Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What will happen if nurses and other professions don't get their pay rise?

161 replies

malificent7 · 15/12/2022 14:21

The country has come to enough of a standstill as it is. I fully support them btw....do they keep striking?

OP posts:
Mydogatemypurse · 15/12/2022 20:16

Workinghardeveryday · 15/12/2022 14:51

a colleague’s sister works for Royal Mail, she gets £80 a day from the union when she is on strike!!!!

I dont think they do. My neighbour certainly doesnt who is currently a striking postie.

LexMitior · 15/12/2022 20:10

Me too, btw! Former public sector, now charging the taxpayer triple the rate.

LexMitior · 15/12/2022 20:09

But they are earning far more now on agency rates. It's the future

Schlaar · 15/12/2022 20:08

LexMitior · 15/12/2022 20:04

Schlaar, they will leave and work on contract. You can charge the public purse three to four times the rate and leave!

That's across the public sector now. The time is now to take your skills and contract.

Contracting isn’t better. In fact colleges and universities are purposely getting rid of permanent teachers and replacing them with contracted teachers, as a money saving exercise because it means they’re no longer liable for sick pay, maternity pay, holiday pay, pensions and all other employment benefits. The agency takes half of your salary so you don’t earn any more money either. So that’s the situation nurses will end up in too if they try to switch to working on contract!

LexMitior · 15/12/2022 20:07

I mean it's ridiculous because it's more expensive, you have less responsibility and you are literally paid more to care less, but that is what is coming.

LexMitior · 15/12/2022 20:04

Schlaar, they will leave and work on contract. You can charge the public purse three to four times the rate and leave!

That's across the public sector now. The time is now to take your skills and contract.

Schlaar · 15/12/2022 20:00

Nothing will happen if they don’t get their pay rise. They’re trained in that profession, they aren’t trained for anything else so will find it difficult to get a similar level job elsewhere. And they aren’t going to leave nursing for a lower paid unskilled position. So they’ll just have to put up and shut up. The same as the teachers who have gone on strike numerous times because of workload and conditions - nothing gets done and they’re trapped in their jobs because they’re not qualified for anything else.

willstarttomorrow · 15/12/2022 19:56

The real issue is that we have a Conservative government that control most of the press and have very successfully spread the narrative that public sector workers are all well off, have an amazing pension and are just greedy. I work in the public sector in a statutory service which does not really exists in the private sector (although the use of agency workers and private placements for looked after children is privatisation through the back door. A residential placement for a hard to place looked after child will usually cost around £8000 a week and that money is not going to the poorly paid, unqualified residential staff). My council has had cuts made EVERY YEAR which equate to multiple, tens of millions. We are all doing more for less, and in real terms have had an over 20% pay cut over the last decade. The current cost of living crisis, and before that covid, has just pushed people too far. There has been years of under investment and reserves and good will has been completely eroded.

No one wants to strike. Striking workers do not get paid and if you do not have a high earning partner, family support or savings, you are really taking a hit. Unions are vilified- however workers not part of a union have benefited from union actions over the years. If/when public sector pay is readjusted to where it should be, this will likely have an impact on the wider workforce. The same with working conditions. It amazes me when people tell us how lucky we are yet no one is racing to fill any of the many vacant posts that exist. You do not need to retrain (at your own expense) as a nurse, allied health professional, teacher or social worker. There remains a huge variety of jobs available. Amazingly, we cannot retain highly skilled admin staff on £16, 000 PA. The same in regards to solicitors, estates workers, accountants etc. It is quite likely if you want to be on the public sector payroll, there is a position available.

It depresses me that everything is always a race to the bottom. If as skilled, highly trained professionals (who tend to be paid a lot less- this is the deal for pensions etc) we express anger at our working conditions and pay depressingly people just jump in telling us how much worse it could be. We should shut up and be grateful to have a job. I have not nursed for nearly 20 years and have worked in child protection after retraining since then. I bloody love my job but the current working conditions are unbearable. Social workers (particularly those in their first 5 years) are just leaving g with nothing to go to.

If you are academically able to retrain (on no pay) and have the necessary disposition and resilience to work in the roles such as nursing, social work, the police etc- there is nothing stopping you. If you believe we have it easy and are just guaranteed pay if we turn up, take numerous paid sick days, will get a huge pension and clock off at 5 (no overtime- time of in lieu- currently have 214 hours to take back) then come and join us.

If not then please stop to think about how important our role is within a functioning society and luckily there are lots of people for whom it is something they love and (working conditions and pay allowing) will continue to want to do. These are not 'vocations' - just some us find this is our skill set and a job we love. Everyone contribites to our society in various ways. I have had police officers say they could not do my job but no way could I do theirs. The same with many private sector jobs, I would be shite at marketing, finance, or anything financial for example, my job is not more important. We just cannot continue to be penalised because of the anti- public service rhetoric. The money is there, we have seen it directed towards very wealthy Tory cronies- particularly during the pandemic.

MrsCarson · 15/12/2022 19:47

I think if they don't get a decent deal, it will force a lot of nurses to look seriously at either retiring, or moving abroad or moving to private. Things they may have considered but have been putting off thinking, maybe one day. But that day will come for many.

Daisy03 · 15/12/2022 19:26

@Workinghardeveryday I'm assuming you're a Tory bot.
If not, how do you think the union could afford to pay strikers salary? There are hardship funds but very hard to access as everyone can claim they need help.
It's a hard decision to strike as you lose your salary, particularly in current times, but it's the choice people are making to fight for their rights.

wonderstuff · 15/12/2022 19:19

I think they won’t get the pay rise and things will get worse, but at some point we’ll get a change in government and things will start getting better. There have been commentators saying the cumulative effect of the strikes could bring down the government. Collectively we need to start protesting I think, the healthcare system is hanging by a thread, education is struggling, social care isn’t sufficient, early years settings are struggling to stay afloat, the railways need investment, housing seems to have become a luxury. We’re a rich economy but somehow there’s less and less for ordinary people.

BaileySharp · 15/12/2022 19:18

I don't think they expect to get 19% tbh, but they may as well start asking high

SapatSea · 15/12/2022 19:15

Always seems to be money in the coffers or on the magic money tree for interfering in wars, "defence" armaments/planes, or spaffed on useless projects such as HS2 (£44.6bn and counting)Track and Trace (£22 bn initially and another £15 bn since - for what???), PPE contracts for mates, bail out for Bulb (£6.5bn, how did it cost that?)and on and on..... Barristers recently went on strike for a few days and got a 15% pay rise, so double digit rises are possible ( I realise there are a lot fewer CPS and Legal Aid barristers than nurses).

Nurses and support staff will leave, or just do the basics. Morale willbe at an all time low. People don't often appreciate just how many hours over shift doctors and nurses put in and don't get paid for. It is decided later if you might get some overtime pay. Even all the Tory MP's and their wealthy friends who can afford to "go private" could be caught out as in the UK private hospitals don't have any emergency facilities. Serious issues after surgery get taken to NHS.

No European countries seem to be training enough medical staff, or treating those they have well. This article in The Guardian yesterday was really interesting. For example, GP's and paediatricians are striking in Spain where there is a 700,000 case backlog of surgery and there is unrest and severe staff shortages in France (especially of GP's - sound familiar?), top spenders Germany and even Finland!
www.theguardian.com/society/2022/dec/14/a-ticking-time-bomb-healthcare-under-threat-across-western-europe

EngTech · 15/12/2022 19:13

Once enough nurses leave and the NHS stops, literally then something will be done

Trouble is, that will not happen overnight

I have no objection in paying more tax if I knew it would go to the right people, not just into a General Coffer

Also patient expectations must be lowered, the NHS can’t cure every I’ll 😳

AthenaPopodopolous · 15/12/2022 19:11

A school mum acquaintance mum was delighted she got a pay rise as a mental health nurse, 7.5% here is Scotland. She was wondering whether to take her family on holiday or low it on something else but the tone was quite flippant to my mind.
im glad for her but I reckon them at her wage rise will probably be ‘blown’ on the gas and electric bills. I think nurses are quite well paid really in comparison to many female dominated professions.

user1047583 · 15/12/2022 19:09

Can I ask a possibly really stupid question ....

If nurses are successful will all of Band 5 get a payrise to match? Or will nurses be moved up a pay band?

AngeloMysterioso · 15/12/2022 19:07

They will leave, people will vote Tory anyway and the NHS will be finished.

JRHartley72 · 15/12/2022 19:05

Teachers are striking next. Voting has already taken place amongst union members and the result will be announced in the new year.

I think by that point the Govt will have to take negotiations seriously for all public sector workers, because there will be none left in work!

PrincessConstance · 15/12/2022 19:05

caringcarer · 15/12/2022 18:54

Just wondering if a nurse goes to work for an agency do they continue to get as much pension payments paid into their pot? Do agency nurses also get the same rates of sick pay? I'm not asking to be contentious I just thought maybe they might get less pension and sick pay but I may well be wrong? It seems weird to be paying souch into pension pots of NHS workers but but paying enough for them to live on. Perhaps it is time to offer NHS staff a choice of a bit less paid into pension in exchange for more to live on now.

No.

You have to remember the agency costs are the equivalent to the subsidy the public purse pays to employ a nurse.

Weefreetiffany · 15/12/2022 19:05

The government is trying to cripple the nhs so we all go private and their mates make a profit. There’s plenty of money, as @Thebestwaytoscareatory has pointed out. Nursery are caring roles so they think women, because let’s face it, this is 90% women affected and therefore a woman’s issue, should just suck it up because we’re supposed to nurture and care and smile for pin money and a pat on the bum. The nurses aren’t asking for enough imo, any issues arising from the strike are
on the governments conscience.

caringcarer · 15/12/2022 19:03

@BadNomad
I thought nurses salary started at £27k. Is this not true? Where does the 19 percent on £25k come from?

Usernamen · 15/12/2022 18:57

caringcarer · 15/12/2022 18:54

Just wondering if a nurse goes to work for an agency do they continue to get as much pension payments paid into their pot? Do agency nurses also get the same rates of sick pay? I'm not asking to be contentious I just thought maybe they might get less pension and sick pay but I may well be wrong? It seems weird to be paying souch into pension pots of NHS workers but but paying enough for them to live on. Perhaps it is time to offer NHS staff a choice of a bit less paid into pension in exchange for more to live on now.

I presume it’s like being any type of contractor - there’s no paid annual leave, no sick pay, no paid maternity leave, etc.

Can any locum nurses confirm?

Usernamen · 15/12/2022 18:54

BadNomad · 15/12/2022 18:42

Most nurses don't become senior nurses. Most nurses stay band 5 for all of their careers. Top of band 7, which is a ward sister, is £47k. So, no, many don't earn close to $80k. £60 is band 8b. You won't find any of those working as a staff nurse on a ward. That is consultant level. Not the average nurse.

Thanks for the helpful detail. It sounds like pay needs to shift down a few bands! I think £60k for an average nurse is about right for outside London. The question is how do we make it happen without privatising the NHS, as the poster above suggested?!

Bluerisotto · 15/12/2022 18:54

Workinghardeveryday · 15/12/2022 15:56

She does definitely get it, she must be in another union then maybe?

Some unions offer daily payments from a hardship fund but you have to evidence that you are in financial hardship.

caringcarer · 15/12/2022 18:54

Just wondering if a nurse goes to work for an agency do they continue to get as much pension payments paid into their pot? Do agency nurses also get the same rates of sick pay? I'm not asking to be contentious I just thought maybe they might get less pension and sick pay but I may well be wrong? It seems weird to be paying souch into pension pots of NHS workers but but paying enough for them to live on. Perhaps it is time to offer NHS staff a choice of a bit less paid into pension in exchange for more to live on now.