Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe H&M because of defamation laws?

388 replies

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 06:11

I've watched the full series on Harry and Meghan.
A few things have struck me.
The most important thing is that there are defamation laws in England. Damage to your reputation is grounds for pursuing such a case. That no such case has yet been initiated by William or Kate, suggests that there is truth in Harry and Meghan's version of events.
Meghan comes across as very vulnerable but very real. She also comes across as very much in love still; as does Harry.
I admire Harry for his decision to leave. I do buy his logic; if the tax payer had even 1% of a contribution to their lives financially, the media could then claim a public interest.
Harry comes across as incredibly intelligent. He has always been touted as the dumb one. He seems to be very much more than some dumb guy.
He adores Meghan and that seems to be reciprocated. She gave him an out.

Harry is very much is mother's son. Diana would have supported Meghan I think. I think they were kindred spirits (Diana and Harry) in a way. Pawns in the game where the king and queen reign...

OP posts:
PrinceHaz · 16/12/2022 10:19

I don’t mind them. They’re very privileged, but privileged people are just as entitled as anyone else to be upset about difficulties they experience.
He seems slightly more intelligent than I expected. Meghan appears to me to be a fundamentally good person. I don’t know of anything proven to suggest she’s not.
I abhor the racism she’s experienced from the press and social media. I’ve regularly looked at the headlines about her over the years she’s been with Harry and been astonished at how the press have got away with it, just endless dog whistling to the lowest common denominator.
And it’s lasted. people keep saying it won’t last. They’ve been proved wrong so far and it’s already been several years.

comedycentral · 16/12/2022 10:17

I'll never believe the press side of the story, they are racist snakes.

Genevieva · 16/12/2022 10:08

No. Defamation is a civil offence not a criminal one. It is dealt with through the civil courts if the victim is minded to bring a prosecution. Such prosecutions are usually lengthy, expensive and provide a valid reason for both sides to present all sorts of unsavoury 'evidence' to defend their case. It is a nasty business and, at the end of it, you get a derisory financial settlement. You can't undo the harm done by the defamatory statements and because of your law suit it will have been in the headlines for a lot longer, instead of becoming yesterday's news. Litigation is time consuming and emotionally exhausting. It should only ever be undertaken when there is no other recourse. Sometimes ignoring people until they run out of steam is the advised option.

LakieLady · 16/12/2022 10:08

RambamThankyouMam · 16/12/2022 06:17

They come across as a pair of over-privileged, attention-seeking wastes of space, to be quite frank.

Just like the rest of the RF then!

Moonpies · 16/12/2022 10:06

Theunamedcat · 16/12/2022 09:46

They take requests they will do what is popular if you watch they are actually interesting and factual not screaming she's a liar Jeremy Kyle style

Please list some of the lies (with receipts) 😆🤯

torquewench · 16/12/2022 10:06

One thing that the Behaviour Panel say stuck a chord with me - the bit along the ones of it being like calling a press conference to say you want more privacy.

Headabovetheparakeet · 16/12/2022 10:05

I felt sorry for Meghan when she was being torn apart in the press, it was racist but I would have had a lot more respect for them if they really had just left to live a quiet life.

So many things in the Netflix show didn't add up for me...

  1. Harry said he was looking for a wife who could do the 'royal' role but apparently never told her what that was. They both seemed to be totally taken by surprise that they would need to go out and meet people, it doesn't make sense. If she really was surprised by it then that's on Harry.
  1. The content on the British slave trade, and Stephen Lawrence. What exactly were they trying to say with this or was it just a potted history of British racism for Americans? Also raised the questions for me of why they would be comfortable accepting money from an institution built on empire.
  1. The 'we just happened to have a photographer there' moments scattered throughout which just made it all feel extremely contrived.
  1. Blaming the press/ Royal Family for the behaviour of Meghan's father. That is entirely on him.
PeaceJoySleep · 16/12/2022 10:04

Sirzy · 16/12/2022 07:14

Families fall out, but that doesn’t mean it needs to be shouted from the rooftops. Whatever has happened you have to question what exactly Harry and Megan are hoping to gain by airing their dirty laundry in public.

A hundred million dollars! my mum slagged me off to all the relatives for FREE. That hurt. I'd nearly rather she'd have done it because she was tempted by an irresistible amount of cash.

Barbudura · 16/12/2022 10:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

worstusernameeverx2 · 16/12/2022 10:00

girlmom21 · 16/12/2022 06:23

They're just destroying every family link they had. The palace haven't responded to anything because they're above that - not because it's untrue.

You'd probably be on another thread telling people to go NC with toxic family.

Isthisreasonable · 16/12/2022 09:58

H&M need to find ways to make money. The way they can make the big bucks is to turn their life into reality tv. So they need dramas to make Netflix pay out. I wouldn't believe very much of it, everything will be exaggerated or invented relying on the theory that the Palace doesn't comment on these sorts of things to get away with their claims.

Reports that they are going to try to build bridges with the family in the new year sounds like planning for season 2 to me. Meghan knows how media works and how to spin something out to keep the revenue coming in.

worstusernameeverx2 · 16/12/2022 09:58

I agree OP. People hate for hatings sake. As if there isn't enough hate and negativity in the world. The same people probably advocate against bullying, such odd behaviour

Morestrangethings · 16/12/2022 09:58

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 16/12/2022 06:28

If you’re doing everything you can to escape the media you don’t create a documentary on Netflix 🤷🏻‍♀️

You do if you want to control your own story. Why let the ruthless, vile tabloids control the narrative? Because they will, if you don’t use your voice.

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2022 09:55

'It must be true because defamation laws' is a gloriously stupid and naive thing to say.

Defamation laws allow people to pursue in court if they wish to, but there's caveats and pitfalls to that too.

  1. Its costly. This is a problem for the Royals image.
    The family spend a lot of effort trying to play down the Royal aspect and pitch a more middle class image to the press as it has wider appeal to the public. In taking on a legal case they would be forced to show wealth. So it's counter productive to their image to bring a case

  2. It invites more press intrusion. This is a problem for the Royals who wish to cultivate a certain image.
    The family control their narrative by pr. If you invite even more scrutiny of private correspondence you 'shatter the mystery' of the Royals. That's their star appeal and the aloofness that makes the Royals. Its self defeating to go down this route even if the Royals did win.

3)Barbara Streisand.
The family understands the effect well. It makes a story bigger than it needed to be. It's a fools errand.

  1. A court case would match the Sussex narrative
    The Sussexes are pushing a line about how they were bullied and silenced by the state and power of the Crown. In taking on a court case in what would be framed a David v Goliath case, the Sussexes can't lose even if they lose the case. Its a good example of 'it doesn't matter what is true, what matters is what people believe'

  2. The no need to do anything approach.
    There may be a feeling that the further the Sussexes push this, the more it will eventually backfire on them if the Windsor maintain a united dignified front and just get on with things. In this way the Sussexes could end up being their own worst enemy as the public get fed up of it.

  3. The historic approach of the Royals of not responding
    The Sussexes were well aware that the family were very unlikely to take to court even if they lied through their teeth.

  4. The burden of proof.
    There is always a danger that there could be an issue with proof in a court case. This is one where its possibly in the eye of the beholder anyway with he said she said simply being misinterpreted. It would be for the Sussexes to prove something but that also involves the family disproving it to an extent too. This isn't necessarily a straightforward case. It's possible both sides utterly believe their own version of events and the evidence could be read in both ways to a degree.

Honestly the Royals would have to be insane to take it on as it could do more harm than good even if they win.

The only conclusion you can draw from the lack of defamation case is that its not in the interests of the Royals to bring one, not that it must mean what the Sussexes say is true.

Stifledlife · 16/12/2022 09:54

At the base of the whole situation, no one blamed them for wanting to step back.. to seek a private life to bring up their children in "peace".
What cheeses everyone off is the constant (and it is constant) bids for attention. They employ a PR company to keep them in the media FFS.
The pseudo royal progress through new york, the photographer "catching" them doing good works or laying flowers in a cemetary. It's all Me me me..

The self seving lies, the half truths and the bits they fail to mention are just plain irritating, and treat the public like villages idiots who should believe what they are told because they are being told it by their betters.

Why is the constant barrage of self produced media content, all with the same theme of victimhood, acceptable.

Filming from their £11m mansion saying how hard their life is, is at best tone deaf and at worst so narcisstic as to require professional help.

I ,for one, would be grateful if they did what the said they would do, and disappear into the sub ether to live their lives away from the glare of the media, and give us some "peace".

..and yes I have watched the netflix doco.. although I admit I had to take several breaks to avoid the onset of diabetes.

BlazinSquaad · 16/12/2022 09:51

NC'd for this. I used to work for Farrer & Co and I don't believe them for the exact reason you do, OP. They've had everything checked by a lawyer (multiple lawyers) with a fine tooth comb to ensure that there's no possible way to be sued for defamation for it but make very clear messages. They've been doing it the whole time - at the Oprah interview with the whole "someone brought up the skin colour of the baby, I don't want to say who but it wasn't X and Y" - that literally translates as "I cannot be sued because I said no name".

It's phrases like "they wanted X" or "they suggested Y" - it's a listeners perspective. If you said to me "pass the napkins please" then you may want to wipe your child's face, but if I said "they wanted to wipe their own face" then it wouldn't be defamation because what I'm saying is my interpretation of what happened and, even though it's incorrect, it's not actually something the other side could prove was and intentional lie. We see this over and over with the H&M interviews. It's never "they said X" or "they did Y" - it's always "wanted/suggested/thought/felt/etc". The only times that it's explicitly saying someone said or did something, they're so vague they couldn't sued - either omitting who said or when they said or what the context was. All these comments of "it wouldn't be fair to go into detail" or "I don't want to name names" are literally "I'm avoiding being specific enough to be sued". On top of that, they know the royal family won't sue them.

Every post, interview answer, video clip etc is all explicitly planned in advance with a lawyer and a marketing team. It's an advertising campaign - none of it is written by H&M themselves (just like how no statements from the royal family are written by them).

I don't know how much of their version I believe but they are absolutely lying on a number of counts - that's a fact and a guarantee.

Anklespraying · 16/12/2022 09:46

Harry could easily have established a successful career whilst being a working family member, many of the others have. If he was actually intelligent something challenging would have appealled to him as a life occupation before now.

Instead he's drifted about aimlessly until this rather shallow woman came along and they are now going full on for a career being famous for being famous. Empty celebrities.

I suppose it's the best he can manage with her. It is her career choice for them both.

Theunamedcat · 16/12/2022 09:46

Moonpies · 16/12/2022 09:27

Also interesting when you check this group's page, how many videos they have about H&M. They obviously make money by fuelling hate. Wonder what that kind of obsession tells you about?

They take requests they will do what is popular if you watch they are actually interesting and factual not screaming she's a liar Jeremy Kyle style

MadameCholetsDirtySecret · 16/12/2022 09:46

Now that religion is no longer the opium of the people, this family are.

We are living through a huge crisis globally. War, famine, poverty, hunger, disease, environmental devastation but the outrage on both sides about the tittle tattle and spats within this family of very little merit, is taking over the media (broadcast and social). It's truly mind blowing.

I have Netflix but no intention of watching it. The sooner we become a republic the better.

Natty13 · 16/12/2022 09:44

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 08:17

They don't need HRH to garner interest. People are interested in them.

Then why haven't they got themselves jobs based on their talents and interests? Why continue to make money off the HRH?

I moved abroad and I also have relatives I don't get on with who go round slagging me off and telling lies about me. I can't empathise with H&M because I would never dream of responding or airing my proof of the lies. I have my life here, my DH and kids here, I'm happy in my job and simply don't care enough to worry what anyone back home is saying about me. I'm their age and I realised long ago that "standing up for myself" or trying to give my side was not going to result in either a peaceful or happy life.

WifeOfEddieMunson · 16/12/2022 09:43

Harry is playing the role of the 'spare' perfectly.

The role of the 'spare' is to create drama & act as a distraction to the heir. This is all done to protect Charles & William as it acts as a distraction from the real question which is how can the UK claim to be a democracy when we have a very real & active royal family?

This tactic has been deployed many times by the royal family over the years.
The fact that they still exist demonstrates it's effectiveness.

The real question is, what else is happening whilst everyone is talking about this nonsense?

GooglyEyeballs · 16/12/2022 09:43

OP sounds extremely star struck and biased. Not sure how anyone can just decide they're sure of what the full story is when we've only heard one side of it.

LightHousePanda · 16/12/2022 09:41

I assume the OP is genuine but saying Harry is intelligent did make me wonder for a second. It does seem like something you'd say and wonder if you've gone too far.

BloodAndFire · 16/12/2022 09:41

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 06:42

I don't get on with my SIL. That doesn't make me a cunt anymore than it makes her a cunt. We simply don't get along.

I suppose, a bit like Meghan, I'm never conformist. I'm more of rebel without a cause in her view.

This is really embarrassing to read on so many levels

LightHousePanda · 16/12/2022 09:39

I'm not a royalist but the royal family are supposed to be above petty squabbles in public although granted they don't always succeed. If someone criticises them they're more likely to stay quiet and deal with it in not such a public way as suing people. Plus, in general suing someone can actually have the opposite effect to what you want. It can create more sensational stories and be damaging even if you win. Saying there must be truth in what H&M are saying because they're not being sued is just silly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread