Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe H&M because of defamation laws?

388 replies

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 06:11

I've watched the full series on Harry and Meghan.
A few things have struck me.
The most important thing is that there are defamation laws in England. Damage to your reputation is grounds for pursuing such a case. That no such case has yet been initiated by William or Kate, suggests that there is truth in Harry and Meghan's version of events.
Meghan comes across as very vulnerable but very real. She also comes across as very much in love still; as does Harry.
I admire Harry for his decision to leave. I do buy his logic; if the tax payer had even 1% of a contribution to their lives financially, the media could then claim a public interest.
Harry comes across as incredibly intelligent. He has always been touted as the dumb one. He seems to be very much more than some dumb guy.
He adores Meghan and that seems to be reciprocated. She gave him an out.

Harry is very much is mother's son. Diana would have supported Meghan I think. I think they were kindred spirits (Diana and Harry) in a way. Pawns in the game where the king and queen reign...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Myleftfoot39 · 18/12/2022 05:39

It’s two people’s version of what happened, there’s actually very little evidence. Yes the press were horrible but there’s nothing but rumour and gossip otherwise

Myleftfoot39 · 18/12/2022 05:37

I think William and Kate just don’t want to lower themselves to this sort of mud slinging. The Sussexes are trying to poke them constantly and so far no reaction. It must be frustrating!

marcopront · 18/12/2022 05:22

@musingsinmidlife

I am sure it was for security reasons and not wanting people to see their personal items or inside their home. Some of their fans / enemies pour over every little detail. The house that was used for the California filming segments is 888 Lilac Dr. Montecito. It is still listed on Redfin so you can see the pictures if you want.

I have no interest in seeing their house. I don't really care about whether they were real or not. However if the whole purpose of the documentary is to set the record straight then make it clear we are watching recreations not real life.

musingsinmidlife · 18/12/2022 05:06

marcopront · 18/12/2022 03:57

In a documentary about sharing the truth????

I am sure it was for security reasons and not wanting people to see their personal items or inside their home. Some of their fans / enemies pour over every little detail. The house that was used for the California filming segments is 888 Lilac Dr. Montecito. It is still listed on Redfin so you can see the pictures if you want.

marcopront · 18/12/2022 03:57

musingsinmidlife · 17/12/2022 18:12

They didn't film in their own home, so any footage that you see that gives the appearance of being at home is a recreation. They used an empty property up the road from them for filming. So the reaction shots are all recreations.

In a documentary about sharing the truth????

DonnaDonna0 · 17/12/2022 21:36

Can you really take what they are saying serious when the true reason for it isn’t “their truth” it’s getting paid 100 million.
That’s what it boils down to money and we all know what that can lead people to say and do.

torquewench · 17/12/2022 20:26

Anklespraying · 17/12/2022 20:07

but what the RF, media and so called great British public (for believing the bull they are fed) have done to her and Harry is disgusting

But what actually have they done to her?

There are 70 million of us great British public which you seem contemptuous of. What have we all done?

Most of those 70 million don't read tabloids, most of us are unaware of the bull we have apparently been fed. If we're unimpressed it's because this six hours of reconstructions are unimpressive.

This. I haven't purchased a tabloid, ever, and I've been around since the 70s. I've seen what Diana, Fergie, Camilla, Sophie and Catherine went through, and Pippa, albeit the press quickly lost interest in her.

I have, however, watched their whiny docco. Even their own show doesn't make them look good.

Spectre8 · 17/12/2022 20:14

AliceMcK · 17/12/2022 12:28

but the public want to see this stopped now and even he must be able to see it’s wrong they are using their titles.

Really, you speak for the entire public? I for one don’t want them to stop. I think it’s great and respect them for speaking out against both the tabloids and the institution. I 100% agree, long before this documentary that Meghan was fed to the wolves, she was completely sacrificed as while the world was slagging her off they weren’t looking at Andrew or the alleged affair William was having. I have always thought the royal family cowards for never speaking up against the tabloids. Harry watched his mom be fed to the wolves, he literally as a child saw the tabloids kill her! He dosnt want the same thing to happen to his wife. He was slow in doing it but he eventually did the right thing and stood up for her.

I also agree the royal family use the media to suit their own narrative. I also don’t think Kate or Camilla ever endured what Meghan has. The bad press camilla got was due to her having an affair with Charles and destroying his “fairytale” marriage, not to mention tampax gate, as soon as he was divorced he used everything he could to protect her, once they were officially together the bad press stopped. Kate got some bad press, but once the engagement was announced, that also stopped.

I fully believe when all the positive press about Meghan was going on it did not sit well with William and Kate, just like it didn't sit well with Charles when Diana was favoured over him, so when the narrative changed to Meghan being a diva, bully, wanting to be queen bee, it absolutely suited them. I also fully without doubt believe the men in grey suits were behind the whole thing, they want the world to think the British Monarchy is modern and progressive on the outside but really they are definitely not on the inside.

The queen apparently was very passionate about keeping the commonwealth, I agree when Harry says Meghan would have been a great asset in this endeavour given her heritage, I don’t think he was boasting about her reforming the royal family, that was all media, but having a woman of colour in the royal family definitely made the royal family more appealing to countries of colour in the commonwealth. I don’t understand how the RF could not have seen and used them as assets in the commonwealth.

I have no real idea who Meghan is, if she’s a bitch in real life or not, but what the RF, media and so called great British public (for believing the bull they are fed) have done to her and Harry is disgusting

As for giving up their titles, why should they, Harry is a royal prince, that should not be taken away from him. when Edward VII abdicated he because the Duke of Windsor and used that title the rest of his life, Harry is now the Duke if Sussex and is entitled to keep that title, if people want to take that away from him then he should be referred to as Prince Harry, because that’s what he is, he didn’t ask for it, it was his birth right

👏 👏 👏 Well said.

Anklespraying · 17/12/2022 20:07

but what the RF, media and so called great British public (for believing the bull they are fed) have done to her and Harry is disgusting

But what actually have they done to her?

There are 70 million of us great British public which you seem contemptuous of. What have we all done?

Most of those 70 million don't read tabloids, most of us are unaware of the bull we have apparently been fed. If we're unimpressed it's because this six hours of reconstructions are unimpressive.

musingsinmidlife · 17/12/2022 18:12

They didn't film in their own home, so any footage that you see that gives the appearance of being at home is a recreation. They used an empty property up the road from them for filming. So the reaction shots are all recreations.

BloodAndFire · 17/12/2022 14:26

Headabovetheparakeet · 16/12/2022 17:57

I think you may have jumped the shark there Op.

A whole row of them.

AliceMcK · 17/12/2022 12:28

but the public want to see this stopped now and even he must be able to see it’s wrong they are using their titles.

Really, you speak for the entire public? I for one don’t want them to stop. I think it’s great and respect them for speaking out against both the tabloids and the institution. I 100% agree, long before this documentary that Meghan was fed to the wolves, she was completely sacrificed as while the world was slagging her off they weren’t looking at Andrew or the alleged affair William was having. I have always thought the royal family cowards for never speaking up against the tabloids. Harry watched his mom be fed to the wolves, he literally as a child saw the tabloids kill her! He dosnt want the same thing to happen to his wife. He was slow in doing it but he eventually did the right thing and stood up for her.

I also agree the royal family use the media to suit their own narrative. I also don’t think Kate or Camilla ever endured what Meghan has. The bad press camilla got was due to her having an affair with Charles and destroying his “fairytale” marriage, not to mention tampax gate, as soon as he was divorced he used everything he could to protect her, once they were officially together the bad press stopped. Kate got some bad press, but once the engagement was announced, that also stopped.

I fully believe when all the positive press about Meghan was going on it did not sit well with William and Kate, just like it didn't sit well with Charles when Diana was favoured over him, so when the narrative changed to Meghan being a diva, bully, wanting to be queen bee, it absolutely suited them. I also fully without doubt believe the men in grey suits were behind the whole thing, they want the world to think the British Monarchy is modern and progressive on the outside but really they are definitely not on the inside.

The queen apparently was very passionate about keeping the commonwealth, I agree when Harry says Meghan would have been a great asset in this endeavour given her heritage, I don’t think he was boasting about her reforming the royal family, that was all media, but having a woman of colour in the royal family definitely made the royal family more appealing to countries of colour in the commonwealth. I don’t understand how the RF could not have seen and used them as assets in the commonwealth.

I have no real idea who Meghan is, if she’s a bitch in real life or not, but what the RF, media and so called great British public (for believing the bull they are fed) have done to her and Harry is disgusting

As for giving up their titles, why should they, Harry is a royal prince, that should not be taken away from him. when Edward VII abdicated he because the Duke of Windsor and used that title the rest of his life, Harry is now the Duke if Sussex and is entitled to keep that title, if people want to take that away from him then he should be referred to as Prince Harry, because that’s what he is, he didn’t ask for it, it was his birth right

sweatyannie · 17/12/2022 12:17

What are you expecting OP ?

A Vardy V Rooney style court case ?

DoraSpenlow · 17/12/2022 12:15

just hate for the mixed race actress.

OK, so all the people lining the route cheering for them on their wedding day hated the mixed race actress? All the members of the British public who sent them cards and gifts for the wedding hated the mixed race actress? All the people who watched the wedding on TV hated the mixed race actress?

The British press can be awful to anyone if they put their mind to it. Catherine had a lot of it before she married William. Camilla too. Like all bullies they pick on the thing they think will hurt the most.

I was so pleased for Harry that he had found a beautiful, independant women to love and love him. I didn't give a shiny one about her heritage. I thought they could do so much good but they were never going to change an institution that has been going for hundreds of years overnight.

It all went downhill for me the minute Meghan inferred that they were already married before the big day. If she had said that the words they exchanged made her feel like they were already married it would have been different. But to have all that money spent on them and not appreciate it was just not on.

Thefriendlyone · 17/12/2022 11:26

I recall one of rhe journalists during their trip to South Africa. I can’t recall which one but she was a serious and well respected one, saying that before harry did his whole we are suing the media speech and Meghan the crying thank you for asking me stuff, the journalist asked harry as he was going back to the car what their trip objective was and he looked at her angrily and snapped why don’t you ask them (indicating his South African hosts) and got in the car.

they really resented that trip , thoroughly graceless behaviour.

what I can’t grasp is why they still use their titles. Why they are still issuing stuff with the duke and Duchess of Sussex on it. Like their Christmas card.

the complete lack of any decency, them clinging on to the titles so desperately is shocking. I really wouldn’t be surprised if they turn up to the coronation and act all smiley.

Charles is clearly reticent to act as it’s his son, which I get, and no the monarchy won’t be damaged by this, but the public want to see this stopped now and even he must be able to see it’s wrong they are using their titles.

Coxspurplepippin · 17/12/2022 10:05

Virginiaplain · 17/12/2022 09:19

Anyone seen a psychologists explanation of why people get so wrapped up in stranger's lives. What is it? I don't think it happened in the past to this extent.

I guess it started with Diana.

To do with the press, 24 hour rolling news and SM I guess. In the past there was no way of talking about things unless it was over the garden fence or round the tea trolley at work, among a small group of people. Now with SM, you can be talking to hundreds of people on another continent at the push of a button. SM companies are all about content, desperate for content, so they're happy when there's a furore, and most of the sites either aren't moderated or aren't moderated very well.

I'm all for freedom of speech, but allowing people to say what they like with no consequences doesn't make for a happy world. Most of the keyboard warriors will say stuff online they wouldn't dream of saying to someone's face - it's the anonymity that empowers them to say it.

There seems to be an expectation these days that everyone has the right to know everything - fuelled by mostly minor celebrities keeping their star in ascendant by continually creating drama, content and clicks. The Katie Prices and TOWIE types.

The real 'stars', whether that be Hollywood, sports, writers, and yes, the rf etc, keep their personal lives well away from public view, the odd photo, public appearance and snippet of news, especially when they have a new film, book or whatever to promote, but otherwise they keep schtum. They seem to manage it fairly well.

Cluelessbeetroot · 17/12/2022 09:46

Shejustwentthere · 16/12/2022 06:32

You do if you're sick of keeping quiet. I'm a bit Meghan. I don't dance on ceremony, I abhor niceties and I can't keep my mouth shut in the face of lies or injustice. It's very apparent to me that her being stifled was terribly difficult for her as a woman. It would be for me too!
Woe betide the man who dates me and expects me to obey some sort of family traditions, in contradiction of who I am fundamentally, when I meet his family! That would the end of that relationship.

wow aren’t you a KRAZY person

Divebar2021 · 17/12/2022 09:45

@SnowlayRoundabout

Im completely with you. I thought they were both lovely. I can remember my first doubt during an interview M did when she was on tour in South Africa. She made a big point of saying how no one had asked how she was. I can remember thinking “ you’ve employed a whole household to look after your needs, you apparently have a large group of friends who throw you expensive parties and you have a very active social life and none of those people have asked how you are. Your mum hasn’t asked how you are?” I also found it incredibly crass that they started the whole “poor me” narrative when they were in SA meeting victims of some truly heinous crimes. So for me that was the start of my reservations. I was disappointed…. I had set them up as lovely in my mind.

Lemonlady22 · 17/12/2022 09:33

This couple tried to sue because they had their security stopped (paid for by the British tax payer) , this couple who had a multi million £ wedding (paid for by the British tax payer) this couple given a free home( paid for by the British tax payer) I could go on… they are always going to play the ‘poor me’ card. They will not stop because people keep giving them the airtime, they want privacy, but they really don’t…they don’t want it til they haven’t got it anymore, then it’s about how it was taken away from them…their ‘true love’ story is really about how much money they want, get, deserve, it’s all about the£££££. The RF won’t respond because they have class, something these two human sponges will never have!

SnowlayRoundabout · 17/12/2022 09:27

When these two got together I was very much in favour. Meghan seemed bright and articulate, and I thought she would be able to cope with the peculiarities of being royal quite well - including the fact that Harry would inevitably attract less interest as William's children grew up. I also thought it was great to have a mixed race person in the royal family, not least to shake up a few stereotypes.

Sadly all of that changed when they decided to have a strop and walk away, demanding to keep as much as possible of their privileges whilst having none of the responsibilities. And their conduct subsequently, particularly the sheer crassness of all this whining at a time when so many people are genuinely suffering, has been even more disappointing.

So, the thing is, it's too easy to say that attitudes to H and M are all down to racism and nothing else. Sometimes people just behave badly, irrespective of their race. Sometimes other people dislike their conduct, not their race. Refusing to acknowledge that is itself racist.

Headabovetheparakeet · 17/12/2022 09:22

I agree the UK press is evil. But we buy the papers so aren't guilt free.

Speak for yourself Hmm

Virginiaplain · 17/12/2022 09:19

Anyone seen a psychologists explanation of why people get so wrapped up in stranger's lives. What is it? I don't think it happened in the past to this extent.

I guess it started with Diana.

LikeTearsInRain · 17/12/2022 09:17

They are far more trustable than the secretive royals who sweep everything under the carpet and have effectively their own private PR firm to make them sound like the bees knees always

Anklespraying · 17/12/2022 09:15

It highlighted how much institutional racism exists in this country.

What is institutional racism? As you have said it's highlighted how much there is please also explain what it is?

BeIaLugosisDead · 17/12/2022 09:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.