Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe H&M because of defamation laws?

388 replies

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 06:11

I've watched the full series on Harry and Meghan.
A few things have struck me.
The most important thing is that there are defamation laws in England. Damage to your reputation is grounds for pursuing such a case. That no such case has yet been initiated by William or Kate, suggests that there is truth in Harry and Meghan's version of events.
Meghan comes across as very vulnerable but very real. She also comes across as very much in love still; as does Harry.
I admire Harry for his decision to leave. I do buy his logic; if the tax payer had even 1% of a contribution to their lives financially, the media could then claim a public interest.
Harry comes across as incredibly intelligent. He has always been touted as the dumb one. He seems to be very much more than some dumb guy.
He adores Meghan and that seems to be reciprocated. She gave him an out.

Harry is very much is mother's son. Diana would have supported Meghan I think. I think they were kindred spirits (Diana and Harry) in a way. Pawns in the game where the king and queen reign...

OP posts:
Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:47

Please God, let me fall in love with an heir to a fortune 😅

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 16/12/2022 17:47

UseAMuckySock · 16/12/2022 07:44

No I didn’t get it from the documentary - I’ve always thought the pair of them look tense and unhappy together. Especially Kate.

Maybe they did fall in love initially but are no longer happy but god forbid they be allowed to admit it and divorce. They’re trapped together and it shows.

Have you seen some recent photos? They look perfectly happy in them to me.

It's all in the eye of the beholder

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:46

Headabovetheparakeet · 16/12/2022 17:45

Op, I think you're getting a couple of things confused here.

I don't think most British (fuck off with your English nonsense) people were upset he married an American but she was essentially taking a new job when she married. Harry was aware of this and has said as much himself.

I think she was treated appalling by the press but she also has said some outstandingly stupid things.

If you don't believe in tradition or curtsying to the Queen then maybe don't marry her grandson? Just a thought.

If I fall in love with a man who is heir to a fortune, I would not be falling in love with his entire family and the institution of monarchy. It would be one man.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 16/12/2022 17:45

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 07:46

I think that one of the more telling interactions actually was at the beginning of ep 5 I think? Archie is toddling around a maze and Harry is encouraging him and then he topples over and Harry is like 'yes, get up, carry on' sort of thing and the little tot starts to cry and Meghan immediately picks him up to console him. I think it was a very real dynamic. Parents are like that.

I genuinely am a bullshitter detector. I don't get 'bullshit' from either of them. Ok, her language and her way of expressing herself is very American, but she's not lying.

How easy is it to 'detect bullshit' from a heavily-edited partisan documentary?

Headabovetheparakeet · 16/12/2022 17:45

Op, I think you're getting a couple of things confused here.

I don't think most British (fuck off with your English nonsense) people were upset he married an American but she was essentially taking a new job when she married. Harry was aware of this and has said as much himself.

I think she was treated appalling by the press but she also has said some outstandingly stupid things.

If you don't believe in tradition or curtsying to the Queen then maybe don't marry her grandson? Just a thought.

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:43

loislovesstewie · 16/12/2022 17:41

OK, I don't think that she had a clue about what the RF actually do or how they behave. Nothing wrong with that, but it feels as though she just didn't think it through. They aren't just a family, they are also at the apex of the hierarchy, and there is a an order within that. They are also a business. I accept that anyone might struggle with the system, I just feel Meghan wanted change from the family but that wasn't going to happen, or maybe not as fast as she wanted.

I know the line of succession of most within the royal family, but would I know how it was to live as the wife of the spare? I wouldn't have had a clue. She wasn't a gullible 18 year old princess in a Disney movie.

OP posts:
Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:42

I would forgive her for singing this song lol

OP posts:
loislovesstewie · 16/12/2022 17:41

OK, I don't think that she had a clue about what the RF actually do or how they behave. Nothing wrong with that, but it feels as though she just didn't think it through. They aren't just a family, they are also at the apex of the hierarchy, and there is a an order within that. They are also a business. I accept that anyone might struggle with the system, I just feel Meghan wanted change from the family but that wasn't going to happen, or maybe not as fast as she wanted.

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:40

I actually don't think that it was much to do with her race within the royal family. I think that it was that she was an outsider. The media did the race thing, she sort of shrunk away, then the media went apeshit at her and him for trying to shrink away and then the new baby. Why hadn't she done the photo on the steps? Why didn't we know the precise due date? Why didn't we know where they gave birth? Why did we not get to view the business end of her birth? Why is she such an attention seeking two bit actress who has no clue about our British standards? Why does she want to ignore tradition? Why is she wanting to not do things OUR WAY?

OP posts:
Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:31

TheVanguardSix · 16/12/2022 12:41

"I'm a bit Megan."
"Woe betide?" 🙄

Who writes this shit?

Some English fucker?

OP posts:
Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:29

hamstersarse · 16/12/2022 10:48

I watched a bit of this

I'm sorry, but these guys are projecting massively. It is impossible not to. Oh and also clearly doing this for questionable reasons.

It's hard to take this seriously.

Pack of imbeciles.

OP posts:
Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:29

Thefriendlyone · 16/12/2022 11:23

She did know who she was marrying, and that is key. She knew exactly who she was marrying and the sort of fame that would bring. The sort of wealth .

harry however fed her vanity , he even says it on the documentary. That she was going to be the star, revitalise the monarchy , which quite frankly was deeply offensive to the queen and the rest of his family.

That some bit part American acresss was going to roll in and save the monarchy and show them the way forward. The last thing the queen needed was Meghan Markle to show her how it was done. And neither did Charles William or Kate, it’s so utterly ludicrous as a concept.

and if anyone notices he bigs her up constantly , how she is beautiful, intelligent,warm loving, the next Diana She doesn’t do it back.

the queen apparently said she wondered if harry wasn’t a bit over in love. And you can see where she was coming from. He doesn’t even cringe when he goes on about her running the monarchy , their greatest asset, the new Diana. and them all being jealous of her.

can anyone in their right minds think that the queen, Phillip, Charles, camilla, William or Kate were sitting there going oh god, we wish we were as good as Meghan , she truly is the new Diana, we are so jealous of her fabulousness?

You see this, is the exact mentality that British people have about Meghan. I've never seen anyone admit to it, so thanks for admitting to it.

I'm not English but it has always been very clear to me that it was this 'bit part American' which was the problem. Why couldn't she have been British? What's wrong with our lovely British ladies? Who does she think she is?

OP posts:
Sartre · 16/12/2022 17:02

I find the way they call themselves H and M really grating, especially when her friends and relatives also call him H. It’s just weird.

I still have the last two episodes to go but so far I don’t like or dislike them, just as I felt before. I think the British media are savage and I certainly wouldn’t want to be brought to task by them. She knew the royal family before she met him and it’s disingenuous of her to suggest otherwise, there’s a v.famous image of her as a child with Diana plastered all over her bedroom… She almost definitely didn’t understand the protocols before meeting ‘Haz’ though so that probably did come as a shock.

I’d love to hear the other side of the story but I know that won’t happen.

Diverging · 16/12/2022 16:59

Meghan comes across as very vulnerable but very real. She also comes across as very much in love still; as does Harry.

No she comes across as totally fake and mawkish. Absolute cringe.
He comes a cross as a someone who has lost his way, overprivileged and going overboard on petty family bickering.

Both of them are quite narcissistic.

In love, yes.

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 16:52

Crispychocolateslab · 16/12/2022 08:55

The UK, not England. If you’re going to slag a country and its people off at least get the name of it right.

I specifically mentioned England as it appears to be only the English who dislike her.

OP posts:
HappinesDependsOnYou · 16/12/2022 13:09

@WatchoRulo. I just answered in the post above yours. We x posted. I didn't write it clear. I basically meant it's a weak defence to them telling the truth when they know the family will say nothing either way. Their response before were "recollections vary" well known for saying nothing at all whether right or wrong to do so

WatchoRulo · 16/12/2022 13:07

Sorry - ignore the question - explained in cross-post

WatchoRulo · 16/12/2022 13:06

@HappinesDependsOnYou
I don't think defamation laws give any weight to whether they are telling the truth.
Why do you think that?

HappinesDependsOnYou · 16/12/2022 13:06

Sorry my post wasnt clear @RunnerBum. What I meant was it doesn't matter if what they say is true or false the royal family will not argue it whether they have a legal right or not. It will open the doors to the public. They always take the stance of say nothing. Defamation trials would fuel the fire so I meant it doesn't give any weight to the argument on whether H&M should be believed. Diana was never challenged and sadly had she been she may have realised she had been tricked into giving the interview

RunnerBum · 16/12/2022 12:49

HappinesDependsOnYou · 16/12/2022 11:13

I don't think defamation laws give any weight to whether they are telling the truth. If Will and Kate took it to court the public would have a right to know more about their private lives, conversations and events. Whether innocent or guilty it wouldn't benefit them only fuel the public scrutiny. I have watched it and have empathy for them. Him as someone who clearly feels they were not given the support he desperately needed as a child and someone who was born into a gilded cage and her as someone whose wings were clipped to be stuffed into a cage and who was then unfairly treated in comparison to Kate. They lost the moral high ground well and truly when they claimed to have married the day before they actually did though. A very quick and simple lie that makes you well and truly question everything said by them

In defamation, it is a complete defence to a claim to show that the statement is true. Section 2(1) Defamation Act 2013 states that “it is a defence to an action for defamation for the defendant to show that the imputation conveyed by the statement complained of is substantially true”.

This doesn't mean OP is right - she's very, very, very naive to make the assumption she has - but defamation laws give huge weight to whether the statement is true. If you can prove that it's true then it cannot be defamation.

TheVanguardSix · 16/12/2022 12:41

"I'm a bit Megan."
"Woe betide?" 🙄

Who writes this shit?

PourMe · 16/12/2022 12:36

*It's disrespectful to the indigenous people

Forgive my typos.

PourMe · 16/12/2022 12:35

*I can't remember who, said that Meghan

PourMe · 16/12/2022 12:34

Anklespraying · 16/12/2022 11:34

It's absolutely cringe @Thefriendlyone

They more or less said this in the engagement interview. How they were going to transform the monarchy and save it. Only they could. Delusional. If that's how they behaved they will have clashed nonstop with everyone, leading to her misery at people thwarting her ambitions.

Well, they edited the Queen' speech to emphasise that the Monarch will serve the Commonwealth. One guy on the programme, I can't remember who, said that the Meghan looks like the majority of people in the Commonwealth and that therefore (based on her skin colour) she was best placed to represent a modern monarchy.

I found this at odds with Meghan's way of talking about visiting Africa with Harry in the early days of their relationship. It didn't sound like the trip was her cup of tea, she probably had never visited Africa beforehand.

One comment in particular sounds rather colonial and undiplomatic for someone who feels uniquely equipped to represent the Commonwealth.

In episode 1* towards the end, Meghan can be heard saying "we'll treat it like we're in the Bush, it's all foreign to me" *when talking about how to deal with the unwelcome Media interest when they first announced their relationship to the world.

I find this expression incredibly ignorant, othering and insensitive. It's disrespectful to the indigenous peoples who live in the African bush to compare facing/surviving the media intrusion, which they hate, with staying in the African bush. "It's all foreign to me" so she clearly doesn't feel a huge kinship and affinity with Africa as opposed to Harry.

This is just one of the many contradictions they lay bare during the various episodes.

BloodAndFire · 16/12/2022 12:33

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 06:32

You do if you're sick of keeping quiet. I'm a bit Meghan. I don't dance on ceremony, I abhor niceties and I can't keep my mouth shut in the face of lies or injustice. It's very apparent to me that her being stifled was terribly difficult for her as a woman. It would be for me too!
Woe betide the man who dates me and expects me to obey some sort of family traditions, in contradiction of who I am fundamentally, when I meet his family! That would the end of that relationship.

Do you have a t-shirt that says "if you can't handle me at my worst, you don't deserve me at my best"?

I think you should.