Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell him not to send the presents with his name on...

233 replies

Jinglejangle09 · 15/12/2022 16:44

From when my children were born we always said all presents were from Santa - even presents from family were just put in with what Santa had bought. We said this to all family and they were obviously under no obligation to buy for the children as they wouldn't get any credit for it.
Most family were fine with it (or at least didn't say anything to my face!).
Kids are now 7 and 8 and both still believe.
My Dad has messaged this year saying oh we are going to put messages on as we want them to know who they are from. I have gone back to him and said that he should save them for the kids birthdays if he wants them to be from him. Both birthdays Jan and Feb anyway.
AIBU? I just don't really know how I can change the whole gifting from Santa now. I maybe should have thought more about it when they were younger.

OP posts:
WhatALotOfAFussAboutNothing · 15/12/2022 19:57

I’ve never understood this - we thought Santa delivered the presents as kids but never that he’d bought them. We knew family had bought them!

Kids need to know things cost money and be appreciative of things people have bought for them.

It’s ridiculous to just say everything is from Santa! It doesn’t ruin the magic of him delivering gifts on Christmas Eve to let your children know they’re from family.

gamechangling · 15/12/2022 19:57

Just shift the story a bit this year and again next year - what's the plan when they don't believe to have no presents?
Our kids think Santa gives stocking and one or two gifts, rest of gifts from family, friends, each other etc -

You can make a small shift like taking your dads gifts and letting them be from the right people so they can thank them -

Hellybelly84 · 15/12/2022 19:55

Its not as complicated as you are making it out to be and it really wont be a big thing on Xmas day. Just have some presents from Santa and some from family. You can even say he delivers the family ones too if you want to. We had that growing up and we do the same for our kids and its never been questioned once. They will be too busy and excited to think twice and nice for relatives to see their faces when they open it.

Twillow · 15/12/2022 19:54

Don't your children ever ask (or wonder) why other people get presents from you but not them?
Santa is a bit of fun, not a religion. YABU.

Menopausecankissmyass · 15/12/2022 19:51

Yabu - when DD was a lot younger and believed we told her that Santa gets her presents but as her family love her they like to get some extra gifts for her as well.
Didn't spoil the magic in any way shape or form and family got the credit for the lovely presents they bought

Dello · 15/12/2022 19:51

You are way too invested in the Santa story to see the lovely thing that is grandparents who care.

milveycrohn · 15/12/2022 19:46

When I was a child, our Christmas stockings were from Santa. These were all small items that fitted into a normal men's sock size (not the giant things you see today).
Presents came from the family, whoever it was that had bought it.

annieannietomjoe · 15/12/2022 19:24

Not particularly helpful but this is the French custom. Think you could just say that GPs have got you a present this year...wouldn't over think it tbh

Greyarea12 · 15/12/2022 19:24

Jinglejangle09 · 15/12/2022 17:14

I agree with you all, I went with what I knew from my childhood before I had really thought it thought then it just carried on each year. I think it was my Mum who said to me something along the lines of 'oh they will say it doesn't matter if I am naughty Grandma will just get it for me'
You are all right I do need to think of a way of undoing it and maybe it's a letter that says as they are getting older santa will bring less.
I really don't think my family have had a big problem with it, my Mum has always said she doesn't buy for the credit.

At their age they won't know if santa gets them less as they unlikely remember how many presents santa got them last year. A simple X, Y and Z are getting you presents this year because as you get older santa doesnt bring you as much. Kids will be excited. Job done.

Personally I wouldn't buy a present for a niece/nephew if it was being passed off as Santa's present.

WandaWonder · 15/12/2022 19:23

I guess my biggest issue with this is the need to control others in how they are with your children

They are not doing anything harmful, mind you it is notcthe first time this has been mentioned, in general I mean

Pearshaped20 · 15/12/2022 19:20

We always had presents from santa and presents from mum and dad and family. Santa's presents had different paper and no tags

darjeelingrose · 15/12/2022 19:15

Nobody buys for the credit, surely? What a weird idea. But giving the children in my family a gift for Christmas, is a way of showing them how much I care, that I have thought about them and want to get them something they will like. Christmas is about giving, not just receiving, and you've made it all about receiving.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 15/12/2022 19:13

I understand the whole I made a decision a few years ago and feel stuck now - and clearly you can't go back in time.

You're kids have got to the age where thank you letters are called for. Could you try with some presents are from Santa and some are from relatives like Grandma and Grandad. Assuming you will see them at some point over Christmas could the GPs hand over the wrapped and labelled present but the presents that magically appear under the tree are 'from santa'?

Hard to know what the best thing to do from here but good luck

EmmaDilemma5 · 15/12/2022 19:05

That's really sad for your kids to think no one in their family cares to get them a gift.

And very weird of you.

If I were your family, I'd wait til you were in the kitchen and tell them that I bought it.

12345mummy · 15/12/2022 19:05

YANBU - every family has its own different story and I’m always happy to take the parents lead on what they’ve told their children. OP cannot just change the story now, so I believe that grandparents etc should continue to go along with it. The children will realise in years to come and can say their thank you’s then. For me it’s all about the children and as a gift giver I’d be happy for them to believe Santa provided my present as long as they’re happy!

Zanatdy · 15/12/2022 19:03

Jinglejangle09 · 15/12/2022 17:14

I agree with you all, I went with what I knew from my childhood before I had really thought it thought then it just carried on each year. I think it was my Mum who said to me something along the lines of 'oh they will say it doesn't matter if I am naughty Grandma will just get it for me'
You are all right I do need to think of a way of undoing it and maybe it's a letter that says as they are getting older santa will bring less.
I really don't think my family have had a big problem with it, my Mum has always said she doesn't buy for the credit.

It’s very easy to undo it, as someone suggested just say now they can read there will be labels. Kids at that age believe anything.

Zanatdy · 15/12/2022 19:00

I think that’s a bit odd to have family presents from Santa. Why can’t Santa bring gifts from him, but other people give a gift direct to the child? In my house Santa was merely the delivery guy, nothing was actually from him. But if find it quite rude to have to tell family that the kids won’t be thanking you as they are from Santa.

bfc1980 · 15/12/2022 18:49

My parents did Christmas this way also and I never thanked them on Christmas day as it was Santa who got the presents for us. As an adult now, I really feel like I didn't appreciate how hard they worked to buy so many gifts for me and my brothers. Especially as we were quite poor.

As a parent, my kids get 2 gifts each from Santa (usually something small - dd wants a talking parrot toy and ds wants Fifa 23 this year). It was usually just 1 gift each but since me and their mum have split up, they now get a gift at each house. All other presents are bought by me and their mum and because of this they appreciate that it's us buying the bulk of their presents.

Stripedbag101 · 15/12/2022 18:44

as an aunt I put a lot of thought into gifts. I write personal messages in books - I buy things that we have enjoyed doing together.

my sister and brother in law buy the Santa presents. They don’t use mine to add to the Santa pile. This would make me really unhappy.

you are right to end this. The children need to know their family members buy them lovely gift for Christmas. They need to say thank you.

how awful for them to think their grandparents don’t buy them Christmas gifts. Awful situations.

WandaWonder · 15/12/2022 18:40

To me it is nothing about giving credit it or not just none of it makes sense

TheKitchenWitch · 15/12/2022 18:36

What on earth gives you the right to take a present for your children that someone else has chosen and bought for them and then pretend that it came from Santa? That is utterly bizarre in every possible way. If you want to put up with the charade of Santa being real (utter madness imo), then go for it, but using family presents to prop up the lie? Fuck that. YABVVVVU

ittakes2 · 15/12/2022 18:34

I don’t get why you are against this - does it mean you buy less presents because of this and don’t want to lose that? I am sure the kids think it’s weird they don’t get presents from grandparents?
I can imagine everyone thought you were crazy when you came up with this looney idea and no one said anything. Hats off to your very understanding family!

Abraxan · 15/12/2022 18:33

Yabu.

Of course grandparents want to buy for their grandchildren. Of course they should be allowed to put their name on it.

This wasn't how FC worked in our house. Doesn't seem a very fair system.

5128gap · 15/12/2022 18:33

You should let your family give the children presents with their names on. Just because you're their mother I don't think you get to dictate every (harmless) interaction your children have with their other relatives in accordance with your own (unusual) preferences. As for denying your children the gifts because people understandably don't want to comply with your rules, well, I think that's highly unfair and not in your children's interests at all.

Inserthiliarioususernamehere · 15/12/2022 18:31

I think you need to put a stop to the ‘Santa only’ presents too. Santa brings little gifts in our family and big presents are from their loving grown ups. I work with children, It’s horrible to hear some saying how much Santa brought them when other kids get very little, or nothing at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread