Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Breastfeeding advice group on Facebook has scared me?!

115 replies

elm26 · 14/12/2022 21:44

I thought it would be a good idea to join a private breastfeeding advice/support group as I hopefully will be breastfeeding when baby comes along.

I introduced myself and asked what they recommend me to buy, any tips, any information etc and oh my god, I feel like I've started WW3.

I do not know the first thing about breastfeeding but one lady commented telling me to get some good nipple cream and another replied saying if your nipples are sore it's a latch problem, so you don't need cream. The other lady then replied it's good to have as nipples can get quite sensitive etc and she replied breasts don't need to get used to being fed from so no need for cream, put up with the sensitivity.

Another said don't put baby's mouth to your nipple let them crawl their way up your stomach and find your nipple themselves.

Another said that I shouldn't have put that I'm "hoping" to breastfeed, it should be that I am going to breastfeed as this is what's best for the baby and there is no such thing as can't. I have always truly believed that "fed is best" and I think I'd get hunted down if I replied with that!

They've absolutely terrified me! I feel even more confused and like I'm a failure if for whatever reason I can't breastfeed/struggle with it.

Is it really worth being a part of these groups? Will I get help from the midwife etc? I do plan on going to the breastfeeding class.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
poweredbyplants · 15/12/2022 15:41

Riddlemethisplz · 15/12/2022 15:37

i think I know that group and I’d dispute the fact it’s run by professionals… there might be some IBLBCs but most are peer supporters, which is great but some of the advice I’ve seen on there… yikes.

just grateful I wasn’t on them when I was struggling with my first

Interesting if they're not as they definitely act like they are. I rarely read into the replies these days tbf, I had to mute it due to struggles and it causing me more stress and guilt seeing other people's issue free journeys.

Riddlemethisplz · 15/12/2022 15:37

poweredbyplants · 15/12/2022 15:15

Those groups can be so hit and miss especially depending on which one it is, there's one that is run by professionals, you can only post during certain "open" times but it's basically so questions go through professionals first rather than just a melting pot of random opinions.

i think I know that group and I’d dispute the fact it’s run by professionals… there might be some IBLBCs but most are peer supporters, which is great but some of the advice I’ve seen on there… yikes.

just grateful I wasn’t on them when I was struggling with my first

PremiumTV · 15/12/2022 15:18

There are lots of nutters in the "breast is best" camp. You do whatever is best for you and the baby. The only important thing is to make sure baby is fed adequately and is growing well, whether it's straight from the breast, or pumped or formula.

poweredbyplants · 15/12/2022 15:15

Those groups can be so hit and miss especially depending on which one it is, there's one that is run by professionals, you can only post during certain "open" times but it's basically so questions go through professionals first rather than just a melting pot of random opinions.

poweredbyplants · 15/12/2022 15:13

MogTheForgetableCat · 14/12/2022 22:05

Also I think nipple confusion is total bullshit made up to make things more difficult.

If you want to use dummies straight away, or bottles if you're mix feeding, it won't mean you can't breastfeed.

I disagree, nipple confusion can definitely be a thing. Great for you that you didn't experience it but it's 100% what ruined my breastfeeding journey after have no latch issues whatsoever until I was pressured into topping up with formula by the HV and suddenly had a baby that didn't seem to know what a nipple was after. My biggest regret is listening to the HV full stop and not seeking help for an IBCLC first.

Greengagesnfennel · 15/12/2022 13:31

Group sounds like a bunch of loons. Definitely leave. I would ask your midwife if there is a bf group for new mums near you. Don't worry about issues that haven't happened yet. They will show you how to do it in hospital before you leave and make sure you are ok with it. If you follow up with a new mum local group it will hopefully filter out the (frankly unhelpful) die hard pros. You will just be with people starting out, all trying to work it out.

I was told that if you are pale skinned (I am - naturally pink nipples not brown) you are more likely to get sore nipples. It still wasn't that bad with the ointment though. It wasn't a major issue.

I thought I would hate it and was a bit grossed out by the thought of doing it tbh. My nipples were associated with sexual arousal for me. But I surprised myself by really enjoying it in the end, it's a completely different feeling. A lovely closeness.

I would definitely buy a feeding pillow. Will get used all the time.

MogTheForgetableCat · 15/12/2022 13:09

racingcar · 15/12/2022 09:46

I had multiple midwives/breastfeeding support people say "hold the baby like a rugby ball" and then position my arms into a position that is absolutely not how you hold a rugby ball. I'm a rugby player - you hold a rugby ball in your hands, about 20cm away from your chest... It irks me every time someone says it, I have to refrain from saying "THAT'S NOT HOW YOU HOLD A RUGBY BALL". And, also, what kind of advice is that when 99% of women don't know how to hold a rugby ball? Might as well say "in labour, breathe like you're playing the French horn" - almost no one would know how to even do that correctly even if the actual professionals weren't talking utter bollocks.

www.tagrugbycoach.com/blog/how-to-hold-a-rugby-ball

Love this! 😁

MintyFreshOne · 15/12/2022 10:06

😅 ah ykwim

fairylimes · 15/12/2022 09:59

MintyFreshOne · 15/12/2022 09:56

I had multiple midwives/breastfeeding support people say "hold the baby like a rugby ball" and then position my arms into a position that is absolutely not how you hold a rugby ball. I'm a rugby player - you hold a rugby ball in your hands, about 20cm away from your chest

Sure looks like a rugby hold though when you are casually watching from the sidelines 😂

Why are you watching people breastfeeding from the sidelines? 😂😂

upfucked · 15/12/2022 09:58

Leave that group.

I found LLL local group helpful.

With DD1 bf just never clicked for us and with DD2 it did but it took work. I have a friend who qualified as a lactation consultant between her first and second and it still took her a week to get a good latch with her second child and she is a professional. It takes time for most people to get a good latch. I found watching YouTube videos really helpful. Remember what works for one baby doesn’t work for another.

MintyFreshOne · 15/12/2022 09:56

I had multiple midwives/breastfeeding support people say "hold the baby like a rugby ball" and then position my arms into a position that is absolutely not how you hold a rugby ball. I'm a rugby player - you hold a rugby ball in your hands, about 20cm away from your chest

Sure looks like a rugby hold though when you are casually watching from the sidelines 😂

pastypirate · 15/12/2022 09:54

Baby groups for bf, baby wearing, baby led weaning and washable nappies are full of nutters. Obviously not all of them but you've had a flavour of it! See also attachment parenting and limited screen time.

racingcar · 15/12/2022 09:46

GhostsJulianforPrimeMinister · 14/12/2022 22:10

Getting a good latch is important but honestly just hold the baby any way that is comfortable for your arms and do some reading up / watch videos about the latch... even with a good latch get nipple cream Lanolin is amazing .. if it doesn't work for you switch to bottles.
I remember a midwife telling me my baby who was gaining weight very well / no issues was being held wrong for breast feeding, tried to contort my arms into an uncomfortable pose ... she left and I went back to how I was getting on fine doing it, he's a very healthy 6 year old Xmas Grin
My second was born in lockdown, bliss not having anyone come around and give their opinions!

I had multiple midwives/breastfeeding support people say "hold the baby like a rugby ball" and then position my arms into a position that is absolutely not how you hold a rugby ball. I'm a rugby player - you hold a rugby ball in your hands, about 20cm away from your chest... It irks me every time someone says it, I have to refrain from saying "THAT'S NOT HOW YOU HOLD A RUGBY BALL". And, also, what kind of advice is that when 99% of women don't know how to hold a rugby ball? Might as well say "in labour, breathe like you're playing the French horn" - almost no one would know how to even do that correctly even if the actual professionals weren't talking utter bollocks.

www.tagrugbycoach.com/blog/how-to-hold-a-rugby-ball

Breastfeeding advice group on Facebook has scared me?!
Aria2015 · 15/12/2022 09:41

What a shame, sorry you've had this experience. I'm on a FB breastfeeding group and it's lovely, lots of great advice and nothing judgey. Sounds like bad luck that the one you joined isn't so friendly!!

I've breastfed (am still breast feeding) two children. The way I look at it is, in the beginning it's new to you and it's new to your baby. You both need to learn how to do it really. It's true a good latch makes things easier and comfier but it takes most new mums time and practice to get that good latch consistently. It can be frustrating and it can be painful to begin with, but like any new skill, perseverance is key.

I don't know anyone who didn't find it tricky to start with. You'll likely feel sore, you'll worry about your supply, you'll Google tongue ties and you'll watch a load of YouTube videos about different feeding positions and how to latch and you'll probably feel like giving up at some point too. All very normal and part of the journey. On the up side - once you and your baby have cracked it, it can be beautifully bonding, relaxing and super duper convenient (it's basically magic to stop them crying!).

Congratulations on your pregnancy and best of luck with the breastfeeding!

elm26 · 15/12/2022 09:37

I didn't expect all of these responses but I've read every single one and you're all amazing and so helpful.

I think I'm going to buy some nipple cream just in case, get measured at 38 weeks for a couple of nursing bras, some breast pads, get myself a couple of feeding pillows and crack on with it and see what works for us. I will keep in mind that fed is best so that in any case it doesn't work out I don't feel like an awful mother like they made it seem 😂

I've left the group. I also went through my midwife pack and the maternity hub in my area does breastfeeding classes and 1-1 support with it 3 days a week so I will go with that, I go there for my antenatal care anyway so it's familiar to me.

Thanks again everyone!

OP posts:
89redballoons · 15/12/2022 09:26

I'd get a tube of Lansinoh nipple cream. If you find it helps then great. If you don't, it's really good as lip balm and for putting on teething babies' sore fingers.

Agree with everyone else that a peer support group is the way to go. Where I am there is also a local breastfeeding support group on Facebook, which the peer supporters post on as well as other local mums. It's not a judgey one and supports all kinds of breastfeeding and combi feeding. I think something about knowing that you could bump into someone from the group in the street or at a baby group etc keeps it a bit more civil.

I think your midwife is supposed to give you information about breastfeeding at one of the later appointments, maybe 36 weeks? You can definitely ask her what local services there are anyway.

Brighton635 · 15/12/2022 09:22

One piece of advice that might be useful getting started when baby first arrives, let them feed for as long as they want to (which can be ages). I was told by a midwife after both births that 5 mins on each side should be enough. That is not what it says on the nhs (it says feed as long as they want). Taking them off means your supply might not establish as well. Also drink plenty of water!

RebeccaCloud9 · 15/12/2022 09:17

Be terrified of the batshit bf militia in the group, not of bf itself!

If you have problems, get real life support (friends, family, health visitor, sure start team, midwife)

If you don't have problems, or when any issues are resolved, bf is honestly the easiest thing! Leave the group and don't look back.

CocoPlum · 15/12/2022 09:12

Leave that group!

I am a peer supporter at a local free drop in run by lactation consultants. I recommend you find a group like this local to you and drop in before baby arrives.

It might feel a bit scary especially if you see women crying and talking about how hard or painful things are - but you'll get to know how the group works, where to find it, where to park ... all things that will be invaluable when you are trying to get there with a newborn! The supporters there will be happy to have a chat with you about how to get off to a good start, and you might be able to listen in on other women being given support which can be useful too.

Good luck!

Parker231 · 15/12/2022 09:07

isitginoclock · 15/12/2022 04:22

Lots of sensible advice here OP. I would dearly love to see what the reaction from the fb group would be if you did post "fed is best". Here's my take. Breastfeeding is fab. Sometimes it's hard/impossible/baby or you can't. Formula is also fab. You don't need to "fail" at breastfeeding to try formula. Sometimes it's right for you. Good luck.

Good post - breast or formula your baby will be getting an excellent start in life. It’s only one of many decisions you will have to make. DC’s had formula from day one - it’s amazing and no guilt in using it exclusively.

Mummy2C · 15/12/2022 09:01

I follow feedeatspeak on Instagram. She's very good. I trust her advice. I BF for 2 years. I found it took work for the first month or so then came more naturally. Part of my issues are probably because my LO haf CMPA.

Plantmoretrees86 · 15/12/2022 08:58

Congratulations to you, you've had great advice so I won't repeat it, I'll just add as I don't think I've seen it mentioned, that the breastfeeding support Scotland page on Facebook is excellent - really supportive and non judgemental advice. I saw up thread that another group doesn't allow discussion of nipple shields, well that was the only way my baby would feed for the first four months! I got really good advice from breastfeeding support Scotland and the national breastfeeding helpline about using shields which kept me going. Not sure if you have to be in Scotland to join... But just in case you are! They mention local groups but lots of the advice is generic in any case. Good luck!

Sceptre86 · 15/12/2022 08:36

Lots of those groups always have militant women who put people off and are no help when things don't go to plan. It can really make people feel shit about themselves.

If you want to breastfeed I would find out what kind of help is available to you in your area. It's better in my opinion to do that before baby arrives then when you are sleep deprived and possibly struggling. So is there an expert midwife that will come out to you, check with your own midwife now, are there drop in clinics at your surgery where they will check the latch and you can meet other breastfeeding mums for a natter as well as hints and tips, what about a lactation consultant, are there any in your area, check reviews and costs.Have a look at YouTube too for different breastfeeding positions and get yourself a pillow to make it comfortable for you.

Kalasbyxor · 15/12/2022 08:29

It could work out beautifully, OP.
I had my first DC in the UK, having grown up in a country where breastfeeding was much more the norm and the default feeding method, and I was never aware that it can be problematic, as I have seen in the UK.
It was absolutely fine from the start, so this is a definite possibility. My peer group of antenatal mum's also all breastfed without any issues well past 12 months.
Good luck, and you are of course right: fed is best.

ttcnumber2x · 15/12/2022 08:24

I'd leave the group they sound very opinionated and unsupportive

Swipe left for the next trending thread