Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
BobBobBobbing · 16/12/2022 07:38

Yes I would. I benefit from good public services directly (eg NHS) or indirectly (living in a nice country with opportunities equally available).

Unifolorn · 16/12/2022 07:37

Also regarding pensions, they're good but they're not as good for new starters as once were. Consultants are leaving in droves as pension changes mean they are paying thousands extra in tax for pay they have essentially already been taxed on- not great when we have a chronic shortage of them anyway.

This will be controversial but I wouldn't pay more tax for some departments to have increases. If you look how departments pay like the MoD map across to NHS its ludicrous.

LimeCheesecake · 16/12/2022 07:36

If we don’t pay more tax, we’ll pay more for healthcare anyway. Couple of months ago I had a private GP video call for £40 when I couldn’t get through to mine. I’ve paid £65 a time to see a physio as I just can’t get to see anyone on the NHS. FIL has spent £20k so far on private treatment after NHS wait lists were too long.

we are paying out for health insurance as well as taxes as we don’t think the NHS will always be there for us. Most middle class people will be paying more via insurance or private appointments. Might as well pay the same out in additional tax and have healthcare available to poor people as well as wealthy.

MarshaBradyo · 16/12/2022 07:35

TreadLight · 16/12/2022 07:33

Completely agree with you, if by "de-funding" you mean increasing the NHS budget in real terms every year (ignoring the extra money they got fire COVID)

Yes I see this term a lot on here but real terms spending has been going up

Fedupofdiets · 16/12/2022 07:35

Income tax is not the only way to generate taxes. We need to take a different approach and tax wealth not income.

Garys Economics - Who pays tax?

This man speaks so much sense, I would urge you to watch if you havent already heard of him.

poshme · 16/12/2022 07:34

Era · 16/12/2022 06:59

Not a popular view I suspect but I wonder whether public sector workers would be prepared to sacrifice their defined benefit pensions for a pay rise? With the government paying around 25% in pension contributions on top of their salary, perhaps one solution is award significant pay rises but reduce the pension?

this. With bells on. I’m sorry but the way things are portrayed is too simplistic. The pension cost taxpayers an absolute fortune. If the pension wasn’t so ridiculously generous then there would be more for salary. It’s about being realistic and putting the money where it needs to be (ie more cash now, not in retirement)

I say this as someone with a public sector pension pot

This is what they did to MPs. They scrapped the massive pensions (it's now contributory based) and gave them a pay rise. That is why their pay looks to have risen so much since 2010.

MP pay is now linked to public sector pay- in 2021 they got 0%, in 2022 2.7%.

For everyone saying scrap their expenses- how would you pay their staff? All MPs employ about 5 people on 'expenses'. Should they all just be sacked? Or should only rich people be MPs? Because if you scrap expenses, only rich people could afford to rent constituency offices, pay the staff, and buy everything necessary for the job.

If you stopped paying MPs their salary, and gave all the money to nurses instead, each nurse would get... £107.

Unifolorn · 16/12/2022 07:34

It's a valid question as I'm sure in reality most would grumble about rises in tax no matter how supportive they are.

The reality is that something major needs to be done if people want a functioning health service. For starters it is outrageous that HCAs are on just above minimum wage, no wonder we can't recruit anywhere near enough. Nurses are also leaving in droves, I have signed more leaving cards in the past few months than I have in the rest of my career. They aren't leaving as they're greedy, they're leaving as they've been able to secure jobs with much less stress but similar take home pay.

If terrifying how dire things are, I'd be scared to need admitting to hospital right now. Across the board HCPs are working well below safe numbers, ward numbers are bumped up by agency staff which isn't financially sustainable or good for patients. These tens of thousands of vacancies need to be filled or more will leave. People are still traumatised from covid, they're burnt out, they're exhausted and scared working so far under ratio each shift. It used to be there'd be peaks in winter which you knew were savage but there'd be light at the end of the tunnel; now there's not and its relentless. Maternity is on its absolute knees as well, you couldn't pay me to give birth in the current system.

Pay isn't the only factor but it would help retain people which in turn would address some of the other issues.

TreadLight · 16/12/2022 07:33

Highlyflavouredgravy · 16/12/2022 06:12

Please don't think that any of this xhit show is down to lack of money thiugh. The defunding of public srvices is a very deliberate ideological tactic.

Completely agree with you, if by "de-funding" you mean increasing the NHS budget in real terms every year (ignoring the extra money they got fire COVID)

For all those who support the strikes
Iamthewombat · 16/12/2022 07:33

FACupcake · 16/12/2022 07:27

Yes I would pay higher taxes for a fairer society. Next!

(P.S. Fuck the Tories.)

Yes but to you and all the others proudly declaring that you would pay more tax, I ask how much more?

The same question has already been asked by me and at least one other poster but funnily enough nobody has answered it.

How much more per year, in pounds sterling, would you pay in income tax to support public sector pay rises?

Saying “yes, I’d pay more” but not saying how much reminds me of the people who thought that an extra penny in the pound on income tax (a manifesto policy by an opposition party a few years ago to fund something specific) meant that they would be paying an extra penny per month. In total. Which of course they congratulated themselves on for being public spirited.

AdamRyan · 16/12/2022 07:33

PicaNewName · 16/12/2022 07:08

Was it 350 million we'd lost per week by being in the EU? Welll.... that's where.

Exactly!
I thought the whole point of Brexit was so those at the bottom got wage increases, as it cost us to be in the EU and there was artificial wage suppression from migrant workers.

So either this was a lie and there is no money in which cases heads should roll.

Or there is money from Brexit in which case the Tories should be using that.

I'd happily pay more tax, if I believed we had a competent government who would use it to improve the lives of most IK workers.

As it stands I think they'd use it to subsidise the shareholders of big business so I'm not happy to pay more, no

Moonmelodies · 16/12/2022 07:32

If my tax burden increases I will go on strike to get more income.

carefulcalculator · 16/12/2022 07:32

The £35 billion lost each year to unrecovered tax - fraud and evasion - might help.

Personally I'd be keen to go after some of that. Very hard to understand why the Tories don't tackle this issue...

FACupcake · 16/12/2022 07:27

Yes I would pay higher taxes for a fairer society. Next!

(P.S. Fuck the Tories.)

Iamthewombat · 16/12/2022 07:26

The OP has only posted once, with a valid question, but you have unilaterally decided that she isn’t decent?

Reasoned debate thrives on Mumsnet!

Forever42 · 16/12/2022 07:25

The NHS is finished as a free-at-the-point-of-use model.
We have 2 choices.
Pay either directly by partial privatization or pay via the tax system.

Most countries that are not free at the point of use still have a higher proportion of government spending on healthcare (as a proportion of GDP) than the UK, eg France, Germany, Japan, Australia. Even if you change the model, government funding still needs to increase.

Tolerant · 16/12/2022 07:25

Era · 16/12/2022 06:59

Not a popular view I suspect but I wonder whether public sector workers would be prepared to sacrifice their defined benefit pensions for a pay rise? With the government paying around 25% in pension contributions on top of their salary, perhaps one solution is award significant pay rises but reduce the pension?

this. With bells on. I’m sorry but the way things are portrayed is too simplistic. The pension cost taxpayers an absolute fortune. If the pension wasn’t so ridiculously generous then there would be more for salary. It’s about being realistic and putting the money where it needs to be (ie more cash now, not in retirement)

I say this as someone with a public sector pension pot

Here’s some facts, not something I “heard on the radio”.

From www.nhsemployers.org/articles/pension-contributions-and-tax-relief:

For the 2019-20, 2020-21, 2021-22 and 2022-23 scheme years, employers are responsible for paying 14.38 per cent of contributions, with the remaining 6.3 per cent being funded centrally.

From www.teacherspensions.co.uk/employers/managing-members/contributions/calculating-contributions.aspx

Since September 2019, the Employer contribution rate is 23.68%, including the 0.08% administration levy.

Rates the average joe working in the private sector can only dream of.

HerReputationMadeItDifficultToProceed · 16/12/2022 07:23

Highlyflavouredgravy · 16/12/2022 06:10

Yes of course I'd be willing to pay more tax.
Paying a decent chunk of tax in return for a fair society os right and good.
Why? Are you not?

This. Although based on their OP I feel like "decency" isn't a word @chopc is much associated with.

FitAt50 · 16/12/2022 07:21

MarshaBradyo · 16/12/2022 07:06

Each 1% rise is £800m apparently

BBC says that's untrue. It's £700m and that figure is for every single NHS employee (1.7 million) and not just nurses (300,000).

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 16/12/2022 07:21

Not being able to recruit and retain nurses, paramedics and teachers is very expensive for the country, both short and long term. We all suffer if hospitals can't recruit and retain nurses.

It's not all about pay though, the working conditions are a huge factor in people leaving these careers, but the pay is easier to address.

I would pay more tax to make under-staffed public sector jobs more appealing.

Long term in NHS we do need to plan as a country what we want the NHS to do.

HerReputationMadeItDifficultToProceed · 16/12/2022 07:21

Hopefully from the money accumulated from not paying MPs ludicrous expenses and other various ways countless millions are wasted each year in our parliament.

PrincessConstance · 16/12/2022 07:20

The NHS is finished as a free-at-the-point-of-use model.
We have 2 choices.
Pay either directly by partial privatization or pay via the tax system.
Public goods by their very nature become overused and swamped by free riders.
This is where we are. The road system is the same. The Uk public needs to forget about VFM re cheap and cheerful and put their hands in their pockets.

This applies across the wider economy, private businesses are upping prices to accommodate higher overall costs. Trades have upped their prices. The pre covid world is NEVER coming back. Even DP this week has decided to up his 1st hr charge from £80 to £130.

BeeDavis · 16/12/2022 07:19

They could start by toning down the king’s coronation next year.

FitAt50 · 16/12/2022 07:19

HollyDollyChristmas · 16/12/2022 06:07

The same place they found the £££ for the MP’s pay rise.

650 MPs Vs 5.5 million public sector workers including over 300,000 nurses. I support the strikers but can we stop with all the anti politicians stuff.

Choccolatte · 16/12/2022 07:17

Whyjustwhy123 · 16/12/2022 06:23

OP please don’t suck up the PR that the Torries are so cleaver at distributing.

They want you to have this view, it’s smoke and mirrors. By making the public feel cross at Nurses, rail workers, etc we don’t focus our anger where it really should be.

  • Mini budget fiasco
  • PPE fiasco
  • Brexit financial fall out
  • Under taxing energy companies such as Shell etc

Your enemy is not a nurse who is trying to pay her heating. It’s a millionaire who is trying to become a billionaire.

This

Quent · 16/12/2022 07:15

I personally am willing to pay more taxes, but I also believe that with decent planning, oversight and management it is possible to properly fund our public services without most people having to pay significantly more taxes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread