Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 29/12/2022 10:53

PrincessConstance · 29/12/2022 10:19

Sending physical mail is becoming obsolete. As people and business move to other formats of communication.
All ticket offices will be "repurposed" within 18 months, and all tickets will have to be purchased online or via a machine. Rail operators also object to inefficient working practices, use of drone footage for track inspections, for instance, walking time, and rather than having 9 people on standby only using 1 to do a singular job.

The NHS much like pensions was not designed to see people through their lives an extra 20-30 yrs. So no the NHS is not fit for purpose.

NON of the services are fit for a modern society.
More pay or striking doesn't change these operational monetary facts.

We are seeing changes you’re right. Rail demand is also down due to decrease in commuting post pandemic.

Change is hard when it comes to people but technology and working patterns force it in the end.

sleepyfelines · 29/12/2022 10:52

If NHS staff were better paid then there wouldn't be so many vacancies and so the reliance on agency staff would be reduced- so the overall bill for wages would be lower.

Also, MPs could stop handing expensive contracts to their friends, or wasting money on non-existent/sub par PPE, or paying for Boris' legal bill, or subsidising MPs' food/alcohol....

Walkaround · 29/12/2022 10:36

What the leaders of these big businesses have basically concluded is that people are their problem - both customers and employees. Don’t give customers access to people to talk to, because customers are a pain and messy and complainy, and just cause problems if you give them access to people, as people have to respond to them, whereas machines can just unhelpfully spew out whatever suits management, which is generally a big fuck off to the customer.

HandItOver · 29/12/2022 10:36

I would be, unfortunately it then relies on politicians keep their promises and put money where it’s meant to go.

or they could stop spaffing it left right and centre as @PAFMO said! MoD mismanagement cost billions this year in cancelled contracts, Im sure that money could’ve made a dent

Walkaround · 29/12/2022 10:29

PrincessConstance · 29/12/2022 10:19

Sending physical mail is becoming obsolete. As people and business move to other formats of communication.
All ticket offices will be "repurposed" within 18 months, and all tickets will have to be purchased online or via a machine. Rail operators also object to inefficient working practices, use of drone footage for track inspections, for instance, walking time, and rather than having 9 people on standby only using 1 to do a singular job.

The NHS much like pensions was not designed to see people through their lives an extra 20-30 yrs. So no the NHS is not fit for purpose.

NON of the services are fit for a modern society.
More pay or striking doesn't change these operational monetary facts.

Ticket machines in railway stations seem deliberately designed to rip off the customer, by making it almost impossible to work out where to find the cheapest fare for the journey. Too much “profit” these days seems to be derived from hoodwinking people into spending more than they needed to, for a service that isn’t appropriate to their needs, rather than in providing a better service than your competitors. It’s dire management at the top - the idiots making the decisions on what is and is not efficient and worthwhile and disseminating a pretty vile culture.

WatchoRulo · 29/12/2022 10:26

Walkaround · 29/12/2022 10:21

The finance industry is a prime example of rewarding the wrong behaviour. Strange how such a dysfunctional industry should command such high rewards.

Correct - and not just in banking - finance directors of relatively small outfits are raking in gut-wrenching salaries.

WatchoRulo · 29/12/2022 10:25

NON of the services are fit for a modern society.
This is true, but privatising them hasn't helped.
The idea that rail workers (except the ticket office) are being replaced by automation is laughable. There are significant parts of the network still running on antiquated Victorian infrastructure because dividends and profits have to be paid before investment is made.

Walkaround · 29/12/2022 10:21

PrincessConstance · 29/12/2022 08:33

I agree with you on the lack of pay. However, if the service is crap now, how will raising pay resolve the issue. You are still rewarding incompetence and a failing system.
As the adage says throwing good money after bad.
The crux of the matter is some services are better provided by private entities, (The post office) and (some rail workers' jobs are becoming automated), and some ideals the services are based on are no longer fit for purpose re the NHS.

The finance industry is a prime example of rewarding the wrong behaviour. Strange how such a dysfunctional industry should command such high rewards.

PrincessConstance · 29/12/2022 10:19

helford · 29/12/2022 08:54

The crux of the matter is some services are better provided by private entities, (The post office)

I doubt the victims of the Horizon scandal would agree with you plus POs aren't on strike. Royal Mail was sold off cheaply & has sent billions over seas and in dividends, it also has to provide a universal service which is price capped, would Evri etc do so well if it was forced to deliver a letter to anywhere in the UK for 68p ?

and (some rail workers' jobs are becoming automated)

The rail strikes aren't about bring back ticket operators and conductors, its about pay AND safe operation.

and some ideals the services are based on are no longer fit for purpose re the NHS

What services aren't fit for purpose?

Sending physical mail is becoming obsolete. As people and business move to other formats of communication.
All ticket offices will be "repurposed" within 18 months, and all tickets will have to be purchased online or via a machine. Rail operators also object to inefficient working practices, use of drone footage for track inspections, for instance, walking time, and rather than having 9 people on standby only using 1 to do a singular job.

The NHS much like pensions was not designed to see people through their lives an extra 20-30 yrs. So no the NHS is not fit for purpose.

NON of the services are fit for a modern society.
More pay or striking doesn't change these operational monetary facts.

Walkaround · 29/12/2022 10:10

PrincessConstance · 29/12/2022 08:25

There is a rule and tendency in many systems, called Price's law or the Mathew effect. There are many examples in nature and in human-made systems.

Looking at the summaries of these from a Google search, Price’s law seems irrelevant to the question of whether parasites with no obvious allegiances rise to the top of society. It also appears to have been taken out of its original context (publication of scientific papers) and applied completely inappropriately to all sorts of scenarios where it is clearly so out of context in its application that it cannot be taken seriously.

The Matthew effect, on the other hand, certainly resonates.

Forever42 · 29/12/2022 08:55

if the service is crap now, how will raising pay resolve the issue.

In the case of health and education, by recruiting and retaining staff. I can't speak for rail services or postal services but one of the major issues in poor health and education provision is lack of staff.

helford · 29/12/2022 08:54

The crux of the matter is some services are better provided by private entities, (The post office)

I doubt the victims of the Horizon scandal would agree with you plus POs aren't on strike. Royal Mail was sold off cheaply & has sent billions over seas and in dividends, it also has to provide a universal service which is price capped, would Evri etc do so well if it was forced to deliver a letter to anywhere in the UK for 68p ?

and (some rail workers' jobs are becoming automated)

The rail strikes aren't about bring back ticket operators and conductors, its about pay AND safe operation.

and some ideals the services are based on are no longer fit for purpose re the NHS

What services aren't fit for purpose?

PrincessConstance · 29/12/2022 08:33

Catlady2021 · 28/12/2022 17:51

But increasing pay doesn’t mean more inflation. As Mick Lynch said, we already have high inflation and that’s without pay rises. So we can’t blame higher inflation on paying people more.

It’s funny how lots of truck companies managed to give some HgV drivers big pay rises with staff shortages. Lots of people I know of went from £12 and hour to £15 an hour reasonably fast.

I’d absolutely pay more tax money if it means I can send my kids to decent schools, get an ambulance when I call 999.

Id pay a grand a year even more if it meant I could make society better for everyone and I’m not a high earner.

The bosses of the rail companies have been creaming tax payers money for three decades now, whilst stripping the bones out of the service. Yet funny how there’s no money yet CEOs of rail operators can earn £400k a year plus bonuses…
The Network rail CEO earns £600k.
Even with covid and almost two years of restrictions with minimal passengers.

I also worry about unmanned stations and trains, particularly at night. We’ve already seen the shocking things that can happen to female traveler’s. How can we put a price on someone’s safety ? Having a train guard on a train and a platform assistant is a choice by the rail companies. Or not to have one I should say. Is woman’s safety not important to train companies?

If I’m totally wrong I accept this and apologise in advance.

I agree with you on the lack of pay. However, if the service is crap now, how will raising pay resolve the issue. You are still rewarding incompetence and a failing system.
As the adage says throwing good money after bad.
The crux of the matter is some services are better provided by private entities, (The post office) and (some rail workers' jobs are becoming automated), and some ideals the services are based on are no longer fit for purpose re the NHS.

Maybebabyno2 · 29/12/2022 08:32

I think they should charge people for wasting appointments by just not turning up. Even £5 would be a good prevention and would save the NHS a lot of money.

But yes, I would pay more tax for this, and I'm not rolling in it by any means. If we lose the NHS, we will all be fucked apart from the mega rich.

PrincessConstance · 29/12/2022 08:25

Walkaround · 28/12/2022 09:46

And it is not actually human nature to allow greedy parasites with no obvious allegiances to anyone but themselves to rise to the top. That is what happens when things have gone badly wrong.

There is a rule and tendency in many systems, called Price's law or the Mathew effect. There are many examples in nature and in human-made systems.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 28/12/2022 20:46

Only yesterday there was a news article about a relative of an MP who set up an agency to supply nurses. These agencies are bleeding the NHS and Education dry.

No wonder qualified teachers and nurses are signing up to them. And they only work set hours.

MarshaBradyo · 28/12/2022 20:38

Walkaround · 28/12/2022 18:04

@MarshaBradyo - I think what frames my opinion is I feel we have a perfect storm of events, not a lot of isolated issues. We are now reliant on the global economy and also therefore more threatened by global events than ever before. We can’t pull up our metaphorical drawbridges and keep the rest of the world out, nor will things go back to “normal” if we hold out for long enough. Never in history have we had this level of flux and then all settled back down to the status quo. I also feel we have had too long a period of “divide to rule,” which is a wholly unhealthy way of maintaining control and, as a result, the level of anger it has built up is not going to be contained by failing adequately to engage with those with excellent reasons to be angry.

Having been fed a variety of differing political views throughout my life, I can see merits and flaws in all of them, but the view that affected me more than any other was the one my father expressed to me many years ago: if you don’t even believe humans are capable of becoming kinder, less aggressive and unnecessarily competitive, then it’s a self-fulfilling prophecy. Too many people have become cynical and now believe, after years of inadequate, divisive and frequently nasty political manouevering, that all leaders are self-serving and corrupt, so they might as well vote for a fairly openly corrupt, self-serving liar in the hope he can fiddle the system to somehow benefit the entire country, or at least focus his corruption on benefiting a different group this time, without being held back by diplomatic compromises and what the politicians have specifically told people are pettifogging officials and red tape. People are suffering a loss of faith in entire systems, not specific leaders, and that is frightening and destabilising.

I appreciate you came back to post as it’s interesting. I’m
not sure I agree fully but need to think about it a bit

YoBeaches · 28/12/2022 18:25

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

From the 150,000 vacancies currently in the NHS. Reduce the headcount, increase pay to stabilise and attract skills , then overhaul the administration and silo ways of working to gain efficiencies.

Break away from hospital centric care and transition to person centric care.

It would take time, but would deliver a better service for all age groups given the changing population and needs of the UK.

Refusing to pay more now, is senseless. The NHS needs investment Operations Managers, not politicians.

Walkaround · 28/12/2022 18:05

Not just specific leaders.

Walkaround · 28/12/2022 18:04

@MarshaBradyo - I think what frames my opinion is I feel we have a perfect storm of events, not a lot of isolated issues. We are now reliant on the global economy and also therefore more threatened by global events than ever before. We can’t pull up our metaphorical drawbridges and keep the rest of the world out, nor will things go back to “normal” if we hold out for long enough. Never in history have we had this level of flux and then all settled back down to the status quo. I also feel we have had too long a period of “divide to rule,” which is a wholly unhealthy way of maintaining control and, as a result, the level of anger it has built up is not going to be contained by failing adequately to engage with those with excellent reasons to be angry.

Having been fed a variety of differing political views throughout my life, I can see merits and flaws in all of them, but the view that affected me more than any other was the one my father expressed to me many years ago: if you don’t even believe humans are capable of becoming kinder, less aggressive and unnecessarily competitive, then it’s a self-fulfilling prophecy. Too many people have become cynical and now believe, after years of inadequate, divisive and frequently nasty political manouevering, that all leaders are self-serving and corrupt, so they might as well vote for a fairly openly corrupt, self-serving liar in the hope he can fiddle the system to somehow benefit the entire country, or at least focus his corruption on benefiting a different group this time, without being held back by diplomatic compromises and what the politicians have specifically told people are pettifogging officials and red tape. People are suffering a loss of faith in entire systems, not specific leaders, and that is frightening and destabilising.

BorisisaLune · 28/12/2022 17:59

Catlady2021 · 28/12/2022 17:51

But increasing pay doesn’t mean more inflation. As Mick Lynch said, we already have high inflation and that’s without pay rises. So we can’t blame higher inflation on paying people more.

It’s funny how lots of truck companies managed to give some HgV drivers big pay rises with staff shortages. Lots of people I know of went from £12 and hour to £15 an hour reasonably fast.

I’d absolutely pay more tax money if it means I can send my kids to decent schools, get an ambulance when I call 999.

Id pay a grand a year even more if it meant I could make society better for everyone and I’m not a high earner.

The bosses of the rail companies have been creaming tax payers money for three decades now, whilst stripping the bones out of the service. Yet funny how there’s no money yet CEOs of rail operators can earn £400k a year plus bonuses…
The Network rail CEO earns £600k.
Even with covid and almost two years of restrictions with minimal passengers.

I also worry about unmanned stations and trains, particularly at night. We’ve already seen the shocking things that can happen to female traveler’s. How can we put a price on someone’s safety ? Having a train guard on a train and a platform assistant is a choice by the rail companies. Or not to have one I should say. Is woman’s safety not important to train companies?

If I’m totally wrong I accept this and apologise in advance.

1000% agree with you, you aren't wrong.

Catlady2021 · 28/12/2022 17:51

But increasing pay doesn’t mean more inflation. As Mick Lynch said, we already have high inflation and that’s without pay rises. So we can’t blame higher inflation on paying people more.

It’s funny how lots of truck companies managed to give some HgV drivers big pay rises with staff shortages. Lots of people I know of went from £12 and hour to £15 an hour reasonably fast.

I’d absolutely pay more tax money if it means I can send my kids to decent schools, get an ambulance when I call 999.

Id pay a grand a year even more if it meant I could make society better for everyone and I’m not a high earner.

The bosses of the rail companies have been creaming tax payers money for three decades now, whilst stripping the bones out of the service. Yet funny how there’s no money yet CEOs of rail operators can earn £400k a year plus bonuses…
The Network rail CEO earns £600k.
Even with covid and almost two years of restrictions with minimal passengers.

I also worry about unmanned stations and trains, particularly at night. We’ve already seen the shocking things that can happen to female traveler’s. How can we put a price on someone’s safety ? Having a train guard on a train and a platform assistant is a choice by the rail companies. Or not to have one I should say. Is woman’s safety not important to train companies?

If I’m totally wrong I accept this and apologise in advance.

BorisisaLune · 28/12/2022 17:30

Catlady2021 · 28/12/2022 17:06

Don’t ever assume. It’s makes an ass of you and me.
You’re also wrong to assume anything to do with me and what I agree with. Heaven forbid someone disagrees with you. You’re a wee charmer aren’t you ?

Quite, agree on all of that

No assumption needed, this is what you said to the pp who said use the Foreign Aid budget i.e use it to spend directly on ourselves.

Now you've done an about turn with "i agree with Foreign Aid"

I can't agree or disagree with you, as you keep changing your mind or you don't know what the FA budget is used for & how it reduces poverty and helps women and girls get an education?
It should be increased back to pre Austerity levels, esp as GDP is down and inflation is up.

Catlady2021 · 28/12/2022 17:14

BorisisaLune · 28/12/2022 14:21

The MPs pay rises would make zero difference to the NHS.

Foreign Aid has been cut drastically, much is used to fund asylum seekers here in the UK now.

Yes cutting FA is a disgrace, its totally immoral to take money from the worlds poorest and i assume you re happy to see FA to Ukraine cut too.

We've food banks because of 12.5 years (on going) of Austerity and a shit tax system.

Oh and another thing. Cutting MPs pay rises might not make a shred of difference. But they could set an example maybe? What MPs can have a significant pay rise each year, yet they’ve told the public sector for 15 years there’s not money left. Is that fair?

Regarding foreign aid- I agree with it but the money should be spent wisely and be accountable. Not sent to corrupt governments, who syphon the money away. The money should be targeted. And yes we should be funding Ukraine with military equipment.
What about the UK government going to poorer countries and over seeing foreign aid spending making sure it goes to who it should?

Catlady2021 · 28/12/2022 17:06

BorisisaLune · 28/12/2022 14:21

The MPs pay rises would make zero difference to the NHS.

Foreign Aid has been cut drastically, much is used to fund asylum seekers here in the UK now.

Yes cutting FA is a disgrace, its totally immoral to take money from the worlds poorest and i assume you re happy to see FA to Ukraine cut too.

We've food banks because of 12.5 years (on going) of Austerity and a shit tax system.

Don’t ever assume. It’s makes an ass of you and me.
You’re also wrong to assume anything to do with me and what I agree with. Heaven forbid someone disagrees with you. You’re a wee charmer aren’t you ?