Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For all those who support the strikes

612 replies

chopc · 16/12/2022 06:03

Where do you think the money will come from for all the pay rises? Are you personally willing to pay more tax?
We all saw during the pandemic it is the poorly paid essential workers that kept the country going and they totally deserve more money than the claps they got. However will YOU be prepared to contribute to the pot ?

If not where do you think the govn will find more money from?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Walkaround · 30/12/2022 20:05

As for globally adopted business models - I didn’t actually say the UK is alone in the world in having issues with the modus operandi of global businesses. It’s a race to the bottom, and the UK is doing quite well in that race at the moment.

I agree that an ageing demographic (and an increasing number of working age people with chronic health issues and climate change and global instability) are a ticking time bomb, however. I also agree that the unions and Government facing off against each other are a bad thing - just like Brexit was a patently stupid thing - but if a country is so phenomenally badly led for so long and builds up colossal amounts of anger and resentment in its population, the result is seldom constructive.

TheHateIsNotGood · 30/12/2022 19:55

A change is as good as a rest as the Old Saying goes - as our version of democracy is divided between 2 political parties (both useless) it seems the Unions are doing what the Labour Party are currently unable to do (poss the Party should refund the Unions their subs).

So yes raise taxes to pay for it all but also revisit the economics and fiscal efficiency of each and every department including the T&Cs of employment that go along with baseline pay.

Carry on Striking, get in the flying pickets, tar and feather the blacklegs, self-implode the govt service you work for - I am truly beyond caring.

Walkaround · 30/12/2022 19:39

Oh, and I specifically didn’t say money was a finite resource, given that I noted that’s all they’ll have left to count when they’ve sucked everything else dry… Money, as we all now know, does actually grow on magic quantitative easing trees and is only unavailable when working people ask for it.

cantkeepawayforever · 30/12/2022 19:14

Machine ticketing in countries where the fare system is transparent, straightforward and obvious (eg by km or in zoned) works well. In the Uk? Less so.

Walkaround · 30/12/2022 19:06

Oh, and then of course there are the train tickets where you are not allowed to travel direct to the destination, but are obliged to go via an intermediate station first. Obviously sooo simple, logical and efficient. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Walkaround · 30/12/2022 19:04

I bought a train ticket the other day in which the small print stated I could not make my return journey between 3.49pm and 7.18pm 🤣🤣.

Walkaround · 30/12/2022 19:02

@PrincessConstance - I promise you, the vast majority of the UK population would be confused by the ticket machines in train stations. I’ve stood behind enough of them.

PrincessConstance · 30/12/2022 18:45

It's interesting to note, unmanned rail services/maintenance are being adopted in other countries successfully.
Then to post the UK pop wouldn't know how to operate a ticket machine.🙄😂
Quasi-private healthcare also works well in other countries. The EU is well aware of the ticking time bomb of an aging demographic. It's a big problem with serious repercussions.
The post relating Tories to business models is laughable, business models are studied/adopted globally. MBA tory approved course. I've not seen that offered yet via workplace training.😆
Oh, and money is not a finite resource. Sucking dry is impossible.🙄

Walkaround · 30/12/2022 10:20

Unfortunately, the Tories used the excuse of “fiscal responsibility” when they ran everything down. Now it’s the reason to wreck it completely. The longer this crisis goes on, the more expensive the fix becomes, not because of inflation, but because of the harm caused by decades of rewarding the wrong behaviour and exacerbating societal problems by ramping up inefficiency and unproductivity through the bizarre belief that the worse you treat people, the better they perform (unless they are hedge fund managers, CEOs, investment bankers or MPs, of course).

Business models have become parasitic - focused on getting as much out of people as possible and giving as little as possible back, whether they be employees or customers, and Tory policy reflects this. This is not efficiency, it’s inhumanity. The result is an ever diminishing number of people who profit from this behaviour until, ultimately, those people will realise they have nothing left that they can do but count their money, because they have sucked everything else dry.

HandItOver · 30/12/2022 09:51

I’ve been reading through a lot and just wanted to thank OP @chopc for starting what I’ve found a really interesting and lively thread!

RIP your notification’s though!

motherfugga · 30/12/2022 08:17

I have marched in support of teachers more than once and happy they got 6% but now is surely not the time for pay rises across the board.

Our mortgage is set to rise by £800 next year. Further inflation and the effect on interest rates is a terrifying prospect. It's not just the payrises that will bite - it's the billions in increased pension contributions. We can't afford the debt right now. I'm genuinely worried about it. It's a horrible state to be in and public services absolutely deserve a pay rise but I privately hope they don't get one. I'd never vote Tory and think what they've done to public services is appalling but in this instance am glad of their fiscal responsibility.

WhenTheCrowdSaysBo · 30/12/2022 08:16

Yes, I would absolutely be prepared to pay more tax.

helford · 30/12/2022 08:10

@PrincessConstance Hot air, you said nothing, no solutions.

Sending mail is not obsolete nor about to be and it doesn't answer the question why is the RM hamstrung but Evri etc isnt?

NR don't use inefficient working practices, they use safe ones, why should one man in a van be sent out in to the middle of no where to work on a track, to do 3 different skilled jobs? which is what the Govt wants.
Whilst you or i might be able to navigate a ticket machine or the internet, millions either can't or don't.

As for less passengers? so we cut services and staff and then when demand goes up we do what exactly? which as we get back to removing more cars from the roads will happen.

Seems some have learnt nothing from the airlines fiasco.

When you say the NHS isn't fit for purpose, again, not true!
it has been run down & not just staff, its equipment and buildings too, perhaps the Tories on here can tell us all what has happened to 40 new hospitals?

Thats before we get to social care, which has been deliberately made a national min wage job, done by women, with an exploited workforce, after car costs (why do they have to use their own?) they work for well below nmw and if they have a work related car issue, it costs them to work for us, yet despite mass staff shortages, wages are still low.

Tories ideologically hate public services and thats at the root of all the issues we see in the UK.

DdraigGoch · 29/12/2022 23:07

MarshaBradyo · 29/12/2022 10:53

We are seeing changes you’re right. Rail demand is also down due to decrease in commuting post pandemic.

Change is hard when it comes to people but technology and working patterns force it in the end.

There's a lot more to rail demand than just commuters. On some days in November demand was at 97% of the equivalent day in 2019, which is particularly impressive considering that 2019 was a record year. Sadly the government arrogantly ignored the advice of the MDs and CEOs back in April and decided to do their best to make the service so unreliable that demand is being stifled.

If you understaff your operation to the extent that you are heavily reliant upon staff volunteering to come in on their days off, and on them doing favours for the roster clerk by swapping shifts or staying late to keep the service going, the last thing that you want to do is to piss them off.

DdraigGoch · 29/12/2022 23:01

Walkaround · 29/12/2022 10:29

Ticket machines in railway stations seem deliberately designed to rip off the customer, by making it almost impossible to work out where to find the cheapest fare for the journey. Too much “profit” these days seems to be derived from hoodwinking people into spending more than they needed to, for a service that isn’t appropriate to their needs, rather than in providing a better service than your competitors. It’s dire management at the top - the idiots making the decisions on what is and is not efficient and worthwhile and disseminating a pretty vile culture.

Oh yes, the management love the fact that they can charge the customer twice by making the system absolutely Byzantine. They of course aren't the poor sod on the ground who has to deal with the angry customer. All sorts of TOC-specific fares for operators who run a couple of trains a day, just to fiddle the ORCATS system (the algorithm that allocates revenue to different operators when they both cover the same route).

DdraigGoch · 29/12/2022 22:57

PrincessConstance · 29/12/2022 10:19

Sending physical mail is becoming obsolete. As people and business move to other formats of communication.
All ticket offices will be "repurposed" within 18 months, and all tickets will have to be purchased online or via a machine. Rail operators also object to inefficient working practices, use of drone footage for track inspections, for instance, walking time, and rather than having 9 people on standby only using 1 to do a singular job.

The NHS much like pensions was not designed to see people through their lives an extra 20-30 yrs. So no the NHS is not fit for purpose.

NON of the services are fit for a modern society.
More pay or striking doesn't change these operational monetary facts.

Tell me that you haven't a clue about railways without telling me you haven't a clue.

Pray do tell me how a drone can tighten a loose fishplate bolt or insert a pandrol clip. We do have inspection trains which use cameras and pattern recognition to detect potential issues in the track. When they detect something they drop yellow paint to mark it for closer inspection by a human. Half the time the human finds that there was nothing actually wrong, it was a false positive. The other half of the time the human had already spotted and reported the issue.

If no one uses ticket offices (as is so often claimed) then why are there always queues when I need to go in and grab some change for my float? Everyone just ignores the vending machines and goes to a human. Yes, lots of people buy online but often find themselves being stung by me because they bought the wrong ticket - not that the government is planning to do anything about the hideously complicated fares system.

Have you mastered the art of disapparation? I haven't so unlike you when I need to go from somewhere to somewhere else I need time to do so. You wouldn't plan home help care without allocating driving time to get from one house to another so why shouldn't I have time allotted to account for the four minutes it takes to get from the depot to the platform? I'm not cutting my break short, if I had an incident and it transpired that I hadn't taken my full break I'd be in the shit.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 29/12/2022 22:32

PAFMO · 16/12/2022 06:04

The govt could stop spunking it up the wall to back up their lies and empty promises.
Might be a start.

This was the first post of the thread and really there didn’t need to be any more - this says it all

QueenSmartypants · 29/12/2022 22:27

Emotionalsupportviper · 29/12/2022 20:47

The government apparently think the country can afford to pay the defence costs for inquiries into Hancock's and Johnson's behaviour regarding their times in office.

Their defences are likely to run into millions. Funny how there is money for that, isn't it?

We're doing what now?!

Emotionalsupportviper · 29/12/2022 20:47

The government apparently think the country can afford to pay the defence costs for inquiries into Hancock's and Johnson's behaviour regarding their times in office.

Their defences are likely to run into millions. Funny how there is money for that, isn't it?

spirit20 · 29/12/2022 15:30

If the government have to pay more, it will hopefully encourage them to be more careful with existing resources and not waste them the way they have done now.

Walkaround · 29/12/2022 15:25

When it comes to incentivised pay, most people can see that it is seldom fairly rewarded and often incentivises undesirable behaviours (eg focusing on work that is noticed and benefits the employee more than the organisation, or worse, actually actively harms the organisation in the long term, but looks good enough for long enough to get that person their promotion out of there so that others have to handle the inevitable fallout). It also doesn’t work when those at the top are given patently unjustified rewards and incentives for appallingly bad management. Nobody is properly incentivised by a plainly rigged system, it just brings out the worst in people. Unfortunately, we have far too few good leaders of business to recognise that - there is a massive dearth of managers with any comprehension of how to handle human beings as opposed to economic units.

sleepyfelines · 29/12/2022 13:46

ivykaty44 · 29/12/2022 13:44

Perhaps a perk of some student debt paid off at each year between 5 and 10 years service would also help, along with a payrise

I'm not sure it would- at current tuition fee levels and salaries, most NHS staff won't pay their student loans off before they're written off, so this wouldn't actually make any real difference- the only difference would be on paper.

ivykaty44 · 29/12/2022 13:44

Perhaps a perk of some student debt paid off at each year between 5 and 10 years service would also help, along with a payrise

PrincessConstance · 29/12/2022 12:42

sleepyfelines · 29/12/2022 10:52

If NHS staff were better paid then there wouldn't be so many vacancies and so the reliance on agency staff would be reduced- so the overall bill for wages would be lower.

Also, MPs could stop handing expensive contracts to their friends, or wasting money on non-existent/sub par PPE, or paying for Boris' legal bill, or subsidising MPs' food/alcohol....

An investigation by the Labour Party showed that during 2021-22 60 trusts in England spent more than £800m on temporary staff and the total spend on bank staffing exceeded £1.7bn.

With vacancies at a record high and shifts a struggle to fill, trusts were forced to break framework agreements that cap their spending on agency staff rates—something they are permitted to override in exceptional cases.

This is another key point, framework, that design is such a nonsense, provision for flexible, incentivized pay should be one of the tools used at times to alleviate pressure.
However, I stand by my point the NHS was not designed for indefinite lifespans or for a sizable portion of the population to be ill or need treatment.
It's not tenable.

I think quasi-private-public with the benefit added by employers to cover will have to be used.
At the moment UK employment benefits are cycling to work, a few cakes, butties, and a perk box with vouchers for a branded outlet.

Twillow · 29/12/2022 10:56

Personally I would be more than happy to pay more tax - if our politicians made a fair call and agreed to a wage cut and to pay for their own fucking dinners at work like the rest of us. I am also angry that the social care levy was axed - such a short-sighted move when the social care crisis is responsible for a fair amount of the NHS issues.
A huge amount of working people are entitled to top-up benefits which tax-payers are essentially paying for. Fairer wages would mean less top-ups surely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread