Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
TheHateIsNotGood · 16/12/2022 20:09

I definitely think that all hospital staff should have free parking.

bravelittletiger · 16/12/2022 20:06

Yes I would be willing to pay more tax.

But I would suggest they find the money by taking on more debt or spending less elsewhere.

To be honest I don't care particularly where it comes from as long as they get a decent increase. It's shameful how little Frontline NHS staff are paid.

Iamboredandgoingforatwix · 16/12/2022 20:04

chopc · 16/12/2022 19:17

For those who think I want to punish the poor - you are wrong. However the way benefits given do need an overhaul eg it must be cost effective for all to go back to work and they shouldn't be only marginally better off than they were on benefits

Like a poster wrote above - both me and DH took our life insurance when we had DC so if one of us dies,m unexpectedly , the other will be able to manage.

There is nothing wrong with encouraging aspiration and to better yourselves and to live within your means. It seems that people who can afford more choose to have fewer kids than those that can't.

However for all the circumstances you have mentioned there will be special considerations

I don't believe in the nanny state and believe in accountability but we do have a social responsibility to look after those who cannot look after themselves

This may be tuppence compared to what is required to pay the essential workers more but perhaps every little helps ?

Can I just ask what you would do about the wastage at the top? You have ideas about the average person, but there are billions wasted in government.

Many people have pointed out on this thread about COVID fraud, government schemes where businesses get loans for R&D but dont have to evidence this has taken place, the dodgy contracts during COVID where billions have been wasted, government projects that have costed billions more than what they agreed when they got the projects approved. I could go on...

We bang on about the NHS being inefficient, but didn't we waste millions on Patel's immigration scheme? Nothing literally happened with that, but it cost the taxpayer millions and then after that the mini budget disaster cost us billions. We are still yet to see any real benefit for Brexit too, but it has cost us money.

I think giving people benefit money for a second child is small fry compared to that, especially since if you support that child well they will eventually become an adult that contributes to the system.

We have had poor economic growth in the UK for a while. It is for a reason and is not an accident.

DuchessDandelion · 16/12/2022 20:00

However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

I actually find this bloody offensive. I DO contribute to the pot.

About time those who can better afford it did so, too.

I'll add that it's the same old arguments rolled out all the bloody time, whether it's for a 21st C pay rise, ending child labour, giving women the vote....

SoSobored · 16/12/2022 19:52

Don't give arseholes bonus' and then tax them properly?!

Iamboredandgoingforatwix · 16/12/2022 19:50

The current problem we have though is we are paying more tax for shitter services with staff who are likely to leave due to low pay.

Which begs the question - what did we have austerity during for much of the last 12 years for? It seems that we have had services cut, bit not much benefit for it and now suddenly it is still not enough. Where did that money go?

MichaelFabricantWig · 16/12/2022 19:47

Well yes I am prepared to pay more tax. That’s kind of how society works?

donttellmehesalive · 16/12/2022 19:46

Surely nobody can really want a low tax, poor public services culture like the US. I lived there and hated it. Paying more tax for properly funded services is far preferable.

nutbrownhare15 · 16/12/2022 19:39

Happy to pay more tax here for a more humane, better funded society which supports the vulnerable and funds it's public services appropriately. I recognise I am in a privileged position to be able to pay more tax. And I'm very happy for those earning more than me to pay more tax.

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2022 19:29

@AdamRyan no. I was saying it was harder to get a routine appointment booked in advance (impossible in fact) post 1997 than pre 1997.

It may piss off people on this thread but our family's lives have got better, year on year - even 2020 when so many were on furlough. I took a paycut that year due to the impact of Covid on my sector and worked harder than I had ever worked before. I have always given 120%.

I'd stand up and fight for the supermarket workers - not the nurses. Nobody has ever answered me when I ask why the nurses were complaining so hard in the mid 90s and mid 00's if those were halcyon.

I can't recall a time when the NHS was fit for purpose and its nursing staff didn’t complain about lack of resources. I do fully agree that the nursing bursary needs to be reintroduced but if so with conditions. Nursing was not a difficult degree to access or complete. Too many people were doing it to get a degree on a bursary and leaving. Bring back the bursary and link it to rendering 7 years' service to the NHS. Leave after two years pay back 100%, leave after 4 pay back 75%, leave after 6 pay back 25%. That is never ever supported but nothing in life is free and other graduates don't get a bursary. Nurses either stand equal with other graduates or they have conditions attached to a free degree. Nobody can have it all ways.

edwinbear · 16/12/2022 19:28

The government has its own magic money orchard called the Bank of England. The money the government “borrows” has no repayment term and they pay no interest on it

This isn’t the case at all - the BoE issues gilts, which absolutely have repayment terms and on which interest is paid.

chopc · 16/12/2022 19:17

For those who think I want to punish the poor - you are wrong. However the way benefits given do need an overhaul eg it must be cost effective for all to go back to work and they shouldn't be only marginally better off than they were on benefits

Like a poster wrote above - both me and DH took our life insurance when we had DC so if one of us dies,m unexpectedly , the other will be able to manage.

There is nothing wrong with encouraging aspiration and to better yourselves and to live within your means. It seems that people who can afford more choose to have fewer kids than those that can't.

However for all the circumstances you have mentioned there will be special considerations

I don't believe in the nanny state and believe in accountability but we do have a social responsibility to look after those who cannot look after themselves

This may be tuppence compared to what is required to pay the essential workers more but perhaps every little helps ?

OP posts:
Figgypudding123 · 16/12/2022 19:08

Yes I'm willing to pay more tax to ensure more fairness and equality in our society.

Anyone who votes for the preserving the wealth of the few over the well-being of the many is an arse in my book. The 'I'm alright Jack' school of politics is just selfish.

Bettyboop3 · 16/12/2022 18:50

Havanananana · 16/12/2022 18:09

@Bettyboop3

Nobody is asking you to pay more in tax if you can't afford it. The discussion is about whether those who can afford it should pay more (although yet again, it is worth saying that income tax is not the only form of taxation and that income tax only accounts for 25% of the tax raised by the Treasury).

The highest paid 10% of the population contribute almost 60% of income tax revenue. They would argue that they already pay too much - others would disagree and think that these people should pay more.

There are two issues:

Is the government willing to raise taxes from those who can best afford it, or in ways that don't impact on the poorest in society? Conservatives think not - they want to reduce taxes for individuals and companies - but the inevitable impact is that there is then less money to pay for public services. Others think that there is room for more taxation of those who can afford it or of assets that are not currently taxed particularly highly. The UK is already a low-tax country (despite what the Conservatives will have you believe) - companies pay relatively low levels of tax on their profits and Capital Gains Tax is far lower than in many other countries.

The second issue is how are the taxes raised to be allocated? I.e. what are the spending priorities? The current government has decided that healthcare should be funded to a far lower level than in other developed countries, with the results that are plain to see. Too few doctors and nurses, long waiting lists, waiting times to se a GP or get an ambulance, run-down buildings and equipment etc. If people find this acceptable in the 6th wealthiest economy on the planet, then so be it. In other countries the Health Minister and government would have been kicked out of office years ago if the situation were to be half as bad as it is currently in the UK. Continuing to expect a Rolls-Royce service while voting for a government that is only willing to invest in keeping a clapped-out Morris Marina on the road will not improve the situation.

I believe highlyflavouredgravy asked if we were prepared to pay more in taxes and i said no.

donttellmehesalive · 16/12/2022 18:23

"Of course because they are private sector, their wage rises are magically unable to cause inflation to rise, only public sector money can affect inflation"

Private sector pay rises do impact inflation and the BoE has requested restraint. But governments can't tell private companies how much to pay their staff.

UthredofBattenberg · 16/12/2022 18:18

I'd personally pay more tax for the workers than for the dodgy contracts the tories seem to be giving their mates

MushMonster · 16/12/2022 18:17

purpledalmation · 16/12/2022 18:12

As we are not given access to how money is raised from all different sources and what goes where, it's impossible to say. We need to see the accounts.

Yes! New government should get a peak to the situation.
There has to be a way we can force elections to happen. Even by raising petitions to force them to discuss it in parlament every single day.

PrincessConstance · 16/12/2022 18:15

MavisMcMinty · 16/12/2022 17:53

“Our taxes” don’t pay for things. The government has its own magic money orchard called the Bank of England. The money the government “borrows” has no repayment term and they pay no interest on it, and is nothing like a normal household loan. Managing the national economy is nothing like managing a household budget. If you give money to poor people they spend it on the things they need, stimulating their local economies. If you give money to rich people they siphon it off to the Caymans, bypassing the UK economy altogether. Austerity was an ideological political decision which has destroyed the UK’s infrastructure and economy (along with Brexit). The pandemic showed us it’s the low-income, low-status workers who keep this country running, not the millionaire/billionaire “wealth creators” who create wealth only for themselves at the expense of you and me and all the other worker-ants.

Here concludes your first economics lesson. You’re welcome.

I do agree with the notion of a sovereign currency, so the government can in effect print money to support whatever the latest fad is at the time.
A prime example is Track and Trace, the clamor for which was started by the media, wanting to copy China, Taiwan, etc. However, the UK population is non-compliant and quite frankly too stupid to use an app. So the concept failed.
Waste of money.

Why they would siphon the money off to the Caymans? They Invest. Pensions, and infrastructure, avoid some taxes because they believe governments are incompetent. Which they are. Basically, they have more control over where their wealth is spent.
Poor people don't spend the money on the wider economy they spend it on direct essentials. They certainly don't spend it in the local eateries or small businesses like plumbers.

MushMonster · 16/12/2022 18:14

But we need to change government. I seriously think that no amount of strikes and social unrest can make the current one ease the everyday citizen burden.
They know they have very low prospectives of returning to power on the next elections and they love making money "disappear".
I think we should demand elections. Otherwise, we are, yet again, losing money to the country, even only on the lost wages so far!)

purpledalmation · 16/12/2022 18:12

As we are not given access to how money is raised from all different sources and what goes where, it's impossible to say. We need to see the accounts.

Havanananana · 16/12/2022 18:09

@Bettyboop3

Nobody is asking you to pay more in tax if you can't afford it. The discussion is about whether those who can afford it should pay more (although yet again, it is worth saying that income tax is not the only form of taxation and that income tax only accounts for 25% of the tax raised by the Treasury).

The highest paid 10% of the population contribute almost 60% of income tax revenue. They would argue that they already pay too much - others would disagree and think that these people should pay more.

There are two issues:

Is the government willing to raise taxes from those who can best afford it, or in ways that don't impact on the poorest in society? Conservatives think not - they want to reduce taxes for individuals and companies - but the inevitable impact is that there is then less money to pay for public services. Others think that there is room for more taxation of those who can afford it or of assets that are not currently taxed particularly highly. The UK is already a low-tax country (despite what the Conservatives will have you believe) - companies pay relatively low levels of tax on their profits and Capital Gains Tax is far lower than in many other countries.

The second issue is how are the taxes raised to be allocated? I.e. what are the spending priorities? The current government has decided that healthcare should be funded to a far lower level than in other developed countries, with the results that are plain to see. Too few doctors and nurses, long waiting lists, waiting times to se a GP or get an ambulance, run-down buildings and equipment etc. If people find this acceptable in the 6th wealthiest economy on the planet, then so be it. In other countries the Health Minister and government would have been kicked out of office years ago if the situation were to be half as bad as it is currently in the UK. Continuing to expect a Rolls-Royce service while voting for a government that is only willing to invest in keeping a clapped-out Morris Marina on the road will not improve the situation.

MavisMcMinty · 16/12/2022 17:53

“Our taxes” don’t pay for things. The government has its own magic money orchard called the Bank of England. The money the government “borrows” has no repayment term and they pay no interest on it, and is nothing like a normal household loan. Managing the national economy is nothing like managing a household budget. If you give money to poor people they spend it on the things they need, stimulating their local economies. If you give money to rich people they siphon it off to the Caymans, bypassing the UK economy altogether. Austerity was an ideological political decision which has destroyed the UK’s infrastructure and economy (along with Brexit). The pandemic showed us it’s the low-income, low-status workers who keep this country running, not the millionaire/billionaire “wealth creators” who create wealth only for themselves at the expense of you and me and all the other worker-ants.

Here concludes your first economics lesson. You’re welcome.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 16/12/2022 17:50

Moonmelodies · 16/12/2022 10:34

Even for the self-employed?

The self employed set their own salary, terms and conditions so they would have to negotiate with themselves. If their self employment can't pay them a living wage then it isn't a viable business so they should find something else to do.

Bettyboop3 · 16/12/2022 17:49

Highlyflavouredgravy · 16/12/2022 06:10

Yes of course I'd be willing to pay more tax.
Paying a decent chunk of tax in return for a fair society os right and good.
Why? Are you not?

I'm not, no & i'm guessing many others are in the same boat as me. I can't afford to pay anymore. Bully for you if you can

Thumbcat · 16/12/2022 17:45

Well the man who is currently running Royal Mail into the ground could stop awarding himself huge bonuses and paying all the profits to shareholders and use that money towards pay rises. Incidentally this is the same man who was in charge of Test and Trace which lost 37 billion pounds of public money.