Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Holiday dilemma making me feel ill!

105 replies

gretti · 15/12/2022 20:09

So my dad doesn't like DH. DH isn't a fan of my dad either. Me and DH went through a rocky patch which made things worse between Dh and my dad.

They've never fallen out. They've never even argued. They just don't speak however I'm not overly close to my dad. My dad has also caused me a lot of trauma and pain from my childhood and also he had an affair which ended his marriage to my mum.

Despite this, he's my dad and he's in my life. I'm not as close to him as I'd like to be but he is always there for me.

Dad took me and my sister out for lunch the other day and said he would like us to have a family holiday abroad next year - he's paying for it. My sister doesn't have a partner or DCs. I have 3 dcs. My sister is really up for it.

Spoken to Dh about it and he's not happy and says I shouldn't go. Youngest ds is 4 and has never been on a plane before. Dh says he wants to be there when DS experiences this for this first time.

He's told me to go - but is in a mood and says 'don't worry about me'

He then said it was out of order and unfair on him. He's told me to tell my dad I can't go because I don't think it's fair Dh misses out on ds first holiday abroad.

I can see why he's upset about this. I really can. I've suggested that maybe he could try contact my dad and reconnect and maybe he could also join us.I think my dad would respect this a lot. DH didn't really say much when I suggested this.

I'm absolutely stuck in the middle. If I tell my dad no then I'm letting him down and my sister and the kids! If I go then I'll just feel shit the whole time and I know DH just won't be happy.

All this being said - regardless of the dh/dad dilemma, im not overly comfortable with going anyway. If it were up to me I'd rather not. I've just finished therapy where I've realised how abusive my dad was as a kid. A very clever man and has a way of making us feel so unimportant. However this is him making an effort so I don't want to let him down either.

It won't be a holiday I'm particularly looking forward to either way.

Advice?

OP posts:
Paq · 16/12/2022 06:31

If your dad really cared about you he would be trying to make amends with your husband, not causing a further wedge in your relationship.

JRHartley72 · 16/12/2022 06:26

gretti · 15/12/2022 22:45

Thank you! I genuinely feel that this is how it is. Drip feeding again I know but when we were having lunch the other day, dad got emotional and said this would be the last family holiday that we could have and he just wanted to make some special memories with me and my sister and his grandkids. He had tears in his eyes. How could I say 'no thank you'? I can't.

I can't predict what the holiday would be like but I want to give my dad that chance to make amends and have the memories.

I'm reading it the same as CJsGoldfish. Your dad isn't the same man he was years ago and you and your sister both recognise that and his willingness to make amends, whereas your DH is stuck firmly in the same pattern of abusive control over you. Let's be honest here, your DH's objection was never about him not being invited on the holiday – it was about your dad doing something nice for you and making you happy and he doesn't want to allow that to happen. He wants you at odds with your dad because it makes you more reliant on him.

Go on the holiday, have an amazing experience with your children, and use the time to take a long, hard look at your marriage, because it does not sound like a healthy relationship at all.

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 15/12/2022 23:55

gretti · 15/12/2022 23:34

I get what people are saying about my dad but no one seems to be reading the full thread here which is a fault Dh not wanting me to go on this holiday because it sends his paranoia into full rage mode. My gut told me it was nothing to do with missing DS first holiday abroad. I knew it was more than that and it turns out I was right when I've been snapped at tonight. Sad thing is I've never ever cheated on him.

My mum thought this too. She was also right.

I did read the thread. Your husband is being a dickhead. He's as abusive as your dad. But, even though his reasons for being mad about the holiday are wrong, the original offer was still wrong.

If your husband wanted to take the kids on holiday without you with his family you would have been super upset and felt very disrespected as the childs mother and left out.

Leave your husband if you want, I would encourage it. But I still don't think you should go on holiday with your dad. Because just like your husband, he's still got the abusive tendencies. You already were not looking forward to it. HE wants to go on holiday because HE is saying its the last chance. There is no reason it is. Its what HE wants to do when HE wants to do it. That's him being controlling. He's using emotion of being 'last chance'. You go away with him on an extended break, on his money, with no escape. He's in control.

They are both abusive, will always be abusive.

gretti · 15/12/2022 23:34

I get what people are saying about my dad but no one seems to be reading the full thread here which is a fault Dh not wanting me to go on this holiday because it sends his paranoia into full rage mode. My gut told me it was nothing to do with missing DS first holiday abroad. I knew it was more than that and it turns out I was right when I've been snapped at tonight. Sad thing is I've never ever cheated on him.

My mum thought this too. She was also right.

OP posts:
gretti · 15/12/2022 23:31

deeperthanallroses · 15/12/2022 23:18

dad got emotional and said this would be the last family holiday that we could have and he just wanted to make some special memories with me and my sister and his grandkids. He had tears in his eyes. How could I say 'no thank you'? I can't.
This doesn’t mean anything necessarily. Abusive men are full of emotion. ‘I only hit you because I love you <sobs>’. ‘If you loved me you wouldn’t take that job where there will be MEN in your office <sobs>’. ‘You can’t destroy our beautiful family by leaving just because I beat you up, I’ll just die if I can’t see my daughter every day <sobs>’
it will be special memories with your dh there too. People can have special memories of holduays with their grandchildren with their children’s partners there too, happens every single minute of every day. If he really wants you all to have a perfect holiday then he’ll say sure your dh can come. If instead he just wants to delude himself he’s a great dad by having everything on his terms he will say No, this trip will only create special memories if YOU ALL FOLLOW MY RULES EXACTLY. Otherwise you will ruin it and it will be all your fault!!
see? Not exactly purely wishing you a great time is he?

Everything you have described as an abusive man points at my DH to be honest. Except the hitting part. Neither my dad or Dh have ever hit me.

OP posts:
deeperthanallroses · 15/12/2022 23:18

dad got emotional and said this would be the last family holiday that we could have and he just wanted to make some special memories with me and my sister and his grandkids. He had tears in his eyes. How could I say 'no thank you'? I can't.
This doesn’t mean anything necessarily. Abusive men are full of emotion. ‘I only hit you because I love you <sobs>’. ‘If you loved me you wouldn’t take that job where there will be MEN in your office <sobs>’. ‘You can’t destroy our beautiful family by leaving just because I beat you up, I’ll just die if I can’t see my daughter every day <sobs>’
it will be special memories with your dh there too. People can have special memories of holduays with their grandchildren with their children’s partners there too, happens every single minute of every day. If he really wants you all to have a perfect holiday then he’ll say sure your dh can come. If instead he just wants to delude himself he’s a great dad by having everything on his terms he will say No, this trip will only create special memories if YOU ALL FOLLOW MY RULES EXACTLY. Otherwise you will ruin it and it will be all your fault!!
see? Not exactly purely wishing you a great time is he?

deeperthanallroses · 15/12/2022 23:12

gretti · 15/12/2022 21:00

Thank you for your replies. It's been really helpful and I'm about to contact my dad to ask him to clarify what he means about who is invited - I will let you all know the response.

Where I just feel let down by Dh is what when we agreed to try again, he was very accepting that my dad probably wouldn't want a relationship with him now. He was going to text my dad to apologise but it never happened. They just haven't spoken for a good 18 months now. I always said I never wanted to feel torn between him and any of my family and he was full of promises that he knows that he has to make amends and would be fully supportive of me.

I just wish he could see it from my point of view.

That doesn’t sound like a huge infraction tbh, making that first move is hard. If he’s genuinely trying with regards to you, there is no way I’d go without him. Thanks dad but I won’t go on dds first overseas holiday without her dad there, it wouldn’t be fair to him.

Mirabai · 15/12/2022 22:59

No “holiday” is worth this kind of hassle.

Mardyface · 15/12/2022 22:54

I don't know why the solution was DH going anyway. YOU don't want to go. That is entirely reasonable and completely separate from the whims of the two men in your life. Don't go if you don't want to. Take your sister away with the kids instead and don't come back

gretti · 15/12/2022 22:47

@Blowthemandown possibly but he's admitted this isn't about missing out on DS first holiday. This is him not wanting to go and him not wanting me to go as he's still as paranoid as ever deep down :-(

OP posts:
ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 15/12/2022 22:46

gretti · 15/12/2022 22:41

I think he will be finishing with me at this rate. I've done everything he asked. He's always been nervous of being around my dad again. I can't ask anymore of my dad in his response.

My dad was abusive a long time ago. It doesn't make it ok but I don't think he is now. Clearly DH continues to be though.

I give up tbh.

Look OP, I don't think your husband is great, nor your dad. Those with abusive tendencies have them. I wish you'd seen this earlier and recognised you were going for someone like your dad and get therapy to break the cycle.

But your husband is nervous of being with your dad, your dad has a history of abusive behaviour, and you want to jump straight into a long holiday abroad together? It's too much! Why not start small with a weekend somewhere first?

gretti · 15/12/2022 22:45

CJsGoldfish · 15/12/2022 22:40

I feel like I'm reading a different thread than everyone else 🙄
I would go.
You feel your dad is trying to make amends and your relationship is in a good place now. His message about your dh backs that up.

I think it is your dh being an arse. Especially after the latest development but even before that. He sounds like he doesn't want you to spend time with your family.

Thank you! I genuinely feel that this is how it is. Drip feeding again I know but when we were having lunch the other day, dad got emotional and said this would be the last family holiday that we could have and he just wanted to make some special memories with me and my sister and his grandkids. He had tears in his eyes. How could I say 'no thank you'? I can't.

I can't predict what the holiday would be like but I want to give my dad that chance to make amends and have the memories.

OP posts:
Blowthemandown · 15/12/2022 22:43

gretti · 15/12/2022 20:19

My husband wasn't a good husband - I'm giving him another chance on the hope he has changed.

@gretti can you go abroad with DH first? Then see how you feel? Do that regardless. And don't go with your Dad, or do, if you want to. But go with DH and DS first.

gretti · 15/12/2022 22:41

OldReliable · 15/12/2022 22:37

Sounds like you're stuck between trying to please two abusive men. But now you don't know which one to placate which is why you're so stressed out.

Don't go, and finish with your husband. He's no good for you.

I think he will be finishing with me at this rate. I've done everything he asked. He's always been nervous of being around my dad again. I can't ask anymore of my dad in his response.

My dad was abusive a long time ago. It doesn't make it ok but I don't think he is now. Clearly DH continues to be though.

I give up tbh.

OP posts:
CJsGoldfish · 15/12/2022 22:40

I feel like I'm reading a different thread than everyone else 🙄
I would go.
You feel your dad is trying to make amends and your relationship is in a good place now. His message about your dh backs that up.

I think it is your dh being an arse. Especially after the latest development but even before that. He sounds like he doesn't want you to spend time with your family.

ethelredonagoodday · 15/12/2022 22:39

ethelredonagoodday · 15/12/2022 22:38

My point was that the dad has said that the husband is invited.

Sorry, should have said that was to @ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen.

ethelredonagoodday · 15/12/2022 22:38

My point was that the dad has said that the husband is invited.

gretti · 15/12/2022 22:37

ethelredonagoodday · 15/12/2022 22:33

Yep I get it @gretti - I felt very much the same about my Dad. He came good in the end, despite being a bit rubbish for a lot of years. I hope yours does too.

Thank you. I'm glad someone does!

I have backed off my dad completely for a while now. And I'm happy with how our relationship is. I gave in and accepted id never have the close dad/daughter relationship that I wander. Equally I didn't want to lose him. He's still my dad.

I told myself I would back off but if he made the effort then I would be there.

OP posts:
OldReliable · 15/12/2022 22:37

Sounds like you're stuck between trying to please two abusive men. But now you don't know which one to placate which is why you're so stressed out.

Don't go, and finish with your husband. He's no good for you.

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 15/12/2022 22:36

ethelredonagoodday · 15/12/2022 22:31

Have you read the full thread?

Yes, and personally I don't think she should be giving her husband another chance but that's her choice. OP is appeasing two abusive men. Both of them are behaving wrongly, but OP made this thread to chat about her dads offer not whether she should be with her husband. Her husband being a shithead doesn't make her dads offer right.

ethelredonagoodday · 15/12/2022 22:33

Yep I get it @gretti - I felt very much the same about my Dad. He came good in the end, despite being a bit rubbish for a lot of years. I hope yours does too.

ethelredonagoodday · 15/12/2022 22:31

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 15/12/2022 22:26

@gretti first of all, you aren't looking forward to the holiday either way so why go irregardless?

Second, you recognise he was a dad father. What will you do if he treats you or DC the same while you're away? If he can't be trusted to behave dear god don't lock yourself into time away with him where you can't escape.

Third, it's just fucking disrespectful. If your husband wanted to take the kids on holiday with his family and leave you home alone you'd be devastated. Would you let him take them and go or expect him to say no?

You say he could call and make nice with your dad. Even if he isn't the best husband, someone who loves you won't like watching you take being treated like shit or making nice with someone he knows does that. He's your dad, you need to be the one that deals with him. You tell him what he's offering is unreasonable.

Have you read the full thread?

gretti · 15/12/2022 22:28

I've spoken to DH and read him my dads response to my message. I said it's a good thing as it's finally put to bed and my dad totally understands of the situation and wouldn't want Dh to miss out. I said it was a chance for them to build bridges.

Dhs response was no - he doesn't want to go and he doesn't want us to go either. He's gone from saying I need to tell my dad that it's unfair because Dh doesn't want to miss dc first holiday abroad to be actually just doesn't want any of us to go.

As I've said, my dad isn't bad hasn't been the best but this is my Dh being controlling which deep down was my gut feeling. It's got nothing to do with not being apart of a family holiday. He just doesn't want us to go - he said he wouldn't trust me being away for a week. Nothings changed in our marriage :-( sadly this has highlighted this.

Now I'm just getting the awful silent treatment from him.

OP posts:
ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 15/12/2022 22:26

@gretti first of all, you aren't looking forward to the holiday either way so why go irregardless?

Second, you recognise he was a dad father. What will you do if he treats you or DC the same while you're away? If he can't be trusted to behave dear god don't lock yourself into time away with him where you can't escape.

Third, it's just fucking disrespectful. If your husband wanted to take the kids on holiday with his family and leave you home alone you'd be devastated. Would you let him take them and go or expect him to say no?

You say he could call and make nice with your dad. Even if he isn't the best husband, someone who loves you won't like watching you take being treated like shit or making nice with someone he knows does that. He's your dad, you need to be the one that deals with him. You tell him what he's offering is unreasonable.

SavingKitten · 15/12/2022 22:15

Can’t you just go without the kids or DH and have it just a family adult holiday?