Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Henry VIII was an abusive physco

306 replies

Iwanttoslowdown · 16/12/2022 07:50

And should be taught in school as such.

One of mine is being taught about this tosser in Secondary school history and I was appalled that it was treated with such blasé that he literally was an abuser.

So I had to retell the story not as someone to be revered or remembered well, but that this abuser killed some of his wives including the mother of his daughter Elizabeth I, had serial mistresses, gorged his way through Court like some oversized pimple set to burst and generally Gould not be taught as a good person.

OP posts:
MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 17/12/2022 13:20

Interesting. I wonder who the heir would have been it he didnt survive the injury

It might well have been another war between the supporters of Mary - an adult - and Elizabeth - who was a baby. Support for the Elizabeth/Boleyn group for Elizabeth wasn't a given. Henry's reforms had a lot of opposition in the country and among the aristocracy.

user1471427614 · 17/12/2022 13:17

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 11:07

Nobody said that, you have just invented it.
Historic Kings are pretty much universally "bad people". They have to make terrible decisions, & are essentially there to prop up the system of primogeniture & inherited wealth for noble families.

The PP mentioned - quite correctly - that Henry's personality underwent a marked change due to a head injury sustained in a jousting accident.

It happened in 1536, & is well documented.
He was unconscious for an hour, & all concerned thought he was a goner.
Courtiers were rushing round in a panic - treason to speculate on the King's death, but all needed to be ready to announce the successor if Henry didn't come round.

Many accounts survive of the previous sunny (but still often terrifying) disposition of the beloved young "King Hal" becoming increasingly mercurial, & eventually paranoid, suspicious & hate-fuelled & cruel.

The jousting accident didn't physically disable him - that came later, from an incurable leg ulcer that put paid to his athleticism & sporting lifestyle.

Interesting. I wonder who the heir would have been it he didnt survive the injury

SinnerBoy · 17/12/2022 11:04

Alexander de Pfeffel?

Mirabai · 17/12/2022 10:36

Hobbi · 17/12/2022 10:24

@Mirabai

A nice, simple source for you that explains how he was the founder of the CofE as we usually view it.

www.history.com/.amp/topics/british-history/church-of-england

Another, that supports my point that it was essentially the same as Catholicism, without the pope. It's pedantry to mention the pre/existing Church of England which was a national chapter of Catholicism.

www.britannica.com/topic/Church-of-England

I strongly suggest that you don’t pick up smatterings of history from ‘nice simple sources’ and then attempt patronise people who studied it to postgrad level. 😉

fatsocatso · 17/12/2022 10:26

2bazookas · 16/12/2022 14:21

Let's hope your childrens' school teaches them how to spell.

And yet you haven't apostrophised correctly in your attempted takedown of someone else's imperfect writing. Being unnecessarily unkind just bit you on the bum.

Hobbi · 17/12/2022 10:24

@Mirabai

A nice, simple source for you that explains how he was the founder of the CofE as we usually view it.

www.history.com/.amp/topics/british-history/church-of-england

Another, that supports my point that it was essentially the same as Catholicism, without the pope. It's pedantry to mention the pre/existing Church of England which was a national chapter of Catholicism.

www.britannica.com/topic/Church-of-England

LlynTegid · 17/12/2022 10:20

Interesting to compare the reign of Henry VIII with someone more recent.

Serial mistresses
Large number of deaths by his actions or inactions
Disregard for the established church
Abusive to others

Does that ring any bells? (Clue not a monarch or prince).

Onnabugeisha · 17/12/2022 09:46

SerendipityJane · 17/12/2022 09:26

Whenever I read about Henry VII or the Bourbon kings, I’m horrified at how little women were valued.

Yet England did have "she-wolves" ...www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01db7z8/episodes/guide

Quite, and you’re only seeing how royal/aristocratic women were treated and these were the privileged, elite women. The life of an average woman was much worse.

Onnabugeisha · 17/12/2022 09:44

SerendipityJane · 17/12/2022 09:31

But society was different then, that's what needs explaining.

Was it ? Was it really ?

Anyone who has read any history will be struck not by how different people were, but how similar we are. As a trivial example, despite centuries of clear blue water, Shakespeare is completely comprehensible apart from a few linguistic twiddles possibly.

I find attempts to say "oh we're different now" tend to be the prelude to excusing some ghastly happenings in our own age.

What sort of history have you been reading? Because the people of earlier societies most definitely thought differently than we do now. They were fundamentally different as their value system and world view was incomprehensible compared to today.

Mirabai · 17/12/2022 09:43

PoseyFlump · 17/12/2022 09:39

This! Total madness.

Do people really know so little of history that they think that Henry VIII was actually responsible for creating the CofE?

PoseyFlump · 17/12/2022 09:39

ShandaLear · 16/12/2022 07:55

He invented a whole new made up religion just because he wanted a divorce. And that religion is now the official religion of England. Bonkers.

This! Total madness.

bellac11 · 17/12/2022 09:37

SerendipityJane · 17/12/2022 09:31

But society was different then, that's what needs explaining.

Was it ? Was it really ?

Anyone who has read any history will be struck not by how different people were, but how similar we are. As a trivial example, despite centuries of clear blue water, Shakespeare is completely comprehensible apart from a few linguistic twiddles possibly.

I find attempts to say "oh we're different now" tend to be the prelude to excusing some ghastly happenings in our own age.

People are never different, you can go back further than Shakespeare to literature about 'people' like 1001 nights, Decameron, Canterbury Tales etc to see how human behaviour never really changes,,, but society was different yes

You simply cannot judge historical people by todays cultural and societal expectations and values.

bellac11 · 17/12/2022 09:34

Mirabai · 17/12/2022 09:23

This is an important point and one I take up with romantic purveyors of historical fiction (this does not include Mantel) who imbue women retrospectively with a power they simply did not have at the time. It appeals to contemporary female readers of a certain kind of historical imagination - but it distorts the reality.

Thats not really the full picture either though

At particular points they did have huge power. Catherine of Aragon ran the country for several years in total while Henry was out doing war all over the place.

There have been a number of queens who have essentially either removed their husbands or have stood in for their husbands due to illness etc

It has been a different sort of power and not as visceral as male power, its usually been seen negatively like as if its sinister, or underhand or collusive and destructive in a way that male power isnt (even if it is all those things)

LizzieW1969 · 17/12/2022 09:32

learieonthewildmoor · 17/12/2022 03:41

Whenever I read about Henry VII or the Bourbon kings, I’m horrified at how little women were valued.
Both Katherine of Aragon and Anne had to have Henry’s new love as their lady in waiting. Henry was madly in love with Anne Boleyn for years, then had her killed without even providing a coffin for her.
All of the men who negotiated the following marriages knew he was dangerous but the allure of power, influence and wealth was worth it to them. The Howards offered up two women to him.
Jane Seymour was taking a very big risk which her brothers were tremendously happy for her to do for their benefit.

Henry was different to the other kings because he actively sought to get rid of his wives. He didn’t just settle for affairs and naming a more distant relative heir.

There were no distant male relatives, though, only female. Henry didn’t believe that a woman could rule, hence his obsession with having a son.

I’ve always loved the fact that Elizabeth proved him so wrong.

Arguingtomyright · 17/12/2022 09:32

She said “I know I have the body of a weak and feeble woman, but I have the heart and stomach of a king, and a king of England too,"

Classic NLOG 😂

SerendipityJane · 17/12/2022 09:31

But society was different then, that's what needs explaining.

Was it ? Was it really ?

Anyone who has read any history will be struck not by how different people were, but how similar we are. As a trivial example, despite centuries of clear blue water, Shakespeare is completely comprehensible apart from a few linguistic twiddles possibly.

I find attempts to say "oh we're different now" tend to be the prelude to excusing some ghastly happenings in our own age.

bellac11 · 17/12/2022 09:29

Hobbi · 17/12/2022 09:17

@bellac11
The pope was never the head of state. Henry made himself head of the state religion. He invented the Church of England, which was originally indistinguishable from Catholicism except its head and defender was the monarch, not the pope. It then adopted Protestant principles. Your clumsy attempt to make some sort of Brexit analogy is tenuous and inaccurate.

Brexit analogy, what on earth are you talking about? Why are you making things up, I know its common on this forum but you dont have to join in

In terms of allegiance and who to look to, the pope was above all others, even monarchs, the pope had the ultimate power which is why monarchs had to seek dispensations for things so whether you call that technically a head of state (most european countries at that time were not 'states' as such, or whether you use some other terminology for it) that is essentially what the position was and if you couldnt recognise the monarch as the ultimate power rather than the pope then you're going to get chopped.

People saying he was 'power hungry' just cant seem to relate to the fact that this is not modern times. He didnt have to be 'power hungry' he was the monarch, the head of everything, its not like someone in power today.

SerendipityJane · 17/12/2022 09:26

Whenever I read about Henry VII or the Bourbon kings, I’m horrified at how little women were valued.

Yet England did have "she-wolves" ...www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01db7z8/episodes/guide

RedHelenB · 17/12/2022 09:25

arethereanyleftatall · 16/12/2022 07:52

Well yes, clearly he was. But I've never heard anyone suggest he wasn't.

This. But society was different then, that's what needs explaining.

Mirabai · 17/12/2022 09:23

learieonthewildmoor · 17/12/2022 03:41

Whenever I read about Henry VII or the Bourbon kings, I’m horrified at how little women were valued.
Both Katherine of Aragon and Anne had to have Henry’s new love as their lady in waiting. Henry was madly in love with Anne Boleyn for years, then had her killed without even providing a coffin for her.
All of the men who negotiated the following marriages knew he was dangerous but the allure of power, influence and wealth was worth it to them. The Howards offered up two women to him.
Jane Seymour was taking a very big risk which her brothers were tremendously happy for her to do for their benefit.

Henry was different to the other kings because he actively sought to get rid of his wives. He didn’t just settle for affairs and naming a more distant relative heir.

This is an important point and one I take up with romantic purveyors of historical fiction (this does not include Mantel) who imbue women retrospectively with a power they simply did not have at the time. It appeals to contemporary female readers of a certain kind of historical imagination - but it distorts the reality.

Hobbi · 17/12/2022 09:17

@bellac11
The pope was never the head of state. Henry made himself head of the state religion. He invented the Church of England, which was originally indistinguishable from Catholicism except its head and defender was the monarch, not the pope. It then adopted Protestant principles. Your clumsy attempt to make some sort of Brexit analogy is tenuous and inaccurate.

SerendipityJane · 17/12/2022 09:05

FuckabethFuckor · 16/12/2022 08:06

MN has its finger on the pulse of the most topical issues once again

Well quite.

Except we are still living with the fall out of those days. As anyone who can read a map would know. Brexit vote ? Almost village by village following the split of the civil war that resulted from Henry reign.

And anyone living in Ireland - either part - is living through the legacy of Henrys actions.

Just remember that 80% of the land William the Conqueror Bastard gave away in 1066 remains in the same families he gave them to.

But, hey, "history is bunk" (misquote - well technically a truncated quote. 😀)

Newlifestartingatlast · 17/12/2022 07:39

Onnabugeisha · 16/12/2022 22:16

Elizabeth I wasn’t a feminist 🙄 so not sure how she can be a ‘feminist icon’?

She said “I know I have the body of a weak and feeble woman, but I have the heart and stomach of a king, and a king of England too,"

She thought all other women were weak and feeble…she was special though.

🙄🤦‍♀️ someone doesn’t need to be a feminist themselves to be a icon for feminist

and she was telling men this…as pretty much standard for a lot of women she played down her sex to fit in…this quote was acknowledging she had a weaker body than blokes, says nothing about her views of other women

learieonthewildmoor · 17/12/2022 03:41

Whenever I read about Henry VII or the Bourbon kings, I’m horrified at how little women were valued.
Both Katherine of Aragon and Anne had to have Henry’s new love as their lady in waiting. Henry was madly in love with Anne Boleyn for years, then had her killed without even providing a coffin for her.
All of the men who negotiated the following marriages knew he was dangerous but the allure of power, influence and wealth was worth it to them. The Howards offered up two women to him.
Jane Seymour was taking a very big risk which her brothers were tremendously happy for her to do for their benefit.

Henry was different to the other kings because he actively sought to get rid of his wives. He didn’t just settle for affairs and naming a more distant relative heir.

AccidentalWhippet · 17/12/2022 00:33

He was a power hungry lunatic. Every time I read about him I think this why we need human rights enshrined in law: to protect us from the arbitrary power of the state.

Yes, they absolutely should teach /in secondary) how little value human life has in those days that s monarch could just snip his finger and you ended up on death row.

Swipe left for the next trending thread