Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
Catlady2021 · 24/12/2022 22:55

I also agree that just throwing money at the NHS doesn’t solve the problems either.
They have tried that model for decades and look where we’re at.
Just giving the NHS a few billion a year isn’t going to help. It needs a massive overhaul and get rid of lots of management roles.

Catlady2021 · 24/12/2022 22:52

We’ve also got lots of people who’ve took early retirement and Brexit, which has helped escalate the labour shortage.

Catlady2021 · 24/12/2022 22:51

I’m not saying they are wrong or right but I’m amazed that border force can strike. The police obviously can’t.

ivykaty44 · 24/12/2022 19:32

There just isn’t more money, can’t get back which was already spent (and one off payments or tax hits won’t sustain increased pay year after year.

yet there is the millions paid to the share holders and the billions that the likes of shell are making.

www.opendemocracy.net/en/firstgroup-abellio-rail-strikes-rmt-shareholders-payout/

5 million in salary and £500 million to shareholders, then ask workers to take a wages cut.

shell had profits of $9.5 billion for the 3rd quarter of 2022

actually paying tax would be a start, we all know the longstanding zero tax payments of very wealthy companies, that could be changed but its choosen not to do so

Unifolorn · 24/12/2022 19:31

OMG12 · 24/12/2022 18:54

There just isn’t more money, can’t get back which was already spent (and one off payments or tax hits won’t sustain increased pay year after year.

the thing is all professions are seeing mass exodus of staff. No salaries have kept pace with inflation. Everyone is having to get used to a different standard of living. Nurses are paid more than the median wage. Train drivers a lot more. There’s a lot of people in the public, private and third sectors paid a lot less but can’t strike. Previously well paid professions are now fair to middling.

most can’t afford more taxes, the government haven’t got the funds to pay out extra without extra income.

random statements about closing tax loopholes, use the billons paid for x, tax y more are pie in the sky blaming of others usually with no back up.

when it comes down to it. The demanded pay rises just aren’t feasible. There are a small amount of very rich people, there !always will be.

The only people who can't strike are the police and the armed forces, technically anyone else can, if people volunteer to be union reps I'm sure they can find out more. I know people will be offended by this but some jobs are more important to society than others. Without nurses people die or have a much lesser quality of life. You can't replace nurses easily as it requires a degree, even if they abolished that there would be a level of competence and experience required to be safe within the role. Many other staff could be replaced if need be that's the sad truth. Areas that are struggling are those industries where cheap labour has previously been exploited, but for stuff like food retail the companies would find the money if they needed to, they turn huge profits.

Again this isn't about peoples worth as people, but some jobs are more valuable.

OMG12 · 24/12/2022 18:54

There just isn’t more money, can’t get back which was already spent (and one off payments or tax hits won’t sustain increased pay year after year.

the thing is all professions are seeing mass exodus of staff. No salaries have kept pace with inflation. Everyone is having to get used to a different standard of living. Nurses are paid more than the median wage. Train drivers a lot more. There’s a lot of people in the public, private and third sectors paid a lot less but can’t strike. Previously well paid professions are now fair to middling.

most can’t afford more taxes, the government haven’t got the funds to pay out extra without extra income.

random statements about closing tax loopholes, use the billons paid for x, tax y more are pie in the sky blaming of others usually with no back up.

when it comes down to it. The demanded pay rises just aren’t feasible. There are a small amount of very rich people, there !always will be.

rwalker · 24/12/2022 18:47

Catlady2021 · 24/12/2022 18:08

The Tories want strikes, they can blame the public sector for failing the NHS , then bring out their privatisation plans.
Anyone think I’m right to think this ?

Somethings got to happen with nhs who knows privatisation of some of it might not be a bad thing
there's been escalating problems for decades under various parties
the way it’s run us a shambles
but they dismiss this and hide behind funding
there’s a live thread on here most posters work for nhs shocking examples of waste
prople are totally brainwashed into thinking it’s purely about funding
new government throw money at it and it’s sorted
it won’t there are many problems as well as funding without sorting them as well you might as well set fire to the extra funding

Catlady2021 · 24/12/2022 18:08

The Tories want strikes, they can blame the public sector for failing the NHS , then bring out their privatisation plans.
Anyone think I’m right to think this ?

Catlady2021 · 24/12/2022 18:07

Agency staff nurses being paid £300 per shift. Just imagine what the NHS pays the agency.
So isn’t it better to pay the nurses a better wage in the first place , rather than pay the private sector double ?

The Tories don’t have a track record of listening to unions though, I’d imagine they’ll let the strikes go on so the NHS is broken up and contracted to the private sector.

Surely people can see what the conservatives are doing? It’s an ideology. Market competition, their mates get contracts. They tried to do it with prisons, only many failed.

DrManhattan · 23/12/2022 09:06

@mimi0708 exactly
I wish more people would see this

Tangled123 · 21/12/2022 21:12

I can’t really afford to pay more tax at the moment. After I pay my fixed bills (like mortgage and childcare), I have very little left. In theory, I would be ok paying more but only if the big corporations with all the money paid their fair share first.

mimi0708 · 21/12/2022 21:05

Well maybe if the tories didn't hand out all the money to Michelle Mone or waste it during the mini budget fiasco we would have money. Also there always seems to be money for their cronies and friends but never for us poor public peasants

LauraIAm · 21/12/2022 20:51

@chopc A key issue in our economy is that too few people work, and that working people work too few hours. Before you even talk about tax rates people have to go to work in the first place. There’s a lot of virtue signalling on this threat but in another recent thread 50% of people didn’t even think they had a moral obligation to work, let alone pay higher taxes - www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4679367-are-we-morally-obliged-to-work. Given that we seem to need more money to look after people who can’t work and people aren’t willing to work voluntarily, in my opinion the first step has to be more action getting people into work. This could be carrot eg NHS fast track for people with health conditions limiting their ability to work, and stick eg stricter conditions for disability benefits.

FixTheBone · 21/12/2022 20:39

LexMitior · 17/12/2022 15:18

Nobody thinks nurses will get 19 per cent. It is a negotiable figure and the Government need to get on and talk to them. That is basic industrial policy which is instead being driven by a kind of collective idiocy where the Government decide they will not.

I think nearly everyone in the country sees that. Nobody is fooled by this approach who has a functioning brain - nursing is not a militant grouping of some kind.

Junior doctors are also likely to strike. This is a mess; an avoidable one, but is kept going for reasons which is about political careers.

It is a mistake.

And soon after that, consultants.

You think the nurses are militant, consultants are considering asking for 35% pay restoration, plus inflation linked salary, plus fixing the pension scheme.

LexMitior · 21/12/2022 17:44

Btw the logic is immaculate- the Tories have always "get a better job".

I don't know why they seem surprised that they do. Good luck to them. The Government don't value them, it seems that public don't either. Unless you have money to pay for private medicine I would really suppose them while they still are motivated by something else other than money.

LexMitior · 21/12/2022 17:40

No it's the market. Public sector wages plus pension good.

Agency wages that don't meet that and a third more? No, not worth.

Tories seem to like market forces except for things like public sector jobs. Cut the pension and give an agency rate? No, people don't take that deal.

FixTheBone · 21/12/2022 15:39

Madamecastafiore · 21/12/2022 14:50

Fixthebone you give the agency workers the positions they're struggling to fill at a decent wage. They're obviously already qualified and most of them already work for the nhs.

Not sure many of them will go for the same job, for half the money.

Its called market forces, and its been brought into every part of the NHS, apart from wages, because as a monopoly employer, with a generous pension scheme and a positive ideology, many people were happy to sacrifice cash, for security and principles.

The value of the pensions have been eroded by 25% in the last 10 years, significantly more for high earners, and wages are 15% down on 2008 for most afc staff, closer to 30% for consultants.

Can't have it both ways, and employees know this, 10 years ago if someone was off sick, there was usually enough people around to cover, now, with everything already on minimum staffing levels, if there's a gap, the trust is going to have to pay a market rate, or close that service.

It's so desperately close to the wire that I was an hour a way from closing one of the largest major trauma centres in the country because a single junior doctor overnight wasn't given IT access needed to do their job.

helford · 21/12/2022 14:54

Madamecastafiore · 21/12/2022 14:50

Fixthebone you give the agency workers the positions they're struggling to fill at a decent wage. They're obviously already qualified and most of them already work for the nhs.

What? The ones who already work for the NHS? they already have a FT job.
Do you want them to have two FT jobs?

What they are doing is working a BH or a weekend to earn extra money.

A decent wage is what they are striking for.

Madamecastafiore · 21/12/2022 14:52

To say I'd drop dead whilst waiting is more of a tongue in cheek joke. I mean I'd already be dead if I had to wait on an ambulance. 111 called me one for a suspected heart attack a few months ago (I did tell them I wasn't having a heart attack but due to my sex and age they insisted they needed one) took 90 minutes.

Madamecastafiore · 21/12/2022 14:50

Fixthebone you give the agency workers the positions they're struggling to fill at a decent wage. They're obviously already qualified and most of them already work for the nhs.

Isitsixoclockalready · 21/12/2022 14:46

If the government believes that their approach is correct then there is a simple way to settle it - call a general election. We'll find out via the ballot box if people agree with them or not.

Emotionalsupportviper · 21/12/2022 14:46

My theory is, to pull the sick pay and I think the sickness will fall significantly.

Sickness won't fall. Taking sick time off work might - and that's exactly what we need - ill people trying to take care of even iller ones.

Have you ever tried joined-up thinking?

Emotionalsupportviper · 21/12/2022 14:41

PrincessConstance · 17/12/2022 15:58

Despite the fact, other industries with significantly more stress and responsibilities have lower rates of sickness.

And to quote stompythedinosaur.
Another poster has already shown the NHS has a long-standing issue with recruitment, this isn't new. I fully support the 19% pay increase. However, I'm nearly 100% sure the pay rises will NOT solve the problems with the service, bullying, and unprofessionalism that exist inwardly and outwardly in the NHS.

Despite the fact, other industries with significantly more stress and responsibilities have lower rates of sickness.

Which industries might those be?

Are they also working with skeleton staff and wondering how they are going to pay their bills, and getting pressured to do extra shifts because there's no-one to cover?

Or do they have decent wages/hours/ time off in lieu if the work an extra shift?

Asking for a wonderful health service.

Whatafool123 · 21/12/2022 14:29

Highlyflavouredgravy · 16/12/2022 06:12

Please don't think that any of this xhit show is down to lack of money thiugh. The defunding of public srvices is a very deliberate ideological tactic.

This.

But assuming it was necessary, yes, I would be happy to pay more tax for this.

FixTheBone · 21/12/2022 13:58

Madamecastafiore · 21/12/2022 13:30

No I'm not willing for my family to pay more. We use money now to shore up this shit show by way of paying for private healthcare and on top of the insurance private GPs appointments because you literally could drop dead whilst being in the telephone queue each morning trying to get an appointment at our surgery.

The money should come from cutting pensions and stopping using agency workers, employing them on a higher wage. Most of the agency workers in our ward were staff that worked there anyway. They'd be part time, do an NHS shift in the morning then an agency shift in the afternoon.
Just pay them more to only work for the nhs taking the agencies out of the equation.

If wages were higher they'd pay more tax, be happier as they'd feel valued and wouldn't be in receipt of in work benefits hopefully (which are the stupidest idea rolled out by any government ever!)

I know they're asking for something ludicrous like 19% at the moment but what do they actually want. Are they going in with a high number hoping to get that or is there room for negotiation?? If the government said they'd give 10% would that be ok?

You probably shouldn't be phoning your GP for something that could result in dropping dead....

Learned helplessness is the fault of an all-encompassing NHS though.

Easier said than done.

Which do you do first? Cut the agency workers and go short until you train and appoint replacements? Or train and appoint replacements while still paying for agency workers...

What if you stop agency workers, and nobody else wants to train because they can get better pay and conditions elsewhere?

Swipe left for the next trending thread