Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/12/2022 06:47

I support the nurses yes.

I support the rail workers, who are concerned about public safety if National Rail only has a driver on board. I don't believe it's all about wages with those strikers but that's what we all immediately believe when we hear strikes. Also removing ticket sellers, how many times have the machines at the station broken down where you are?

Nurses are not just facing yet another real terms cut. It's the understaffing. The under funding.

If the whole total lack of PPE during the worst days of a pandemic doesn't show that money is being spent in the wrong way in hospitals, nothing will.

And yes, stop giving MPs sickening levels of expenses. Stop allowing them to be paid eye watering sums for sitting occasionally in a local MP surgery pretending to care when someone comes to them to complain about buses.

Stop allowing the likes of Michelle Mone to effectively help themselves to billions collectively. If someone on UC over claims by a few quid they are sanctioned and made to feel like a criminal. Yet time and again massive fraud occurs but it OK cos it's a mate of a Tory.

Make the likes of BP and British Gas pay proper taxes. Along with Amazon, Google etc. It's lies that they will pull out the country of they're made to pay properly. It would cost them a stupid amount to do that and not have a market in the UK.

There are ways to make it easy to pay these people properly. The government just doesn't want to.

greenacrylicpaint · 16/12/2022 06:46

yes I would.

I would also support 'working to rule' for caring staff (which should imo be the norm not exception).

Monkeyrules · 16/12/2022 06:45

Motnight · 16/12/2022 06:38

I am more than willing to pay more tax.

How much more would you be willing to pay?

Monkeyrules · 16/12/2022 06:43

I get your point OP and until recently I would have accepted that taxes would need to rise or money would be diverted away from other services to pay for the payrises.

Now I think there's so much money wasted by the government they should get on with tackling that and fund any payrises out of the money saved. However I expect that's asking too much of them!

Examples:
The lack of staff at HMRC resulting in repeated phone calls and letters to get the simplist of tasks done generating more paperwork and leading to errors in collecting tax in the first place.

Money wasted on handouts to railway companies that don't deliver a good service regardless of whether they make a loss or profit.

Academy schools (why filter money to the executive team at the expense of teachers and teaching assistants? You need them to run the school you greedy lot!)

Making student nurses pay for their own tuition fees and not getting the universities to increase places is a complete own goal and reversing this policy would have probably have helped existing nurses too by generating more staff to fill vacant positions.

I think the people running the country are incompetent. I looked at jobs on the civil service website and a lot of them involve gathering data to improve services which probably gets talked about by people in suits when it's plainly obvious where the waste is. The law makers love introducing more procedures and policies so implementing any real change is like wading through treacle.

WhaleInAManger · 16/12/2022 06:41

PAFMO · 16/12/2022 06:04

The govt could stop spunking it up the wall to back up their lies and empty promises.
Might be a start.

FPNI

Motnight · 16/12/2022 06:38

I am more than willing to pay more tax.

foxynoxy · 16/12/2022 06:37

In theory, yes, I would support higher taxes but I truly don't believe that underfunding of public services is the issue here.

Public services are grossly mismanaged at both government and service level. The wastage is obscene and until we have a grown up conversation about this and the part that we as the public also play (missed NHS appointments for example) then things will not improve.

Not a popular view I suspect but I wonder whether public sector workers would be prepared to sacrifice their defined benefit pensions for a pay rise? With the government paying around 25% in pension contributions on top of their salary, perhaps one solution is award significant pay rises but reduce the pension?

girlmom21 · 16/12/2022 06:37

I heard on the radio yesterday that abolishing tax breaks would make £6.7 billion and the increase the nurses want would only cost £1.6 billion.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 16/12/2022 06:37

No. I wouldn't. I wouldn't be happy with more money going to the NHS until an overhaul is done and the model changed.

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 16/12/2022 06:36

SueVineer · 16/12/2022 06:28

the third sector are usually (but not always) delivering services more efficiently and at less cost than the public sector.

the amounts paid to charities are a pittance compared to taxation.

Disagree they are more efficient. They are usually run on the backs of staff who tolerate the dire pay because they often offer family friendly hours and jobs that fit round the kids are not easy to find.
So you have underpaid staff doing what they can with a shoe string budget. It's nothing to aspire to. Charities bid for funding is competitive so it's a race to the bottom cost base wise and this does not improve services they do.
As a society we need employers who offer good pay and conditions, if all there are to choose from is gig economy jobs and crap pay options we all lose.

LucyWhipple · 16/12/2022 06:35

I would gladly pay more tax to feel confident that if I needed to call an ambulance, one would come. I don’t feel that at the moment.

But regardless, there is always money for the things governments want to spend on. For this government that’s giving money to their mates and benefiting themselves. Liz Truss’s decisions have cost us all far more than proper public sector pay rises would. Not funding the public sector properly is an ideological decision by people who don’t use it and believe people like them should get richer while everyone else stays in their boxes.

SueVineer · 16/12/2022 06:32

Inyournightgarden · 16/12/2022 06:26

Ridiculous post, I’m no fan of MP’s but they got a 2.9% pay rise, and there’s not many of them so total cost is peanuts

Agreed. Such a stupid point to make. There are only 650 MPs. They could up their salary to £1m each and it would still be a tiny overall cost in proportion. I don’t think they deserve a payrise but the cost of them is very small because they are so few.

FangedFrisbee · 16/12/2022 06:29

Nadhim Zahawi claimed 5000 of taxpayers money to heat his horses stables.

Maybe if they stopped spunking money up the wall they could afford it?

SueVineer · 16/12/2022 06:28

Whyjustwhy123 · 16/12/2022 06:25

The rise of the ‘third sector’ is an interesting one.

Remove and privatise public sector, increase charity sector - stealth tax. Just imagine what could be done if instead of us all paying to charities we paid that in tax.

the third sector are usually (but not always) delivering services more efficiently and at less cost than the public sector.

the amounts paid to charities are a pittance compared to taxation.

Inyournightgarden · 16/12/2022 06:26

HollyDollyChristmas · 16/12/2022 06:07

The same place they found the £££ for the MP’s pay rise.

Ridiculous post, I’m no fan of MP’s but they got a 2.9% pay rise, and there’s not many of them so total cost is peanuts

SueVineer · 16/12/2022 06:25

ThisWormHasTurned · 16/12/2022 06:11

Well Shell announced record breaking profits and paid 0 tax so….

Shell actually paid about $58.7 billion in tax globally in 2021. They just happen to not have paid anything in respect of North Sea drilling activities because of the facts of those activities that didn’t incur tax. So that’s not really helpful.

if we want better public services we have to be honest that WE have to pay for them. It isn’t the case that large companies are not being taxed and there is an easy solution. Large companies already pay vast amounts of tax and tax law is extremely complicated. There are no easy answers.

Whyjustwhy123 · 16/12/2022 06:25

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 16/12/2022 06:22

No personally I can't afford to pay more tax sorry. I work for a charity. We're very low paid and overworked too. Only we don't have a union. And everyone seems ro forget about us. It's all public sector workers vs private. Nobody even remembers there's a 3rd sector in these threads.

The rise of the ‘third sector’ is an interesting one.

Remove and privatise public sector, increase charity sector - stealth tax. Just imagine what could be done if instead of us all paying to charities we paid that in tax.

Whyjustwhy123 · 16/12/2022 06:23

OP please don’t suck up the PR that the Torries are so cleaver at distributing.

They want you to have this view, it’s smoke and mirrors. By making the public feel cross at Nurses, rail workers, etc we don’t focus our anger where it really should be.

  • Mini budget fiasco
  • PPE fiasco
  • Brexit financial fall out
  • Under taxing energy companies such as Shell etc

Your enemy is not a nurse who is trying to pay her heating. It’s a millionaire who is trying to become a billionaire.

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 16/12/2022 06:22

No personally I can't afford to pay more tax sorry. I work for a charity. We're very low paid and overworked too. Only we don't have a union. And everyone seems ro forget about us. It's all public sector workers vs private. Nobody even remembers there's a 3rd sector in these threads.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 16/12/2022 06:17

Yes of course.

And if people are paid higher wages they pay more income tax themselves (so the government gets some of it back anyway). Also, they will spend more on VAT rated products (so the government gets a bit more of it back), and they spend the money in the private sector, keeping that afloat, so maintaining employment and reducing redundancies, which increases the tax take even more, and reduces the benefit expenditure...

The economy is not a household budget.

Iamwhatiam52 · 16/12/2022 06:15

I'd be happy to pay more in taxes if it meant public sector workers such as nurses, fire and police officers got paid a decent wage for the jobs they do. Trouble is, if we pay more in tax, there's no way of ring fencing the increase for any particular sector.

I'd be even happier if we had a half decent government who stopped giving their pals million dollar contracts, themselves pay rises when they earn enough already and ensured big foreign companies paid their fair whack in taxes!

HettySunshine · 16/12/2022 06:14

This government is incredibly wasteful. They wasted BILLIONS of pounds buying unusable PPE from companies hastily set up by Tory donors and Tory peers.

They have also spent billions trying to shore up Brexit and make it palatable, when really it is the biggest white elephant we've had to accept in a very long time.

Every time the government is forced to u turn on one of their stupid ideas, it costs hundred of thousands, if not millions, of pounds.

The way I would fund all the pay rises and improvement of working conditions is to vote for a better government.

Disabrie22 · 16/12/2022 06:14

Public services have been under paid and under resourced for years - we are already suffering and it does need to be addressed.
To give you an example - teaching recruitment crisis. The starting wage for a teacher in no way reflects the hours or accountability.

Sirzy · 16/12/2022 06:14

If the staff where properly paid and the conditions where better then it would actually stop them wasting money through agency staff and cancelled clinics and operations.

add to that the money we lose through the goverment wasting and it shouldn’t be impossible.

DenholmElliot11 · 16/12/2022 06:13

the money for nurses pay rises will easily be able to be taken out of

  1. The money they spend on agency staff
  2. The money they will save by not having to top them up with universal credits.

But if that didn't cover it then i'd quite happily pay more taxes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread