Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Breastfeeding advice group on Facebook has scared me?!

115 replies

elm26 · 14/12/2022 21:44

I thought it would be a good idea to join a private breastfeeding advice/support group as I hopefully will be breastfeeding when baby comes along.

I introduced myself and asked what they recommend me to buy, any tips, any information etc and oh my god, I feel like I've started WW3.

I do not know the first thing about breastfeeding but one lady commented telling me to get some good nipple cream and another replied saying if your nipples are sore it's a latch problem, so you don't need cream. The other lady then replied it's good to have as nipples can get quite sensitive etc and she replied breasts don't need to get used to being fed from so no need for cream, put up with the sensitivity.

Another said don't put baby's mouth to your nipple let them crawl their way up your stomach and find your nipple themselves.

Another said that I shouldn't have put that I'm "hoping" to breastfeed, it should be that I am going to breastfeed as this is what's best for the baby and there is no such thing as can't. I have always truly believed that "fed is best" and I think I'd get hunted down if I replied with that!

They've absolutely terrified me! I feel even more confused and like I'm a failure if for whatever reason I can't breastfeed/struggle with it.

Is it really worth being a part of these groups? Will I get help from the midwife etc? I do plan on going to the breastfeeding class.

OP posts:
Tripsabroad · 14/12/2022 23:56

I'd leave the group tbh. I had a similar experience with a terrifying Baby-led weaning group. They acted as if you wanted to kill your baby if you mentioned puree.

Re nipple cream - I bought some and didn't need it. Its quite expensive and easily available so personally I wouldn't buy any in advance. If you get sore just nip to the shops.

Breastfeeding comes easily to many women. I wouldn't overthink it - see what happens.

You really need very little to start. I didn't even need a nursing bra as I just hiked up my top and went bra less most of the time. The only thing I really needed were breast pads. Everything you can buy is available at Tesco or next day on Amazon.

Purplechicken207 · 14/12/2022 23:54

You'll get too many opposing views, and people only actually know what worked for them! Google real life in person groups in your area, as their support in my area is excellent. Fully trained people and even if it's all fine you can rock up for moral support. Also, find a specialist private lactation consultant near you, just in case. Both mine had feeding issues and our local expert helped massively, including diagnosing and dividing a tongue tie in youngest. Midwives will help after the birth but with first I found them a bit brutal (and baby just kept crying and popping off after they forced her on). With 2nd I knew what I was doing so aside from v lovely midwife looking in on us we didn't need help until tongue tie stated causing issues a few days later. Be prepared for various women to be handling your boobs though, and possibly helping you hand express colostrum. Despite difficult feeding for the first few weeks with 1st and few months with 2nd, I fed 1st to 18months when she wasn't bothered anymore, and still going with 2nd at 10m. Tongue tie and another issue caused 2nd to create a lot of friction and my nipples were open and bleeding before the end of week 1. I don't say it to scare you (didn't happen with 1st), but it can happen and if it does it needs assessment by lactation consultant. Still sensitive and painful at first with 1st - it can be painful/tender even when things are OK as most nips aren't used to being sucked on for hours a day!!
It means all the work (and night feeds!) has to be you (aside from moral support and bringing hot food and drinks, occasional burping by someone else maybe) unless you pump the odd bottle for a few hours sleep, but personally I found having instant shutupability with boob in mouth of screaming baby was gold. Plus no need to get out of bed for night feeds, just lift baby from crib to bed, feed, put back. No leaving them to cry while prepping bottles, or running out! And no/very little sterilising! It's rewarding, but you do need to make the choice for your family circumstances at the time - it's not for everyone and I have friends very happy with formula and sharing feeding responsibility. And those who pump and bottle feed expressed milk? Warriors. Champions. Pump, cleaning equipment, store milk. Feed milk. Pump, clean...etc. so much involved and they have to pump longer/more often than baby would normally feed (including every few hours overnight!) as pumps aren't as efficient as baby.

I have a feeding pillow (actually 1 for bedroom and 1 for sofa) and swear by it, but some people don't get on with them. Also useful for propped tummy time though! (Milestones and motherhood online and instagram is gold for gross motor development tips like that).
Worth getting some nipple balm just in case, but if you don't use it all it's good as lip balm too 🙂 Other things you don't need but good to be aware of in case your journey is challenging at first are nipple shields (have a Google and read up). Almost everyone needs breast pads (personally I go eco friendly and have a load of washable ones, not disposable) - I have a lot of milk and a serious letdown and in the first months or so could easily need to change mine a few times a day. I also liked having a pump, back up bottles and premade formula, which we did end up needing for 1st for the first week. A good lactation consultant will be able to help get baby onto boob if you need to use bottles at first. And both mine had dummies from about 1 week old, no issue with it affecting breastfeeding whatsoever. 1st still had the odd bottle right through to maybe 9m, 2nd has refused since about 3m and it doesn't really affect us so I've not bothered persevering.

A great resource online is KellyMom, also La Leche League. And something which worked for me was the nipple flip - possibly worth a Google (make sure you include breastfeeding in that search, otherwise I won't be held responsible for what comes up!!)

But yes most importantly, don't force yourself, or allow yourself to be forced, into a decision which doesn't feel right for your situation. Or guilted. There's enough self imposed and other guilt in parenthood. Baby will be fed. Baby will grow. You will be that baby's mother come hell or highwater.

catflycat · 14/12/2022 23:49

Leave the group 😅 But I would suggest going to a local breast feeding meeting or La Leche League, whatever they have where you are. It's useful to have someone watch you feed and check you don't have any issues/resolve them for you (plus the social side and trees and biscuits 😅). The midwives didn't help with this in my experience, they checked I was managing to feed and left me to it, but I got very sore very quickly and the groups were amazing at figuring out what was wrong. I had to go back with my youngest because it was like starting again, and I was used to feeding a much bigger baby and had forgotten what to do with a newborn again.

VanillaSpiceCandle · 14/12/2022 23:43

AwkwardPaws27 · 14/12/2022 22:46

They do have some strict rules but it's because it's admin-led & it helps avoid the "free for all" of conflicting advice. For example, they offer 1-2-1 support for things like latch issues, nipple pain via the admin inbox rather than letting group members suggest nipple shields when they may not be the first solution to try 🙂

It's not for everyone but personally I prefer trained admin-led groups to general advice groups now - I find the more general groups overwhelming tbh!

That’s the group I joined. What a mistake. Full of absolute nutters and the admins are the worst. I wasn’t allowed to post because I used nipple shields at first, given to me by the infant feeding team in NICU. But according to the group the incredibly well educated and well trained medical staff don’t know anything about breastfeeding. It attracts people who’ve nothing better to do and people who think they’re very special just for breastfeeding.

I’ve stopped feeding at a year old and the best thing for me was supportive cushions, pillows and making sure you’re comfortable before - including a massive drink. And I had to force my nipple in at first, no way could my baby have climbed onto it.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 14/12/2022 23:33

Breastfeeding can be really hard for most people in the initial couple of weeks so they probably thought they were being helpful so you'd be prepared. Just un-join if it's not helpful or join again once baby is here and the advice is useful/makes sense

PropertyGeek525 · 14/12/2022 23:30

tiredpuppymum · 14/12/2022 23:18

Midwives who haven't breastfed themselves won't be able to help you? What a completely ridiculous comment.

You're telling me my 3 years of degree level training, a lot of which was focussed on bf actually! Lots of specific competencies relating to bf must be completed and signed before you're even able to qualify. The multiple annual mandatory training courses, the years I've spent on postnatal wards and out in the community support women to BF day in day out, 37.5 hours per week, all means nothing because I haven't breast fed my own baby so that means I can't do it. Pull the other one!

I am personally very offended by your response to the OP.

Sorry your offended, I’m just a stranger on a forum, maybe lighten up and don’t take things so seriously.

Bestcatmum · 14/12/2022 23:22

This is why the 21 year old me never went to any classes. I just trusted my instincts and as it turned out I didn't need any help. i breastfed without any problems at all until I went back to work.

tiredpuppymum · 14/12/2022 23:18

PropertyGeek525 · 14/12/2022 21:50

Best people to get advice about breastfeeding from is those who have done it themselves. Many midwife’s only get a small amount of training and if they haven’t done it themselves they won’t really be able to help you. A midwife’s job is more centred around mum and making sure you are ok before, during and after birth.

If your area has a breastfeeding peer support service then they will be the best people to go to. They are usually mums who have undergone training to help other mums. They are non judgement and have all the up to date evidence based info that new mums need.

fb groups can be helpful but you will find the info is conflicting, best to seek out a peer support group if you can.

Midwives who haven't breastfed themselves won't be able to help you? What a completely ridiculous comment.

You're telling me my 3 years of degree level training, a lot of which was focussed on bf actually! Lots of specific competencies relating to bf must be completed and signed before you're even able to qualify. The multiple annual mandatory training courses, the years I've spent on postnatal wards and out in the community support women to BF day in day out, 37.5 hours per week, all means nothing because I haven't breast fed my own baby so that means I can't do it. Pull the other one!

I am personally very offended by your response to the OP.

Nottodaty · 14/12/2022 23:01

Things I remember from both my babies.

When born they also need to learn. My first never got this memo wasn’t interested and bottle fed - she was fine.
My second a little more willing and it took about 2 weeks for us both to fully get it. It hurts at first I remember a moment screaming hungry baby, knowing it was going to hurt, then I looked down and saw a feeding baby - and it was all ok (with a lot of cream after she finished. ) If you need them to move breast or finish- pop you little finger in the corner of the mouth - no one told me. I nearly ended up in more pain and a walking dummy (also a dummy was fine she wasn’t interested after around 6 weeks)
Eventually you get into a rhythm and your body knows what to do. I got an awful sick bug when she was 6 weeks panicked that she wouldn’t be feed - she was fine.
The only frustrating thing wasn’t I couldn’t pump - I tried! And it doesn’t matter.

I would say give it a go, yes it will hurt and at times be bloomin hard, it will be worth it if you both can do it - but if not formula is not a sign of failure it’s just one of those many parent choices that’s none of anyone else’s business.

Knowitall2112 · 14/12/2022 22:57

Hi @elm26 again,

I just wanted to share some great Breastfeeding resources, all of the information contained within is evidenced based.

Global Health Media: Good quality Breastfeeding videos to assist with latching and other things: globalhealthmedia.org/topic/breastfeeding/

NHS: Off to the best start leaflet, everything you and anyone supporting you needs to know about Breastfeeding: www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.uhcw.nhs.uk/clientfiles/files/otbs_leaflet.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwiy_7rRmPr7AhWWM8AKHVrtCjMQFnoECAwQAQ&usg=AOvVaw1IURRU03GUkndZ85cPvq1p

BfN: Drugs in Breastmilk factsheets. If ever you need to take medication whilst Breastfeeding you may want to check these BfN factsheets out as part of making an informed decision. Many health professionals will instinctively advise that medication cannot be taken whilst Breastfeeding. There are many occasions when that advice is, untrue, unhelpful and at times harmful. The bfn factsheets are produced by a pharmacist, Dr Wendy Jones who specialises in Breastfeeding. She's a legend www.breastfeedingnetwork.org.uk/drugs-factsheets/

MissMaple82 · 14/12/2022 22:55

Honestly you need to stay away from Facebook, everybody does. It's full to the brim of fucktards

jumperoozles · 14/12/2022 22:48

My baby is over a year now and still breastfeeding - I used both cream and nipple shields in the early days. Cream before and after every feed. Nipple shields were a life saver for the few days when I got a sore nipple on one side. After a few weeks I didn’t need either thing any more. Just ignore people who say you should never use them - if you want to do it! If you don’t need them then great!

octoberfarm · 14/12/2022 22:46

Bless you OP, they sound absolutely bonkers Grin Breastfeeding discussions do tend to bring out the most militant voices and honestly, you will figure it out one way or another, I promise. I exclusively breast fed and then combi fed and I have two healthy, lovely kids despite what my local breastfeeding group told me about breast and only breast being best. If your LO is loved, fed and happy, you're doing brilliantly. I would probably swerve and avoid that group moving forward, do the class and speak with your midwife. It took me a bit of perseverance (and yes, nipple cream!) and I never got my supply quite right but one way or another, but we got there, and you'll make it work in whatever way you and the baby need it to. Congratulations Flowers

lifeinthehills · 14/12/2022 22:46

I have breasted a number of babies and they are all so different. I tended to get tender nipples to start but no creams needed. Those women are posting off their own experience. Yours will be your own.

As far as letting baby crawl up to the nipple, that's fine if you give birth on your back (which I consider an unnatural position). Mine could never have done that as I gave birth kneeling and had to lift them to me. I've never known a newborn that could climb vertically.

AwkwardPaws27 · 14/12/2022 22:46

MogTheForgetableCat · 14/12/2022 22:30

Not having a go at you personally as it's a helpful suggestion, but even that group has a rule that you can't mention dummies or nipple shields. These kinds of restrictions are crazy and just not helpful for the average person.

They do have some strict rules but it's because it's admin-led & it helps avoid the "free for all" of conflicting advice. For example, they offer 1-2-1 support for things like latch issues, nipple pain via the admin inbox rather than letting group members suggest nipple shields when they may not be the first solution to try 🙂

It's not for everyone but personally I prefer trained admin-led groups to general advice groups now - I find the more general groups overwhelming tbh!

Knowitall2112 · 14/12/2022 22:44

Hi @elm26 ,

Many congratulations on your pregnancy, wishing you and baby well over the coming days and weeks.

I'm sorry that the local FB group has been so unhelpful, such a shame!

If you have time, you might find it helpful to visit your local Breastfeeding Network (BfN) drop-in session. The BfN are a UK based charity which supports Breastfeeding families in their local communities. You may find BfN peer supporters in your maternity ward, at your local children's centre and/or other community space.

You can find your nearest BfN drop-ins at this link: www.breastfeedingnetwork.org.uk/drop-in/

They would love you to visit them whilst pregnant, they'd be happy to talk you through some of the things you may want to be aware of ahead of baby's arrival. You'll not know ahead of time how you and baby will find breastfeeding, by visiting your local Breastfeeding drop-in service before baby arrives, you'll be well prepared if you do find that you need help.

Depending on where you live, you might find that there are different drop-in sessions running at different times on different days in different locations, you may want to familiarise yourself with that information now, if you can.

As well as being a great resource for support, advice and guidance from trained and qualified Breastfeeding experts, it can also be a space where great friendships and support networks are found. There'll be other women with young baby's and children who you will meet, and you'll likely bump into these same women at different parent and baby groups in your area, it's great to have the opportunity to start building those networks early.

Confusion101 · 14/12/2022 22:41

Another said that I shouldn't have put that I'm "hoping" to breastfeed, it should be that I am going to breastfeed as this is what's best for the baby and there is no such thing as can't

As soon as you read this message you shouldve told them all to fuck off and left the group! For fuck sake what a horrible attitude!!!

You've gotten loads of great advice here already so I won't add more but best of luck and you seem to have a great attitude toward it already 😊

Kanfuzed123 · 14/12/2022 22:40

MogTheForgetableCat · 14/12/2022 22:30

Not having a go at you personally as it's a helpful suggestion, but even that group has a rule that you can't mention dummies or nipple shields. These kinds of restrictions are crazy and just not helpful for the average person.

It’s also not entirely evidence led, I saw a post when admin closed a comment of a woman with a baby with cmpa down saying that they don’t actually have cmpa because all cmpa babies react through breast milk, completely not evidence based at all and factually inaccurate

point is; the groups are ok but face to face support from someone who’s profession it is will always be better and less problematic at times also

MogTheForgetableCat · 14/12/2022 22:30

AwkwardPaws27 · 14/12/2022 22:13

This group was invaluable for me: www.facebook.com/groups/bflsuk/?ref=share

It's called "Breastfeeding and Lactation Support UK", its evidence based and admin-led so not a free for all of conflicting advice, & the admin are all trained in breastfeeding support. They can even offer latch checks via video.

There are good groups out there but as with the Internet in general there's also a lot of not so great ones.

Its a new skill for you & your baby so its great you are seeking advice in advance. I'm 6 months in after a bumpy start (DS was very sleepy and lost too much weight) but I'm so glad we managed to learn it together (& I really appreciate not having to get out of bed at 3am to make a feed!).

Not having a go at you personally as it's a helpful suggestion, but even that group has a rule that you can't mention dummies or nipple shields. These kinds of restrictions are crazy and just not helpful for the average person.

Kanfuzed123 · 14/12/2022 22:28

MichelleScarn · 14/12/2022 22:19

Go to a local f2f group, the online ones are crazy. As are the car seat advice ones I found. Have seen a recent one with regards to turning a 5 year old to forward face and how this is evil to do as still loads of room to rear face at 5!.. (awaits a flame... 😱)

But that’s true though… rear facing is just safer even at 5. It’s not evil of course to turn your 5 year old forward facing (not with a 5 point harness) but if they’re within the weight limit of their RF car seat, why not keep them RF if you can?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 14/12/2022 22:27

Hi OP

These groups can be really militant. I fed for 18 months and almost felt isolated as didnt bottle feed so was the odd one out sometimes, and when I asked for advice on these breastfeeding groups on things like how to cut down, how to stop night feeds, how to get a breastfed baby to take a bottle, a lot of the time I felt really dismissed and just got responses like 'waking up every 90 min through the night to comfort feed at 8 months is completely normal, just go with it, it's what your baby needs' etc etc. Its not normal, it was a habit that almost broke me! There doesn't seem to be many people that sit in the middle and can see the downsides of breastfeeding even though they breastfeed.

In any case
Buy:
A feeding bra, when you're quite pregnant so you dont grow any more (eg 35 weeks)
Then buy some more if you stick with it
Breast pads
A cheap feeding cushion from asda

Everything else like feeding clothes just buy if you stick with it, use zip hoodies and cardies and stuff in the meantime.

I did find a light up kindle useful for night feeds, bright enough to read but not too bright that I properly woke up, and i could just go straight back to sleep after.

I had a really good breastfeeding support group for establishing feeding so ask midwives what is available in your local area. I found midwives didnt help much, I dont think they get much training. The main thing the group taught me was feeding All The Time is normal, and 'nose to nipple'. Just make sure the babys mouth is open really wide so your whole nipple goes in. And I was told to google the 'flipple' to achieve this (someone showed me so didnt need to but apparently there are good YouTube videos).

Lastly if you get continuing pain and the latch is ok, go to an independent qualified tongue tie practitioner to check for tongue tie. midwives and doctors are NOT properly trained and can't always tell. Practitioners do 7 different checks of tongue movement. Doctors and nurses do a quick visual.

Good luck!

Kanfuzed123 · 14/12/2022 22:26

Those groups are bananas, although it is true that pain is a sign of a sore latch and those lanolin nipple creams can just make everything more slippy and not really do a lot else.

support from midwives and health visitors is hit and miss, i won’t lie to you.

are you having a hospital birth? Ie not a home one? You can ask to speak to the infant feeding team before discharge; they are specialists who can help with positioning and attachement and free! Don’t let anyone mug you off and say it’s only for if you’re struggling, nope not true, insist.

a good piece of advice would be to find an IBLBC in your area in advance just in case you run into difficulties, so you know who you’ll turn to.

most importantly though, do your best and forget the rest.

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 14/12/2022 22:21

To set expectation it really hurt me at the beginning. My mum was breastfeeding for about 7 years of her life and she said it hurt at the start every time. It wasn't just "latch issue" - it does take getting used to. Then it's really easy.

MichelleScarn · 14/12/2022 22:19

Go to a local f2f group, the online ones are crazy. As are the car seat advice ones I found. Have seen a recent one with regards to turning a 5 year old to forward face and how this is evil to do as still loads of room to rear face at 5!.. (awaits a flame... 😱)

Barleysugar86 · 14/12/2022 22:19

elm26 · 14/12/2022 22:14

Wow thank you all so much!

They really made it sound like a huge scary military operation which had strict rules you had to adhere to at all times otherwise you are some kind of feeding failure 🤦🏻‍♀️

You've all made me feel so much better, thank you for all the advice and who to contact etc. x

Haha I wouldn't worry about that. I used to just offer it to them a lot. My kids snacked a lot and we never did proper long feeds and they'd often fall asleep feeding but they gained weight really well. I never timed anything.

That's actually what I think is so great about breastfeeding. They eat what they want and stop. They can come back in twenty minutes for more. No worrying about a bottle spoiling as its always good to go.

I used to drink alcohol whilst feeding too. My midwife told me as long as you aren't getting really drunk the amount that passes through is negligible and there is no need to abstain.

Swipe left for the next trending thread