Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
WatchoRulo · 27/12/2022 18:41

Miss03852 · 27/12/2022 16:10

The people who are happy with these strikes are people who don’t regularly use the train and it doesn’t effect them in the slightest, so they can martyr themselves.

That's not true, even on this thread.

WatchoRulo · 27/12/2022 18:40

OMG12 · 24/12/2022 18:54

There just isn’t more money, can’t get back which was already spent (and one off payments or tax hits won’t sustain increased pay year after year.

the thing is all professions are seeing mass exodus of staff. No salaries have kept pace with inflation. Everyone is having to get used to a different standard of living. Nurses are paid more than the median wage. Train drivers a lot more. There’s a lot of people in the public, private and third sectors paid a lot less but can’t strike. Previously well paid professions are now fair to middling.

most can’t afford more taxes, the government haven’t got the funds to pay out extra without extra income.

random statements about closing tax loopholes, use the billons paid for x, tax y more are pie in the sky blaming of others usually with no back up.

when it comes down to it. The demanded pay rises just aren’t feasible. There are a small amount of very rich people, there !always will be.

So what you are saying is that capitalism will always rob most ordinary people?
Isn't that what people used to say about communism?

Catlady2021 · 27/12/2022 18:37

chopc · 27/12/2022 16:39

I don't know why we can't adopt a semi privatised health service like in Australia. People seem generally satisfied with the service they receive

Yes, I think they need to look at all options here. You cannot have a free healthcare system fully dependent on people paying taxes, with a rising ageing population.

It’s not all about extra money, they’ve been throwing billions extra at it for years.

Maybe the other problem is many younger British people now don’t want to go into the NHS to be nurses. Work Xmas, New year, night shift for no extra thanks. Make all these sacrifices, when their friends can do good jobs working in other fields, including working at home.
Thats without working anti social shifts and being chronically short staffed.

I just don’t think nursing is seen as an attractive career to people now ,as it was 30/40 years ago.

chopc · 27/12/2022 16:39

I don't know why we can't adopt a semi privatised health service like in Australia. People seem generally satisfied with the service they receive

OP posts:
helford · 27/12/2022 16:18

@Miss03852 I rarely use the train but i have had my out patients appoint postponed 3x now and i still support the NHS strikers.
I support the train strikes because it is about safety, not just pay, i want guards on trains and i want a driver too, Network Rail operatives should not go out working at night in all weathers, middle of no where, with minimum staff & not trained.

helford · 27/12/2022 16:14

Good Pensions and sick benefits do not pay the bills right now.

However, it is sad that things that were considered the norm in the private sector 30 or 40 years ago have now gone, in my sector 6months sick pay was the bare minimum, we had great loyalty to our employer, knowing that if anyone broke a leg or had a long term illness, they would stand by us.

NHS staff need a good sick scheme, they cannot go into work like most can with a sprained ankle or a heavy cold and many are subject to attack by the public but even so, many trusts do have quite draconian sick policies.

Miss03852 · 27/12/2022 16:10

The people who are happy with these strikes are people who don’t regularly use the train and it doesn’t effect them in the slightest, so they can martyr themselves.

Forever42 · 27/12/2022 16:05

Public sector has reasonable pensions compared to private sector (although nowhere near as good as they once were) and they STILL can't get enough staff. The pension is not a big enough incentive to keep people working in rubbish conditions for less money than they can earn elsewhere. It's the same with school holidays for teachers/TAs. They're not enough of a carrot to put up with the crappiness of the job. If they were, there wouldn't be recruitment issues.

Walkaround · 27/12/2022 16:00

Catlady2021 · 27/12/2022 13:19

Wasn’t there an old theory, something along the lines of the private sector may get paid more than the public sector ( in some fields) but the pension is better in the public sector?

Generally public sector workers get six months full sick pay, and have their pensions heavily subsidised by the government. I’ve never personally worked for a private sector company that can beat that.

Of course it depends on what job you do, your earnings etc etc.

😂It’s not really a good advert for the public sector that they treat you so badly you might need 6 months off work sick in order to cope. As for pensions, you can’t benefit fully from the pension unless you devote your entire working life to the service it is tied to - you can’t port it to a different employer. So bollocks to these features being hugely attractive to most people - either you are attracted to the career or you aren’t, you are not going to join just because if you are still working there at the end of your working life, you might get a reasonable pension (but might not, as the terms and conditions of pretty much all public sector pensions have been altered over the years). You might as well earn more and be free to invest your extra income as you see fit (and pay more tax to invest in better essential services) rather than be trapped by poor working conditions and lower than reasonable levels of pay on the fantasy that you will have a jolly retirement rolling in cash as your reward.

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/12/2022 13:49

Catlady2021 · 27/12/2022 10:02

Also worth pointing out that the Tories want to change the law every time something doesn’t go their way- including strike laws.

We are being steamrollered into fascism

Catlady2021 · 27/12/2022 13:19

Wasn’t there an old theory, something along the lines of the private sector may get paid more than the public sector ( in some fields) but the pension is better in the public sector?

Generally public sector workers get six months full sick pay, and have their pensions heavily subsidised by the government. I’ve never personally worked for a private sector company that can beat that.

Of course it depends on what job you do, your earnings etc etc.

Catlady2021 · 27/12/2022 13:14

Hold the government to account as the opposition? I’m not hearing enough from Starmer.

Alexandra2001 · 27/12/2022 10:29

Catlady2021 · 27/12/2022 10:00

The inequality in this country is shameful. People are freezing in their homes and can’t afford to eat whilst billionaires get even more billions.
The rich are getting richer and it’s us mugs paying the price for it.
Ive listened to what Mick Lynch has been saying not just about the railway’s but also wider society and how unfair it is.

If we’re not careful we’re all going to be working for Amazon on zero hour contracts with no employment benefits.

And where is Labour ? Why aren’t they doing more in opposition?

What do you want Labour to do?

Catlady2021 · 27/12/2022 10:02

Also worth pointing out that the Tories want to change the law every time something doesn’t go their way- including strike laws.

Catlady2021 · 27/12/2022 10:00

The inequality in this country is shameful. People are freezing in their homes and can’t afford to eat whilst billionaires get even more billions.
The rich are getting richer and it’s us mugs paying the price for it.
Ive listened to what Mick Lynch has been saying not just about the railway’s but also wider society and how unfair it is.

If we’re not careful we’re all going to be working for Amazon on zero hour contracts with no employment benefits.

And where is Labour ? Why aren’t they doing more in opposition?

Walkaround · 27/12/2022 09:38

Tory policy is to underfund public services and claim they are inefficient. Nobody ever created efficiency by simply starving an organisation of cash and telling people to do more with less, because the result is always the same - getting rid of people and expecting the same workload to be achieved with the same crappy infrastructure, zero investment, and far fewer, more stressed, harassed people with no energy, money or time resources whatsoever left over to think how to work more efficiently. The Tories have systematically destroyed systems and procedures and filled in the blanks with exactly the chaos you expect from the rudderless ship of an incompetently governed, poor country. Yes, I would like to pay more tax - to a government that believes in public service as a concept, not one that believes greed is good.

anaconda1831 · 27/12/2022 09:17

A 1% annual wealth tax on assets above 4 million - closing tax loopholes for billionaires - our tax evasion and avoidance hole is far bigger than the national debt or the asks of the workers on strike

Theres loads on money in this country it’s just concentrated in a few hanfs

SleepyRich · 27/12/2022 09:13

Jadebanditchillipepper · 26/12/2022 23:58

I'm sorry, I haven't read the whole thread but.....

How much do the NHS pay nurses compared to how much they pay agency nurses (not forgetting the fee that the agency take)?

How much do the NHS pay NHS junior doctors compared to how much they pay agency doctors (again, not forgetting the fee that the agency take)?

If they paid their in house staff enough in the first place, then they wouldn't have to pay three times as much to an agency.

Sort that out and then see how much of a defecit we have.....

Im n NHS Paramedic, if I switched to private then my hourly wage would double but I'd lose job security, training opportunities, holiday/sickness pay. But the shortage of staff through poor retention mostly since we've got strong recruitment means that loads of agency staff are employed long term, the agencies must be making an absolute fortune from the NHS!

BrinleyGirl · 27/12/2022 00:16

A good NHS and education system helps us to have a strong economy. The number of people of working age on long term sickness has soared. How does that help anyone?

Jadebanditchillipepper · 26/12/2022 23:58

I'm sorry, I haven't read the whole thread but.....

How much do the NHS pay nurses compared to how much they pay agency nurses (not forgetting the fee that the agency take)?

How much do the NHS pay NHS junior doctors compared to how much they pay agency doctors (again, not forgetting the fee that the agency take)?

If they paid their in house staff enough in the first place, then they wouldn't have to pay three times as much to an agency.

Sort that out and then see how much of a defecit we have.....

schoolsoutforever · 26/12/2022 21:02

I haven’t read the whole thread because it’s massive but, yes, I would take a modest tax increase. I’d also like to see a much bigger tax increase on the super rich and big business. Plus I’d like the tortes to stop giving massive contracts to their chums. These things would help. The inequality in this country is scandalous and I’d like a government to tackle these things, at the same time as funding a decent NHS and education system. I would pay a little more of my (teachers) salary to do so but I’d expect others to pay or economise too.

Emotionalsupportviper · 26/12/2022 20:48

Catlady2021 · 24/12/2022 18:08

The Tories want strikes, they can blame the public sector for failing the NHS , then bring out their privatisation plans.
Anyone think I’m right to think this ?

That is EXACTLY what they want.

And not just in the NHS.

SleepyRich · 26/12/2022 09:40

In theory if the services were properly funded then fewer staff would leave to join these private agencies. The NHS is then forced to pay exorbitant rates to these agencies in order to meet minimum safe staffing levels.

Better working conditions for staff, improved retention and reduce sickness levels - will give better quality service (staff not exhausted with overlode/pressure to work OT), no more headlines about paying some private agency x thousand pounds to cover a single nursing or doctor shift.

Alexandra2001 · 26/12/2022 08:36

@Catlady2021 I asked my DD that despite all the multitude of cock up and poor service she sees most days ... "what is the one think that would make the place run more smoothly?"

She replied "More staff and more management"

When i talk to her, the over whelming impression is lack of oversight and control.. well meaning people all operating in their bubbles and no one in overall charge.

Medics cannot do it all and any good organisation i ve worked worked for has had excellent management... there is also a huge demand for communication.. with both patients and family... So...
'Should medically trained staff be doing this?

my DD can often spend 30 or 40 minutes on the phone several times a day talking through care options with family members... most of whom will be highly critical (and get very angry) of what the NHS can offer whilst living 100s of miles away or in some case, live abroad.
Half the time she is doing a management role and not a caring one.

Sorry but imho the NHS needs a management overhaul, more of them/change in roles and much more long term and thoughtful funding.

...and stop this "we will give the the nhs 2billion this winter to do x y or z rubbish" which then gets wasted.

However, the NHS .... even under these conditions makes real positive differences to peoples lives each and every day and this shouldn't be forgotten either.

booklovingmum · 24/12/2022 22:55

As a firefighters wife, you can bet your ass I am more than willing to contribute.