Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really not get the mentality of some parents…

204 replies

LivIoe · 15/12/2022 08:37

I live near a school and it’s snowed heavily. I noticed that quite a few children were in the snow in slip on ballet pump style shoes or canvas shoes, or generally inappropriate footwear that would leave them with wet feet or slipping over.

I hunted out my children’s old snow boots/ study walking boots. They ranged from about a size 10 to size 3, primary school sizes. Then I put them in pairs on the wall outside, with a post-it saying ‘free’ and noting the size. Just ‘free, size 12) for example.

I came home and some were in the bush, didn’t think much of it- just put them back. I then saw a child run up with a stick and sweep them all off the wall, while his mum watched.

Put them back.

Then I heard shouting, some kids were throwing them at each other! About yr 3, their mums said stop and left them all over the pavement (I saw from upstairs, so didn’t get out to say anything).

before people aak

  • all shoes were in good condition, some branded, not tatty
  • Ive not had any negative interaction with anyone locally, didn’t recognise them
  • yes, some of the kids doing it were in light shoes…
  • all were around mid primary age with parents

What am I missing in the thought process here?

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 15/12/2022 11:56

Maybe being from abroad is the difference? It never would have occurred to me to buy winter boots or hiking boots for my children in the UK, never can I think of a single time I have seen a child wearing these things. If it snowed we put them in wellies or they wore their normal school shoes. I live in Germany now and it is amazing to me how many varieties of shoe there are and that children are expected to have all of them - indeed, it would be seen as the height of neglect to put a child in wellies or trainers on a winter's day if there is even a light frost!

And if you did so, it would be assumed that the reason was you were caught out by the weather, and not because you did not believe them to be necessary. Like your assumption in the OP. But I do not think that parents in general in the UK would make this assumption, instead I think most people would assume winter boots are not a necessary garment for our climate. They are probably not even permitted as part of the school uniform policy.

(Things might have changed recently, I haven't parented in the UK for nearly 10 years now).

SinnerBoy · 15/12/2022 11:54

Whydidimarryhim · Today 10:46

You did a very kind thoughtful thing. How bloody rude of children outside and the adults who clearly have issues with boundaries.

I agree entirely, she made a kind gesture and some horrible people thought it would be fun to spoil it.

Someone said that an academy sends out patrols, to ensure that kids in uniforms are walking through snow, or in heavy rain, in soaking wet shoes. My daughter's school says to come in wellies etc, but take the school shoes with them and change inside.

If they didn't and sanctioned her for wearing them outside school, I'd be seeking legal advice.

Sockwomble · 15/12/2022 11:52

"How can you let your child out of the house with matted hair? I am autistic, but my mother brushed my hair throughly every day."

Because it is better to get my son onto school transport to his special school than have him miss school because he is either so distressed it is unsafe to go anywhere near him or he is so distressed he has shut down and is unable to move. His school agrees.

AndEverWhoKnew · 15/12/2022 11:37

There's quite a difference between buying second-hand and picking up boots from a wall (that have been left outside for you know not how long or by whom) in full view of everyone else. I'm surprised you can't see that.

You may also be perfectly kind but we teach DCs not to accept items from strangers. There are a few safeguarding red flags about an adult near a school trying to create a bond with DCs by providing something free and then watching to see how they interact.

As a PP said, donate them to the school or to a charity shop.

NinjaSnail · 15/12/2022 11:35

I think you did a really nice thing and I despair at some of the responses on this thread.

In the past I've often sat and waited in my car for DC in my very nice middle class area and watched some truly awful behaviour from local, middle-class, "outstanding" infant / junior school children - vandalism of people's gardens, cars, fences etc just general lack of respect, utter thoughtlessness for other people or property. More often than not the well-to-do mums are off to the side, chatting, seeing what their children are doing but for some reason very rarely stepping and in telling them to stop.

Occasionally I have stepped in when for example it looks as though someone's car is about to be damaged or something is thrown at my windscreen.

Always utterly baffled me. Has nothing to do with money or class imo. Just a sad reflection of today's society and people's general sense of total entitlement perhaps?

Fuckitydoodah · 15/12/2022 11:31

You did a nice thing. Some people are just arseholes, that applies to kids too.

Ericaequites · 15/12/2022 11:22

I went to a strict private girls’ school in a winters climate. We could wear boots to school, but had to change shoes before homeroom. It’s terrible children are penalized for wearing appropriate outdoor clothes.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 15/12/2022 11:18

I understand that a sense of pride would prevent them from taking the boots / shoes, but why pick them up and throw them around? And why do the parents let this happen? Manners have nothing to do with money.

Yes, exactly. As I always think when people come on to MN threads just to berate people for caring about the subject, if something is not for you, just scroll/walk on by and ignore it.

I despise vandals even more than thieves, tbh (excepting genuine poor people who steal basic essentials that they simply cannot afford to buy) - I can fully see the motivation of thieves, but where is the joy in just wantonly ruining things for everybody else?

Ericaequites · 15/12/2022 11:18

How can you let your child out of the house with matted hair? I am autistic, but my mother brushed my hair throughly every day. Saying no was not an option. Parents can’t be friends with young children. They need to be authoritarian alphas. Though I usually look like I was dragged through a hedge, I start the day neat and tidy. Early habits are like compound interest.

ButterCrackers · 15/12/2022 11:16

LivIoe · 15/12/2022 10:58

Well I promise they have been chucked now and no one will be exposed to the sheer offence of it again 🤷‍♀️
I simply didn’t cotton on that people think offering snow boots is judging them, but I have given up ok? Wear flip flops if it rocks your boat

Keep putting things out for others. It’s so kind.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 15/12/2022 11:14

I’m interested. Those of you who say it’s about being poor and pride.

How many of you are personally experiencing this. Your children have needs. Bit pride is stopping you from buying hand me downs or cheaper items.

I don't get that, either. If you can afford to buy the brand new designer/branded stuff, in order to show that you aren't poor and have 'pride', then you can't actually be that poor in the first place, can you?!

Genuinely poor people will accept being given things or cheap second-hand stuff, however much it may hit their pride, as the alternative is not having essential things at all.

It doesn't help when the tabloids run 'gotcha'-style 'features' about somebody who bought an item of clothing at some stage actually wearing it - just because it isn't the first time they've been spotted wearing it in public. I think there should be 'shame' (for want of a nicer word) in not wearing clothes many times and then passing/selling them on - or receiving/buying them - when they've been outgrown or become unloved. It's utter madness to consider clothes as disposable items.

LivIoe · 15/12/2022 11:14

Sugarfree23 · 15/12/2022 11:07

Surely you could have bunged them back in the cupboard awaiting the next charity bag that comes in the door?

Or drop them into a recycling bin outside the supermarket?

Binning them is just daft.

Maybe I could have left them scattered over the road and pavement? That ok?

I’ m off to work if anyone does the WHERE’S OP????

Tbh, they’re in a clean bag on top of the bin, I’ll move them if I can but right now I cannot be bothered with people. Every charity shop has a ‘we are not accepting donations sign’, the clothes bins were removed due to vandalism and I don’t have a working car to go miles to the recycling centre. Im not on your world, which is the simple answer to why it might be a little different in my world to do the same things you find easy.

This thread has made me give up quite a bit on trying as well.

pleas can people note I am at work now… hence the replies

OP posts:
Sugarfree23 · 15/12/2022 11:07

LivIoe · 15/12/2022 10:58

Well I promise they have been chucked now and no one will be exposed to the sheer offence of it again 🤷‍♀️
I simply didn’t cotton on that people think offering snow boots is judging them, but I have given up ok? Wear flip flops if it rocks your boat

Surely you could have bunged them back in the cupboard awaiting the next charity bag that comes in the door?

Or drop them into a recycling bin outside the supermarket?

Binning them is just daft.

amiaf · 15/12/2022 11:06

I wish there were more people like you around OP

MilkyYay · 15/12/2022 11:05

Honestly it was not so much snow on pavements that kids would have soaking feet in side normal leather school shoes. Leather school shoes are quite robust, even the ones with ballet style uppers usually have thick rubber soles.

You sound like you are quite OTT about the weather and imposing that on others. Kids are tough. In an in demand school those kids will only be walking 5-10 mins to school, snow boots really are not essential.

The kids shouldn't have been knocking them off the wall but its a confusing place to put them, where i live that would irritate people as it makes the neighbourhood look scruffy, and the only things that people would put on a wall like that would be lost items.

Doubtmyself · 15/12/2022 11:05

FeelingwearyFeeelingsmall · 15/12/2022 11:01

This is so true. When my D.C. were little we were doing ok. We were older parents who lived in a detached house in a nice area and we had enough to pay the mortgage and bills etc whilst I remained a SAHM. We could get by on DH's salary but even so my middle class friends and I were very keen on swapping secondhand kids clothes/toys etc.

At one point I took a weekend job in a call call centre, mostly to pay for luxuries like meals out and holidays and also to get out of the house. Working there I made good friends with younger people who were properly hard up. So next time I had a few (good quality, good condition) baby/toddler clothes to pass on I took them to work before offering them to my local network. Nobody wanted anything.

One man said to me that his wife would be ashamed to dress their children in second hand stuff, that she would see it as them failing as parents. She would be insulted of he took any of the clothes home. This guy was a mate so I know he worked full time weekdays in the civil service, 4 nights a week in a petrol station and then weekends at the call centre and was always first in line for BH overtime. He was literally never at home with his family but his wife thought that was better than dressing the kids in second hand Clothkits/Boden/M&S.

Needless to say that at the next NCT coffee morning, the SAHM mums who drove up in their BMWs fell on the clothes with cries of rapture!

Poor people have little joy in their lives, they struggle to pay rent/mortgage, both parents must work like dogs, they live in poor areas with stress of rubbish, break ins, gangs, etc.
So why wouldn't they want to participate in the "joys of consumerism" ?

Sistanotcista · 15/12/2022 11:04

Climbingsteepsteps · 15/12/2022 08:41

What you’re missing is how strong the sense of pride is for some people.

People without money do not like admitting that fact, as a rule. Hence the liking for branded sportswear for babies / very young children amongst certain socioeconomic groups.

Go further up the economic ladder and they’ll gladly buy and accept second hand, because they have nothing to prove.

I understand that a sense of pride would prevent them from taking the boots / shoes, but why pick them up and throw them around? And why do the parents let this happen? Manners have nothing to do with money.

ByTheGrace · 15/12/2022 11:04

DD's school doesn't allow any kind of boots, or shoes with thick soles. They aren't allowed wellies as there is no place to store them. They have to remove coats at the gate. It gives me the absolute rage, we live somewhere where 9 times out of 10 it is pissing down.
People who can only afford one pair of shoes are forced to buy something impractical. DD's school isn't an academy and has above average fsm pupils, they are just utterly batshit about certain things.

FeelingwearyFeeelingsmall · 15/12/2022 11:01

This is so true. When my D.C. were little we were doing ok. We were older parents who lived in a detached house in a nice area and we had enough to pay the mortgage and bills etc whilst I remained a SAHM. We could get by on DH's salary but even so my middle class friends and I were very keen on swapping secondhand kids clothes/toys etc.

At one point I took a weekend job in a call call centre, mostly to pay for luxuries like meals out and holidays and also to get out of the house. Working there I made good friends with younger people who were properly hard up. So next time I had a few (good quality, good condition) baby/toddler clothes to pass on I took them to work before offering them to my local network. Nobody wanted anything.

One man said to me that his wife would be ashamed to dress their children in second hand stuff, that she would see it as them failing as parents. She would be insulted of he took any of the clothes home. This guy was a mate so I know he worked full time weekdays in the civil service, 4 nights a week in a petrol station and then weekends at the call centre and was always first in line for BH overtime. He was literally never at home with his family but his wife thought that was better than dressing the kids in second hand Clothkits/Boden/M&S.

Needless to say that at the next NCT coffee morning, the SAHM mums who drove up in their BMWs fell on the clothes with cries of rapture!

Doubtmyself · 15/12/2022 11:00

LivIoe · 15/12/2022 10:58

Well I promise they have been chucked now and no one will be exposed to the sheer offence of it again 🤷‍♀️
I simply didn’t cotton on that people think offering snow boots is judging them, but I have given up ok? Wear flip flops if it rocks your boat

Real shame they were chucked, if you mean landfill site.

I'm forever donating stuff to charity, if its really tatty I go to the recycling centre, which accepts clothes and shoes.

Bluegingerbread · 15/12/2022 10:59

LivIoe · 15/12/2022 10:54

Wow… that is awful! I’m glad our local schools are like that!

Ill be honest, I have 5 kids and one is disabled and two are sick and I feel rough. I’ve tried what I could but I don’t have the energy to go delivering them around or even lugging the bag. It was just a try that didn’t work, within the means I had.

Yep, uniform is a pseudo religion with the local chain. Apparently you'll learn much better by travelling in school shoes and having wet cold feet than being sensible and using boots. Being shown those messages by friends with older kids had a big impact on my decision making for secondary school.

You've done your best, OP, don't feel guilty.

LivIoe · 15/12/2022 10:59

lieselotte · 15/12/2022 10:57

It was for London, given there is usually no snow at all! And it was more than I've got here, which is just an icing-sugar type sprinkle.

It’s above ankle height.

This is really really wild…. But sometimes just because you didn’t see it doesn’t mean it didn’t happen. But as I said, if you want to wear flip flops or whatever… it’s fine by me

OP posts:
Dreamsoffreedomjoyandpeace · 15/12/2022 10:58

No idea but I’d keep doing it because someone might be really grateful. I got a lovely Laura Ashley coat that someone had left in their front garden. I doubt anyone else would have taken it because it was very creased but after a dry clean it’s my favourite coat!

Doubtmyself · 15/12/2022 10:58

Climbingsteepsteps · 15/12/2022 08:41

What you’re missing is how strong the sense of pride is for some people.

People without money do not like admitting that fact, as a rule. Hence the liking for branded sportswear for babies / very young children amongst certain socioeconomic groups.

Go further up the economic ladder and they’ll gladly buy and accept second hand, because they have nothing to prove.

That's not true.

Yes, people in the middle generally do have no issue with second hand but lots of very wealthy people are just as brand mad as the poor, its usually more subtle, but its the same little insecure markers .

LivIoe · 15/12/2022 10:58

MilkyYay · 15/12/2022 10:55

People won't just pick up random boots off a wall.

Can you offer them free via a local buy sell or whatsapp group.

You sound a bit judgy btw. Lots of kids will refuse to wear those sorts of boots even when very cold.

Well I promise they have been chucked now and no one will be exposed to the sheer offence of it again 🤷‍♀️
I simply didn’t cotton on that people think offering snow boots is judging them, but I have given up ok? Wear flip flops if it rocks your boat

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread