Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Henry VIII was an abusive physco

306 replies

Iwanttoslowdown · 16/12/2022 07:50

And should be taught in school as such.

One of mine is being taught about this tosser in Secondary school history and I was appalled that it was treated with such blasé that he literally was an abuser.

So I had to retell the story not as someone to be revered or remembered well, but that this abuser killed some of his wives including the mother of his daughter Elizabeth I, had serial mistresses, gorged his way through Court like some oversized pimple set to burst and generally Gould not be taught as a good person.

OP posts:
Ronbo · 16/12/2022 09:52

This is projecting our current moral standards 500 years into the past.

When Henry VIII was on the throne the Incas were still sacrificing children.

It's worth rembering that we too are destined to be judged harshly by our decendents.

santasbushybeard · 16/12/2022 09:34

ShandaLear · 16/12/2022 07:55

He invented a whole new made up religion just because he wanted a divorce. And that religion is now the official religion of England. Bonkers.

Yes this!

I believe in God but I don’t follow any religion, but CofE is laughable to me because if it’s beginnings (I don’t like any religion, they are all ultimately about control).

BumWeasel · 16/12/2022 09:25

#Toddlerteaplease I find it quite an uncomfortable view to hold because ultimately I'm a feminist and a pacifist but my Dd1 has a very good argument for the fact that things wouldn't change if violence wasn't used. I confess though that it's a long time since I have looked at any of it in great detail and my memory isn't great though, so I don't want to state any beliefs with great conviction.

It's just really interesting how things are spun to fit the desired narrative, like the fact is always glossed over that medical advances wouldn't be where they are today if the Nazis hadn't conducted those hideous experiments on humans.

Henry the Vlll was a odious man, I'm sure, but he is part of our history good, bad and the ugly and I believe it's more beneficial to the future not to pretty up the past, but to teach it and all the unpleasant bits as well. It's the only way we won't repeat the mistakes that have been made.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/12/2022 09:22

However you must view Mary Tudor as tyrannical too. She had no excuse of a jousting accident

Mary I had seen a much beloved mother persecuted and banished, saw the religion that was the centre of their lives changed and its adherents tortured and excecuted. She also lived through the experience of the father she adored persecuting her and demanding she acknowledge him as head of the church instead of the pope and she spend a long time in actual fear of execution. She had no supporters and friends at all who dared speak out for her - the emotional and mental agony she went through in those years must have been extreme, and definitely warped her outlook. Come her accession, she's out for revenge.

In fact, look at the Tudors as a whole and they are definitely an odd and not at all pleasant family. Lady Jane Grey was as much a religious fanatic as Edward VI, she gets sympathy because she was young, didn't want to be queen and was executed for something she wasn't even involved in.

FangsForTheMemory · 16/12/2022 09:17

arethereanyleftatall · 16/12/2022 07:52

Well yes, clearly he was. But I've never heard anyone suggest he wasn't.

Exactly this.

EileenAdler · 16/12/2022 09:16

First of all you have to view him in terms of his own time, you cannot template opinions and standards of 500 years later. Also, bear in mind , that religion and politics were one of the same. Second, in his earlier life he was cultured, educated and charming. That his personally change so much was most probably due to blunt trauma injury to his head, one that very nearly killed him.

However you must view Mary Tudor as tyrannical too. She had no excuse of a jousting accident.

As Hartley said, “ Yesterday is a different country, they do thing differently there”.

RaRaRaspoutine · 16/12/2022 09:12

WOW formatting fail there, sorry!

RaRaRaspoutine · 16/12/2022 09:12

YANBU, his wives were so interesting - yet we get the tired Catherine vs. Anne Boleyn trope with the focus on Henry being the "prize" at the end. All the wives were accomplished and fascinating, and often tragic. As Six the muscial puts it of Catherine Parr:So I sent that letter to my loveGot married to the kingBecame the one who survivedI've told you about my lifeThe final wifeBut why should that storyBe the one I have to sing aboutJust to win? I'm outThat's not my storyThere's so much moreRemember that I was a writerI wrote books and psalms and meditationsFought for female educationSo all my women could independentlyStudy scriptureI even got a woman to paint my pictureWhy can't I tell that story?'Cause in historyI'm fixed as one of sixAnd without himI disappearWe all disappear

latetothefisting · 16/12/2022 09:07

ShandaLear · 16/12/2022 07:55

He invented a whole new made up religion just because he wanted a divorce. And that religion is now the official religion of England. Bonkers.

Well thats a fast way of telling the whole Internet you don't know anything about religion or history....
How can you believe he invented protestantism? Have you not heard of Martin Luther?

GettingStuffed · 16/12/2022 09:05

The problem with Henry VIII is that his reign was very complex. I've studied the Tudors up to degree level and still don't know everything. First of all you need to take some of his behaviours in context of the time. Firstly it was never a requirement that he would be faithful to his wives. Regal weddings at the time were all about forging alliances and producing heirs, so it was expected that he would have numerous mistresses.

secondly the misconception that he changed the country protestant, he didn't . He changed the country from Roman Catholicism to Catholicism.

The worst of his behaviour came after a hunting accident nearly killed him and most probably caused a brain injury as he certainly changed his behaviour after this point.

I could go on but I've probably written too much

vix3rd · 16/12/2022 09:02

Psycho

Toddlerteaplease · 16/12/2022 09:01

@BumWeasel I have the same view on the suffragettes.

Kalasbyxor · 16/12/2022 08:59

Thank goodness for Protestantism and the church reforms brought in under Henry VIII and Cromwell. It served Henry's pursuit of a divorce, but was already a movement in Europe.
Hilary Mantel paraphrasing John Frith:
"The Eucharist is but bread.
Of penance we have no need,
Purgatory is an invention unfounded in Scripture."
Profound and liberating, yet still heretical at the time.

Toddlerteaplease · 16/12/2022 08:58

crumpet · 16/12/2022 07:53

There is a suggestion that a major accident during a jousting contest affected his personality/decision making

Yes. I think he got a frontal lobe Injury.

Pismascrescents · 16/12/2022 08:57

It’s psycho. Anyway back then the “Divine right of Kings” was everything and human rights were not in existence. As a result, nobody cared.

GardenIce · 16/12/2022 08:57

Ivyonafence · 16/12/2022 08:54

Absolutely.

Abusive murdering misogynistic prick.

@Ivyonafence Get off that fence Ivy!

Notellinganyone · 16/12/2022 08:57

BumWeasel · 16/12/2022 08:04

I felt the same when my kids were taught about the Suffragettes. It's all seen as very positive and it can certainly be argued that if they hadn't used violence women wouldn't have gained the right to vote, but it was terrorism, plain and simple. They did some heinous things. I don't think I would object so much if the teaching was a bit more balanced and instead of making heoros/heroines out of these people they at least looked at both sides of the argument. History isn't as black and white as its often portrayed in schools.

Decent History teaching is about teaching students the unreliability of sources and bias and also the contexts within which events happened. It’s not a litany of facts . I suspect OP is not much of a historian or she’d spend her entire life in a permanent state of outrage.

Georgeskitchen · 16/12/2022 08:56

I think you're about 500 years too late with this news OP

Lesserspottedmama · 16/12/2022 08:55

Y7drama · 16/12/2022 07:58

Apparently his son if he’d lived for a long adulthood would have made Henry look like blancmange. Still remember that quote from a level history!

That’s interesting. I wonder what that’s based on as he was just a kid who had been in poor health for a long time and controlled by his uncle surely?

Ivyonafence · 16/12/2022 08:54

Absolutely.

Abusive murdering misogynistic prick.

Needmorelego · 16/12/2022 08:52

I saw the musical Six a couple of weeks ago - absolutely brilliant.
I would say that he was pretty much an arse and tbh that's how it's taught about in education.
He wasn't very nice. I don't think anyone thinks different.

Virginiaplain · 16/12/2022 08:46

Didn't he have a fall from a horse when jousting or similar - which could explain his nasty behaviour.
We have had cruel wars and leaders throughout time - it isn't all kind and considerate now - people just claim it's kind and considerate. Russia v Ukraine anyone? Iran?

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 08:40

FestiveAF · 16/12/2022 07:55

In school they are taught the facts. And those are the facts. I’m not sure they are taught otherwise, but obviously the gory details are spared as they are children not adults and the violence and torture that occurred was not for children to hear about.

The facts? Which version of the 'facts'?

GardenIce · 16/12/2022 08:38

Did anyone else misread the title as
"To think that Harry was an abusive physco"

WhaleInAManger · 16/12/2022 08:38

Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.

I don't think there's ever been an especially nice monarch - though certainly many have been nicer than H8.

Maybe Jane Grey, but virtue of her unexpected inheritance and short tenure.

Swipe left for the next trending thread