Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Holiday dilemma making me feel ill!

105 replies

gretti · 15/12/2022 20:09

So my dad doesn't like DH. DH isn't a fan of my dad either. Me and DH went through a rocky patch which made things worse between Dh and my dad.

They've never fallen out. They've never even argued. They just don't speak however I'm not overly close to my dad. My dad has also caused me a lot of trauma and pain from my childhood and also he had an affair which ended his marriage to my mum.

Despite this, he's my dad and he's in my life. I'm not as close to him as I'd like to be but he is always there for me.

Dad took me and my sister out for lunch the other day and said he would like us to have a family holiday abroad next year - he's paying for it. My sister doesn't have a partner or DCs. I have 3 dcs. My sister is really up for it.

Spoken to Dh about it and he's not happy and says I shouldn't go. Youngest ds is 4 and has never been on a plane before. Dh says he wants to be there when DS experiences this for this first time.

He's told me to go - but is in a mood and says 'don't worry about me'

He then said it was out of order and unfair on him. He's told me to tell my dad I can't go because I don't think it's fair Dh misses out on ds first holiday abroad.

I can see why he's upset about this. I really can. I've suggested that maybe he could try contact my dad and reconnect and maybe he could also join us.I think my dad would respect this a lot. DH didn't really say much when I suggested this.

I'm absolutely stuck in the middle. If I tell my dad no then I'm letting him down and my sister and the kids! If I go then I'll just feel shit the whole time and I know DH just won't be happy.

All this being said - regardless of the dh/dad dilemma, im not overly comfortable with going anyway. If it were up to me I'd rather not. I've just finished therapy where I've realised how abusive my dad was as a kid. A very clever man and has a way of making us feel so unimportant. However this is him making an effort so I don't want to let him down either.

It won't be a holiday I'm particularly looking forward to either way.

Advice?

OP posts:
AxolotlEars · 15/12/2022 22:08

If the tables were turned and my in laws offered to take my husband and children on holidays without me I wouldn't be pleased but the thing I would be really cross about is my husband being willing to go along with that level of dysfunction, control and manipulation. So, no, I wouldn't do that to my husband either. You get to choose what you do but if you go then you you are making a huge and loud statement without uttering a word. Then what exactly will you be communicating to your kids? Somehow I can't see anyone sitting them down and saying "Oh Grandad doesn't like Daddy so he won't pay for Daddy to come with us all" and even if you gave that honest answer it sounds completely ridiculous!

Stomacharmeleon · 15/12/2022 22:07

That's the problem with over sharing.
Are you surprised they don't talk? Your husband is probably embarrassed and your dad will really dislike him for the way he treated you.
I would expect some major bridge building and a thawing of relations way before you go or you will have a holiday living on your nerves.

Lost123454 · 15/12/2022 21:54

I think the offer of a free holiday is clouding your judgement

Don't expect your DH to go on holiday with somebody he doesn't like and who doesn't like him

Sounds like a stupid idea

Why don't you go and take the kids if your dad is so good with them

gretti · 15/12/2022 21:51

AnneLovesGilbert · 15/12/2022 21:24

What is it your DH did that was so bad? Cheating?

At the risk of drip feeding - I was fed up with Dh. For a good year before I left him, he was completely selfish and so difficult to be around. Again not violent, no shouting but everything was just about him all the time. Whenever I would try voice how I felt, it didn't matter. So my mental health took a knock. As predicted when I told Dh that I wasn't well mentally, he turned it around to be all on him so I left.

It knocked him for six. I refused to go back until I was sure there was going to be a change. Dh then convinced himself that I was seeing someone else and that's where it all got messy. He sent some very nasty messages to me over a period of time which I showed both my parents. Although my dad never slated DH, he said that he needed help.

Dh ended up putting himself in therapy and we have been rebuilding for a while now. All was going well until this happened.

OP posts:
gretti · 15/12/2022 21:45

ethelredonagoodday · 15/12/2022 21:39

I had a similar relationship with my Dad OP. He wasn't the best Dad, he wasn't abusive or anything like that, but he had an affair and put his AP first for a lot of years. However, over time things changed and he was a much better Dad and really good grandad to my kids. My DH did get on with him, so we didn't have the dynamic that you do, but I do understand your situation.
I'd say that if your DH, who sounds to actually have been equally shitty to you, could be persuaded to go, it could actually be chance to build bridges between you all?

I sympathise OP.

From the sound of my dads reply - it could actually turn out that way.

My dads reply was along the lines of he totally understands, he's happy for DH to come and he's happy that we are making things work. I can't ask anymore from my dad.

My dad is a complicated man and I gave up trying to figure him out a long time ago. He wasn't the best dad at all. But he has always always been there for me and there's been a lot of times when I've needed him and he's there no questions asked. I can see why people wonder why I would even want to go but its difficult to understand.

OP posts:
FleasNavidad · 15/12/2022 21:42

Depends what either of them did. It's all so vague that nobody can say either way tbh

ethelredonagoodday · 15/12/2022 21:39

I had a similar relationship with my Dad OP. He wasn't the best Dad, he wasn't abusive or anything like that, but he had an affair and put his AP first for a lot of years. However, over time things changed and he was a much better Dad and really good grandad to my kids. My DH did get on with him, so we didn't have the dynamic that you do, but I do understand your situation.
I'd say that if your DH, who sounds to actually have been equally shitty to you, could be persuaded to go, it could actually be chance to build bridges between you all?

I sympathise OP.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 15/12/2022 21:28

I'm with your husband tbh

Nosecamera · 15/12/2022 21:26

Your dad is being devisive, say no thank you but brace yourself from some bad behaviour.
I can't get my head around how some women can hold the 2 opposing thoughts that thier dad is an abuser and yet still a great man. I suppose it's a way of protecting themselves, properly rejecting him would put themselves at risk.

AnneLovesGilbert · 15/12/2022 21:24

What is it your DH did that was so bad? Cheating?

Hopeyoursproutsarealreadyon · 15/12/2022 21:21

So when it causes tension if dh says no dh gets the blame? Op can you not see manipulation going on here +

Beancounter1 · 15/12/2022 21:20

All this being said - regardless of the dh/dad dilemma, im not overly comfortable with going anyway. If it were up to me I'd rather not.

There is your answer - you don't want to go, so don't. It is up to you - entirely just up to you and no-one else. What makes you think it isn't?

susiesuelou · 15/12/2022 21:20

I wouldn't be going on holiday with an abusive parent, with or without my DH. 🤷‍♀️

gretti · 15/12/2022 21:16

Update - I text my dad and he replied straight away saying of course Dh can come. He understands and wouldn't want Dh to miss out.

It all lies with Dh now I suppose.

OP posts:
wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 15/12/2022 21:07

My dad has also caused me a lot of trauma and pain from my childhood and also he had an affair which ended his marriage to my mum.

So why would you want to holiday with him?

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 15/12/2022 21:00

blubberyboo · 15/12/2022 20:28

Your husband is right

he should be there for his daughters first holiday

your dad is creating a rift by not inviting him and he knows it. He’s still controlling you.

Agreed.

You say you want to make your marriage work and that your DH is making efforts to improve and is doing therapy.

Why do you see turning down the holiday as letting your Dad down?
Your Dad is creating a rift in your marriage by excluding your DH, just as he must know the two of you are trying to make a go of it.

You've already said you don't particularly want to go on this holiday and he wasn't a good dad when you were growing up.

You don't have to go on a holiday to have a relationship with your Dad.
You already see him regularly. If turning down the holiday makes your Dad withdraw his affection then the holiday is just emotional blackmail.

If you are getting on well with your DH, I'm sure your DC would want him on holiday too.

gretti · 15/12/2022 21:00

Thank you for your replies. It's been really helpful and I'm about to contact my dad to ask him to clarify what he means about who is invited - I will let you all know the response.

Where I just feel let down by Dh is what when we agreed to try again, he was very accepting that my dad probably wouldn't want a relationship with him now. He was going to text my dad to apologise but it never happened. They just haven't spoken for a good 18 months now. I always said I never wanted to feel torn between him and any of my family and he was full of promises that he knows that he has to make amends and would be fully supportive of me.

I just wish he could see it from my point of view.

OP posts:
Natty13 · 15/12/2022 20:54

You say there is no way he hasn't included your DH (though you do need to clarify this point tbh) to cause friction in your marriage but you have to accept that despite that, it will harm your marriage if you go without him. I would also be furious if my DH was considering taking my kids abroad for the first time without me.

You have made the choice to work on your marriage and your side of the famy should respect that choice. It's not for them to decide that the won't support your decision and your mum, sister and father should be supporting you to have a healthier marriage - sounds like you have terrible boundaries in general - rather than encouraging you to take actions which will harm it further.

Hopeyoursproutsarealreadyon · 15/12/2022 20:49

Maybe your df invited you knowing it would cause issues between you are your dh?

pippinsleftleg · 15/12/2022 20:46

Forget what your dad and husband want. What do YOU want?

PlanningTowns · 15/12/2022 20:45

Honestly it would be the worst time if you went and you dh went and your dh and dad didn’t speak the whole time. You’ll be stressed the entire time. As a compromise could you not go on a city break or long weekend with your Dad and sister and go away with your family separately? It seems that you are between a rock and a hard place given the relationship with both of these men. You will not win whatever you decide.

tabulahrasa · 15/12/2022 20:45

There’s no magic solution here tbh.

I’d go, but mostly because I can’t be bothered with adults who’ll deny their kids something just because they’re in a strop about not going too, especially when it sounds like he’s not invited because they fell out about him treating you badly anyway.

gretti · 15/12/2022 20:44

Wakk · 15/12/2022 20:37

Why do you care about letting your abusive dad down? I think your DH is right to say you shouldn't go without him.

I hate letting anyone down. Can't stand it. It doesn't matter who it is.

I don't want to have a bad relationship with my dad. I'd rather get on with him. He absolutely wasn't the best dad in the world. All he did was work, never interested in me or my sister. There was never any violence or even any shouting. It was just not always a nice atmosphere.

He had an affair when I was an adult because my mum didn't show him any love. Which I'm not surprised she didn't. My loyalties have always remained with my mum and always will.

Surprisingly though she says for me to go on the holiday. She says Dh made his bed with what he's done and shouldn't expect to be involved in everything even though we are trying to make our marriage work.

OP posts:
surreygirl1987 · 15/12/2022 20:43

What, your dad invited you on a holiday, with your kids, but without your husband?! What on earth? I can not imagine my parents even dreaming of doing that. I'd be furious if I was hour husband - and you too, to be honest. I wouldn't be going on principle, and would be explaining why to my ridiculous, manipulative, controlling father!

gretti · 15/12/2022 20:39

JustCleaningtheBBQ · 15/12/2022 20:35

Seems like your dad is still abusing you. They probably don't like each other as they recognise they are both the same people. Are you sure your dad hasn't proposed this holiday just to cause trouble, especially if he knows it would upset your DH?

Also, you can't ask DH to contact your dad to try and smooth things over, it would never work with people like this.

No I'm sure he hasn't done it to cause friction. My dad doesn't work like that.

He's done it and is expecting both me and my sister to be really excited and thankful. My sister is - she wants a free holiday. I'm not overly thrilled.

It really won't of crossed his mind that he's putting me in this situation. He will just be thinking that he's doing a good thing.

OP posts: