has led me down an internet rabbit hole. Started off with prince Arthur and what killed him meaning Henry took his place (English sweating sickness, which mysteriously vanished a few decades later and has never been seen again!?) And poor Edward VI who also died at 15 probably because of TB. The mortality rates were awful back then. Plus the amount of miscarriages and early deaths poor Catherine of Aragon went through. Life must have been brutal.

SaveMeCheezus · 16/12/2022 14:07

arethereanyleftatall · 16/12/2022 07:52

Well yes, clearly he was. But I've never heard anyone suggest he wasn't.

Same. I've never thought of him as being anything other than a murderous serial shagger and gluttonous pig.