Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What will happen if nurses and other professions don't get their pay rise?

161 replies

malificent7 · 15/12/2022 14:21

The country has come to enough of a standstill as it is. I fully support them btw....do they keep striking?

OP posts:
JamSandle · 15/12/2022 18:52

I imagine they will bring in more overseas nurses and treat them like shit until they leave too. Nurses deserve more.

JamSandle · 15/12/2022 18:51

They better get that pay rise!

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 15/12/2022 18:50

Always worth remembering that this government have;

Blown a £30 billion hole in the economy with trussenomics.

Spent £38 billion on test and trace.

Spent £9 billion on useless PPE.

Spent £11 billion in over paying interest.

Lost £40 billion in tax revenue from Brexit.

Spent £15 billion on projects described as wasteful or duff (with £4 billion of that going to companies with links to tory mps).

They're very good at finding and spending money when it suits them and it should be blatantly obvious that the only reason there "isn't any money" for nurses or rail workers is because isn't doesn't suit the tories grand privatisation plans.

caringcarer · 15/12/2022 18:47

They will continue to strike I think. Some will leave for alternative employment. @Thelnebriati it would cost £27 billion to give nurses these pay demands. Where would it come from? It cost a fortune to give benefits claimants and pensioners a cost of living match pay rise. I guess the government only had one lot of money and chose to give it to benefits claimants and pensioners. They could have chose 5.6 percent for the lot which was average pay across private sector. I suppose then none would be happy. Civil servants only got 2 percent. I don't think Teachers, firefighters or police will get huge cost of living pay rise either. Anyone that gets paid from public purse is easy target for government. They are trying to keep a lid on inflation so B of E can stop having to increase base rate affecting most people's mortgages.

Toddlerteaplease · 15/12/2022 18:46

TabithaTittlemouse · 15/12/2022 18:40

I’ll seriously considering joining an agency. Most days I work alongside agency staff on a much higher wage than me and get told that they can’t do a lot of the job because they are agency.

I'm in two, I quite like seeing different hospitals, doing different skills. I've worked on a surgical ward for 18 years, and rarely do medical. So it's a good opportunity to brush up on those skills. It's given me loads more confidence in my own practice, as you are out I do your comfort zone. Plus you know if you don't like a place, you never have to go back. And it's made me realise that everyone is in the same boat and the grass is not greener!

Greensky90 · 15/12/2022 18:45

@Usernamen what generous pension? In NHS I think you pay a decent chunk something like 12.5 percent from your salary. Nurses often working till 60 which isn't easy for nurses your body slows down.

BadNomad · 15/12/2022 18:42

Usernamen · 15/12/2022 18:26

Not all nurses earn £25k. Many more earn close to the $80k figure you quoted than you perhaps realise. I used to know one who is quite senior and earned £60k (some years ago now), and if you include the very generous pension you pretty much get to that $80k salary in the US.

That being said, I’d like to see many more nurses on this pay level, not just the senior ones. It’s a really tough job and this needs to be reflected in the pay.

Most nurses don't become senior nurses. Most nurses stay band 5 for all of their careers. Top of band 7, which is a ward sister, is £47k. So, no, many don't earn close to $80k. £60 is band 8b. You won't find any of those working as a staff nurse on a ward. That is consultant level. Not the average nurse.

TabithaTittlemouse · 15/12/2022 18:40

I’ll seriously considering joining an agency. Most days I work alongside agency staff on a much higher wage than me and get told that they can’t do a lot of the job because they are agency.

iRun2eatCake · 15/12/2022 18:34

Thelnebriati · 15/12/2022 14:34

YANBU to wonder but why shouldn't they get a pay rise in line with inflation?

Because there would be no money to give the politicians their rises.

LakieLady · 15/12/2022 18:31

AelinAshriver · 15/12/2022 17:16

Ok so where can the government find the money to avoid making cuts?

Easy. A series of weath tax:

End Non Dom Status - 3 billion pounds

Annual 1% tax on wealth over 5million - 10 billion pounds

45p income tax rate over £80,000 and a 50p rate for income over £125,000 - 6 billion.

Finally, if you equalise dividends and capital gains tax with income tax rates, that would raise 21 billion pounds.

These measures would raise 40 billion. This isnt thinking about a windfall tax or ending the loophole which allows the rich to not pay tax on their companies (Google, Amazon etc) or the super rich squirrling away their billions in offshore accounts...

Perhaps MP's could put an end to paying their energy bills from their second homes on expenses and allowances when they earn £84,000 anyway. This is when their pay has increased by 28% since 2010 and have had a £2200 pay rise this year alone during the cost of living crisis.

But there's no money for nurses....

We could do with a chancellor of the exchequer like you, @AelinAshriver !

You'd get my vote.

Usernamen · 15/12/2022 18:26

BadNomad · 15/12/2022 16:49

Nah. They'll just have to privatise the healthcare system. The average nurse will then get paid what he/she is worth (that's around $80k in the USA), then the public will be charged a small fortune every time they need anything.

That's much better than giving nurses 19% on their £25k.

Not all nurses earn £25k. Many more earn close to the $80k figure you quoted than you perhaps realise. I used to know one who is quite senior and earned £60k (some years ago now), and if you include the very generous pension you pretty much get to that $80k salary in the US.

That being said, I’d like to see many more nurses on this pay level, not just the senior ones. It’s a really tough job and this needs to be reflected in the pay.

MoanySloney · 15/12/2022 18:26

Bard6817 · 15/12/2022 15:01

19% according to the news. Mad, unreasonable. I wish they were paid more, but not that much now.

Seems to me it’s nurses, rmt, etc, vs the taxpayer now. Some will support no doubt, but goodwill is fading fast for RMT and Nurses will only get it til someone you know can’t get treatment.

Will the tax payer be happy when there are no nurses at all?

LakieLady · 15/12/2022 18:23

Florenz · 15/12/2022 16:17

Yes but they receive more public money (from taxes) than they pay in taxes. So in reality they don't pay tax. It's like giving someone £10 and taking £2 of it back. In reality you just gave them £8. They didn't give you anything.

I don't disagree that nurses deserve a payrise but 19% is too much. Private sector workers have suffered a great deal in recent years what with COVID etc and it's time we were thought about a bit more instead of being taken for granted/used as cash cows.

The money they receive from tax revenue is for the work they do though, same as police officers and any other public sector workers. They "give" us all their labour, skills and knowledge.

If private sector workers don't like their pay and conditions, they can vote with their feet and move to the public sector. They can even train to be nurses if they fancy it.

Tiredalwaystired · 15/12/2022 18:12

Florenz · 15/12/2022 16:03

Where does the money for all these rises come from? It's private sector workers that have to pay for it all and most of us will not see anything like a 19% raise this year.

Uh…public sector staff pay the same level of tax as you do.

EmmaAgain22 · 15/12/2022 18:12

MarshaBradyo · 15/12/2022 17:40

Taxing everything to the hilt is no good answer when companies and people have options - ie more favourable countries

I wouldn't want to tax everything to the hilt. Just saying a corp tax raise is where I'd start.

Thisismynamenow · 15/12/2022 17:41

ohsotired2022 · 15/12/2022 15:32

The RCN spokeswoman on the news this morning discussed that Nurses haven't had their wages brought up to inflation in 12 years so the 19% would bring them up to where they should be.

I think the current government don't care about the nhs, the nurses, the patients who access the nhs.
They have wanted to privatise for years and the cynic in me thinks this is part of the bigger plan for privatisation.

Interesting that Nicola Sturgeon doesn't want to privatise the NHS in Scotland and has met with the unions, had discussion around pay and has made an offer resulting in the strikes currently called off in Scotland.

@ohsotired2022 but no public sector, local government or civil servant has. I've worked in the public sector for 12 years and never got more than a 1% payrise.

I support the strike fully but if they get 19% or even 10% the entire public sector will likely down tools for the same.

MarshaBradyo · 15/12/2022 17:40

EmmaAgain22 · 15/12/2022 17:34

Interesting
I'd put corporation tax up before any of this

are the government thinking that the NHS will be like care homes, just a profit option? I don't think many people will want to start private hospitals so I can only conclude they really want to recreate Victorian Britain.

Taxing everything to the hilt is no good answer when companies and people have options - ie more favourable countries

MushMonster · 15/12/2022 17:37

That is a good question OP.
We could see nurses leaving in mass.
I wish the government would offer something fair, but I have little hope with this lot.
That is why I think we should demand new elections. Now.

EmmaAgain22 · 15/12/2022 17:34

AelinAshriver · 15/12/2022 17:16

Ok so where can the government find the money to avoid making cuts?

Easy. A series of weath tax:

End Non Dom Status - 3 billion pounds

Annual 1% tax on wealth over 5million - 10 billion pounds

45p income tax rate over £80,000 and a 50p rate for income over £125,000 - 6 billion.

Finally, if you equalise dividends and capital gains tax with income tax rates, that would raise 21 billion pounds.

These measures would raise 40 billion. This isnt thinking about a windfall tax or ending the loophole which allows the rich to not pay tax on their companies (Google, Amazon etc) or the super rich squirrling away their billions in offshore accounts...

Perhaps MP's could put an end to paying their energy bills from their second homes on expenses and allowances when they earn £84,000 anyway. This is when their pay has increased by 28% since 2010 and have had a £2200 pay rise this year alone during the cost of living crisis.

But there's no money for nurses....

Interesting
I'd put corporation tax up before any of this

are the government thinking that the NHS will be like care homes, just a profit option? I don't think many people will want to start private hospitals so I can only conclude they really want to recreate Victorian Britain.

AelinAshriver · 15/12/2022 17:32

MilkyYay · 15/12/2022 17:19

Finally, if you equalise dividends and capital gains tax with income tax rates, that would raise 21 billion pounds.

Not sure how you've worked this one out? Do you work in tax? Im going to guess not.

I don't work in tax no. But Richard Burgon did as an employment lawyer who I quoted directly from.

vm.tiktok.com/ZMFsgdXyp/

HTH 🤷

MilkyYay · 15/12/2022 17:19

Finally, if you equalise dividends and capital gains tax with income tax rates, that would raise 21 billion pounds.

Not sure how you've worked this one out? Do you work in tax? Im going to guess not.

MilkyYay · 15/12/2022 17:18

The problem is the government know that with healthcare workers, the NHS is the biggest employer. There are not enough alternatives for most nurses to go and work elsewhere.

Most nurses also can't in reality afford to simply stop. For many, even though the pay is not good enough, they need the money.

Many nurses also really do love what they do, the patients etc, they have a vocation.

All these things mean that as a workforce they are vulnerable to being taken advantage of for too little money.

I hope they hold out for a good deal, i really do, but i worry that as a pp said we'll end with an agency structure where nurses refuse to work directly for NHS and go via agencies to access bettee pay. A bad option because this will cost the government far more.

AelinAshriver · 15/12/2022 17:16

Ok so where can the government find the money to avoid making cuts?

Easy. A series of weath tax:

End Non Dom Status - 3 billion pounds

Annual 1% tax on wealth over 5million - 10 billion pounds

45p income tax rate over £80,000 and a 50p rate for income over £125,000 - 6 billion.

Finally, if you equalise dividends and capital gains tax with income tax rates, that would raise 21 billion pounds.

These measures would raise 40 billion. This isnt thinking about a windfall tax or ending the loophole which allows the rich to not pay tax on their companies (Google, Amazon etc) or the super rich squirrling away their billions in offshore accounts...

Perhaps MP's could put an end to paying their energy bills from their second homes on expenses and allowances when they earn £84,000 anyway. This is when their pay has increased by 28% since 2010 and have had a £2200 pay rise this year alone during the cost of living crisis.

But there's no money for nurses....

Toddlerteaplease · 15/12/2022 16:52

Just had a message from a striking colleague to say that they've all been called back in, as the people covering were only on short days.

AelinAshriver · 15/12/2022 16:50

Where does the money come from?

Well

We had the 11 billion that Rishi cost us when he forgot to insure the national debt.

And we had the 37 billion for the failed Test and Trace that never really cut infection.

And we had the 9 billion for the defective PPE.

And we had the 30 billion that Liz Truss cost us in her Mini Budget.

And of course we've had the 31 billion that Brexit has cost us so far. Which adds us to 118 billion.

So there's no magic money tree and we simply don't have the money for these pay rises for the public sector. It's just maths.

Or is it a corrupted Tory Government?