Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
Iamboredandgoingforatwix · 16/12/2022 16:18

The trouble with this country is people think everything is simple cause and effect. It's far more complicated. We can only think in a linear way, when really everything is connected to everything else in a series of complex systems. You can't just choke money off one aspect off it and expect things to suddenly change for the better elsewhere.

This ideology in our government is a sign of people in charge who have never had to deal with any complexity in their own lives outside their jobs. Don't have to weigh up between working and paying extortionate childcare, where to move to because of housing costs, where and how to shop so they still have money for bills at the end of the month. Completely out of touch ideas, because they have never lived a life that is anywhere close to ours. They have hired help, or had privilege to relieve the struggle. I know some MP's have started from humble beginnings, but it is also quite easy to forget if you have been lucky and been in the right place at the right time and then just assume their success is all due to all hard work alone. For many, it's hard work AND luck and self belief that leads to success. Lots of people don't have the latter two on their side.

The media and government pedal this simplistic linear way of thinking that the OP highlights because they benefit from the division it creates. The cracks are really starting to show now and people aren't falling for it anymore. The bots that do the "back in my day I ate nothing but potatoes and had frozen feet" thing doesn't convince even the stupidest of people now. I'm glad people are starting to think about the root cause of everything more and realise the issue have often come from the top.

Surprisingly, the BBC actually debunked some of the figures the government have being throwing around regarding the cost of payrises.

CloudBusted · 16/12/2022 16:15

only providing benefits for one child is heinous. Children don’t chose which family to be born into. If they are born into poverty their future health and prosperity are effected negatively. OP you clearly have zero understanding of human beings and development. Human beings are complex. Massively complex.

Benefits for one child as a policy is highly unlikely to affect reproductive decisions but will most certainly negatively affect children. The next generation. The generation that will work in the care home you end up in.

TreadLight · 16/12/2022 16:12

Isitsixoclockalready · 16/12/2022 14:55

Trouble is that a rise in minimum wage can put you in danger of falling within the tax threshold, which is almost self defeating.

Surely falling within the tax threshold and therefore paying tax is good thing so that we can have properly funded public services.

Or is paying tax only a good thing for other people?

CloudBusted · 16/12/2022 16:05

WatchoRulo

Very true.

CloudBusted · 16/12/2022 16:04

m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXP8gH0wddE&feature=youtu.be

Not sure if it’s ok to post links but this guy explains city finances in an easy to understand way. Shows how wealth and income are different. There is an abundance of wealth held by the few. This needs taxing. Everyone should watch it. It might not make you want economic change but at least you’ll be making a more informed choice next election.

WatchoRulo · 16/12/2022 16:04

The irony is we do have a form of communism - where the markets are rigged so rich people never lose out.

CloudBusted · 16/12/2022 16:00

We need to properly tax wealth and assets rather than just focus on income.

The disparity between those with the most and those with the least is obscene at the moment. That’s bad for crime rates and for the mental health of all.

Check out Garyseconomics on You tube. He is an ex city banker who made millions but grew up with very little. He explains economics in a really easy to understand way. Explains how the wealthy are able to accrue more and more but avoid tax. I hadn’t fully understood this before.

There is plenty of money.

We need a big shift in economic policy to even things out more and properly pay all workers and properly fund public services. I’m not talking about ‘socialism’ or ‘communism’ but something that doesn’t just leave it to ‘the markets’. Trickle down economics doesn’t work.

BirmaBrite · 16/12/2022 15:59

@foxynoxy Wow , I genuinely had no idea so much extra was being added to the 9.8% I pay in, I thought they rounded it up to about 20% not that they added a full extra 20% on top of my contribution of 9.8%. It feels a long way off before I can claim it, hopefully I will make it !

Iamboredandgoingforatwix · 16/12/2022 15:46

Erm, they find the money for a lot if things.

To provide Ukraine with weapons.

And to pay their friends for contracts they couldnt fulfil.

Apparently it's not worth chasing up billions in COVID fraud either.

And MP payrises and expenses.

OP open your bloody eyes, clean out your ears and fire up your brain.

Endlesssummer2022 · 16/12/2022 15:40

Same place they found money for Michelle Mone, Dido Harding, Queens Funeral, Charles coronation next year, fake PPE.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/12/2022 15:37

chopc · 16/12/2022 13:48

Just reading through all the replies

Everything needs to be overhauled - including the benefit system eg benefits available for only one child , social housing only 2 bedrooms. If you need to claim benefits with one child you already know you can't afford another

And minimum wage to be raised . However I wonder if this will mean that people won't be able to afford cleaners, gardeners etc The people who can afford them are already earning more than average so are unlikely to benefit from a raise in minimum wage and they may pay more tax if taxes are raised

Jesus.

You do realise some people's circumstances change after they've had one than one child, right?

This is exactly what is wrong with the belief system around benefits. Everyone on them are feckless, lazy sods with Spanish holidays twice a year and big fancy cars.

It's actually more the case that the benefits system leaves people destitute and disillusioned and removes any self respect you had. They will find any excuse to sanction. People have died due to the system.

It's the bankers who take the piss, politicians, big business. But you keep believing the Telegraph that the downturn is the fault of people on a pittance they have to beg for.

MarshaBradyo · 16/12/2022 15:36

AdamRyan · 16/12/2022 15:32

I don't recall super times in the 70s at all, nor do I recall them being better between 1997 and 2010
I recall 1997 to 2010 being much better than now. I had young children and working tax credits were a big help. I could get a same day appointment at the GP and at weekends there were NHS walk ins that I did use (now I have been sent to a&e by 111 instead).
I used to work in the public sector then and my colleagues were reasonably happy and relaxed. They have all left recently citing the horrific work pressure.

I don't know on what measure 2010 was worse than now?

Re some of this - with all the stuff on SM about how hard it is atm I was pleased to get a same day appointment the other day, plus a weekend one previously same day (f2f during pandemic)

GP was really good etc I sent feedback to say thanks etc

AdamRyan · 16/12/2022 15:32

I don't recall super times in the 70s at all, nor do I recall them being better between 1997 and 2010
I recall 1997 to 2010 being much better than now. I had young children and working tax credits were a big help. I could get a same day appointment at the GP and at weekends there were NHS walk ins that I did use (now I have been sent to a&e by 111 instead).
I used to work in the public sector then and my colleagues were reasonably happy and relaxed. They have all left recently citing the horrific work pressure.

I don't know on what measure 2010 was worse than now?

HelsyQ · 16/12/2022 15:15

chopc · 16/12/2022 13:48

Just reading through all the replies

Everything needs to be overhauled - including the benefit system eg benefits available for only one child , social housing only 2 bedrooms. If you need to claim benefits with one child you already know you can't afford another

And minimum wage to be raised . However I wonder if this will mean that people won't be able to afford cleaners, gardeners etc The people who can afford them are already earning more than average so are unlikely to benefit from a raise in minimum wage and they may pay more tax if taxes are raised

Who hurt you?

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 15:13

Alexandra2001 · 16/12/2022 14:34

Frankly, 115k however mis spent... (and i have no idea what a Lived Experience Director does..) is chicken feed in terms of running a trust.

However, i did look up my local Trust, one of the biggest in the country in terms of area covered... fortunately nothing weird.... 8 posts... all seemed relevant.

I hope the Midlands is a one off?

But if you want a well run Trust... then i'm afraid management is essential for front line staff to do their roles.

Yes there is money, £11 billion un collected tax owed... according to R4.... FFS £11 billion! written off.. like covid furlough fraud.. that was billions too Angry

They were boasting of the role being the first of its kind. It may be a drop in the ocean on its own, but sum up all of the non-jobs and it adds to something more significant.

I agree that good management is essential. I'm just struggling to see much in the way of it.

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2022 15:10

@ClangingBell I am deeply sorry that your husband died and left you with two young children. That is a wicked turn of fate.

Presumably you have access to benefits as a single parent in straitened circumstances?

I agree nobody plans on their partner dying but it is prudent to make plans in case they do when one plans to start a family. To put in place life insurance or critical Ill health insurance, particularly if you don't work in the public sector with generous sick pay and pensions. I didn't work for seven years when the dc were small - we planned for that so we could afford it. Also DH took out life insurance on my life even though I wasn't bringing in an income because he knew he would have spend a lot on care if I were not there or lose his career.

I look at my grown up children and think often that if they were in the straits you find yourself in, then we would look after them, possibly not re childcare because we may be too old but we could certainly help with money. Just as the parents of a family member helped their dd when her dh died. They downsized and paid off their dd's mortgage to help out. That's what I call society and it starts with family.

I am sorry that your safety net hasn't been sufficient but I don't think you can blame a Conservative Government for whom voters have democratically voted. I am sure your choice of government will gain power next. I don't recall much being better regardless of the prevailing government. I don't recall super times in the 70s at all, nor do I recall them being better between 1997 and 2010. I believe that if we had had a Labour government during Covid we might be in an even bigger economic bearing in mind how Labour wanted to delay the return to normal. I certainly don't recall the mythical super NHS that is mourned from the start of my adulthood in 1978.

Isitsixoclockalready · 16/12/2022 14:55

chopc · 16/12/2022 13:48

Just reading through all the replies

Everything needs to be overhauled - including the benefit system eg benefits available for only one child , social housing only 2 bedrooms. If you need to claim benefits with one child you already know you can't afford another

And minimum wage to be raised . However I wonder if this will mean that people won't be able to afford cleaners, gardeners etc The people who can afford them are already earning more than average so are unlikely to benefit from a raise in minimum wage and they may pay more tax if taxes are raised

Trouble is that a rise in minimum wage can put you in danger of falling within the tax threshold, which is almost self defeating.

ivykaty44 · 16/12/2022 14:39

Everything needs to be overhauled - including the benefit system eg benefits available for only one child , social housing only 2 bedrooms. If you need to claim benefits with one child you already know you can't afford another

Are you really so simple minded that you don't understand that life doesn't work like this?

Life for a man with 3 children then his wife died, his private rental he can't afford and he has to wait to be evicted before he can get a council house. He is now out of work as he is looking after the dc and trying to keep everything together. You want to punish him further by only allowing him a 2 bed council property and benefits for one child.

Alexandra2001 · 16/12/2022 14:34

DdraigGoch · 16/12/2022 13:32

Right on cue, the Midlands Partnership NHS Foundation Trust is advertising for a "Director of Lived Experience" on £115k/year.

Nice work if you can get it, as they used to say. Of course there's money, if there's money for shite like this.

Frankly, 115k however mis spent... (and i have no idea what a Lived Experience Director does..) is chicken feed in terms of running a trust.

However, i did look up my local Trust, one of the biggest in the country in terms of area covered... fortunately nothing weird.... 8 posts... all seemed relevant.

I hope the Midlands is a one off?

But if you want a well run Trust... then i'm afraid management is essential for front line staff to do their roles.

Yes there is money, £11 billion un collected tax owed... according to R4.... FFS £11 billion! written off.. like covid furlough fraud.. that was billions too Angry

Havanananana · 16/12/2022 14:29

We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

Let's turn this discussion around.

If you could see a GP at any time just by walking in to the surgery. If the GP's medical centre had facilities such as X-ray and ultrasound scanners (saving you a trip to the local hospital and time waiting for results and follow-up appointments etc.). If there were no waiting lists to speak of. If a minor surgical operation could take just 5 weeks from seeing the GP to seeing the Consultant and having the surgery. If there were no waits for ambulances. If there were twice the number of doctors per 1,000 population than currently in the UK.

How much tax would you expect to pay? (More / less / the same as now?)
How much better would it be for your general everyday health if you knew that should you or your relatives, neighbours, friends fall ill or have an accident, a suitable and modern health service as described above would be in place and available to everyone?

Wiluli · 16/12/2022 14:23

chopc · 16/12/2022 13:48

Just reading through all the replies

Everything needs to be overhauled - including the benefit system eg benefits available for only one child , social housing only 2 bedrooms. If you need to claim benefits with one child you already know you can't afford another

And minimum wage to be raised . However I wonder if this will mean that people won't be able to afford cleaners, gardeners etc The people who can afford them are already earning more than average so are unlikely to benefit from a raise in minimum wage and they may pay more tax if taxes are raised

So basically you think punishing the poor is the way ? Clearly you have very little knowledge of how economics work

HelsyQ · 16/12/2022 14:08

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

Sunaks wife taxes? I assume as wife of the PM the billionaire lady no longer has non dom status?

problem solved.

DillonPanthersTexas · 16/12/2022 14:06

AdamRyan · 16/12/2022 08:14

OK I'll engage on this I'd increase taxes on people not in a company PAYE scheme and earning over 100k. At the moment too many of them use loopholes around paying themselves minimum wage + "dividends" from their company and end up paying basic rate tax only. I think that's disgusting.

However this Conservative government have cancelled IR35 reforms that were meant to target these people.

In my view "the rich" are that sector who can afford to pay accountants and restructure their financial affairs to minimise the tax they pay to almost nothing. The government need to do something to tax these people.

Increase CGT, increase corporation tax or put a higher tax on dividends. Go back to cracking down on IR35.

Focusing on PAYE tax bands is an error as most of the "ultra rich" aren't in the PAYE system

Those IR35 reforms are very much still in place and as alluded to already the unintended consequence is that a lot of the freelance work is now being offshored. I work in oil and gas, the industry has always tapped into a floating pool of consultant/freelance engineers to facilitate their projects. Most companies simply cant afford to keep a load of inactive staff on the books between projects so will instead assemble a project team each time they win a large job and demob it afterwards. It is not uncommon for a company to have a skeleton staff of under 100 people that gets ramped up to 500 plus engineers for the duration of the design phase. Now many companies have to carry out fairly torturous IR35 assessment to see if a contractor can be engaged on a limited company basis or PAYE via an agency. Those freelancers typically are on a weeks notice, have no sick pay, holiday pay, pension, healthcare or long term job security. Yes there used to be perks insofar as favourable tax arrangements but they have been eroded (increases in dividend tax for one) over the last 15 years or so to the point where there is very little advantage given the above downsides. IR35 was just the latest thing that made a lot of freelancers not bother anymore and for the older ones they just retired.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 16/12/2022 14:00

Yeah I’d pay more tax
We will be anyway

that said my strongest and only allegiance is to the nurses

girlmom21 · 16/12/2022 14:00

Everything needs to be overhauled - including the benefit system eg benefits available for only one child , social housing only 2 bedrooms. If you need to claim benefits with one child you already know you can't afford another

How would you enforce this?
What about people whose circumstances change?
What about people who claim benefits because they can't afford to work and pay fucking outrageous childcare costs?
Should people with disabilities only be allowed one child?