Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 10:36

Moonmelodies · 16/12/2022 10:34

Even for the self-employed?

If you want to down tools and protest about your own mistreatment of yourself, you'll find no one stopping you.

Would you like to borrow some matches for your brazier?

Rhythmisadancer · 16/12/2022 10:35

well if they paid nurses a decent salary people would actually apply for the jobs that are currently vacant and hospitals could stop spunking ££££ on agency staff

Moonmelodies · 16/12/2022 10:34

Sugarplumfairy65 · 16/12/2022 09:30

There is a union for everyone. There's absolutely nothing stopping you from joining one.

Even for the self-employed?

ClangingBell · 16/12/2022 10:32

Imnotswallowingthat · 16/12/2022 10:25

Scotland's nurses in the Unite and Unison unions have accepted a pay offer of 7.5% and the RCM have also recommended their members accept it.

So why are those in England demanding 19% ?

England’s nurses haven’t been offered 7.5%. They probably wouldn’t be on strike if they had been. The 19% is a headline negotiating position, designed to highlight how far nurses wages have fallen in real terms. They don’t expect to get it. A reasonable pay offer would have avoided the strikes.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 16/12/2022 10:30

There’s no way to square how much money the current government have given away - no logical argument. Pure base corruption. I think people should pay more attention let alone more taxes - my friends who are comfortably off saying “ooh I don’t watch the news/don’t understand politics/they’re all the same” - hard to hear adults spout this crap and vote them in again and again.

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 10:28

Imnotswallowingthat · 16/12/2022 10:25

Scotland's nurses in the Unite and Unison unions have accepted a pay offer of 7.5% and the RCM have also recommended their members accept it.

So why are those in England demanding 19% ?

  1. Have Scottish nurses been subject to the same "public sector pay restraint" over a decade or so that English nurses have?
  2. In a negotiation you start out at extremes and find a compromise somewhere in the middle.
Voerendaal · 16/12/2022 10:27

Not going to read thd whole thread . If you even contemplate what will happen to you if you get ill or need a hospital bed then you should really start worrying. Nursing is not a vocation that only requires shit wages. Registered nurses are degree educated highly skilled professionals who are worried sick and stressed out with trying to look after patients when so understaffed.
Wards are frequently run on skeleton staff. Agency nurses prop up numbers but are not as efficient as substantive staff as have to be trained to use different computer systems when they arrive to pick up a shift. Nurses are moved around the hospital to prop up areas which are really short of staff. This often means nurses are working outside their area of expertise which is highly stressful. Think of an example when you might be moved to a different area of work where you have no experience and people’s lives depend on you. Thd stress at the moment is unbelievable and nurses are leaving. We need more nurses and they must be adequately paid for their job .

LakieLady · 16/12/2022 10:25

OldWivesTale · 16/12/2022 09:49

Small place they found a billion quid to bung to the DUP in order to keep the Tories in power. There's plenty of money sloshing around when they want it for something. This breaking down of public services is ideological.

Absolutely. They're doing a Robin Hood in reverse.

How much did Michelle Mone and her husband scam the country for? And now they've legged it to Honduras and have put a lot of the property they bought with their ill-gotten gains up for sale.

The whole fucking lot should be sequestrated while their profiteering is looked into.

Imnotswallowingthat · 16/12/2022 10:25

Scotland's nurses in the Unite and Unison unions have accepted a pay offer of 7.5% and the RCM have also recommended their members accept it.

So why are those in England demanding 19% ?

HotChoxs · 16/12/2022 10:23

The other option is to let the housing market crash massively. Rental and housing decreases by a third will be as good as a payrise.

Imnotswallowingthat · 16/12/2022 10:21

thebellagio · 16/12/2022 09:31

I would pay more tax.

Theres a population of 68 million in this country. It every person paid an additional £5 over the course of a year, (41p a month each) it would generate an additional £340 MILLION.

Of course, that 68 mill figure does include children. But even if you said 50 million people paying an additional £5 throughout the year, that provides an added income of £250 million.

that £250m could be a huge difference between keeping people out of food banks, away from universal credit, away from fuel poverty - it could mean more spending in shops, boosting local economies, keeping people in jobs because they are incentivised to stay....

Of course, I have no belief that this government could manage anything so straightforward.

There are only 29m taxpayers in England & Wales, not 50m.

Scotland has 3m taxpayers and their taxes go to the Scottish government, who have of course just raised their income tax rates this week.

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 10:21

Every extra £1 a nurse gets only costs the public purse 68p, because 32% will go in tax and NI. And if that nurse is on UC (highly likely if they have children and pay rent) the govt will save 55% of the remaining 68p in UC reduction.

The nurse will probably be making extra student loan repayments too, which are a tax in all but name. Add 9p to the above.

HotChoxs · 16/12/2022 10:19

It's quite easy, give lower paid public sector workers like nurses and teachers a good payrise and give none to higher paid management. There's no need for a blanket payrise and I don't know why it has to be done this way.

Crabbity · 16/12/2022 10:16

Whyjustwhy123 · 16/12/2022 06:23

OP please don’t suck up the PR that the Torries are so cleaver at distributing.

They want you to have this view, it’s smoke and mirrors. By making the public feel cross at Nurses, rail workers, etc we don’t focus our anger where it really should be.

  • Mini budget fiasco
  • PPE fiasco
  • Brexit financial fall out
  • Under taxing energy companies such as Shell etc

Your enemy is not a nurse who is trying to pay her heating. It’s a millionaire who is trying to become a billionaire.

This. And that’s only the tip of the iceberg.

ClangingBell · 16/12/2022 10:15

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2022 10:05

Those in skilled work should not be claiming universal credit. Neither should any skilled worker be allowed to claim universal credit because they only work 16 hours per week unless they have a disability or disabled child or someone else for whom they are a principal carer.

If nurses get what they are demanding, the teachers, police, and all other sectors will follow.

Our circumstances are similar to @RegularNameChangerVersion21 and whilst we would accept paying more tax, under no circumstances would I be prepared to accept the present standards of patient care in the NHS. I also think it's interesting that despite the media coverage very few hospitals.were affected by yesterday's nursing strike.

There have been many comments on this thread about the PPE fiasco over PPE. I understood that NHS England had purchased the PPE but lost sight of the fact it was out of date. That marvellous institution run by Sir Simon Stephens who was spectacularly silent during Covid having been a former adviser to BLiar.

For the pp quoting £3k per month childcare/nursery costs, and wanting free childcare I would like to respectfully point out that children are the responsibility of their parents for whom financial planning is required. The costs also only prevail for a brief and limited period. I absolutely would not be prepared to subsidise other people's childcare. It's a personal choice over career v childcare and one where women in particular need to plan and compromise vis a vis career/full time parenthood. It is an argument for a different thread.

Things are tight, covid appeared from nowhere and imo the economy should not have shut down as it did. It was followed by the declaration of war on Ukraine. It is an unprecedented period. I am not aware that economies are better across Europe and in the EEC countries. The thing that is better across most of Europe are health services. Giving nurses a pay increase is not going to improve UK healthcare. A root and branch inquiry comprising a cross party panel, and a judge or two, I to its running and future viability, with freedom to suggest alternative models would be the only thing to effect an improvement.

What the fuck are you doing coming here on Mumsnet with that misogynistic shit about women having to plan and compromise, like men aren’t involved in the whole baby making thing? Children are essential for a functioning society and society should balance some of the costs of them to ensure women aren’t forced to stay at home. Women have had enough of this crap.

WatchoRulo · 16/12/2022 10:13

Dervel · 16/12/2022 09:49

I feel like we are stuck between two untenable political choices. The right seeks to cut public spending, and leave most things to individual responsibility. Then there is the left that would seek to increase borrowing, and pass on the financial burden to future generations to pay for the stuff we want in the now, which is unethical as the people we are asking to foot the bill either aren’t even born yet or old enough to vote. It’s a similar way we wreck the environment without any thought to those coming after us.

Clearly both situations are untenable, and whilst it’s really tempting to think well tax big business, or the richest 1% or even 10% will sort it. Yet that really isn’t going to capture the sorts of revenue to maintain all public services and pay workers what they are worth. We’d have to tax working classes and middle classes way more to even get close to that, and as a country we simply don’t vote for that. So that shafts both Labour and the Tories, as they would never have the sorts of policy options available to them to affect meaningful change without massively rolling back on manifesto promises (the both always argue they will be the party of low taxation).

We the electorate are as part to blame as they are. In fact I often think part of the point of politicians is we use them as scapegoats, we vote them in, give em a run at it for a decade or two, then get sick on their particular flavour of bullshit and blame them in total for everything we don’t like, and go on to vote in the next bunch with our consciences artificially clear.

We are moving away from centre based politics and being able to reach the meaningful compromises of consensus based politics. We need to start thinking very differently.

You are describing a false and over-simplistic picture of left vs right. For a start off, this "low tax" "personal responsibility" government has borrowed more than any in history and we have record levels of tax. Recent Tory governments only cut public spending on direct funding, they funnel plenty of taxpayer money to private companies - that's ideology not fiscal responsibility.

sHREDDIES19 · 16/12/2022 10:11

This is, in part, the fallout of the disastrous decision to tank the economy by locking down the UK for protracted periods of time during Covid. It was a succession of decisions backed by all major political parties (in fact, Labour were calling for a delay to a return to normality) but ultimately the Tories have to take this one on the chin and deal with the horrendous consequences.

poetryandwine · 16/12/2022 10:10

@RosesAndHellebores it is very much a matter of public record that the UK economy is doing the worst amongst the G7 economies and amongst the major Western European economies. (In terms of growth)

Fearforfriend · 16/12/2022 10:08

They could reverse the tax cut for the banks - this is estimated to lose circa £7.2 billion in revenue …. That might be a start.

Stop paying millions storing faulty PPE which was obtained during the (truly dodgy) fast track contract process.

Stop using tax payer money to fund Boris’ legal fees (ok that one doesn’t make much difference but just boils my piss!)

Chase tax evaders / people who defrauded the Covid grants. Close tax loopholes ….

Also yes I would pay more tax!

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2022 10:05

Those in skilled work should not be claiming universal credit. Neither should any skilled worker be allowed to claim universal credit because they only work 16 hours per week unless they have a disability or disabled child or someone else for whom they are a principal carer.

If nurses get what they are demanding, the teachers, police, and all other sectors will follow.

Our circumstances are similar to @RegularNameChangerVersion21 and whilst we would accept paying more tax, under no circumstances would I be prepared to accept the present standards of patient care in the NHS. I also think it's interesting that despite the media coverage very few hospitals.were affected by yesterday's nursing strike.

There have been many comments on this thread about the PPE fiasco over PPE. I understood that NHS England had purchased the PPE but lost sight of the fact it was out of date. That marvellous institution run by Sir Simon Stephens who was spectacularly silent during Covid having been a former adviser to BLiar.

For the pp quoting £3k per month childcare/nursery costs, and wanting free childcare I would like to respectfully point out that children are the responsibility of their parents for whom financial planning is required. The costs also only prevail for a brief and limited period. I absolutely would not be prepared to subsidise other people's childcare. It's a personal choice over career v childcare and one where women in particular need to plan and compromise vis a vis career/full time parenthood. It is an argument for a different thread.

Things are tight, covid appeared from nowhere and imo the economy should not have shut down as it did. It was followed by the declaration of war on Ukraine. It is an unprecedented period. I am not aware that economies are better across Europe and in the EEC countries. The thing that is better across most of Europe are health services. Giving nurses a pay increase is not going to improve UK healthcare. A root and branch inquiry comprising a cross party panel, and a judge or two, I to its running and future viability, with freedom to suggest alternative models would be the only thing to effect an improvement.

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 10:03

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 10:00

Still an incredibly good wage for a job that requires no qualifications or experience, and where you can just turn up once to swear in and not be seen again for five years - whereupon you get a nice payment for being sacked.

And what do they need pensions for when there's a paid retirement home in the form of the House of Lords?

MrsDoyle351 · 16/12/2022 10:00

Then there is the left that would seek to increase borrowing, and pass on the financial burden to future generations to pay for the stuff we want in the now

I think you must be very muddled this morning. Get that second cup of coffee and review the facts. How much has the national debt increased under the last 12 years of the Tories? How exactly has a decade of austerity helped the country?

From where I'm sitting, we have a massive amount of interest to pay on borrowing that the Tories have borrowed, that we will be paying back for generations.

Shame your 'logical' viewpoint is so full of holes it resembles swiss cheese.

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 10:00

Overthebow · 16/12/2022 09:20

As a PP said they got significant pay rises around that time as they had their pensions significantly cut.

Still an incredibly good wage for a job that requires no qualifications or experience, and where you can just turn up once to swear in and not be seen again for five years - whereupon you get a nice payment for being sacked.

poetryandwine · 16/12/2022 09:59

Yes, I would pay more taxes to support the nurses and other striking public employees.

But I am infuriated to be doing so in the face of the financial carnage imposed on the country as the Tories have repeatedly supported their mates, vanity projects and ideological fallacies ahead of the public interest. PP’s including @Whyjustwhy123 , @AelinAshriver and whoever reminded us about HS2 have shown that public sector workers and services could easily be properly funded by a government with any integrity.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 16/12/2022 09:59

I absolutely would be prepared to pay more tax, in fact in sensible world that should happen.
I support anyone's right to collective strike action. I hope they get something near what they need.