Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What will happen if nurses and other professions don't get their pay rise?

161 replies

malificent7 · 15/12/2022 14:21

The country has come to enough of a standstill as it is. I fully support them btw....do they keep striking?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
kitcat15 · 29/01/2023 12:59

Tessasanderson · 15/12/2022 15:56

I fully support giving you all a pay rise. If you dont mind me asking, what would you do if you left? You must have some very specific qualifications and earn a pretty good wage (I have family at similar levels). If you quit, what would you do to earn the same or more? Surely the job you are doing doesnt offer much options elsewhere. I often wonder what the quit option actually means for some

In the past 3 years...in my community team .....8 have retired at 55 on full nhs pension and gone to wprk ad bank nurses...with bonuses each month on completion of x y and z number of shifts......2 have become nursing lecturers....2 have got jobs in sales ( medical devices ...very lucrative work).....1 has taken and works ad hoc at a private clinic doing botox injections.... 1 has taken a job as school nurse at a private school....1 has emigrated......loads of scope out there if you look hard enough

kitcat15 · 29/01/2023 12:51

AthenaPopodopolous · 15/12/2022 19:11

A school mum acquaintance mum was delighted she got a pay rise as a mental health nurse, 7.5% here is Scotland. She was wondering whether to take her family on holiday or low it on something else but the tone was quite flippant to my mind.
im glad for her but I reckon them at her wage rise will probably be ‘blown’ on the gas and electric bills. I think nurses are quite well paid really in comparison to many female dominated professions.

🤣🤣🤣 there's a comedian in the room 🙄

PrincessConstance · 29/01/2023 12:33

RumandSpinach · 29/01/2023 11:52

I'm not sure you understand the costs involved in healthcare staffing?

Agency nurses often get double the standard rate of substantive staff, plus the agency fee.

My ward is massively (6 figures) over budget solely because we use agency staff out of necessity to plug nursing vacancies.

Just to add.
The article highlights s an issue that is very telling and specific to all services delivered by the public sector.
Unproductive and wasted hours
You may have told your new employee that they will work a 35-hour week, but how many productive hours will they really work during the year? A considerable portion of the working hours you pay for is for the time your team is not actually being productive or generating profit. For example:
Statutory holiday allowance
Sick leave
Maternity/paternity leave
Training
Other non-productive time: visiting the restroom, brewing coffee, surfing the internet, or socializing
And there is the risk of employees with poor performance or issues that could cost you additional time and increased hidden costs.

Criticism of public sector budgets and the workforce generally points in this direction. Governments and specific departments tackle this by using the word, 'efficiency'.

PrincessConstance · 29/01/2023 12:13

RumandSpinach · 29/01/2023 11:52

I'm not sure you understand the costs involved in healthcare staffing?

Agency nurses often get double the standard rate of substantive staff, plus the agency fee.

My ward is massively (6 figures) over budget solely because we use agency staff out of necessity to plug nursing vacancies.

I'm not sure you understand the specific costs of providing a service and how this is shared across the different parties, agencies, and the government.
This is an issue with people who work in the public sector, unfortunately.
You're only seeing how these interactions relate to your budget.

RumandSpinach · 29/01/2023 11:52

PrincessConstance · 29/01/2023 08:39

Why of people struggle with the concept of agencies?
Agency fees include the cost of employing a person. Currently, the government is covering that cost.
That applies to any job.
accountingservicesforbusiness.co.uk/insights-articles/how-much-does-it-really-cost-to-employ-someone-1/

A clear example is.
The real cost of an employee
You might think that you’re going to pay your employee £18,000 per year, but on top of this, you need to allow for a variety of additional costs.
Let’s have a look at them:
After adding all of these up, the picture starts to look quite different… That £18,000 a year you started with is growing bigger and the cost per hour is increasing. It’s no longer the £9.89 per hour (for a 35-hour week) that you budgeted.
In fact, your costs are now almost double the amount. Your employees are likely to cost you over £33,000 per year (that’s £18.13 per hour).

Agencies cover the costs of employment then they factor in a margin so they can make a profit.
This is why DP employs subcontractors.

I'm not sure you understand the costs involved in healthcare staffing?

Agency nurses often get double the standard rate of substantive staff, plus the agency fee.

My ward is massively (6 figures) over budget solely because we use agency staff out of necessity to plug nursing vacancies.

PrincessConstance · 29/01/2023 08:40

PrincessConstance · 29/01/2023 08:39

Why of people struggle with the concept of agencies?
Agency fees include the cost of employing a person. Currently, the government is covering that cost.
That applies to any job.
accountingservicesforbusiness.co.uk/insights-articles/how-much-does-it-really-cost-to-employ-someone-1/

A clear example is.
The real cost of an employee
You might think that you’re going to pay your employee £18,000 per year, but on top of this, you need to allow for a variety of additional costs.
Let’s have a look at them:
After adding all of these up, the picture starts to look quite different… That £18,000 a year you started with is growing bigger and the cost per hour is increasing. It’s no longer the £9.89 per hour (for a 35-hour week) that you budgeted.
In fact, your costs are now almost double the amount. Your employees are likely to cost you over £33,000 per year (that’s £18.13 per hour).

Agencies cover the costs of employment then they factor in a margin so they can make a profit.
This is why DP employs subcontractors.

Why do?
Not why of.🙄

PrincessConstance · 29/01/2023 08:39

Kazzyhoward · 29/01/2023 07:47

The employer (NHS) doesn't have the same obligations when using an agency and the employee doesn't get the same benefits, i.e. generous sick/maternity pay, pensions, etc. so yes there's an agency fee but you have to offset the other liabilities they save.

Why of people struggle with the concept of agencies?
Agency fees include the cost of employing a person. Currently, the government is covering that cost.
That applies to any job.
accountingservicesforbusiness.co.uk/insights-articles/how-much-does-it-really-cost-to-employ-someone-1/

A clear example is.
The real cost of an employee
You might think that you’re going to pay your employee £18,000 per year, but on top of this, you need to allow for a variety of additional costs.
Let’s have a look at them:
After adding all of these up, the picture starts to look quite different… That £18,000 a year you started with is growing bigger and the cost per hour is increasing. It’s no longer the £9.89 per hour (for a 35-hour week) that you budgeted.
In fact, your costs are now almost double the amount. Your employees are likely to cost you over £33,000 per year (that’s £18.13 per hour).

Agencies cover the costs of employment then they factor in a margin so they can make a profit.
This is why DP employs subcontractors.

Kazzyhoward · 29/01/2023 07:47

Maggie178 · 29/01/2023 06:59

I'd leave and work for a locum agency. I'd get paid more. The government would be paying me more but they'd also be paying an agency fee. Already have four locums in my department. Half of them used to work in the department under NHS. I suppose it's a way of slowly privatisation staff. It certainly doesn't cost the government less just means a middleman gets paid too.

The employer (NHS) doesn't have the same obligations when using an agency and the employee doesn't get the same benefits, i.e. generous sick/maternity pay, pensions, etc. so yes there's an agency fee but you have to offset the other liabilities they save.

RumandSpinach · 29/01/2023 07:42

My same job in a private hospital pays 10k more, plus a 5k welcome bonus, with significantly less stress and better conditions.

RumandSpinach · 29/01/2023 07:40

Corcory · 29/01/2023 01:08

I don't think anyone would dispute that nurses and paramedics should be paid more but where will the money come from? Government borrowing, from funds that should go to patients? More and more people would want pay rises and as they are settled interest rates will go up, mortgages would go up and cost would go up getting us all into a dreadful inflationary spiral. I actually think that the government are trying to sit all these strikes out as they can see inflation going down thus reducing the possible wage increases.

We've found the money to pay prison officers a starting wage of 32k with no qualifications or previous experience necessary.

They deserve this wage, but it does highlight how unfair a starting wage of 27k is for a graduate profession that is highly stressful.

Maggie178 · 29/01/2023 06:59

Tessasanderson · 15/12/2022 15:56

I fully support giving you all a pay rise. If you dont mind me asking, what would you do if you left? You must have some very specific qualifications and earn a pretty good wage (I have family at similar levels). If you quit, what would you do to earn the same or more? Surely the job you are doing doesnt offer much options elsewhere. I often wonder what the quit option actually means for some

I'd leave and work for a locum agency. I'd get paid more. The government would be paying me more but they'd also be paying an agency fee. Already have four locums in my department. Half of them used to work in the department under NHS. I suppose it's a way of slowly privatisation staff. It certainly doesn't cost the government less just means a middleman gets paid too.

MaryBerrysCamelToe · 29/01/2023 06:11

I haven't been on strike as on mat leave but even if I wasn't I couldn't afford to do more than one days strike. That is the case for most nursing staff.
I won't be able to leave the profession, I love my job despite the poor pay, exhausting shift pattern and 12 hour shifts.
I have just moved departments to my dream job (NICU) and can't see myself doing anything else and I'm no good at anything else anyway Smile

MrsMikeDrop · 29/01/2023 03:49

They'll all eventually leave, and those that remain will resent it. Everyone loses

ConcordeOoter · 29/01/2023 03:01

If they aren't going to work I want a tax rebate. I 100% support their right to strike, and nurses i do not blame, but the government needs to stop taking money for nothing. For a health service that is often fucking deadly, it has collapsed.

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/01/2023 02:46

Nurses will continue to leave the profession/country and we will find it very difficult to replace them. As is happening now.🤷‍♀️

But if all the bankers we attract do a First Aid course, that should help.🙄

Corcory · 29/01/2023 01:08

I don't think anyone would dispute that nurses and paramedics should be paid more but where will the money come from? Government borrowing, from funds that should go to patients? More and more people would want pay rises and as they are settled interest rates will go up, mortgages would go up and cost would go up getting us all into a dreadful inflationary spiral. I actually think that the government are trying to sit all these strikes out as they can see inflation going down thus reducing the possible wage increases.

Door1 · 28/01/2023 22:02

personally as nurses we are better off. The general public will suffer, however they chose tories. Agency pay is good. When privatised nurses will earn great money and likely free private health care. Staff will be funded at the front door by the public. Tories will take it in but you need to be connected to get a chunk of the serious cash like PPE , private test kits. Tories made millions

Siayg · 18/12/2022 11:01

DailyMailReporterTellMeAllYourSecrets · 16/12/2022 07:47

They used to be and are still ok. I’m a band 6 and pay in 9.8% of my salary. The NHS pays in something like 20% (or makes it up to 20%) you can easily look it up online. When we changed from the 2008 version of the pension to the 2015, it got worse. I used to pay in less 🤷‍♀️ I get good annual leave though. 33 days plus 8 bank holidays.

The contribution rates mean nothing in a defined benefit pension.

The NHS pension is very, very good indeed.

Nw22 · 17/12/2022 19:06

my issue with this strike is that the nhs always get bigger pay rises than the rest of the public sector and I think it needs to be equal. They got a payrise last year when all other public sector for a freeze.
also, it’s not just nurses. The pay rise would be for anyone on agenda for change. So all the non clinical staff too

DrowsyDragon · 16/12/2022 09:17

Right, I'm a striking public sector worker, though not a nurse, and if I got my pay rise, I would actually benefit the private sector. I'd replace my shoes that are falling apart, fix the almost broken window, turn my heating on a bit more, maybe take my kids to a show and go on holiday. Nurses are living off foodbanks in cold houses, they have said so. You put more money in the hands of public sector workers you will be better public service from them and they will go and spend that money in the private sector generating revenue and enabling the private sector for ask for their pay rises too. You will retain people and increase the circulation of wealth. OR you can keep falling for the lie that public sector workers are robbing you by wanting a decent standard of pay and you can continue to vote for a tory government that won't do anything for you but will make the billionaires (Like Mrs Sunak) richer. The public sector pay raises would ultimate benefit everyone. Happier, spending more, retained NHS and pubvlic sector workers and more liquidity in the economy. Makes sense to me

MrsDoyle351 · 16/12/2022 08:16

hellesbells · 15/12/2022 21:04

Let's not forget Michelle Mone who scammed 29 million out of the taxpayer, small fry compared to the above but hey every penny counts

Yeah - if the Tories and all their corrupt bastard mates stopped pissing our hard earned taxes up the fricking wall we would certainly be able to afford to pay public sector workers properly.

Michelle Mone is an absolute fucking joke, and have a read about her delightful husband en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doug_Barrowman who has siphoned off around £45 million to off shore funds for PPE.... he's got 6 homes, a super yacht and a private jet - plus a load of clever lawyers and accountants to make sure he stays rich.

anyolddinosaur · 16/12/2022 07:59

"Not a nurse, so just guessing here, but if they are not getting paid during strikes and it carries on with no action on pay, then they will just leave probably. So things would still be shit unless they get a payrise. The NHS will probably just pay them more as an agency worker, which is probably what will happen. An indirect pay rise, but without the stability and continuity of care of having them in the NHS on a permanent contract.
Great. Look forward to that."

This,

DailyMailReporterTellMeAllYourSecrets · 16/12/2022 07:47

Whoknew42 · 15/12/2022 16:16

They are constantly changing the NHS pension goal posts it may have stopped me leaving at one point but not now

They used to be and are still ok. I’m a band 6 and pay in 9.8% of my salary. The NHS pays in something like 20% (or makes it up to 20%) you can easily look it up online. When we changed from the 2008 version of the pension to the 2015, it got worse. I used to pay in less 🤷‍♀️ I get good annual leave though. 33 days plus 8 bank holidays.

MrsDoyle351 · 16/12/2022 07:44

Notonthestairs · 15/12/2022 16:36

Feel free to inform the FT Florenz.

Grin Grin

DailyMailReporterTellMeAllYourSecrets · 16/12/2022 07:41

mrsm43s · 15/12/2022 15:27

I actually think it would be reasonable for all public sector employees to have a contractual payrise in line with inflation. I realise that would be expensive, hence why it's not done, but not doing it devalues public sector jobs and decimates services. And so much time (and therefore money) would be saved by not having these endless negotiations with unions.

They’d actually save themselves so much in agency fees. Plus, when they take on temps
constantly, experienced members of staff are taken away from their work to train them up which is a hidden cost. Amanda Pritchard, head of NHS England, earns circa £250k PA which I think is disgraceful. Also, the % annual increase sounds good but really, they should have a pot of money and people on lower bands should get more of it.