Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Breastfeeding advice group on Facebook has scared me?!

115 replies

elm26 · 14/12/2022 21:44

I thought it would be a good idea to join a private breastfeeding advice/support group as I hopefully will be breastfeeding when baby comes along.

I introduced myself and asked what they recommend me to buy, any tips, any information etc and oh my god, I feel like I've started WW3.

I do not know the first thing about breastfeeding but one lady commented telling me to get some good nipple cream and another replied saying if your nipples are sore it's a latch problem, so you don't need cream. The other lady then replied it's good to have as nipples can get quite sensitive etc and she replied breasts don't need to get used to being fed from so no need for cream, put up with the sensitivity.

Another said don't put baby's mouth to your nipple let them crawl their way up your stomach and find your nipple themselves.

Another said that I shouldn't have put that I'm "hoping" to breastfeed, it should be that I am going to breastfeed as this is what's best for the baby and there is no such thing as can't. I have always truly believed that "fed is best" and I think I'd get hunted down if I replied with that!

They've absolutely terrified me! I feel even more confused and like I'm a failure if for whatever reason I can't breastfeed/struggle with it.

Is it really worth being a part of these groups? Will I get help from the midwife etc? I do plan on going to the breastfeeding class.

OP posts:
LadyLucksters · 14/12/2022 22:17

I read this book before I had my DC - absolutely brilliant! I had no issues (EBF both on demand for 6 months and continued to feed DC1 to 18 months and DC2 to 2 years), which I completely attribute to this book. I knew instantly that my latch was incorrect from the book rather than the midwives. The “advice” I got from others was just anecdotal and scientifically inaccurate. www.amazon.co.uk/What-Expect-When-Youre-Breastfeeding/dp/0091906962

Jsh125 · 14/12/2022 22:17

Wowzers that sounds insanely confusing! They're obviously all passionate but that's not massively helpful to you!

I really struggled with breastfeeding my first but am also so stubborn that I didn't want to give up. My best bit of advice would be that if you need support find that one trusted group / advice line or whatever it may be & try not to disappear down the rabbit hole of trying everything & anything people suggest.

My son was slow to put on weight & I saw a different midwife almost every other day for the first month of his life - I also had different advice from every single one of them & it was so confusing I literally didn't know what to do. Finally someone thought to mention the infant feeding team at our hospital & that's when things changed - consistent advice from people trained to help & we were off & running, ok maybe not running quite yet but it was a definite turning point.

If you do need cream I definitely vote for the purple lansinoh cream - probably the only thing everyone i spoke to agreed on 😂.

Good luck for the new arrival 😊😊

Mylittlesandwich · 14/12/2022 22:16

Whatever you do please please please keep the mantra of "fed is best" I took it so far to heart that I had to breastfeed that when it didn't work out I took it very hard. I really hope it works out for you but if it doesn't or if you just don't like it your baby will be just fine.

elm26 · 14/12/2022 22:14

Wow thank you all so much!

They really made it sound like a huge scary military operation which had strict rules you had to adhere to at all times otherwise you are some kind of feeding failure 🤦🏻‍♀️

You've all made me feel so much better, thank you for all the advice and who to contact etc. x

OP posts:
Barleysugar86 · 14/12/2022 22:13

It did hurt at the start. I wish I had been better prepared for that. I would comfort you that it all goes by the end of the first month in my experience, and after that it was really easy. But that first month was hard. It didn't hurt with my next kid. I think it's just as they get used to their new role.

Those first few weeks there were times I squealed everytime the baby latched as it was that painful. Like shooting pains. I think he had a pretty strong latch or I had a strong letdown. But a hot bath helped. And it is such a short time relatively, I went on to feed my first until 1 year and my second until nearly 2 before stopping. It was totally worth pushing through that first month and I'm glad I did.

I found it such a comfort to always have their food near me when I was out and to feed them when they were ill thinking I could give them some antibodies.

Both of mine fed within an hour or so of birth, but the hospital midwives were really useful in helping with positioning so please do make use of them while you are in.

AwkwardPaws27 · 14/12/2022 22:13

This group was invaluable for me: www.facebook.com/groups/bflsuk/?ref=share

It's called "Breastfeeding and Lactation Support UK", its evidence based and admin-led so not a free for all of conflicting advice, & the admin are all trained in breastfeeding support. They can even offer latch checks via video.

There are good groups out there but as with the Internet in general there's also a lot of not so great ones.

Its a new skill for you & your baby so its great you are seeking advice in advance. I'm 6 months in after a bumpy start (DS was very sleepy and lost too much weight) but I'm so glad we managed to learn it together (& I really appreciate not having to get out of bed at 3am to make a feed!).

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 14/12/2022 22:13

I thought it would be a good idea to join a private breastfeeding advice/support group

That was your BIG mistake. Those groups are nuts. Better to ask on here or Kellymom.

BYW Lanisnoh is worth every penny. Don’t let people tell you breast and nipple pain isn’t normal. It is.

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 14/12/2022 22:12

But just like anything there are lots of ways to do it and everyone will have differing advice. It's hard to know what to trust. I agree go into it with a positive mindset and know the details of a local breastfeeding support group. These can be super for proper hands on help rather than trying to figure it out from Internet advice.

ReluctantLondoners · 14/12/2022 22:12

Oh god, these groups are NUTS. Avoid like the plague.

I didn't ever need nipple cream though fwiw. I got slightly sore nipples but never needed the cream.

Kokeshi123 · 14/12/2022 22:11

breastfeedingwithoutbs.blogspot.com/p/no-bs-breastfeeding-resources.html

This page is about eight or nine years old, but has a list of breastfeeding the forums listed may be inactive now, but take a look at the books and some of the websites with helpful videos.

Good luck, OP! I breastfed my two, but also gave a bottle of formula once we were well established (for convenience, not because I had to), mostly breastfed on a "rough" routine, and night-weaned once mine had been eating solids for a few months. I doubt I'd be welcome on Kellymom and the other sites, where the mods are horrified at that kind of thing. Yet my kids are happy and healthy, and I mostly enjoyed breastfeeding rather than being martyr to it.

GhostsJulianforPrimeMinister · 14/12/2022 22:10

Getting a good latch is important but honestly just hold the baby any way that is comfortable for your arms and do some reading up / watch videos about the latch... even with a good latch get nipple cream Lanolin is amazing .. if it doesn't work for you switch to bottles.
I remember a midwife telling me my baby who was gaining weight very well / no issues was being held wrong for breast feeding, tried to contort my arms into an uncomfortable pose ... she left and I went back to how I was getting on fine doing it, he's a very healthy 6 year old Xmas Grin
My second was born in lockdown, bliss not having anyone come around and give their opinions!

bloodyeverlastinghell · 14/12/2022 22:09

I bf all of mine till 2. They'd of starved trying to crawl up my stomach so breast to baby and definitely lanolin based nipple cream for the early days.

This is what worked for me though. Everyone is different. My best advice would be to give it a go as colostrum is really beneficial to baby but yes fed is best.

Chimna · 14/12/2022 22:09

Don't overthink it or panic too much. Take advice in hospital/from HV. Anything you're struggling with ask on here or search previous threads. The only Facebook group I would recommend is the Can I Breastfeed In It? Group that recommends breastfeeding friendly clothes. I BF my eldest until 3 and second is still BF at 18 months. I needed nipple cream in the first weeks with my first and now my second is teething. Just remember nipple to nose, feeding for hours on end is normal and milk can take a week to come in. You don't need much more than that to begin with and see hope you go. Congratulations!

Allsizes8to14 · 14/12/2022 22:09

This is the first time I’ve seen this discussed, but same as a lot of others have said these groups seem to be run by/attract what I call militant breast feeders! I’ve seen so many posts by women wanting advice on how to wean babies off the breast and being shot down for wanting to stop when all they wanted was advice.
I’m still BF my 18m DD (but only once a day these days which would probably horrify half the posters in the 2 local groups I’m part of as should he feeding hourly until their 18th birthday at least 🤣)
Good support in hospital is key, I had a great midwife who supervised every feed I did on her shift. I then had contact with a BF support worker which was organised by the community midwives. Lansinoh nipple cream I used after every feed from the word go. Loads of nursing bras (they get soggy quickly, I’d bought a few but had to buy more!) Big muslins for absorbing dribbles, giving privacy etc. I did some online courses at ‘the baby academy’ which were very helpful to give the basics in advance without being scary. Congratulations on your imminent arrival!

marzipaninyourpieplatebingo · 14/12/2022 22:05

please don’t be terrified OP, some people are just so die hard in their attitude. i breast fed my son for 14 months and my daughter until she was 2. it does hurt at the start, it can be painful so a good nipple cream is essential in the early days until you get used to it and it’s nothing to do with latch it’s the sensation as it’s new and your nipples aren’t used to it - once it’s established and your nipples don’t feel sore it will be the best thing you ever do and is so freeing and flexible when your out and about altho can be hard if baby refuses a bottle - my son was okayish on occasion but my daughter refused fo take a bottle ever! 😂 either way give it a go and if it doesn’t work out then you tried, don’t feel guilty, happy mother is happy baby xx wish you all the best on your breastfeeding journeyed 😊

bakewellbride · 14/12/2022 22:05

You could also phone the National breastfeeding helpline with questions. They're brilliant.

MogTheForgetableCat · 14/12/2022 22:05

Also I think nipple confusion is total bullshit made up to make things more difficult.

If you want to use dummies straight away, or bottles if you're mix feeding, it won't mean you can't breastfeed.

bakewellbride · 14/12/2022 22:04

To prepare for breastfeeding I:

  • read books
-watched a ton of YouTube videos (Emily Norris ones are great)
  • bought stuff I thought would make life easier e.g feeding pillow etc
  • attended a breastfeeding class held at a breastfeeding support group
And that was it. No crazy Facebook groups necessary! Good luck. I'm breastfeeding my second baby and it's amazing, one of the best things I ever did.
Pocketfullofdogtreats · 14/12/2022 22:03

Just remember that women have been doing this for thousands of years! Re cream, I was advised to spread a tiny bit of milk over each nipple once the baby had finished each time, which stops cracking. This worked for me - I don't know if I was just lucky but I never needed cream.

RoomOfRequirement · 14/12/2022 22:02

The militant BF brigade are some of the worst kinds of people. Their purpose in life is to make mums who don't fit their mould feel like shit. Stay far away.

Good luck with baby!

Itisbetter · 14/12/2022 22:02

It’s really not as complicated as people make out. It’s feeding not a political stance. Try for a few months if it doesn’t suit you then do something else.

MogTheForgetableCat · 14/12/2022 22:02

Join a few and lurk for a bit, as some can be brilliant and some are full of obsessives.

The cream thing is interesting - I was obsessed with it last time. This time I didn't bother and I think the pain was similar both times. But anything that might help is worth a try!

Babies don't know how to breastfeed at all usually, you have to learn together, usually by ramming a boob in their mouth, so if I'd left my children to find the nipple themselves they'd be talking before they got it.

Be prepared that breastfeeding is painful and difficult and time consuming for the first few weeks. Once you get through that it can be lovely and very convenient and quick and easy.

Absolutely nothing wrong with formula though nor going in open minded. I also just hoped to breastfeed last time and bought formula incase I hated it but exclusively breastfed for 18 months last time and three months and counting this time.

abbs1 · 14/12/2022 21:59

Op I would speak with your midwife and get help from them or a trained breastfeeding support midwife as from what you've written you're getting all kinds of mixed messages.
I found the same issue so asked my midwife team who were absolutely fab as was the hospital in helping me get feeding established. Fed is best and always remember that. I didn't get the help and support with my 1st and ended up formula feeding him from day 3 and he's doing great! Happy little boy. With my daughter I've breastfed from day 1 and still now at nearly 10 months old. It's completely your decision on how you feed your baby, breast, combi or formula. All of them is completely fine. You do what's right for you and your baby.
I did use lansinoh nipple cream in the first week or two as my nipples were really sore even with a good latch once established over the first few days and then didn't need it anymore.
Best of luck with your little one coming!

RoseslnTheHospital · 14/12/2022 21:58

It's an optional group full of randomers. It hasn't been helpful to you so leave the group and find another one.

Breastfeeding and infant feeding in general can be an emotive topic, people can hold strong opinions and be prone to being strident or argumentative. Don't let it worry you or put you off.

Midwives and HV tbh can be patchy with helpful breastfeeding advice, and I found them to be inconsistent with their advice, sometimes contradicting each other. There may well be a specialist breastfeeding advisor at the hospital or elsewhere that you can ask to speak to. The NCT have classes on it, usually, which can be helpful. The infant feeding topic on here can be useful too, for moral support and for getting the thoughts of women who have been through it themselves.

vincettenoir · 14/12/2022 21:58

The breastfeeding cafe at my local childrens’ centre was really good. It might be worth checking out your nearest one as they are a great resource.

Swipe left for the next trending thread