Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 17/12/2022 10:06

Overthebow · 17/12/2022 09:52

Well yes but the problem is now that money has all been spent and huge debts wracked up from furlough, covid lockdowns, bail outs. The country is not in a good position and we can’t keep adding hugely to the debt. We all knew when trillions was spent on lockdowns that we would have to pay for it sometime, well now here we are.

There does seem to be a crossover in those who demanded more lockdowns and more now. If you thought it would end in constraints later on then it was expected to an extent

Aside from war not expected so extra impact, but yeh here we are paying.

Iamthewombat · 17/12/2022 10:05

….once tax becomes punitive people just don’t work as much. This is exactly what’s happening with experienced doctors- the tax charges on pension growth and loss of personal allowance means means that at a certain point by working more they earn less.

We often hear variations on this statement in relation to NHS consultants, which is why it is important to put it into context.

The ‘tax charges on pension’ affect everybody with a pension pot valued at just over £1m. You heard that correctly. £1m. That was a policy brought in by the coalition government, to reduce the amount of pension tax relief being claimed by the wealthiest. Charges now apply if you contribute more than £40k in any year, or if the overall value of the fund exceeds around £1.1m. Which was the right thing to do: the wealthiest really were claiming the lion’s share of tax relief on pensions. For defined benefit pensions, like the NHS pension, a multiplier of 20x is applied to the expected annual pension income on retirement.

NHS consultants and GPs and other highly paid NHS professionals in this position have a publicly-funded, from general taxation, pension fund of more than £1m. In other words, around £50k a year on retirement. Am I crying for the plight of those people? No. They could leave the NHS pension scheme, of course, and work more, but choose not to.

I’m affected by pension savings limits too (I’m not a clinician) but I’m not refusing to work, or cutting my hours down in a fit of pique.

Alexandra2001 · 17/12/2022 10:04

Overthebow · 17/12/2022 09:52

Well yes but the problem is now that money has all been spent and huge debts wracked up from furlough, covid lockdowns, bail outs. The country is not in a good position and we can’t keep adding hugely to the debt. We all knew when trillions was spent on lockdowns that we would have to pay for it sometime, well now here we are.

We didn't spend Trillions on Lockdowns... it was between 310 and 420 billion, about 20% of GDP.

QE is printing money to buy assets... BOE now selling them off, its also money in the economy for investment, loans to business and satisfying markets.. which is somewhat important.

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 17/12/2022 10:02

There's always something to blame for the underfunding of the public sector. Banking crash led to years of austerity and pay freezes - the effects of which seemed to be felt for longer by the public sector than by the bankers themselves.
Then covid - a drain on the economy but also a money making opportunity for the government.
What will be the next excuse?

cansu · 17/12/2022 09:56

Let's focus on getting the wealthy to pay more tax. Let's stop allowing bankers to stop profiteering from the fuck ups of the government. Let's get rid of paying for the royal family. Let's get the royal family paying taxes too. That's just a start.

Pipsquiggle · 17/12/2022 09:52

taybert · 17/12/2022 09:33

It’s simple to say “higher earners should pay more tax” but once tax becomes punitive people just don’t work as much. This is exactly what’s happening with experienced doctors- the tax charges on pension growth and loss of personal allowance means means that at a certain point by working more they earn less. Not proportionally less for each hour they work, they actually take home less money than if they’d worked fewer hours. Now of course, anyone in that bracket is fortunate to be earning a very good income but no one would work more to earn less no matter where they are on the pay scale. Why would you?

Taxation is complicated, you can’t just look at a workforce and say how much more money there would be if certain groups were taxed more because those changes to tax would in turn change the behaviour of the workers. It’s the same with big companies and how much tax they pay- it isn’t “fair” but if their tax bill went up by millions of pounds they wouldn’t just absorb that, they’d change something to make up for it (increase prices, decrease wages, move operations elsewhere, make redundancies). There’s always a knock on effect elsewhere.

I agree it's not just about taxation but needs to work with effective, efficient governance to distribute monies. Governance process change will take a long time to change. The taxation is a sticking plaster to get people fair wages.

I look at countries like Switzerland, that are non-EU and tax EVERYTHING - even down to whether you practice religion. Their public services are just amazing and things just work. I remember waiting for a bus in Zurich that was due at 5.07pm and guess when it arrived. Another time a bus was 1 minute late and the bus driver said I didn't need to pay

Overthebow · 17/12/2022 09:52

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 17/12/2022 09:47

The government can afford anything it actually wants to afford. It doesn't want to pay public sector workers more, that's it. Millions can be spent on furlough, PPE, to bail out bankers, on arms deals.

Well yes but the problem is now that money has all been spent and huge debts wracked up from furlough, covid lockdowns, bail outs. The country is not in a good position and we can’t keep adding hugely to the debt. We all knew when trillions was spent on lockdowns that we would have to pay for it sometime, well now here we are.

Iamthewombat · 17/12/2022 09:51

Miajk · 16/12/2022 09:34

How is it a change of subject to say the goc wastes money?

It's very much relevant. I wouldn't pay more tax, because I know it would be wasted.

Pretty sure the agency staffing model that makes private companies lots of money costs more per year than what nurses are asking for. So on top of giving them a payrise we could also hire more nurses.

But instead we should pay more tax? That doesn't even make sense.

We've already been paying more, ex. For railway tickets each year. No one benefits but big bosses.

If the greedy and incompetent people at the top started to do their jobs and got a bit less greedy there wouldn't be a need for us to pay more.

Your logic is a little fuzzy - I’ll let you re-read your own post to figure out why - but I’ll happily answer your first question:

How is it a change of subject to say the goc wastes money?

(Context: people saying that they would happily pay more tax never say how much more, instead changing the subject to rant about money they think that the government has wasted.)

It’s a change of subject because it means that you are avoiding the difficult and uncomfortable question of how much more tax you, personally, in pounds sterling, are prepared to pay each year to fund public sector pay rises.

So far we’ve had one person say that she’d pay another £3k per month. Provided her childcare, which she says costs £3k a month, became free, of course. And train tickets. And other things too. So that’s not going to help much, is it?

We’ve also had some vague pontificating on ‘taxing all the billionaires and millionaires 1%’. Which apparently will raise billions. Taxing them on what? There are different types of taxation: income taxes, transaction taxes (like VAT and stamp duty), taxes on the estates of dead people, like IHT, and taxes on crystallised gains, like CGT.

Which of those would you apply to these billionaires and millionaires? If they haven’t earned any U.K. income that year, or died, or crystallised a chargeable gain? Or would you invent a new wealth tax especially for them? Have you ever thought about the complexity of bringing in a wealth tax? plenty of other countries have, and have abandoned the idea. I can imagine the howls when somebody living in a semi in London ‘worth’ more than £1m is told to find 1%, or £10k, stat. Do you think that those people, and the billionaires, will happily hand over the cash? Or might the latter relocate to another country, thus spending their money somewhere other than London’s finest hotels, restaurants, car dealerships and retailers?

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 17/12/2022 09:47

The government can afford anything it actually wants to afford. It doesn't want to pay public sector workers more, that's it. Millions can be spent on furlough, PPE, to bail out bankers, on arms deals.

MarshaBradyo · 17/12/2022 09:44

taybert · 17/12/2022 09:33

It’s simple to say “higher earners should pay more tax” but once tax becomes punitive people just don’t work as much. This is exactly what’s happening with experienced doctors- the tax charges on pension growth and loss of personal allowance means means that at a certain point by working more they earn less. Not proportionally less for each hour they work, they actually take home less money than if they’d worked fewer hours. Now of course, anyone in that bracket is fortunate to be earning a very good income but no one would work more to earn less no matter where they are on the pay scale. Why would you?

Taxation is complicated, you can’t just look at a workforce and say how much more money there would be if certain groups were taxed more because those changes to tax would in turn change the behaviour of the workers. It’s the same with big companies and how much tax they pay- it isn’t “fair” but if their tax bill went up by millions of pounds they wouldn’t just absorb that, they’d change something to make up for it (increase prices, decrease wages, move operations elsewhere, make redundancies). There’s always a knock on effect elsewhere.

Good post. Especially the last part.

Alexandra2001 · 17/12/2022 09:41

@taybert You could make that case for far lower tax rates.

I ve been lucky enough to pay tax at 40% if it went to 45% i would still take home 55% more (over and above my 20% taxable pay) than i would by not working the extra to put me in that higher tax bracket.

No one is working more to earn less, we don't have 100% plus tax rates.

the Doctors pensions stuff isn't a HMRC issue.... its a Govt cock up or even deliberate, as they could fix easily.

Other European countries function better than we do with higher tax rates.. your argument doesn't stack up.

LivIoe · 17/12/2022 09:36

@taybert I calculated once that if I worked 3 days I earned 4 fifths of what I’d earn working 5 days. I went part time to 3 days, had two days at home with my children and saved two days childcare so I was better off too. It didn’t affect me career wise either, so why wouldn’t I have more money and work less?

taybert · 17/12/2022 09:33

It’s simple to say “higher earners should pay more tax” but once tax becomes punitive people just don’t work as much. This is exactly what’s happening with experienced doctors- the tax charges on pension growth and loss of personal allowance means means that at a certain point by working more they earn less. Not proportionally less for each hour they work, they actually take home less money than if they’d worked fewer hours. Now of course, anyone in that bracket is fortunate to be earning a very good income but no one would work more to earn less no matter where they are on the pay scale. Why would you?

Taxation is complicated, you can’t just look at a workforce and say how much more money there would be if certain groups were taxed more because those changes to tax would in turn change the behaviour of the workers. It’s the same with big companies and how much tax they pay- it isn’t “fair” but if their tax bill went up by millions of pounds they wouldn’t just absorb that, they’d change something to make up for it (increase prices, decrease wages, move operations elsewhere, make redundancies). There’s always a knock on effect elsewhere.

Alexandra2001 · 17/12/2022 09:29

saleorbouy · 17/12/2022 08:25

Each 1% pay rise for nurses would cost £700milliion so the requested 19% would cost £13.3Billion annually.
I'm sure if the nurses got this then many other public service workers would be queuing up too.
The NHS is currently unsustainable and needs a complete rethink.
I hope the nurses get some of their payrise but 19% is madness.

So how much goes back in tax and NI ? less tax credits/UC? better retention....so increased return on training costs and far less spent on agency staff.

Increased morale leading to greater up take of nursing/AHP places.. better productivity... less sickness.. its well known low morale in a workforce leads to a whole host of issues.

Since 2010, nurses have seen a 20% fall in real terms pay (RCN figures) as have other blue light services...

Why shouldn't they all get a decent pay rise....? why should have all the money saved by Austerity (apparently) only go to the likes of the Sunaks or the Hunts or the Zahawi's ?

The nursing dispute can be paused by just talking about pay...

Why won't the Govt even do this????

Iamthewombat · 17/12/2022 09:10

RooRooCooChoo · 16/12/2022 09:27

OK, I'll bite.

I currently have 2 children under 3 in full time childcare. I pay £3,000 per month in nursery fees. I believe that childcare should be free or heavily subsidised. I would happily pay that £3,000 in additional taxation to subsidise public services such as childcare, healthcare, social care and all the other benefits which come from being the citizen of a country with a functional welfare state.

Clearly, I can afford to pay the £3,000 per month that I am currently paying for childcare. I cannot afford to pay a high rate of taxation on top of the £3,000 per month but in a properly funded system I wouldn't have to. The services that I am now forced to pay for out of my post-tax income - such as childcare, dental care, extortionate train fares - would be financed through receipts from general taxation.

This is what is so disingengenuous about you 'whatabouters'; you insist on double counting! Of course very few people can currently afford to pay higher taxes. We're currently paying through the nose for privately procured, expensive services. If we all paid in taxation what we pay for those services we'd see significant cuts in current levels of household expenditure.

So you’d pay extra tax provided that you got a load of free stuff in exchange so that you weren’t really paying more? Hahaha. How selfless.

Tax doesn’t work like that, I’m afraid. There have to be net contributors. I’m one of them, and proud of it. The people who generate more than they get back are the people paying for the state pension, and UC, and all the other stuff that poorer people need: that’s how society functions.

Your furious rant about “you whatabouters” rather gives away the fact that you don’t like being called on your own BS.

CoffeeBoy · 17/12/2022 09:04

Well maybe the6 could request a refund of the £223million they paid Baroness Mourne for useless ppe. Because apparently they’re currently not going to bother. 🤷‍♀️ And that £223million is the tip of the iceberg. But hey, they seem happy to give their friends hundreds of millions of pounds for nothing!

Ginsloth · 17/12/2022 09:03

A PP mentioned about the role of a nurse changing over the years and I think that’s a very good point. (Sorry I can’t find it to quote)

Go back 15-20 years, a nurse’s role was closer to that of today’s HCA.

So along with our pay not increasing with inflation, we’ve also gradually been expected to gain more skills and take on more responsibility with no reward.

Ginsloth · 17/12/2022 09:00

Overthebow · 17/12/2022 08:45

Yes it’s just a ridiculous amount to ask for. And there’s so much focus on nurses but really if they got it then everyone would want it, there’s a lot of different roles in the addenda for change who would all deserve it too. Then there’s teachers who would then also want the same, admin, police, the list is endless.

I’ve been trying really hard, genuinely, to understand the different viewpoints posted on this thread so far.
What I can’t get my head around is this idea of “if nurses get a pay rise, so should teachers/admin/any other profession”.
Well, yeah, they should. No public sector pay should drag massively behind inflation over an extended period like it has done. So what are we to do? None of us strike and all stay badly paid? Or one organisation strike, and the rest might follow? Why would that be such a bad thing?

As for the repeated notions that 19% is absurd, it’s called a starting negotiation. You go in higher, the government hopefully enter negotiations and come back with an offer. We’re not expecting 19%. We’ve had a real terms pay cut over the last decade, the 19% represents 5% over inflation, giving us room for negotiations.

Overthebow · 17/12/2022 08:45

saleorbouy · 17/12/2022 08:25

Each 1% pay rise for nurses would cost £700milliion so the requested 19% would cost £13.3Billion annually.
I'm sure if the nurses got this then many other public service workers would be queuing up too.
The NHS is currently unsustainable and needs a complete rethink.
I hope the nurses get some of their payrise but 19% is madness.

Yes it’s just a ridiculous amount to ask for. And there’s so much focus on nurses but really if they got it then everyone would want it, there’s a lot of different roles in the addenda for change who would all deserve it too. Then there’s teachers who would then also want the same, admin, police, the list is endless.

Emotionalsupportviper · 17/12/2022 08:40

I hope the nurses get some of their payrise but 19% is madness.

I don't think they are expecting 19% - this is an opening negotiating position.

The reason the NHS is unsustainable is because successive Tory govts have deliberately made it so - underfunding, contracts to Tory supporting firms, rather than the most competitive, expert ones etc.

There are too may of our politicians on the payroll of too many big businesses - and American insurance and pharmaceutical companies are itching to get their hands on it.

Of course we don't have to have the American system - we could go for one of the European ones.

But we won't

We'll get the American one, and people will be made bankrupt if they get big bills - just as they are over there. I wish to Christ we had a good, strong opposition who would just blow this lot out of the water - the ammunition is there; the support is there; the decent politicians aren't.

saleorbouy · 17/12/2022 08:25

Each 1% pay rise for nurses would cost £700milliion so the requested 19% would cost £13.3Billion annually.
I'm sure if the nurses got this then many other public service workers would be queuing up too.
The NHS is currently unsustainable and needs a complete rethink.
I hope the nurses get some of their payrise but 19% is madness.

Alexandra2001 · 17/12/2022 08:19

Emotionalsupportviper · 17/12/2022 08:06

The govt claim "the country can't afford it", but are managing to afford subsidising the rail companies to the tune of £30 mill/ week to induce them to stand firm against the strikers.

Strikers are losing wages, businesses are losing money, public is being massively inconvenienced, rail companies are losing NOTHING and the govt it pulling all of the strings.

Yes the Cons want the strikes... a: want to break & humiliate workers, putting them back in their boxes... knowing they can't afford to keep losing pay and b: use the strikes to attack Labour with.

The damage to the UK ie us lot ? who cares.

Emotionalsupportviper · 17/12/2022 08:17

Alexandra2001 · 17/12/2022 08:12

You ve either mis read or are deliberately ignoring what i wrote.

Staff shortages.... fix that and the NHS will improve.. no one has any time to support staff, too many PT workers because they simply find it too stressful.... as not enough staff.

You cannot fix or reform, remodel.. whatever you want to call it .. unless staffing is sorted first.

imho there are too many PT staff, so deal with childcare, pay, parking, shifts... longer term, more training places & open up nhs to EU workers, so no visas, no health insurances, right to bring in family, unlimited right to remain.

We should not be signing deals with Ghana to do the same, whilst refusing to do similar with EU.

Ghana is a developing country, EU member states are not... its immoral.

Given the constraints on the ballot majorities for strikes (the toughest in Europe) i think you will find there were majorities for strike action in every trust in England, just not enough to make strikes lawful.

Good post.

Emotionalsupportviper · 17/12/2022 08:16

RooRooCooChoo · 17/12/2022 06:58

@RosesAndHellebores Desperately trying to ignore the "women should stay in the homes" argument for the sake of my sanity, it's quite clear you don't understand my point.

I believe in all sorts of state provided free services, childcare being one. I also believe in state-owned transport, power and water infrastructure, health and social care etc etc. I believe that the way to pay for these goods is through general taxation. Were we to pay for them out of taxation we would no longer need to pay for them out of the money that currently remains after taxation. Therefore the financial burden on our net salary would be completely different. It's a very simple point.

Excellent post.

Some decades ago, when the Beatles were at the height of their fame, they were paying 95p in the £1 in tax. All very high earners were.

Then the Tories capped the maximum at 50p and the rich got richer at an obscenely fast rate, and the essential services went downhill because they weren't supported, and the poor got poorer and poorer.

The likes of Jacob Rees-Smug should not be able to filter their money through offshore account to avoid even the mediocre tax levels they're paying.

He and his ilk are the people who are breaking this country and robbing it blind - not the striking nurses, rail workers etc. The govt is working hard to divide and conquer the electorate, and to disenfranchise as many "undesirable" voters as possible with the new ID measures. They are trying to remove workers single weapon - the right to strike, and withdraw their labour; they are taking away so many civil liberties, such as the right to peaceful protest - and we are letting them do it!

They are being aided by the media which only very selectively reports what is happening - too many newspapers and news organisations are no longer independent. The few individuals who are and who try to speak out are silenced.

We live under a fascist dictatorship.

Alexandra2001 · 17/12/2022 08:12

RosesAndHellebores · 17/12/2022 07:45

@Alexandra2001 if your dd is being shat upon by staff and management does that not indicate the NHS as it stands is totally broken? Presumably the patients have just had enough. Paying nurses more without restructuring the NHS and sorting out its toxic culture won't hp the overall picture. I accept it will help individual nurses. Support for the strike though was not that widespread; very few hospitals participated.

You ve either mis read or are deliberately ignoring what i wrote.

Staff shortages.... fix that and the NHS will improve.. no one has any time to support staff, too many PT workers because they simply find it too stressful.... as not enough staff.

You cannot fix or reform, remodel.. whatever you want to call it .. unless staffing is sorted first.

imho there are too many PT staff, so deal with childcare, pay, parking, shifts... longer term, more training places & open up nhs to EU workers, so no visas, no health insurances, right to bring in family, unlimited right to remain.

We should not be signing deals with Ghana to do the same, whilst refusing to do similar with EU.

Ghana is a developing country, EU member states are not... its immoral.

Given the constraints on the ballot majorities for strikes (the toughest in Europe) i think you will find there were majorities for strike action in every trust in England, just not enough to make strikes lawful.