Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe H&M because of defamation laws?

388 replies

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 06:11

I've watched the full series on Harry and Meghan.
A few things have struck me.
The most important thing is that there are defamation laws in England. Damage to your reputation is grounds for pursuing such a case. That no such case has yet been initiated by William or Kate, suggests that there is truth in Harry and Meghan's version of events.
Meghan comes across as very vulnerable but very real. She also comes across as very much in love still; as does Harry.
I admire Harry for his decision to leave. I do buy his logic; if the tax payer had even 1% of a contribution to their lives financially, the media could then claim a public interest.
Harry comes across as incredibly intelligent. He has always been touted as the dumb one. He seems to be very much more than some dumb guy.
He adores Meghan and that seems to be reciprocated. She gave him an out.

Harry is very much is mother's son. Diana would have supported Meghan I think. I think they were kindred spirits (Diana and Harry) in a way. Pawns in the game where the king and queen reign...

OP posts:
Anklespraying · 17/12/2022 09:14

The programme showed how the British public are heavily influenced by the British media, very little critical thinking, just hate for the mixed race actress.

The British public! We think as one now! We all hate a mixed race actress. Every single one of the British public.

I suppose the good outcome of them putting out six hours of their grievances is that we can actually see that this is untrue. The single most divisive thing they have done is take up this anti British position and call the country racist. This has put people off them.

The programmes show that it's unsubstantiated.

Thefriendlyone · 17/12/2022 09:08

Actually if you think about it, they have levied very little accusations at the royal family

they have said they were all so jealous of Meghans stardom and ability to do the job that they had staff leak negative stories about her
that William screamed and harry was terrified, that Charles lied and the queen watched passively At one meeting
that they had a little house and Oprah couldn’t believe they had to live somewhere little like that.
royal men married women who fit the mould and not for love, unlike harry
that Kate wasn’t a hugger.
that they advised her not to have her niece at the wedding
that the head of staff refused to get her a therapist when she was suicidal as it looked bad on the family
that they put out a press release saying William wasn’t bullying harry without asking harry.
that their security was being pulled and their lives were at risk due to it and that they had to get out fast and go live for free in oprahs mates house and have him pay for their security

everything else was just vague shit.

in Oprah they went further with the Kate made me cry , they took her passport and held her prisoner. and someone made a comment on babies skin colour.

but there was really very little , it was all petty shit or mis truths and whinging mainly about how they were victims and no one recognised their sacrifice doing the job for 17 months except a pilot who knelt in front of Meghan to thank her for her service

GodisaBC · 17/12/2022 09:00

The programme showed how the British public are heavily influenced by the British media, very little critical thinking, just hate for the mixed race actress.
I think they’re a fantastic couple and do a hell of a lot of good. Grenfell showed how genuine and hardworking she was. She didn’t just pop in once for a photo opportunity, she was there week after week.
It highlighted how much institutional racism exists in this country.
I wish them every happiness and think thank god they had the guts to get out.

CanYouMe · 17/12/2022 08:54

It screams snobbery on behalf of a family that couldn't care less about the public.

Did Meg and Haz ever care about the public? 🤔

Anklespraying · 17/12/2022 08:53

So I would only think that an actress might be acting in a documentary because the Royal Family told me to think this?

And not because it's a perfectly reasonable and straightforward connection to make?

Yes that's it, definitely 😁

Lampshadered · 17/12/2022 08:45

The whole "She is an actress" (a bit part one at that!) and so can't be believed shows how good a number the royal family have done on the British public. It screams snobbery on behalf of a family that couldn't care less about the public. They won't not respond because they are above all that; they won't respond because they don't need to - they will continue to take taxpayer money to fund their lavish lifestyle and what anybody thinks of them doesn't matter.

Do you all not believe a word that any actress says about their personal lives? Aren't the Royal Family the greatest actors of them all?

Coxspurplepippin · 17/12/2022 08:31

MissTrip82, I think what people find so, dunno, maybe distasteful about the wedding story is the almost gleeful way it was said -almost like 'see, suckers, £30mil of taxpayers money and it wasn't even our real wedding!' If they'd said they had a few private minutes in the garden saying some meaningful words to each other before the pomp and ceremony of the wedding no-one would have batted an eyelid.

There was a lot of goodwill towards them at the time of the wedding, people were excited, it was a beautiful wedding with dresses and glamour and music and choirs chosen by the couple. To then hear the bride say it was all for show and didn't actually mean anything to them, well, bit rude.

If they hadn't wanted the big glitzy do, I'm pretty sure they could have had a small private wedding if they'd chosen to, nipped down to the registry office, or even not married at all - it's not as if previous royal couples haven't just lived together - Kate and William did for years before they were married.

I certainly don't 'hate' the daft pair. I think they think what they're doing is cathartic but fear they'll find the opposite in the long run. Isn't one thing therapists often suggest is writing a letter to the people you have a grievance with, then not sending it? Harry and Meghan have written the letters time and time again and are mailing them, then publishing the contents to the world. Naive to think people won't have opinions, good and bad.

MissTrip82 · 17/12/2022 08:13

I watched it and found it plausible. I have no doubt if I were to watch a similar series from the perspective of the royal family it’d be plausible too.

I find it utterly bizarre that there are people who think there’s a ‘truth’ in this, I can’t imagine what their families are like if they are so black and white they’ve never encountered a difference in perspective. The way I see my late father is very different to the way my sister sees him and different again to the way my brother sees him. None of us are lying. It’s incredible to me that many people have apparently never encountered this sort of nuance.

I feel similarly perplexed by the people who seem to just about froth at the mouth exposing what they see as ‘lies’. It’s so odd to me to invest so much anger, so much emotional energy, in these total strangers. The ‘wedding’ prior to the official day is a good example - it seemed perfectly clear to me that they were describing an emotional commitment that was entirely private and that they saw as being more ‘real’ (emotionally) than the public event but an astonishing number of people are intensely literal and apparently furious that they’re being ‘lied to’ (again…..by strangers they have never and will never meet about a matter that is surely of no consequence to the rest of us). I feel sometimes as though posters must need to wipe their own spittle off the screen after posting, so vitriolic are they about the different perspective of people who mean nothing to them. It’s absolutely extraordinary.

I really wonder how these types cope with the ordinary nuances of relationships and communication in the real world. I wonder also why on earth they continue to engage with strangers they despise.

Virginiaplain · 17/12/2022 07:43

Becclescake · 17/12/2022 07:03

I've watched the series and think they come across as credible and genuine. I'm actually really ashamed of the UK press, and I'm ashamed I actually believed some of what was written. I wish them all the best.

I agree the UK press is evil. But we buy the papers so aren't guilt free.

But I still wouldn't trash my family globally - I didn't have a perfect childhood but I still kept it mostly in the family.

Becclescake · 17/12/2022 07:03

I've watched the series and think they come across as credible and genuine. I'm actually really ashamed of the UK press, and I'm ashamed I actually believed some of what was written. I wish them all the best.

Nodancingshoes · 16/12/2022 18:38

Of course it was extremely difficult to marry into the Royal family for an American woman. It would be extremely difficult for a normal British 'commoner' aswell. I think it's been said that William took so long to marry Kate because he was keen to prepare her for what was to come. And Kate has smashed it out the park to be honest hasn't she? Harry's status was always going to get less and less as time went by as he got further down the line of sucession. And I don't think he could handle that. To criticise the institution but still claim they had no problem with the Queen and even name their child after her makes no sense. She was head of the Royal family and the buck stopped with her. Personally I feel this Netflix series has done Harry and meghan NO favours whatsoever, whether there is any truth in it or not.

Ch3wylemon · 16/12/2022 18:36

OP I think your latest insight is interesting. You did have the foresight to see what a nightmare you would be setting yourself up for and knew you would lose yourself.

I think Meghan believed it would be very different, perhaps because Harry misled her, I don't know. To Meghan it was all about the fame and the glamour and so she wasn't prepared the day to day tedium or the harsh reality of being as famous as she thought she wanted to be. I find it very sad. But not surprising.

I am sorry she is unhappy, but I think she is wrong to present their story in such a tone deaf way. It still won't make her happy.

MissFancyDay · 16/12/2022 18:29

So a photographer is there when they are watching the Oprah interview. A photographer there when they get a text from William. Meghan seemingly forgetting that she had met Beyonce. Do you honestly think that any of it is genuine OP? If so you are very gullible

Catintinsel · 16/12/2022 18:24

OP, please consider that this entire documentary is 100% one-sided - with emotional music, quips from carefully selected 'friends' and commentators... the lot. The whole thing is blatant manipulative propaganda.

Take a step back. Ask yourself why would the cameras have just happened to be rolling the second Harry gets the 'unexpected' text from William?

So many similar supposedly 'real' moments in this series - which they have been carefully and systematically curating for years.

The woman is an actress. She is a very beautiful woman. She is accustomed to everyone dancing to her tune.

They are criticising the media machine, while exploiting it to the max. They have been advised by lawyers, directors, you name it. Advised specifically on what is defamation and what is not. They know that not naming names is actually more damaging to the RF because it invites speculation (in the media). They are playing the media like a fiddle. This is what they are about now.

All the schmaltz would have been better left out. The orchestrated interviews of the crying friends - years after the events they are commenting on. Really? It's beyond ridiculous. The whole style is like the "Real Housewives of ...." - ie. 100% narcissistic, cringe-inducing and totally tone deaf.

They would have been better off just doing an interview - unrehearsed and genuine. People would have respected them then.

The public are not stupid. They understand that, as in any family drama, there is no monopoly of 'right' and ''wrong'. It is nearly always more nuanced and complicated. All Meghan has done is played the victim. No introspection. Half-statements and insinuation designed to invite media gossip. She knows EXACTLY what she is doing. And she is surrounded by Hollywood , schmaltzy 'yes people' who are intoxicated by that kind of narcissistic, celebrity culture and don't comprehend anything beyond that bubble.

I am no massive fan of the RF. But no, they will not respond. There is nothing to be gained from engaging with Hollywood schmaltz. They will just carry on.

girlmom21 · 16/12/2022 18:12

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:56

Actually thinking back, (it's a long time ago), I knew that he was the only son and that he was expected to inherit and run the business. I knew that I couldn't live in their culture. We split up and I came home. He then wanted to move to live here but I knew that it would break his parents' hearts and that he would never be able to be what he was over here (language). So I knew it had to end.

Chelsy Davy? Is that you?

fatsocatso · 16/12/2022 18:07

Headabovetheparakeet · 16/12/2022 17:57

I think you may have jumped the shark there Op.

😂

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:58

Headabovetheparakeet · 16/12/2022 17:57

I think you may have jumped the shark there Op.

What does that mean?

OP posts:
Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:57

It was the biggest heartbreak I ever went through. Would I have been better off if I stayed and conformed? Who knows.

OP posts:
Headabovetheparakeet · 16/12/2022 17:57

I think you may have jumped the shark there Op.

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:56

Actually thinking back, (it's a long time ago), I knew that he was the only son and that he was expected to inherit and run the business. I knew that I couldn't live in their culture. We split up and I came home. He then wanted to move to live here but I knew that it would break his parents' hearts and that he would never be able to be what he was over here (language). So I knew it had to end.

OP posts:
Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:51

Nanny0gg · 16/12/2022 17:45

How easy is it to 'detect bullshit' from a heavily-edited partisan documentary?

I think that when something resonates or makes sense, I buy it. I don't buy much lol

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 16/12/2022 17:50

WeWereInParis · 16/12/2022 07:51

Has anyone ever seen George smile when he hasn’t been told to for a photo shoot? He’s the most miserable looking kid ever.

He's a 10(?) year old child - does he need to be criticised for not smiling enough in public? I always thinks he looks more nervous/unsure than miserable, which is understandable given his age and the fact we only see him at more formal events.

And besides, yes I have seen him smile outside of photo shoots, he looked thrilled at that football match they went to.

There was a photo of them last night at the carol concert, taken from behind. When you saw the bank of photographers they were facing, no wonder he wasn't smiling! My grandsons wouldn't either (well, one might. The others definitely not).

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 17:50

Incidentally, I did fall in love with an heir to a fortune and I left the relationship as I knew that I simply couldn't have lived by their rules. Looking back, I suppose he was my greatest love story, but I was very unhappy within the confines of the relationship. There was a cultural clash too. I'm not American, but I'm European and so was he. Their culture was very misogynistic.

OP posts:
loislovesstewie · 16/12/2022 17:48

No and neither would I, and frankly I don't think I would have married into the RF, because I am clearly working class and the whole system would be alien to me. However if I did, I would grab any help I could, I would ask questions, I would admit that I did not have a clue and understand that I was in it for the long haul. I would expect it to be years before I was confident enough to fit in. I'm just not sure that Meghan did that or thought that.

Headabovetheparakeet · 16/12/2022 17:48

If I fall in love with a man who is heir to a fortune, I would not be falling in love with his entire family and the institution of monarchy. It would be one man.

And in that case, maybe he should have resigned from his role before they married and they could have both gone off and gotten jobs to support themselves?