Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe H&M because of defamation laws?

388 replies

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 06:11

I've watched the full series on Harry and Meghan.
A few things have struck me.
The most important thing is that there are defamation laws in England. Damage to your reputation is grounds for pursuing such a case. That no such case has yet been initiated by William or Kate, suggests that there is truth in Harry and Meghan's version of events.
Meghan comes across as very vulnerable but very real. She also comes across as very much in love still; as does Harry.
I admire Harry for his decision to leave. I do buy his logic; if the tax payer had even 1% of a contribution to their lives financially, the media could then claim a public interest.
Harry comes across as incredibly intelligent. He has always been touted as the dumb one. He seems to be very much more than some dumb guy.
He adores Meghan and that seems to be reciprocated. She gave him an out.

Harry is very much is mother's son. Diana would have supported Meghan I think. I think they were kindred spirits (Diana and Harry) in a way. Pawns in the game where the king and queen reign...

OP posts:
CHRIST0PHERR0BIN · 16/12/2022 11:36

Calling him "Haz" though 😂

Anklespraying · 16/12/2022 11:34

It's absolutely cringe @Thefriendlyone

They more or less said this in the engagement interview. How they were going to transform the monarchy and save it. Only they could. Delusional. If that's how they behaved they will have clashed nonstop with everyone, leading to her misery at people thwarting her ambitions.

marcopront · 16/12/2022 11:33

@Shejustwentthere

You are still yet to give evidence of why you think Harry came across as extremely intelligent.

I'm interested in your opinion on this incident from one of the early episodes.

When he first took Meghan to meet the queen, he gave her little warning. He said jokingly "you do know how to curtsy, don't you?"

Is that the action of an intelligent or empathetic man?

She tells this story and then it cuts to him saying. "How do you explain this to an American?".
He looked like a 6 year old trying to get out of trouble. Definitely not an intelligent man.

Thefriendlyone · 16/12/2022 11:23

She did know who she was marrying, and that is key. She knew exactly who she was marrying and the sort of fame that would bring. The sort of wealth .

harry however fed her vanity , he even says it on the documentary. That she was going to be the star, revitalise the monarchy , which quite frankly was deeply offensive to the queen and the rest of his family.

That some bit part American acresss was going to roll in and save the monarchy and show them the way forward. The last thing the queen needed was Meghan Markle to show her how it was done. And neither did Charles William or Kate, it’s so utterly ludicrous as a concept.

and if anyone notices he bigs her up constantly , how she is beautiful, intelligent,warm loving, the next Diana She doesn’t do it back.

the queen apparently said she wondered if harry wasn’t a bit over in love. And you can see where she was coming from. He doesn’t even cringe when he goes on about her running the monarchy , their greatest asset, the new Diana. and them all being jealous of her.

can anyone in their right minds think that the queen, Phillip, Charles, camilla, William or Kate were sitting there going oh god, we wish we were as good as Meghan , she truly is the new Diana, we are so jealous of her fabulousness?

HappinesDependsOnYou · 16/12/2022 11:13

I don't think defamation laws give any weight to whether they are telling the truth. If Will and Kate took it to court the public would have a right to know more about their private lives, conversations and events. Whether innocent or guilty it wouldn't benefit them only fuel the public scrutiny. I have watched it and have empathy for them. Him as someone who clearly feels they were not given the support he desperately needed as a child and someone who was born into a gilded cage and her as someone whose wings were clipped to be stuffed into a cage and who was then unfairly treated in comparison to Kate. They lost the moral high ground well and truly when they claimed to have married the day before they actually did though. A very quick and simple lie that makes you well and truly question everything said by them

DrManhattan · 16/12/2022 11:12

RambamThankyouMam · 16/12/2022 06:17

They come across as a pair of over-privileged, attention-seeking wastes of space, to be quite frank.

Totally agree. If they want privacy why don't they stop using the royal titles and go away?

Ch3wylemon · 16/12/2022 11:10

Diana would have supported Meghan I think.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Diana had emotional nous.

Mooovingonout · 16/12/2022 10:56

PortiasBiscuit · 16/12/2022 07:14

Meghan, is that you?

Grin
Bogofftosomewherehot · 16/12/2022 10:55

@Shejustwentthere

"Woe betide the man who dates me and expects me to obey some sort of family traditions, in contradiction of who I am fundamentally, when I meet his family! That would the end of that relationship."

I think you're safe!!!
Your posts suggest you don't have to worry about the prospect of marrying into probably the most famous family in the world and having to 'obey' or respect tradition.

The expectation/weight of becoming a senior royal shouldn't have been a shock.

She knew who she was marrying, was happy for the country to foot the bill for that and also complain about the size of H's batchelor pad in one of the most prestigious postcode in the UK whilst waiting for Frogmore Cottage. It's not difficult to google how to curtsey without the dramatised/Disney/Hollywood version (or piss take). Let's not pretend she's an idiot, without access to understanding what she was buying into.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 16/12/2022 10:49

RambamThankyouMam · 16/12/2022 06:17

They come across as a pair of over-privileged, attention-seeking wastes of space, to be quite frank.

Exactly THIS.

hamstersarse · 16/12/2022 10:48

dogmandu · 16/12/2022 09:18

Have you read this assessment of their truthfulness by the American Behaviour Panel (4 people trained in U.S. in interrogation and analysing body language and being able to discern natural facial expressions from 'acting' ) Very interesting

#

I watched a bit of this

I'm sorry, but these guys are projecting massively. It is impossible not to. Oh and also clearly doing this for questionable reasons.

It's hard to take this seriously.

lieselotte · 16/12/2022 10:45

RambamThankyouMam · 16/12/2022 06:17

They come across as a pair of over-privileged, attention-seeking wastes of space, to be quite frank.

I agree. Totally self-indulgent whiners. I wish I had as much to put up with as they do.

I actually liked them before they started lecturing us about the environment and then started using private jets to travel around the place.

Headabovetheparakeet · 16/12/2022 10:44

Genevieva · 16/12/2022 10:36

@Headabovetheparakeet There is a left-wing American narrative that sees Britain and, more specifically England, as the source of all evil in the world and in particular, the source of racism. This is factually incorrect. If you look back at the History of Ideas you discover that the concept of race came to Britain from the United States. I could give you a potted history, but it is a bit long for this sort of forum!

Are you British or American?

AutumnCrow · 16/12/2022 10:44

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 16/12/2022 09:25

And as someone who has suffered a miscarriage, they pissed me off royally when they claimed that was caused by stress.

I'm not surprised. Other posters on MN have made the same point. It's just promulgating a very unhelpful myth.

dogmandu · 16/12/2022 10:43

Moonpies · 16/12/2022 09:27

Also interesting when you check this group's page, how many videos they have about H&M. They obviously make money by fuelling hate. Wonder what that kind of obsession tells you about?

they have videos about a lot of people. I thought at least one of their earlier videos was very supportive of M&H. I haven't watched many of their videos as they are too detailed and long winded, however their credentials are impressive. They know what they are talking about.

Anklespraying · 16/12/2022 10:37

But I thought it was very refreshing to see such honestly about mental suffering and suicidal thoughts.

Really? This is everybody's story in the 2020s!

Thefriendlyone · 16/12/2022 10:36

BlazinSquaad · 16/12/2022 10:27

Keeping in mind everything they say is intentionally vague or scripted to be "not a lie" but implying things that aren't true. It's like if I said "your husband is being unfaithful" then you'd assume from that that I'm saying he's having an affair but, factually speaking, I never said he had an affair. If he sued me for defamation for saying he'd had an affair then I'd just throw my hands up and say "nah, I said "unfaithful", it's my opinion" and the court would rule in my favour. So, they're not so much lies as misleading statements - things that are said that omit necessary information or use leading words to make you think something that isn't true - but that they didn't actually say.

Misleading Statement:
Harry: "But, also, the Netflix and the Spotify, they’re all . . . that was never part of the plan...my family literally cut me off financially, and I had to afford . . . afford security for us...in the first half, the first quarter of 2020. But I’ve got what my mum left me, and, without that, we would not have been able to do this."

However:
"The royal expenditure reports published Thursday reveal that, in the fiscal year beginning of April 2020, he provided both Harry and Prince William’s families with £4.5 million. The report does not break down how much money went to each prince, but a spokesman for Charles at Clarence House clarified that the Prince of Wales had allotted “a substantial sum” to support Harry and Meghan as they transitioned out of their royal roles. “That funding ceased in the summer of last year,” the spokesperson continued. “The couple are now financially independent.”"

What you reasonably believe after Harry's statement:
When Harry and Meghan said they were leaving the Royal Family, his family stopped giving them any money and had to rely on media outlets in order to keep their family safe.

Reality:
Their transition was paid for by the royal family and security and funds were provided for many months after they left the royal family (well beyond the time that they were seeking contracts from media outlets). Their home, safety and lifestyle was ensured by the royal family's funds.

What Harry said is not what most people would consider to be the truth. It is what a lawyer and a marketing team scripted to give the impression he was immediately cut off but, in reality, he wasn't.

When you write these kind of statements for a living, you get pretty good at recognising them.

Well,said. As I wrote earlier, harry and Meghan were never left without security, only the met police protection was being pulled, and for good reason, you couldn’t have met officers in Canada , there was several of them on rotation and it was costing a fortune. Then the Canadian government provided it, but the Canadians kicked off. But even when the Canadian government pulled out, Charles was still paying for their dry heavy private security , so they were misleading. Charles was personally paying in the region of 2musd a year for their private security.

they did the same over Archie’s security before they even left. They said Archie wasn’t getting security. The palace confirmed that babies don’t get met officer security as they are incapable of going places alone. No royal baby got their own met security protection.

so again, it was based in truth, Archie wasn’t getting personal security but totally misleading, as it was the adults with Archie who got the security. And no different to Beatrice and Eugenie when they were kids.

Genevieva · 16/12/2022 10:36

@Headabovetheparakeet There is a left-wing American narrative that sees Britain and, more specifically England, as the source of all evil in the world and in particular, the source of racism. This is factually incorrect. If you look back at the History of Ideas you discover that the concept of race came to Britain from the United States. I could give you a potted history, but it is a bit long for this sort of forum!

Anklespraying · 16/12/2022 10:35

You do if you want to control your own story. Why let the ruthless, vile tabloids control the narrative? Because they will, if you don’t use your voice.

This is quite perplexing. Far more people DON'T read tabloids than do. I have no idea what they said about Meghan as I'm sure is the case for the majority.

So how have they controlled the narrative?
This couple have ignored those who were on their side and wallowed in a futile war with a few gossip sites. It's sad. It's a phoney war.

Nasty gossip is an unfortunate side of humans but we can also not take part, not give it any credence and not fan the flames.

It's a shame they didn't just ignore it and let it fizzle out.

Laiste · 16/12/2022 10:35

This is hillarious.

Couple make a docu. about themselves.

It's biased towards ... guess who?
A: Themselves!

Who'd have thought? I mean - quelle fucking surprise 🙄

And people are taking it all as gospel 🙄

Caneloalvarez · 16/12/2022 10:29

I agree OP. I find the level of hate for H&M really odd. I’ve watched all episodes. Why do people keep mentioning the privacy thing? People change their minds. Maybe when they were in the midst of everything they were desperate for privacy. And now they’ve had some distance they’re like, hang on, we want to tell our side. They’ve lived through very unique experiences and the documentary was interesting, whether you like them or not.

Toxic family is toxic family. You don’t get a pass because you’re royalty. I think a lot of people have the mindset of not making a fuss, especially in the UK. So their way of doing things is ruffling feathers. But I thought it was very refreshing to see such honestly about mental suffering and suicidal thoughts. Oh she’s not sad enough for you? She’s smiling too much, she must have been lying about being suicidal? You only have to read the recent news about DJ tWitch to see that there are NO true indicators that someone is suicidal. It can be extremely well hidden. Yes they’re privileged but money doesn’t make you immune to mental health issues.

I think opening up is their way of taking control. The media will never ever leave them alone so if they share their family moments, at least they’re more in control of what’s out there.

Thefriendlyone · 16/12/2022 10:29

I also think harry and Meghan could have done so much together in role. They really could have been something. Even their own series showed rhe hateful ness shown was limited to a small number of accounts and some limited press articles, overall they received a very positive welcome. The focus has all been on the negativity

however Harry’s desire to outshine his brother and meghans desire to be famous, and his egging her on telling her she was going to lead the British family , her believing him and going for it, has led to their mutual downfall..

I was looking at some images last night, and harry was often the hanger on. He’d tag along with William and Kate, but did very very little solo. Not much other than the invictus games. By comparison. Kate, Sophie, even Beatrice and Eugenie do a lot solo. Harry just didn’t.

the reality is he’s never been big up for doing royal engagements. His military career was his high point.

he clearly has major issues with the fact he was born royal and is supposed to be both grateful for the privilege and repay in terms of service, whilst his brother gets preferential treatment .

Then he met an actress, whose ultimate desire is to be rich and famous.

He looked at her and thought she’d be perfect for the role, a shining media star who could give him equal or not superior status to his brother, who would do all these engagements with him, support him in what was needed, and who would also be his wife and give him kids .

She looked at him and thought he’d make her rich and famous beyond her wildest dreams. And she’s be a princess. Her children royalty. You didn’t get a much faster ticket to global stardom and wealth than that.

They pretty much decided on their second date barely knowing each other that they were in it for thr long haul. Each promising the other what they most wanted.

however what harry promised, was not his to give, she was never going to be the next Diana, the lead role of the Britush royals. So as he couldn’t fullfil his promise, they are in America trying to do it another way and mighty pissed off with it

BlazinSquaad · 16/12/2022 10:27

Moonpies · 16/12/2022 10:06

Please list some of the lies (with receipts) 😆🤯

Keeping in mind everything they say is intentionally vague or scripted to be "not a lie" but implying things that aren't true. It's like if I said "your husband is being unfaithful" then you'd assume from that that I'm saying he's having an affair but, factually speaking, I never said he had an affair. If he sued me for defamation for saying he'd had an affair then I'd just throw my hands up and say "nah, I said "unfaithful", it's my opinion" and the court would rule in my favour. So, they're not so much lies as misleading statements - things that are said that omit necessary information or use leading words to make you think something that isn't true - but that they didn't actually say.

Misleading Statement:
Harry: "But, also, the Netflix and the Spotify, they’re all . . . that was never part of the plan...my family literally cut me off financially, and I had to afford . . . afford security for us...in the first half, the first quarter of 2020. But I’ve got what my mum left me, and, without that, we would not have been able to do this."

However:
"The royal expenditure reports published Thursday reveal that, in the fiscal year beginning of April 2020, he provided both Harry and Prince William’s families with £4.5 million. The report does not break down how much money went to each prince, but a spokesman for Charles at Clarence House clarified that the Prince of Wales had allotted “a substantial sum” to support Harry and Meghan as they transitioned out of their royal roles. “That funding ceased in the summer of last year,” the spokesperson continued. “The couple are now financially independent.”"

What you reasonably believe after Harry's statement:
When Harry and Meghan said they were leaving the Royal Family, his family stopped giving them any money and had to rely on media outlets in order to keep their family safe.

Reality:
Their transition was paid for by the royal family and security and funds were provided for many months after they left the royal family (well beyond the time that they were seeking contracts from media outlets). Their home, safety and lifestyle was ensured by the royal family's funds.

What Harry said is not what most people would consider to be the truth. It is what a lawyer and a marketing team scripted to give the impression he was immediately cut off but, in reality, he wasn't.

When you write these kind of statements for a living, you get pretty good at recognising them.

Luredbyapomegranate · 16/12/2022 10:24

No. With kindness - don't be so dim.

The Royal Family can't and won't get dragged into a slanging match and they know that.

I am sure the whole lot of them acted badly at times, as all families do.

But the primary purpose of this series, Harry's book etc, is to tell a heavily biased version of the story, to make money and set themselves up for an influencer career - that's fair enough, sort of, they have to earn a living. But you are a fool if you don't see it for what it is.

Lndnmummy · 16/12/2022 10:23

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 06:11

I've watched the full series on Harry and Meghan.
A few things have struck me.
The most important thing is that there are defamation laws in England. Damage to your reputation is grounds for pursuing such a case. That no such case has yet been initiated by William or Kate, suggests that there is truth in Harry and Meghan's version of events.
Meghan comes across as very vulnerable but very real. She also comes across as very much in love still; as does Harry.
I admire Harry for his decision to leave. I do buy his logic; if the tax payer had even 1% of a contribution to their lives financially, the media could then claim a public interest.
Harry comes across as incredibly intelligent. He has always been touted as the dumb one. He seems to be very much more than some dumb guy.
He adores Meghan and that seems to be reciprocated. She gave him an out.

Harry is very much is mother's son. Diana would have supported Meghan I think. I think they were kindred spirits (Diana and Harry) in a way. Pawns in the game where the king and queen reign...

I agree whole heartedly with everything you have said.