Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
WordtoYoMumma · 16/12/2022 08:01

Tax the rich.

Yeh, I'd be happy to pay more tax if it meant saving the NHS. But my piddly wage isn't gonna help anyone. Tax The Rich. Corporation Tax needs to increase. Stricter laws about tax avoidance. Windfall tax.

TAX THE RICH

Bayleaf25 · 16/12/2022 08:01

Yes.
They could find money (many of the reasons already listed). It’s clear that some change needs to happen.

Unifolorn · 16/12/2022 08:01

sst1234 · 16/12/2022 07:57

There is not more money. All the lockdown already spent all of it. £1 trillion of it to be precise. Yes that’s right. The Covid restrictions to make you ‘feel safe’ cost £1 trillion of borrowed and printed money.

Of course you can continue to borrow and print more, but I think everyone here already has a problem wit the 15% inflation we have now. So it might not be such a good idea.

It’s like some people in this forum don’t understand a single thing about the economy. You can’t have it both ways. Froth at the mouth in the summer of 2020 because your neighbour took their second walk of the the day. And demon higher pay for public sector workers when the chickens come home to roost.

What do you propose then to address the chronic shortage of healthcare staff? At this point the nhs cannot even provide adequate emergency care which is terrifying.

poshme · 16/12/2022 08:00

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 16/12/2022 07:44

The same place they found the 44 million pounds to pay for the front bench MPs expense claims. I.e. not my pocket.

So MPs should sack all their staff? They're public sector workers. Their wages make up the majority of expense claims.

Stompythedinosaur · 16/12/2022 08:00

The quote missed off my message! I was pointed out the MP pay rise in response to the pp who claimed they had only had a small payrise.

Unifolorn · 16/12/2022 08:00

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 16/12/2022 07:56

Yep, less generous pension scheme could fund a raise I reckon.

I know lots who already opt out of paying much into their pension (the amount the employer then pays in is consumerate so they're getting less employer contiribution). This creates its own issues though, many people once they reach say 50 and are exhausted by shift work and their bodies tired from the physical demands only really stay for the pension. The pension trap is nothing new and is widely recognised of keeping highly experienced people in these jobs- does this not just create more issues?

sst1234 · 16/12/2022 08:00

AelinAshriver · 16/12/2022 07:55

Well, We had the 11 billion that Rishi cost us when he forgot to insure the national debt. And we had the 37 billion for the failed Test and Trace that never really cut infection. And we had the 9 billion for the defective PPE. And we had the 30 billion that Liz Truss cost us in her Mini Budget. And of course we've had the 31 billion that Brexit has cost us so far. Which adds us to 118 billion.

So there's no magic money tree and we simply don't have the money for these pay rises for the public sector. It's just maths. Or is it a corrupted Tory Government.

The easiest way to find the money would be A series of weath tax:

End Non Dom Status - 3 billion pounds. Annual 1% tax on wealth over 5million - 10 billion pounds. 45p income tax rate over £80,000 and a 50p rate for income over £125,000 - 6 billion. Finally, if you equalise dividends and capital gains tax with income tax rates, that would raise 21 billion pounds. These measures would raise 40 billion.
This isnt thinking about a windfall tax or ending the loophole which allows the rich to not pay tax on their companies (Google, Amazon etc) or the super rich squirrling away their billions in offshore accounts...

Perhaps MP's could put an end to paying their energy bills from their second homes on expenses and allowances when they earn £84,000 anyway. This is when their pay has increased by 28% since 2010 and have had a £2200 pay rise this year alone during the cost of living crisis.

But there's no money for nurses....

Oh dear. These ideas are even worse than what the government has already done. A lesson in how to kill your economy stone dead. No wonder the country is a mess when the general population comes out with stuff like this.

Stompythedinosaur · 16/12/2022 07:58

MP pay has increased 28% since 2010.

sst1234 · 16/12/2022 07:57

There is not more money. All the lockdown already spent all of it. £1 trillion of it to be precise. Yes that’s right. The Covid restrictions to make you ‘feel safe’ cost £1 trillion of borrowed and printed money.

Of course you can continue to borrow and print more, but I think everyone here already has a problem wit the 15% inflation we have now. So it might not be such a good idea.

It’s like some people in this forum don’t understand a single thing about the economy. You can’t have it both ways. Froth at the mouth in the summer of 2020 because your neighbour took their second walk of the the day. And demon higher pay for public sector workers when the chickens come home to roost.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 16/12/2022 07:56

Yep, less generous pension scheme could fund a raise I reckon.

AelinAshriver · 16/12/2022 07:55

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

Well, We had the 11 billion that Rishi cost us when he forgot to insure the national debt. And we had the 37 billion for the failed Test and Trace that never really cut infection. And we had the 9 billion for the defective PPE. And we had the 30 billion that Liz Truss cost us in her Mini Budget. And of course we've had the 31 billion that Brexit has cost us so far. Which adds us to 118 billion.

So there's no magic money tree and we simply don't have the money for these pay rises for the public sector. It's just maths. Or is it a corrupted Tory Government.

The easiest way to find the money would be A series of weath tax:

End Non Dom Status - 3 billion pounds. Annual 1% tax on wealth over 5million - 10 billion pounds. 45p income tax rate over £80,000 and a 50p rate for income over £125,000 - 6 billion. Finally, if you equalise dividends and capital gains tax with income tax rates, that would raise 21 billion pounds. These measures would raise 40 billion.
This isnt thinking about a windfall tax or ending the loophole which allows the rich to not pay tax on their companies (Google, Amazon etc) or the super rich squirrling away their billions in offshore accounts...

Perhaps MP's could put an end to paying their energy bills from their second homes on expenses and allowances when they earn £84,000 anyway. This is when their pay has increased by 28% since 2010 and have had a £2200 pay rise this year alone during the cost of living crisis.

But there's no money for nurses....

PhilInt · 16/12/2022 07:54

Whataretheodds · 16/12/2022 06:10

Maybe if they hadn't handed £billions in dodgy PPE contracts to their mates there would be a bit more cash to fund the NHS.

Yes, it will cost more than it currently does. What do you think is the alternative? Buying in agency staff won't be cheaper. Buying in services from private hospitals won't be cheaper. Having to go private won't be cheaper for me as an individual.

☝️ this

MarshaBradyo · 16/12/2022 07:51

Raising taxes sounds more popular on mn but it wouldn’t go down as well with voters otherwise Labour would lead on it across the board rather than small yield changes.

Unifolorn · 16/12/2022 07:51

^ this applies to all public spending not just nhs.

Unifolorn · 16/12/2022 07:50

But what i would want more than ever is efficient auditing and oversight of government spending and procurement policies.

Efficient auditing I agree needs addressing, but due to transparency laws you can view all contracts awarded above PCR threshold online, and policies are also available to view.

Tolerant · 16/12/2022 07:48

BirmaBrite · 16/12/2022 07:42

Not a popular view I suspect but I wonder whether public sector workers would be prepared to sacrifice their defined benefit pensions for a pay rise? With the government paying around 25% in pension contributions on top of their salary, perhaps one solution is award significant pay rises but reduce the pension?

So I pay 10% of my wage in pension contributions as a nurse and that is topped up by the Government by another 25% ? Are you sure ?

@BirmaBrite

Its actually just over 20% @BirmaBrite , according to your employer’s website.

From www.nhsemployers.org/articles/pension-contributions-and-tax-relief:

For the 2019-20, 2020-21, 2021-22 and 2022-23 scheme years, employers are responsible for paying 14.38 per cent of contributions, with the remaining 6.3 per cent being funded centrally.

Brefugee · 16/12/2022 07:47

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

not in the UK but the same would apply here if it happened: yes i am prepared to pay more tax.
But what i would want more than ever is efficient auditing and oversight of government spending and procurement policies.
Followed by an upgrade to the NHS in terms of processes and streamlining and the funding of enough admin staff to leave clinical staff free to do their jobs properly and with enough resources and good terms and conditions so that their health and that of the patients isn't being put at risk.

What you seem to be saying, OP, is it's shit. You know it's shit but you don't want to pay a penny extra to help improve it. Slow handclap.

fernz · 16/12/2022 07:47

Rising salaries while prices keep going up just as fast seems rather pointless. Instead we need something like a universal basic income so that everyone can have a decent standard of living and more people will be able to continue spending.

Public sector wage rises alone will leave millions falling through the gaps, seeing their own living standards decline.

Overthebow · 16/12/2022 07:46

Yes I would pay more tax, as long as everyone paid more tax not just the working population (so income tax rose not NI rise). I don’t understand when people say NHS deserve more money but aren’t willing to pay for it themselves, where do they think the money comes from?

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 16/12/2022 07:44

The same place they found the 44 million pounds to pay for the front bench MPs expense claims. I.e. not my pocket.

BirmaBrite · 16/12/2022 07:42

Not a popular view I suspect but I wonder whether public sector workers would be prepared to sacrifice their defined benefit pensions for a pay rise? With the government paying around 25% in pension contributions on top of their salary, perhaps one solution is award significant pay rises but reduce the pension?

So I pay 10% of my wage in pension contributions as a nurse and that is topped up by the Government by another 25% ? Are you sure ?

Notonthestairs · 16/12/2022 07:40

"Completely agree with you, if by "de-funding" you mean increasing the NHS budget in real terms every year (ignoring the extra money they got fire COVID)"

Inflation has eaten up the budget.
There has been huge failures in workforce planning (hence 100000 vacancies), maintaining and investing in infrastructure and in social care which means patients can't be discharged.

None of this is the workers responsibility.

helford · 16/12/2022 07:40

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

Better question is what is the alternative?

You might not like paying for wage rises but how would you feel if a loved one or yourself couldn't get medical treatment at all or if the only way was very expensive insurance or self funded?

Someone i knew as a child recently died of a heart attack, ambulance took over 2 hours, early 60s.

A better rewarded and happier nhs workforce would be more productive and increased retention, so less spent on agency workers.

£400bn was taken out of the rail industry in profit last year, money is there for them too.

£9bn lost in tax fraud because the Govt failed to investigate tax fraud, 11bn would give nurses a 11% pay rise.

megletthesecond · 16/12/2022 07:38

I'd happily pay tax (I'm just under the threshold at the moment).
Then they need to raise taxes on the ultra rich, the private jets and yachts type.

Nogbreaks · 16/12/2022 07:38

I’d pay more for healthcare and decent travel networks.
The government seem to find ££ to subsidised the oil companies who currently have record breaking profits - maybe start there?
Our nurses can’t afford to be nurses, WTF are we going to do when they move abroad or go and work in Pharma or Research or change careers?