Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Henry VIII was an abusive physco

306 replies

Iwanttoslowdown · 16/12/2022 07:50

And should be taught in school as such.

One of mine is being taught about this tosser in Secondary school history and I was appalled that it was treated with such blasé that he literally was an abuser.

So I had to retell the story not as someone to be revered or remembered well, but that this abuser killed some of his wives including the mother of his daughter Elizabeth I, had serial mistresses, gorged his way through Court like some oversized pimple set to burst and generally Gould not be taught as a good person.

OP posts:
Newlifestartingatlast · 16/12/2022 21:29

lokss · 16/12/2022 08:22

He gave us Elizabeth I 😍

Whist I admire Liz 1 immensely ..she had one of the most brutal and efficient/effective secret services. It is recognised as the first proper institutionalised secret service in the world. Even down to the 007 which was her most famous spies John Dee insignia (Fleming got his idea from it) It’s main purpose Was to literally wipe out a whole religion (catholic) and she and her advisors were determined to do that at any cost including killing Mary of Scotland . This region of terror, for many people, continued for 40 years of her reign . About 1000 were executed , and many more tortured or died from torture

that aside, I often wonder what we would know about Liz 1 if she had married - I think her decision to not marry marks her out as a brilliant strategist and not some thwarted schoolgirl who missed out on love that is depicted as at times. I think it was a calculated strategy she saw would give her chance to reign for a long time rather than be usurped/beheaded by a more powerful husband or son. She only had to look at Mary of scotland to see what getting married did to you.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 21:16

bellac11 · 16/12/2022 21:11

I do wonder if people on threads like this know anything at all about history

So you think Henry 8th is like a serial killer?

The 'killings' were done in the name of treason. The same reason for most executions by monarchs over all time.

So what do you make of all the previous monarchs to him?

See post at 21:11, which doubles up as a response here too.

You're right about H8 behaving no differently from other monarchs.
"In the name of treason" isn't accurate though.
Most historians agree that eg Anne Boleyn was fitted up, as was her brother.
Ooops - sorry - unless that's what you were implying by "in the name of treason?" - ie a trumped-up charge?

& many of Henry's victims were high in his esteem before he weathervaned on them according to current rumour or political expediency.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 21:11

He wasn’t unusual at all for a monarch or aristo of the times. He was just much more in the public eye.

Don't disagree @Onnabugeisha
Psychopathy was celebrated in those times - so long as it was directed at preserving the nobility's entitlement to gather wealth, resource hoard, preserve generational privilege through primogeniture, & keep the peasantry tugging its forelock.

bellac11 · 16/12/2022 21:11

I do wonder if people on threads like this know anything at all about history

So you think Henry 8th is like a serial killer?

The 'killings' were done in the name of treason. The same reason for most executions by monarchs over all time.

So what do you make of all the previous monarchs to him?

Onnabugeisha · 16/12/2022 21:06

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 21:04

Some of these posts are quite funny, it’s like you’re talking about a serial killer.

You are so funny. He WAS a serial killer.
You surely haven't forgotten all the beheadings, & burnings, or the random executions of people who he decided were now inconvenient, no longer useful, or annoying?

Saying he was easily influenced doesn't get him off!

So was Bloody Mary……

He wasn’t unusual at all for a monarch or aristo of the times. He was just much more in the public eye.

HowVeryLikeSibella · 16/12/2022 21:06

Ladysodor · 16/12/2022 20:52

Some of these posts are quite funny, it’s like you’re talking about a serial killer. He was a very athletic, popular and handsome young man. His father was considered tight fisted but when he came to the throne he created a more ‘fun’ court. His problem was that he was influenced by the people around him, once a negative thought was placed in his head he became obsessed. The jousting accident caused him years of illness and further clouded his judgment. Henry did indeed turn into a tyrannical bully but he was not always like that.

And Idi Amin served with distinction in the UK and Ugandan armies, before coming to power, as well as being an accomplished amateur sportsman. How many people do you have to have killed before you qualify as a serial killer?

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 21:05

Henry did indeed turn into a tyrannical bully but he was not always like that.

Harold Shipman killed hundreds of patients - but he wasn't always like that.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 21:04

Some of these posts are quite funny, it’s like you’re talking about a serial killer.

You are so funny. He WAS a serial killer.
You surely haven't forgotten all the beheadings, & burnings, or the random executions of people who he decided were now inconvenient, no longer useful, or annoying?

Saying he was easily influenced doesn't get him off!

Onnabugeisha · 16/12/2022 21:02

Iwanttoslowdown · 16/12/2022 07:50

And should be taught in school as such.

One of mine is being taught about this tosser in Secondary school history and I was appalled that it was treated with such blasé that he literally was an abuser.

So I had to retell the story not as someone to be revered or remembered well, but that this abuser killed some of his wives including the mother of his daughter Elizabeth I, had serial mistresses, gorged his way through Court like some oversized pimple set to burst and generally Gould not be taught as a good person.

So just like many other aristocratic men down through history, then.
He wasn’t uniquely monstrous. Men with titles were entitled to sleep around and keep an official mistress or two as well. They were entitled to bump off their wives or banish them to a nunnery or lock them in a castle and let them starve to death or die of disease. Abuse was considered correction. It’s blasé because it was common, it’s why he didn’t kill any actual foreign princesses too because it would have started a war. He only had wives who were also English subjects executed.

It would be wrong to treat him like an aberration, he was very much a man of the times. Times which were horrendous for women.

BorisJohnsonsHair · 16/12/2022 20:55

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 16/12/2022 10:54

Oh wow, look at you correcting spelling on the internet. Not all heroes wear capes eh. Keep up the stellar work.

You're very welcome.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/12/2022 20:53

Pedallleur · 16/12/2022 20:46

History is written by the victors. Lots on him but he was a king who laid the foundations of the Tudors and everything after. Hindsight after 500 yrs is good. Lucy Worsley prob love him.

That was Henry VII. Lucy Worsley would love to dress up as Henry VIII - in fact she probably already has.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 16/12/2022 20:52

2bazookas · 16/12/2022 14:21

Let's hope your childrens' school teaches them how to spell.

Let's hope your children's school teaches them how to punctuate.

Ladysodor · 16/12/2022 20:52

Some of these posts are quite funny, it’s like you’re talking about a serial killer. He was a very athletic, popular and handsome young man. His father was considered tight fisted but when he came to the throne he created a more ‘fun’ court. His problem was that he was influenced by the people around him, once a negative thought was placed in his head he became obsessed. The jousting accident caused him years of illness and further clouded his judgment. Henry did indeed turn into a tyrannical bully but he was not always like that.

Pedallleur · 16/12/2022 20:46

History is written by the victors. Lots on him but he was a king who laid the foundations of the Tudors and everything after. Hindsight after 500 yrs is good. Lucy Worsley prob love him.

EmpressoftheMundane · 16/12/2022 20:43

Thanks @BeanieTeen , that’s an interesting take.

LadyEloise1 · 16/12/2022 20:32

@Blocked
"..The whole sorry mess that was Ireland." as written by @loislovesstewie

I think what she meant was, because of the Norman invasion by the Welsh Norman, Strongbow and later by Henry11 and his descendants and the confiscation of lands and the awful treatment of the natives, the Penal Laws against the Catholic population and the impact these had on land ownership and division, the Plantations of settlers, the horror of various famines in Ireland ( and food being exported to Britain at the time of the 1845 Great Famine ), Ireland was a sorry mess.

I think children in the UK don't learn much about Irish history and the impact of British colonialism on the country.

Prescottdanni123 · 16/12/2022 20:13

It is part of our history. Schools teach the facts and those are the facts. I doubt any teacher is implying that it is OK to lop your spouse's head off after they annoy you.

LadyEloise1 · 16/12/2022 20:07

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 16/12/2022 13:47

At my Catholic school, Mary, Queen of Scots was presented to us as a tragic heroine and Elizabeth, a bit of a cow.

To paraphrase Mandy Rice Davies
"They would say that wouldn't they."

Ch3wylemon · 16/12/2022 19:58

KettrickenSmiled Sorry. Should have added a spoiler alert

LadyEloise1 · 16/12/2022 19:56

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 16/12/2022 09:54

Let's hope Netflix makes a series about him - then we'll find out the REAL truth.

You are very naughty😀

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/12/2022 19:44

Our Shakespeare was bowdlerised

As was Chaucer - a little row of dots where all the salacious stuff had been taken out. A level English was pretty eye opening in that respect. Although as one teacher pointed out, all the really filthy stuff was so obscure the bowdlerisers didn't get the meaning and left it in.

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 16/12/2022 19:31

Ch3wylemon · 16/12/2022 19:12

An AIBU about Henry the eighth has to be the most mumsnet thing ever.

When he tells you who he is...

😂 So many red flags!

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 19:27

BellePeppa · 16/12/2022 19:12

I learnt it in the 70s as well. My learning of it was nothing like that. It was factual with no ‘agenda’.

I envy you @BellePeppa

Our Shakespeare was bowdlerised, & I don't recall any female authors other than Austen & Bronte. Probably because they were compulsory curriculum.

We were also taught that e.g. the East India Company was pretty much a social enterprise which the 'recipient' countries were fortunate to encounter.

Oh! & the only thing we learned about British involvement in the slave trade was Wilberforce. Hurrah for the liberators!! 😢

This, btw, was a school ranked as one of the top grammars in england.
Shocking, innit.
At least they taught me how to learn ... college was quite a surprise.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 19:20

Ch3wylemon · 16/12/2022 19:12

An AIBU about Henry the eighth has to be the most mumsnet thing ever.

When he tells you who he is...

😂

AND a PP has already popped in to scold us all for discussing him, because "he's not one of your modern day husbands" - it's perfect innit.

Ch3wylemon · 16/12/2022 19:12

An AIBU about Henry the eighth has to be the most mumsnet thing ever.

When he tells you who he is...

Swipe left for the next trending thread