Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say upstairs neighbour should pay?

58 replies

Leakingtoilet · 15/12/2022 18:50

Looking for advice for anyone with knowledge about the law here. Daughter lives in a flat and 2 days ago the upstairs neighbours toilet flooded and came through the ceiling. Vague reason given was too much paper blocked the toilet and caused it to overflow. They have no lights because of this and need an emergency electrician due to fire risk.

Upstairs neighbour is refusing to pay and says they are not insured. Downstairs neighbour has told daughter that she shouldn't pay as she won't be able to get the money back.

Upstairs neighbour should definitely be paying imo but is there anything daughter and her partner can do to make neighbour pay?

Both flats are owned

AIBU to say neighbour should pay?

Just to add I have always rented so not in best position to advise her on this.

OP posts:
Getoff · 15/12/2022 23:07

formulatingAresponse · 15/12/2022 23:01

The owners of the upstairs flat are complete and utter idiots for not having their flat insured unless they're just flat out lying so their premiums don't go up

In a flat it's not the owners job to take out buildings insurance, it's the management company. Flat-owners only need contents insurance, which is irrelevant, because it's buildings insurance that pays for water leaks.

Getoff · 15/12/2022 23:05

The circumstances are important. Buildings insurance won't cover it when it was caused by the neighbour blocking their toilet with too much paper.

It is the job of buildings insurance on a block of flats to cover damage caused by a flat above. They can't not cover you because the person who damaged your flat was negligent.

Would your car insurance refuse to fix your car because the person who crashed into you was drunk?

formulatingAresponse · 15/12/2022 23:01

The owners of the upstairs flat are complete and utter idiots for not having their flat insured unless they're just flat out lying so their premiums don't go up

formulatingAresponse · 15/12/2022 22:58

Sorry to be blunt

formulatingAresponse · 15/12/2022 22:58

I can't believe how clueless people are

formulatingAresponse · 15/12/2022 22:58

Your daughter should be discussing this with her insurance company that's what they're for

ZenNudist · 15/12/2022 22:57

thefirstmrsrochester · 15/12/2022 18:56

Yep, as has been said, your daughter should claim on her insurance and leave it to them to recover the losses from the neighbour upstairs.

This.

formulatingAresponse · 15/12/2022 22:55

The Upstairs neighbours are at fault and will have to pay for all repairs

formulatingAresponse · 15/12/2022 22:55

This happened to me a few years ago

You just contact your insurance and they sort it all out regardless

The sooner she calls them the better as they need to assess and take photos etc etc

SinnerBoy · 15/12/2022 22:36

*billy1966 ·

I would think that she claims from her insurance and the insurance company goes after payment from the apartment upstairs.

Yes, that will be the case, if her insurers think that it's worth the effort.

As mentioned, we were rear ended, it was a guy on a trade plate. It turned out later that he wasn't insured. I think that either he was using it as a runaround, or his boss said, "I'm not claiming 8 grand, you can pay."

Because of policy clauses, the rental company and insurance company wouldn't pay up. I had to lodge about £6,000 with the rental company, for the temporary car.

I also had to provide credit card details and statements of income, to prove that I couldn't afford it. I mean, I had savings to cover it, but couldn't afford it. It took 3 years to get MIB to cover the cost and get the money back, along with scads of bank statements, emails and legal declarations.

The strain was awful.

The solicitor told me that it was so that they could sue him for costs.

Our car was a Passat, which they paid £4,500 for. They rented us an Audi A4 at £220 daily. I kept asking for something more sedate, not least because of how damned thirsty it was.

LBOCS2 · 15/12/2022 20:34

Buildings insurance covers this, including inside demised areas, it's for the structure of the building and services. They may try and recover it from the at-fault flat, but it is 100% covered. It will not cover your daughter's possessions however - she needs to claim on her own contents insurance for those.

HundredMilesAnHour · 15/12/2022 20:14

The circumstances are important. Buildings insurance won't cover it when it was caused by the neighbour blocking their toilet with too much paper.

She needs to make a claim with her contents insurer and let them decide if they want to go after the neighbour to get costs back. Usually with a leak from a neighbouring flat, the 'owner' of the leak isn't held financially responsible as long as they dealt with it promptly (rather than ignoring it for days). However, if the neighbour has admitted responsibility, the insurer may have a case against them but let the insurer worry about that. I'd suggest you ask the neighbour to put any excess on her claim and if the neighbour refuses, I'd consider going down the Small Claims route (depending on the amount of the excess).

Dazzledee · 15/12/2022 20:06

This exact thing happened to us - overflow toilet flooded our flat. The damage was worth about £15 grand as we had to have the full bathroom striped out and left to dry before rebuilding. We most definitely claimed on our own insurance and they most definitely paid out!

Natty13 · 15/12/2022 19:58

I had to get a separate policy (in addition to buildings insurange) to cover for damage caused if the neighbouring properties aren't insured. My solicitor wouldn't proceed with the sale without it. I got one for about £250 that lasts for 25 years or something, I can't remember exactly but those are rough numbers.

Thisismadness · 15/12/2022 19:51

I’m not in England so don’t entirely know the leasehold/freehold position but it’s likely there would be a communal buildings policy that covers common areas and each flat owner insures their own property or one policy that covers everything which your daughter probably pays towards.
Her contents policy would cover damaged contents like carpets but not say light fittings, damaged plaster and paintwork, that’s building insurance.

2ManyPjs · 15/12/2022 19:41

@Leakingtoilet If it's not covered on the communal buildings insurance then she could try her home contents insurance, which is probably a separate policy?

JhsLs · 15/12/2022 19:37

Is the building leasehold to freehold? If it’s leasehold, the freeholder is required to sort out the buildings insurance, which will cover this. If it’s freehold, it’ll be managed by someone on the building and everyone will be paying money towards the management of the building. I would suggest using that money to pay for the damage if that’s the case.

Askinforabaskin · 15/12/2022 19:33

Her own insurance might include legal costs of chasing the upstairs owner

Thisismadness · 15/12/2022 19:19

She or her Insurers will be able to claim from the neighbour if it can be shown they were negligent. It doesn’t really sound like they were unless they ignored a problem with the toilet or caused it in some way.

billy1966 · 15/12/2022 19:13

She needs to contact her insurance company and ask for their advice.

I would think that she claims from her insurance and the insurance company goes after payment from the apartment upstairs.

Flapjackquack · 15/12/2022 19:06

Leakingtoilet · 15/12/2022 18:57

Apparently downstairs neighbour who has lived there a long time says this isn't covered by the buildings insurance as that only covers communal areas and pipes. My research so far seems to back that up

Ah yes, ours was due to pipes. I do wonder though if the electrics are unsafe whether it becomes the buildings problem.

Thefriendlyone · 15/12/2022 19:05

She needs to tell her buildings insurer. They will sort it

MajorCarolDanvers · 15/12/2022 19:04

Leave to insurance to sort it out.

birdsandthewasps · 15/12/2022 19:01

Let the insurance company sort it out no other option tbh

ohioriver · 15/12/2022 18:58

But your dd should have insurance of her own?

Otherwise she can only pay for it and take the upstairs neighbour to the small claims. And if they've no money she won't get anything in actuality.