Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
PrincessConstance · 16/12/2022 13:58

Emotionalsupportviper · 16/12/2022 09:09

And remember - that when hospitals are short of nurses, they have to employ agency staff. These staff are paid more than the regular nurses, and the agency added a 20-30% fee ON TOP of these higher wages . . . surely it would be better to have more, better paid, less stressed staff in the first place.

The agency rate is the REAL cost the government pays to employ a member of staff.
NHS staff need to STOP bullying agency staff based on false premises and gossip.

chopc · 16/12/2022 13:48

Just reading through all the replies

Everything needs to be overhauled - including the benefit system eg benefits available for only one child , social housing only 2 bedrooms. If you need to claim benefits with one child you already know you can't afford another

And minimum wage to be raised . However I wonder if this will mean that people won't be able to afford cleaners, gardeners etc The people who can afford them are already earning more than average so are unlikely to benefit from a raise in minimum wage and they may pay more tax if taxes are raised

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 16/12/2022 13:45

SparklyLeprechaun · 16/12/2022 11:19

So? My pay has almost trebled since 2010. Being an MP is not exactly a job with significant career progression opportunities. They are paid a fair wage, as it should be.

My comment was in response to the pp who said MPs have not had much of a rise.

Havanananana · 16/12/2022 13:43

"Being an MP is not exactly a job with significant career progression opportunities."

Well not if you discount the progression to Minister - with an additional £67,505 for a Cabinet Minister or £31,680 for a Minister of State. Or the "outside opportunities" that MPs with the right connections attract, from luxury trips to Qatar to full-blown "consultancy" contracts - e.g. Chris Grayling being paid £100,000 a year to advise a ports company after being Transport Secretary. No other job offers the opportunity to attempt to pass the cost of keeping one's horses warm on to the taxpayer.

fernz · 16/12/2022 13:37

Lived Experience is not shite though, service users have worked for decades to have their voices heard especially in mental health to ensure the services available are actually meeting the needs of those who use them.

MaryBeardsShoes · 16/12/2022 13:36

Just because someone thinks differently to you doesn't mean they are stupid.

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 13:32

xogossipgirlxo · 16/12/2022 09:47

I have to agree. Plus managers on £100k+ who aren't clinical staff. Give these monies to doctors, nurses, midwives and paramedics. No use of managers if there's no service. What are they pretending to manage.

Right on cue, the Midlands Partnership NHS Foundation Trust is advertising for a "Director of Lived Experience" on £115k/year.

Nice work if you can get it, as they used to say. Of course there's money, if there's money for shite like this.

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 13:27

SparklyLeprechaun · 16/12/2022 11:19

So? My pay has almost trebled since 2010. Being an MP is not exactly a job with significant career progression opportunities. They are paid a fair wage, as it should be.

Is that as a result of rises while you've been in the same job, or have you been promoted?

Emotionalsupportviper · 16/12/2022 13:22

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 16/12/2022 09:42

Since Boris was prime minister billions upon billions hav been misspent or lost. This includes;

£40 billion at least lost in tax revenue from how the government enacted brexit.

£37 billion on test and trace.

£9 billion on PPE kit that couldn't be used.

£4.3 billion written off to covid fraud

Up to £20 billion lost failure to repay covid loans

£11 billion in interest overpayment when Rishi was chancellor

£4 billion in contracts to companies with ties to the tory party

£12 billion spent on projects described by analysts as either "wasteful" or "in support of government excess"

£4 billion overspend on the £15 billion budget for Elizabeth line

And that's just a few, I've not even mentioned (until now) the £30 billion hole trussenomics blew through our economy.

We don't have a lack of money problem, and we dont need the average jane to contribute any more through tax, we have an unbelievable inept government problem.

Frankly, the level of ineptitude displayed by the tories borders on the criminal and corrupt. At this stage I'm 99.9% sure any random person over the age of 3 could do a better job of running the economy than the tories.

HEAR, HEAR!

Corruption, ineptitude and greed - that's what we are up against.

Havanananana · 16/12/2022 13:09

"Taxation and funding of public services isn't some sort of lottery, where people have a whip round to fund a scanner"

Actually, this is very nearly the real situation in the UK healthcare system. To provide the excellent cancer surgery and treatment available through the NHS at my local UK hospital (when I lived in the UK), the expensive robotic equipment was indeed paid for by voluntary donations - i.e through a whip-round and charitable contributions. Having paid for the machine, the charity also funds the training of the nurses, doctors and technicians that use it. The hospital Trust could not afford this.

That cutting-edge, 21st Century treatment is only available through the goodwill and donations of others is a scandal - a sign that Cameron's "Big Society " was a government abdication of its duty to look after ALL the citizens of the country.

As my German friends say, "In Germany we don't really do "Charity" - we pay our taxes instead"

foxynoxy · 16/12/2022 13:06

^ apologies for the formatting

foxynoxy · 16/12/2022 13:05

@BirmaBrite

For NHS it's 20.68%, teachers pension around 25%, civil service 27%. Other defined benefit are similar, if not more.

It's not meant to be goady. In the private sector anything over 7% is deemed good and I'm not aware of anyone that receives more than 11%.

I don't want a "race to the bottom" but defined benefit pensions are hugely costly and for public sectors workers it's the tax payer that is footing the bill for their pension. Until we have a sensible discussion around the whole compensation package then we are going to get nowhere fast.

I think a model whereby public sector workers can flex and take a higher salary now and forfeit some pension benefits down the line should be considered.

I say this as someone that works in the public sector and am constantly educating colleagues of our pension situation when they moan about lack of pay rise. It's frightening how little people understand about their pensions.

BirmaBrite · 16/12/2022 12:20

I think its worthwhile to remember that the majority of social care is now privatised, be that domicillary or residential and nursing. It would be interesting to see if a saving has actually been made by doing this ? I suspect not. We just aren't very good at privatisation in this country, well not for the benefit of the consumer anyway !

Havanananana · 16/12/2022 11:59

Nobody on this thread has pointed out that people are already "paying" more than just tax as a result of the poor state of the health service. For example:

The loss of income caused by needing to take occasional days off work - either for one's own health condition or that of relatives, children, neighbours etc. - is also a form of "payment."

For some people, the almost total loss of income - i.e. they have had to give up work or reduce their hours while waiting for their condition to be treated, or while caring for someone else who is waiting;

The costs involved (time, petrol, parking, lost earnings etc.) in travelling to a hospital 30-40 miles away for an appointment because the local hospital doesn't have that specialisation or doesn't have a certain item of equipment;

The emotional cost of being unable to see a GP, of waiting months to see a Consultant and even longer to actually be treated and not knowing with certainty when the situation might improve (while the health condition continues to deteriorate). The emotional cost of having long-awaited surgery cancelled at the last minute. The emotional cost of the loss of independence - of being reliant on others for transport, shopping, social interaction, or for essentials such as hygiene, food and getting around the house.

None of these ever enter the government's calculations - they only count the direct costs to the Treasury and ignore the losses or costs to the individual. Which is a false way of calculating, because if a person can no longer work they become a "cost" to the Treasury (in the form of benefits payments and support etc.) and an additional "cost" in the form of lost income tax revenue, and lost VAT and other revenues as the individual earns and spends less.

MarshaBradyo · 16/12/2022 11:54

poetryandwine · 16/12/2022 11:33

Believe me, @MarshaBradyo we are considering Scotland because of its social values although certain practicalities make that difficult.

I don’t blame people if they’d like to go - in either direction. Some will prefer England’s version of tax etc

Although given learnings from Brexit and SNP referendum better to go before if it happens.. I know you can’t atm but just generally

vera99 · 16/12/2022 11:52

The arguments the government don't want you to have - don't believe the crap they spout in the Daily Mail and the like the people who keep this country going are the working class time to find our voice and optimism and support each other. A new world is possible and it's not communism but common sense.

helford · 16/12/2022 11:50

I haven't read the whole thread so apologies if this has already been pointed out, but those of you willing to pay more tax to support nurses and other workers are already free to contribute more to the government's bank balance. All you need to do is send a payment to HMRC and they will happily receive your contribution
I wonder how many of those who say they're happy to pay more tax are actually doing so?

TBH these sorts of comments are akin to "If you don't like Brexit, fuck off" or "Move to Scotland if you like higher taxes"

Taxation and funding of public services isn't some sort of lottery, where people have a whip round to fund a scanner, maybe we could fund a new type 45 frigate by voluntary contributions? no, thought not.

Healthcare needs allocation of funds based on predicted tax take and long term planning both on staffing levels and demand.

None of that can be done based on voluntary contributions or charity

Its not rocket science but time and time again we get idiotic suggestions from the 'right of the argument, no thought, which is why we are in this mess, either that or these people want to go back to pre NHS.

Taxation in UK is actually lower than most EU countries, who seem to do better both economically & on public services, health education and rail in particular.

poetryandwine · 16/12/2022 11:33

Believe me, @MarshaBradyo we are considering Scotland because of its social values although certain practicalities make that difficult.

MarshaBradyo · 16/12/2022 11:23

poetryandwine · 16/12/2022 11:12

@Dotjones and @MarshaBradyo you are criticising those of us not voluntarily paying more taxes. But as many of us have indicated, as much as we are willing to do that, we are furious at the wasteful, unethical and incompetent spending of successive Tory governments which easily could fund adequate salaries and benefits for the public sector. We have listed these above.

Voluntary payments cannot be ring fenced. As long as the government refuses to raise salaries to a proper level they are likely to fund more waste, incompetence and unethical spending

Up to you of course, although Labour may be in soon and it doesn’t look like they’re going for income tax rises so then maybe.

Another shift could be those wanting to pay higher tax being drawn to Scotland and vice versa. Not everyone can move obvs but just in general if higher taxation is a draw.

Notonthestairs · 16/12/2022 11:21

Individual choosing to top up Government funds won't change the Conservatives ideological choice to run down public services. It is a choice. They can find money for vanity projects - revamping trade planes, yachts, festivals of Brexit etc.

The taxpayer is paying for the agency workers. The tax payer is paying for storage of useless PPE.

Mismanagement of the NHS comes down to failures in Government. Ditto failures in workforce planning & social care.

Havanananana · 16/12/2022 11:20

The OP's post is based on the fallacy that funding to pay more to nurses (and to the public sector in general) only comes from Income Tax - i.e. if the nurses get more pay, someone else has to pay more income tax.

This is not strictly true on several counts.

There are numerous other sources of taxation revenue such as Customs duties, alcohol duty, VAT, Corporation Tax, Capital Gains Tax etc.

The government decides how the tax revenue collected is then spent. It could be spent for example on defence, education, policing, infrastructure, local services and healthcare and social care. The proportions are decided by the government - and the government of the last 12 years has decided that other things take priority over healthcare and social care. Not only is nurses' pay falling behind, but insufficient is being spent on hospital facilities and buildings, on modern medical equipment and on administration systems.

The UK is actually a low-tax country when compared with many other developed countries. Income Tax rates are comparatively low, as are Corporation Tax rates and Capital Gains Tax. This stems from the core Conservative beliefs that low taxation is a benefit in itself and that public services should be left to the Free Market. The result is clear for all to see - too few doctors and nurses, poor facilities and outdated equipment, 10% of the population on waiting lists etc.; a situation that simply would not be tolerated in any other developed country except the USA.

SparklyLeprechaun · 16/12/2022 11:19

Stompythedinosaur · 16/12/2022 07:58

MP pay has increased 28% since 2010.

So? My pay has almost trebled since 2010. Being an MP is not exactly a job with significant career progression opportunities. They are paid a fair wage, as it should be.

Isitsixoclockalready · 16/12/2022 11:17

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

The government seem to be able to find the money when they need to. Giving MPs pay rises doesn't seem to be an issue. Does it need to be a race to the bottom? Should everyone accept their lot and metaphorically doff their caps?

girlmom21 · 16/12/2022 11:15

it's a pity you aren't able to present an argument without resorting to foul language.

Anyone wanna play pin the tail on the dickhead?

WatchoRulo · 16/12/2022 11:13

it's a pity you aren't able to present an argument without resorting to foul language. It says rather a lot in relation to critical thinking.
No it doesn't - there is zero correlation between critical thinking ability and swearing - except in a ridiculously pompous sneering attempt to discredit people. Some of the cleverest people I know swear like fuckery.