Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell him not to send the presents with his name on...

233 replies

Jinglejangle09 · 15/12/2022 16:44

From when my children were born we always said all presents were from Santa - even presents from family were just put in with what Santa had bought. We said this to all family and they were obviously under no obligation to buy for the children as they wouldn't get any credit for it.
Most family were fine with it (or at least didn't say anything to my face!).
Kids are now 7 and 8 and both still believe.
My Dad has messaged this year saying oh we are going to put messages on as we want them to know who they are from. I have gone back to him and said that he should save them for the kids birthdays if he wants them to be from him. Both birthdays Jan and Feb anyway.
AIBU? I just don't really know how I can change the whole gifting from Santa now. I maybe should have thought more about it when they were younger.

OP posts:
Heliumburgers · 15/12/2022 21:00

I think you need to buy some Stockings or Santa bags, get them very excited about leaving them out and then any other gifts under the tree.
You could even have an elf (either elf on shelf or one of Santa's helpers) deliver them with a letter about how he's changing it and a Chocolate coins. You can be super surprised and excited about it. Presents under the tree are from family including you. Take each out to pick a gift for the other they can wrap up and put under the tree.
This system you decided is mental and unsustainable

Kitkatcatflap · 15/12/2022 20:52

Ibouncetothebeat · 15/12/2022 16:48

Mmmm, I think YABU. This sounds a bit precious and your children are old enough for you to let it go now. Why can’t they receive presents from family and show some gratitude for them? In the grand scheme of things it won’t affect their belief in Santa to know that grandad sent them a gift. This tradition is all about you at this point, let it go.

This - every word

blubberyboo · 15/12/2022 20:37

Yabu

presumably if you take this stance then your children have never made nor bought a Christmas gift for their family…. Because all their presents come from Santa too???

you are preventing your children from learning the value and joy in giving and causing them to believe goodness only come from fantasy characters.

they are a good age now to stop this and I don’t agree it will make them naughty if they think someone else will buy them stuff! They don’t get to choose their gifts from people.
they will learn gratitude and to say thank you.
I say by sticking to this Santa story you have actually more chance of turning them into brats

let your dad put the label on

SugarNspices · 15/12/2022 20:34

No you abvu. It's dishonest to your kids also taking it so seriously saying it's all from Santa. If you want to put your gifts from him then fine it's up to you you bought them. Family should have the choice to say it's from them.

pimlicoanna · 15/12/2022 20:33

Yes YABU!

DarkDarkNight · 15/12/2022 20:32

YABU, I think you should have thought about it earlier. It’s unfair to expect people to give presents yet tell the children they’re from Santa. So your children will see other people get presents off friends and relatives but think theirs don’t give presents? They never say thank you?

How do you explain why Santa gives your children way more presents?

reallyhatewinter · 15/12/2022 20:30

Can grandad not give the present early so DC can then put it under the tree until Xmas day.
YABVU - you're poor family giving a gift that the DC never know is from them.

gluteustothemaximus · 15/12/2022 20:28

I must have been thick as pig shit as a child, because I thought all the presents came from Santa, yet I spent Christmas hols writing thank you letters to various relatives Xmas Confused

WildImaginings · 15/12/2022 20:25

Utterly ridiculous.

You, not your dad.

Wallstick · 15/12/2022 20:24

"... And this one's from Grandad."

Job done?

Reugny · 15/12/2022 20:22

Hellno44 · 15/12/2022 20:12

Do the stocking from Santa.

This.

Though I'm sure my 4 year old says she believes in Santa so she can get presents. She doesn't believe in fairies and ghosts. I have absolutely no idea why as I've not discussed them with her.

AlwaysFullOfQuestions22 · 15/12/2022 20:20

Also when little Johnny says oh my grandpa and grandma got me a cool lego set.
Your dcs may think oh my GPs got me nothing!

AlwaysFullOfQuestions22 · 15/12/2022 20:18

So when your dcs go to school and say o had 40 presents from santa ranging from. For example bikes, lego etc

And their mates say we only got a Stocking from santa. It seems a bit ott

My kids will say oh nana i would love xyz for xmas. Or Aunty please can i have... (when they are asked of course not randomly)

My 4yr old remembers who gets her what for occasions. She really appreciates it

You sound controlling

Blanketpolicy · 15/12/2022 20:18

Why can't you just say the presents that you have bought and are under the tree are from Santa and keep the others from your family separate and they can open them later once the Santa presents have been unwrapped and played with?

PurpleWisteria1 · 15/12/2022 20:16

It’s not really about getting ‘credit’
It’s about building that relationship and memories between grandparent and grandchild.
My kids talk all year about the gift that ‘grandad’ bought them for Christmas.
As they get older, they will think it’s very strange that grandparents presents weren’t given out from them? They must be already thinking I wonder why no one else buys us presents. My 3 kids asked why me and their dad didn’t buy presents at that age. They said Santa got lots but nothing from mum and dad so they do think about these things.

comfortablylesslumpy · 15/12/2022 20:15

YABVVU.
Sorry, but this a weird way to deal with presents. And totally unfair on those giving them.

Hellno44 · 15/12/2022 20:12

Do the stocking from Santa.

Jouto · 15/12/2022 20:09

Well that was a quite bonkers approach. But what's done is done.
Talk to them, about the season of giving. Santa can still bring presents, but santa knows they have a loving family and its important to appreciate the ones we loce and get them to help wrap a present to give to a relative and get them writing thank you notes after for the relative presents to them.

Linning · 15/12/2022 20:08

I find it very strange that people send in their Xmas present to be open when they won’t be around to see it (unless they live in another country entirely). In my family all gifts were technically from Santa but you would get your Xmas gift at the different relatives houses so you would know those gifts where the ones ordered by whoever relatives it was and be grateful to them.

Which means that if I wanted the Xmas from my grandma or my aunt, I would need to go visit them. Which was somehow nice because it forced you to do your part and visit family and it meant you could still get Xmas gift weeks or even months later if you hadn’t gone to a close relatives house since December 24th.

I couldn’t personally imagine, having my kids receive present and not know who it’s from and for those people to not even be present when they are opened. It seems a bit greedy to have people send in the presents and then give them no recognition or credit as if they weren’t even part of making Xmas at all.

Blueblell · 15/12/2022 20:08

Yes you are making a mistake here. Some gifts from Santa some from you and definitely family should get the credit for the ones they give. I made a similar mistake in the early years, made all my presents from Santa but then one year the kids asked why I never bought them anything and I realised it was not the way to do things!

EasterIsland · 15/12/2022 20:05

Of course you’re unreasonable.

You are depriving your children of knowing that there are so many people in their family who love them, and take pleasure in giving them presents. And you are depriving your children of the chance to thank their grandparents and other family, and talk about their presents and what they like etc etc.

The whole “presents from Santa” thing is really naff. It distorts the loving exchange of gifts within families, where people show their care for each other.

Give them a stocking from Father Christmas by all means - you can fill it full of stuff from Poundland. But let the children appreciate their grandparents!!

FlamingoQueen · 15/12/2022 20:04

I would not buy anything for them! Is it just to save them having to write thank you cards?

BellePeppa · 15/12/2022 20:00

It’s far better for presents to be a mix of Santa and family. Even though my children believed in Santa when they were young all the presents were labelled by whoever bought them. No one gave it a thought, not even the kids😁

Beelezebub · 15/12/2022 20:00

My MIL wanted to do this but by saying that he’d been to her house and left things there.

That was a hard no.

YABU. Really unreasonable. I can guarantee that while no one said anything to you, they’ve definitely said things about it that you aren’t aware of.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/12/2022 19:58

We’ll that’s an odd setup, but hey it’s worked until now. I think to undo it is pretty easy. Just start putting the names of the givers on the presents and still have some from Santa.

To be honest your kids are in prime ‘finding out’ time so it won’t be weird and will naturally make sense. If your mum isn’t fussed then include hers in the Santa pile.

To be honest I came into this thinking the worst as we had an incident of my MIL swapping our names with hers on our niece’s Christmas presents. Honestly still don’t know what possessed her to do that it’s not that we were super extravagant or anything. We would buy her an outfit, some books, and a couple of toys.