Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
Emotionalsupportviper · 17/12/2022 08:06

donttellmehesalive · 16/12/2022 17:02

I haven't rtft so I suppose it's been said but if we accept that the country can't afford it right now, what about the last 12 years? Why were public sector workers consistently offered under-inflation (or no) annual pay increases then? It'd be easier to stomach now if we'd been treated fairly since 2010.

The govt claim "the country can't afford it", but are managing to afford subsidising the rail companies to the tune of £30 mill/ week to induce them to stand firm against the strikers.

Strikers are losing wages, businesses are losing money, public is being massively inconvenienced, rail companies are losing NOTHING and the govt it pulling all of the strings.

AclowncalledAlice · 17/12/2022 08:04

There's "no money", yet the government do this.......

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-64006885

CoffeeMama1 · 17/12/2022 07:46

For a start if we abolished MPs being able to claim expenses for their energy bills, and scrap the subsidised menu in parliament, that would go some way! Frankly they should only be able to claim expenses for work trips, if they're having to pay for their own travel or something.
Also if they had to follow proper channels for spending taxpayers money they'd get better deals on all their contracts, instead of spunking millions into the faces of their mates, it's an absolute shambles and frankly illegal. They all deserve to be locked away for what they've done to this country.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2022 07:45

@Alexandra2001 if your dd is being shat upon by staff and management does that not indicate the NHS as it stands is totally broken? Presumably the patients have just had enough. Paying nurses more without restructuring the NHS and sorting out its toxic culture won't hp the overall picture. I accept it will help individual nurses. Support for the strike though was not that widespread; very few hospitals participated.

PrincessConstance · 17/12/2022 07:42

LexMitior · 16/12/2022 21:00

Oh come on, Roses likes to berate the NHS for a lack of politeness. Most people are properly concerned with the actual viability of the service. It's a fine thing when your issues are rudeness or perceived respect. This is either a silly pose or a very sheltered one. Forgive it.

Can you not understand being polite is part of the Service? Dp was sent to the emergency day surgery unit to be assessed by a consultant. Upon arrival, he was, asked in a surly manner,
"What do you want", the nurse couldn't even be arsed to get up, she just slid around her office on her chair.
He was told to go sit down over there. Eventually, he was approached by the same nurse, apologized to, and explained A/e hadn't updated the system.

The NHS does need a pay review but they do need a course on customer relations, I don't care how stressful you perceive your job, treat people with respect. There are posters everywhere reminding people aggression will not be tolerated. This however is a two-way street.
In my industry, talking to people like that would be a disciplinary, with an eventual dismissal if you carried on.
The NHS is well known for bullying.

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2022 07:41

@RooRooCooChoo I have never ever said or argued women should stay in the home. I firmly believe that women should plan so that they can, comfortably, if they wish. Also that some women are "wired to be mothers" and some aren't. I was but it never stopped me working from 20 to 35 and again from 43 to 62 and to continue to do so.

I recall the 70s as a young adult. State ownership was truly not superb. I disagreed with water being privatised and they went too far with the trains. I do not want state provision across the board. The state has no business dictating how my children are cared for or indeed educated. They received a better education than the state is able to provide. The state will certainly not dictate how and by whom I am cared for in old age if necessary.

Our views are oppositional. I believe in individual freedoms and choice, you believe in a state run economy. Do you remember what it was like when everything in the UK was nationalised?

I would have no issue paying more tax for the NHS but not in its present form. The structure and culture have to change. We have experience of healthcare in Austria and France. It is significantly better than in the UK. We need to which to a model of social insurance.

RooRooCooChoo · 17/12/2022 06:58

@RosesAndHellebores Desperately trying to ignore the "women should stay in the homes" argument for the sake of my sanity, it's quite clear you don't understand my point.

I believe in all sorts of state provided free services, childcare being one. I also believe in state-owned transport, power and water infrastructure, health and social care etc etc. I believe that the way to pay for these goods is through general taxation. Were we to pay for them out of taxation we would no longer need to pay for them out of the money that currently remains after taxation. Therefore the financial burden on our net salary would be completely different. It's a very simple point.

Alexandra2001 · 17/12/2022 06:57

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2022 21:08

@Alexandra2001 when my employer supported my professional quals as a mature adult I had to sign a contract to say I'd pay it back of I left within three years. It only cost about £4k.

If more nurses stayed in nursing perhaps fewer would leave and conditions would be better for all. Unfortunately the bursaries were abused by quite a lot of people.

If only people could argue their points without being personally abusive.

For as long as the NHS provides sub-optimal care it is unacceptable. To provide suboptimal care without extending basic courtesy and affording other humans dignity is reprehensible. But we must all worship nurses and Dr's. I think not. They are supposed to be professionals, therefore they all need to start behaving like professionals.

You say the bursary was abused? so you have evidence for this? or is it a belief, based on........

Why should someone stay in a job they find stressful, tiring and pays them so little? why not address the causes of this?

My DD is an AHP, she loves her job but in all honesty? she is being shat on, by staff, management and patients... all for 27k.

Nurses/Doctors are human beings, they make errors, screw up... just like the rest of us, no one is putting them on a pedestal but when you have a medical emergency... they are all we have.
But all you are doing is criticising them... with a series of anecdotal allegations designed to rubbish the NHS and its staff.

How on earth do you expect staff to be at their best when they are so short staffed, working 12 hr shifts, no breaks & money worries?

Professional? ....pay them as such then.

Pipsquiggle · 17/12/2022 06:45

It's just so depressing how bad this country is at the moment.
Working people going to food banks!

I would like to pay more tax but also ensure it is spent in the most efficient and effective way possible. We would probably need to get a more federal system so local economies have more autonomy over funding and spending

TeachesOfPeaches · 17/12/2022 06:37

I'm a single parent who earns £90k and I don't get child benefit because I earn over the threshold. Makes no sense that a household with 2 parents earning £49k each do get it!

chipshopElvis · 17/12/2022 06:17

Well the train companies and Royal Mail are private companies who make lots of profit so I don't expect that to have a tax cost.

I would absolutely pay more tax to have decent services which are fit for purpose including the NHS. Don't forget that in this scenario those striking would also pay more tax.

MilkyYay · 17/12/2022 06:15

Yes, im willing to pay significantly more tax.

If we can afford the pension triple lock, we can afford proper inflation linked pay rises for nurses. We have far, far more pensioners than nurses.

FangedFrisbee · 17/12/2022 06:14

I'd get rid of child benefit

AdamRyan · 17/12/2022 06:11

As I mentioned upthread, the government spends most on pensions, by quite some margin.
Maybe they should do something to reduce that bill? Get rid of the triple lock, for instance? Get rid of state pensions for those lucky enough to have retired on a generous final salary scheme? They don't need it.
We could even means test the state pension, like we do with child benefit.

Usee8789754 · 16/12/2022 23:25

I also agree that child benefit should be scrapped.

Overthebow · 16/12/2022 22:10

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 22:04

To be honest, I'd scrap child benefit entirely. Full time workers shouldn't need to be in receipt of any form of benefit, if the minimum wage needs to rise to ensure this then so be it, the government shouldn't be effectively subsidising exploitative employers.

For those unable to work full time, provision for the costs of raising children could be incorporated into Universal Credit. Increased coverage of free childcare would reduce the number of people who fall into this category.

I agree with this. Many of us use child benefit as savings for our DC. Our household income is over £90k yet we get it, we don’t need it.

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 22:04

CloudBusted · 16/12/2022 16:15

only providing benefits for one child is heinous. Children don’t chose which family to be born into. If they are born into poverty their future health and prosperity are effected negatively. OP you clearly have zero understanding of human beings and development. Human beings are complex. Massively complex.

Benefits for one child as a policy is highly unlikely to affect reproductive decisions but will most certainly negatively affect children. The next generation. The generation that will work in the care home you end up in.

To be honest, I'd scrap child benefit entirely. Full time workers shouldn't need to be in receipt of any form of benefit, if the minimum wage needs to rise to ensure this then so be it, the government shouldn't be effectively subsidising exploitative employers.

For those unable to work full time, provision for the costs of raising children could be incorporated into Universal Credit. Increased coverage of free childcare would reduce the number of people who fall into this category.

Stompythedinosaur · 16/12/2022 21:33

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2022 21:08

@Alexandra2001 when my employer supported my professional quals as a mature adult I had to sign a contract to say I'd pay it back of I left within three years. It only cost about £4k.

If more nurses stayed in nursing perhaps fewer would leave and conditions would be better for all. Unfortunately the bursaries were abused by quite a lot of people.

If only people could argue their points without being personally abusive.

For as long as the NHS provides sub-optimal care it is unacceptable. To provide suboptimal care without extending basic courtesy and affording other humans dignity is reprehensible. But we must all worship nurses and Dr's. I think not. They are supposed to be professionals, therefore they all need to start behaving like professionals.

😂i love the idea that behaving like a professional includes being willing to sign your life away for seven years!

If you can't see the difference between having to repay 4k if you leave within 3 years and having to repay 16-30k if you leave within 7 years then I think you aren't thinking about it very hard. But I suppose you've made it clear when you come on every nursing thread to attack nursing as a profession that you don't view nurses as worthy for basic decency, so maybe indentured service is what you are hoping for! Anyway, I suspect this policy may not be the genius way to encourage more people into the profession that you are suggesting.

Can you give any evidence of the bursary being abused? My role involves following quite a lot of the relevance evidence around why nurses leave nursing and I've never seen anything to indicate this. Besides, bursaries haven't been around for some years, and there hasn't been a reduction in the rate that newly qualified nurses leave, this has increased since the bursary was done away with.

Justcuriouser · 16/12/2022 21:16

BirmaBrite · 16/12/2022 07:42

Not a popular view I suspect but I wonder whether public sector workers would be prepared to sacrifice their defined benefit pensions for a pay rise? With the government paying around 25% in pension contributions on top of their salary, perhaps one solution is award significant pay rises but reduce the pension?

So I pay 10% of my wage in pension contributions as a nurse and that is topped up by the Government by another 25% ? Are you sure ?

Most public sector pensions are way way better than anyone gets in the private sector.

Average public sector workers gets £10 for every £1 saved.

Average private sector worker gets £3 for every £1 saved.

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/pensions/article-9737111/The-great-pension-divide-private-public-sector-workers.html

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2022 21:08

@Alexandra2001 when my employer supported my professional quals as a mature adult I had to sign a contract to say I'd pay it back of I left within three years. It only cost about £4k.

If more nurses stayed in nursing perhaps fewer would leave and conditions would be better for all. Unfortunately the bursaries were abused by quite a lot of people.

If only people could argue their points without being personally abusive.

For as long as the NHS provides sub-optimal care it is unacceptable. To provide suboptimal care without extending basic courtesy and affording other humans dignity is reprehensible. But we must all worship nurses and Dr's. I think not. They are supposed to be professionals, therefore they all need to start behaving like professionals.

LexMitior · 16/12/2022 21:00

Oh come on, Roses likes to berate the NHS for a lack of politeness. Most people are properly concerned with the actual viability of the service. It's a fine thing when your issues are rudeness or perceived respect. This is either a silly pose or a very sheltered one. Forgive it.

Alexandra2001 · 16/12/2022 20:51

@RosesAndHellebores

Oh yes a form of Indentured Service, i would imagine that would go down well at your Surrey Conservative Club...

People go into nursing with the very best on intentions, then find they hate it, are treated like shit, their qualifications demeaned.. talked down too plus 60 hour weeks... so guess what? they leave.

So all your stupid idea would do is make sure less went into nursing and for those that do but find it intolerable, they are stuck.. debt, MH issues or worse.

Nursing has changed beyond measure compared to when my Mum was an SRN, back then and she'd be the first to admit it, she was basically doing the job of a band 3 HCA & there were loads of them..... an essential role but nothing compared to what my DD has to know or the responsibility dumped on her 6 months in..... no support, often only FT band 5 on ward too

...healthcare has moved on... its really time you did too.

donttellmehesalive · 16/12/2022 20:49

I can't agree watchrulo. I knew too many people who were too poor to access decent healthcare, suffering with ailments that would have been sorted by the NHS even if you did have a bit of a wait. I think the bottom 20% in the US are treated abysmally. Perfectly willing to accept that this may vary by state.

WatchoRulo · 16/12/2022 20:40

donttellmehesalive · 16/12/2022 19:46

Surely nobody can really want a low tax, poor public services culture like the US. I lived there and hated it. Paying more tax for properly funded services is far preferable.

Having spent some time in the US I'd say many of their public services are actually better. They are delivered at local level with pride and democratic accountability we can only dream of. The UK's over centralisation and continual stripping of central funding has destroyed our local services and the only thing left is to rubber stamp more housing estates with zero infrastructure improvements.

Ginsloth · 16/12/2022 20:16

The magic money tree was in full spring when the government threw £200million at Michelle Mone and her “PPE”.