Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secondary school not allowing kids to eat lunch inside in cold weather

208 replies

Bananabrain99 · 14/12/2022 20:53

Secondary school not allowing kids to eat their lunch indoors in this cold weather AIBU to feel cross with this as it is detrimental to pupils' health and wellbeing? My child was upset going into school today due to this and less than half the kids are in her class at the moment due to illness. Reasons cited by the school not to open up the hall is building works and needing the hall for flu vaccinations. Obviously I do expect my DC to have fresh air at breaks, but I don't think many adults would like a freezing cold picnic. Don't think there is anything I can do now (and school say will open a hall in January) but just feel upset about it and not sure if AIBU - I had presumed DC had somewhere warm to eat at least (12yrs old)

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 15/12/2022 10:53

Prettyinpink22 · 15/12/2022 10:13

As I have said before I have worked in schools and only primary has ever had supervisors at lunchtime. Not one secondary school I have worked at or the one my child attends have lunchtime supervisors they are supervised by teachers. School budgets are tight tespecially secondary schools.

The headteacher/heads of years/deputy’s are the ones who make the rules. So if they think it’s fine for the children to eat out side when it’s currently -7 here, then the should also be eating outside and not in warm offices/classrooms.

As I said, more fool those teachers for supervising during their lunch break. Do you think it's fine for people to work without pay @Prettyinpink22 ?

And while I don't think it's at all desirable for pupils to eat outside, it's utterly ludicrous to suggest that as a general rule senior staff should be subject to the same rules and expectations as pupils are.

Prettyinpink22 · 15/12/2022 10:13

cansu · 14/12/2022 21:48

Prettyinpink22 Teachers are not paid to supervise at lunchtime. They are strangely enough entitled to an unpaid lunchbreak. Schools employ MDS to supervise at lunch. The OP is right about the school offering g an indoor place to eat lunch but this has absolutely nothing to do with where the teachers eat!

As I have said before I have worked in schools and only primary has ever had supervisors at lunchtime. Not one secondary school I have worked at or the one my child attends have lunchtime supervisors they are supervised by teachers. School budgets are tight tespecially secondary schools.

The headteacher/heads of years/deputy’s are the ones who make the rules. So if they think it’s fine for the children to eat out side when it’s currently -7 here, then the should also be eating outside and not in warm offices/classrooms.

ilovesooty · 15/12/2022 10:00

Prettyinpink22 · 15/12/2022 08:20

As I have said none round here have lunch time supervisors in their secondary schools or any I have worked in. The teachers supervise.

More fool them.

ilovesooty · 15/12/2022 09:57

Untitledsquatboulder · 15/12/2022 07:49

If this is how it is in your kids school (or the one you teach in) then you have a big behavioural problem. In a normal school children of 11 and over can be left in classrooms with light supervision.

It was exactly how it was in the last school I taught at. And yes, it had horrendous behavioural problems. I don't think pupil behaviour in general has improved since I left teaching.

Goldenbear · 15/12/2022 09:44

Is this a private school as that's what used to happen at my private school but under 12? My DD is at a state comprehensive were i think there is some competitive under eating happening. I've noticed she'll buy a small thing and a drink as they have flavoured water. She is in year 7 and I noticed her enjoyment of the food has gone down hill as thee months have gone on as its not practical to have a roast outside and too cold to sit on the floor outside to have it. I would go as far to say the lack of social side of eating is contributing to a dysfunctional approach to food- it is becoming quite damaging.

Courgettecity · 15/12/2022 09:34

It's 30 mins total but they have form monitors, one puts out cups and pours water while rest of dorm start. Second monitor clears cups and wipes table at the end. The slow eaters usually take the full 30! It's also good that staff can watch what's being eaten. There are a few girls competitive under eating atm and it can be discretely monitored. I think it's especially important for teenage kids, fewer swop lunch and most eat something as it's a set time and place whereas they wouldn't bother if milling around a play ground.

ShamedBySiri · 15/12/2022 09:22

Agree with @Palacepicker and @SpicyFoodRocks

ShamedBySiri · 15/12/2022 09:20

Utterly shocked by this thread. I had no idea so many schools have no proper provision for children to sit and eat their lunch. What is the point if campaigning for free school meals or Jamie Oliver's war in turkey twizzlers if the children are just thrown outside to eat their food standing up. Someone upthread mentioned their child having a roast dinner but not having gravy incase she spilt it!

What do they do when it's raining?

Lunch is a very important part of the day for children both for nutrition and socially.

Our school has 3 lunch sittings, long tables and the form teacher sits with their form on a table. 20 minutes for lunch then kids go outside,

Is how it should be though 20 mins is tight for slow eaters.

SpicyFoodRocks · 15/12/2022 09:14

caringcarer · 15/12/2022 01:59

I don't teach any more but retired from secondary teaching. It used to upset me how kids don't have any lunch. No school meal or no lunch brought on to eat. I'm a bit of a softy and used to take be a loaf of f bread in each day and let them make toast in my classroom. It meant I had to stay in my class at lunchtime when toaster was being used and I had to go keep a tub of spread in a mini fridge in classroom too. I just could not see them go hungry let alone pushed out in cold or rain every day.

You sound lovely.

I am shocked to read that this happens. It’s freezing right now. Thankfully my kids could eat indoors. I accept that due to resources many schools now don’t have the space or staff to facilitate indoor eating.

What’s awful is that so many teachers thinking it’s acceptable, fine for the kids to do this etc. Depressing attitude. Not caring at all.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 15/12/2022 09:01

They do in every secondary school I have worked at and the one my child attends.

I think your experience is unusual. I don't know any local secondary where teachers do lunchtime supervision. They do a lot of extra-curricular clubs though.

Of course it is appalling that they have to eat outside. The fact that I had to do it in the late 90s doesn't mean children should still be doing it now. I don't blame individual schools and teachers though because they aren't to blame for lack of funding for supervision and dining halls. The idea that it is acceptable to leave groups of children unsupervised in classrooms is ridiculous - I hope none of those suggesting it are responsible for children's safety in school!

Prettyinpink22 · 15/12/2022 08:20

ilovesooty · 14/12/2022 21:50

Break times are paid hours in the school day. Lunchtimes aren't and teachers can leave the premises if they wish.

As I have said none round here have lunch time supervisors in their secondary schools or any I have worked in. The teachers supervise.

Prettyinpink22 · 15/12/2022 08:17

Valeriekat · 15/12/2022 07:47

Actually teachers aren't supposed to do lunchtime supervision.

They do in every secondary school I have worked at and the one my child attends.

Courgettecity · 15/12/2022 08:15

We're -10 right now, though will be warmer at lunch time. Our school has 3 lunch sittings, long tables and the form teacher sits with their form on a table. 20 minutes for lunch then kids go outside, where they have other staff on duty. It works. Staff get breaks.

Palacepicker · 15/12/2022 08:00

CinnamonJellyBeans · 15/12/2022 07:37

Buy her a warm coat, hat and gloves. Walking briskly, or playing a ball game will also generate heat energy. You may also wish to consider one of those metal thermos containers filled with hot noodles/soup/pasta.

Or you could ask for a refund.

What if you can’t afford a warm coat, hat and gloves? What if you are a neglectful parent who thinks that school should keep your child warm and so you don’t bother? There are lots of kids who turn up to school without breakfast, without coats etc - throw them out into the cold for 45mins - what harm will that do? I honestly feel schools have lost their moral compass. League tables and order/control seem to be all that matter.

Bananabrain99 · 15/12/2022 07:49

Thanks for all the replies. To @CinnamonJellyBeans the school haven't told parents this was what they were doing so I didn't think to give her a flask of hot chocolate and hardwarmers, it was only when she was upset and was coming home with a full lunch box (which often happens anyway because her lunchbreak is only 30mins post covid and she says she doesn't get time to eat) that I was finding out. I am not sure what you mean by refund? It is a comprehensive school not private so I couldn't ask for one, just feel upset for my 12 year old that she hasn't got an indoors space to eat her lunch during subzero temp in 2022 England. Seems pretty common place though.

As to those saying they'll survive and they will only care if there are deaths, that is a bit dramatic but more than 50 per cent of the class are off ill at the moment (not too many teachers though) and there is a cost of living crisis where public buildings are being designated as warm spaces for people to go to as there homes are cold, surely it would make sense for kids to be warm at school when eating.

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 15/12/2022 07:49

It doesn't fill you with much confidence if the school's starting position is that every child is there to ruin school equipment and property rather than 'most' children are fine so let's do the decent and morally, ethically right thing and have a canteen/hall children can eat in! Mine DC's school just can't be bothered post Covid as with my eldest who is 15, I saw the canteen on open evening, my youngest in year 7 can walk around, has her food card taken off her even though £100 on it, so mix up as staff are incompetent and if you lose or don't have enough money on it, the child has to queue outside in cold to get a new one. The system is inefficient and I have emailed the school to point this out but all you get in reply is one line answers asking me the parent how to solve their IT software issues! I should really have to tell them how to procure a product that works! I work with schools for my job and I find it too depressing, it was better in my 90s school days, hence I am leaving to a different sector.

Untitledsquatboulder · 15/12/2022 07:49

ilovesooty · 14/12/2022 21:49

Great way to get the rooms wrecked, parents to complain if their child has an accident, and teachers not to be able to access rooms to set up for afternoon lessons.

If pupils absolutely have to be inside they should be supervised in the hall and gym by senior management - and the hall shouldn't be used for anything else if needed at lunchtime.

If this is how it is in your kids school (or the one you teach in) then you have a big behavioural problem. In a normal school children of 11 and over can be left in classrooms with light supervision.

Valeriekat · 15/12/2022 07:47

Prettyinpink22 · 14/12/2022 21:22

The teachers can’t supervise from inside can they. They should be outside eating with the children.

Actually teachers aren't supposed to do lunchtime supervision.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 15/12/2022 07:37

Buy her a warm coat, hat and gloves. Walking briskly, or playing a ball game will also generate heat energy. You may also wish to consider one of those metal thermos containers filled with hot noodles/soup/pasta.

Or you could ask for a refund.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 15/12/2022 07:30

Part of the problem is lack of space in schools - a lot of schools now have staggered lunches which means classrooms are in use by other students whilst half the school eats their lunch. There may be some classrooms available but not enough (and they may not be suitable for eating lunch in, eg a science lab).

Also, for those saying students can be unsupervised at secondary age, the school would be liable if someone had an accident etc, it is very difficult to leave secondary students unsupervised now. So there would need to be supervision if not in every classroom certainly in every area of the school. Teachers, just like everyone else, do have legal entitlements to breaks, so it's not as simple as giving every form tutor an extra lunch duty.

I do think the school has messed up by having the hall in use for something else if it's the only inside eating space, though.

Palacepicker · 15/12/2022 07:30

PortiasBiscuit · 15/12/2022 07:22

It’s the only time my DD gets any fresh air. They can all have a whinge together, it’s bonding,
I will reconsider my stance if anyone actually dies from this policy.

Does your dd not walk to and from school? Ah whinge together about the school being shit - that sounds right. As an employer - you think I should treat our employees badly so that they can bond over a whinge? That sounds like a great idea! 😁
What are we doing to our schools?

HappyOnion · 15/12/2022 07:29

MrsMurphyIWish · 15/12/2022 07:20

I would be all in favour of this …

Reasons why pupils eat outside? No facilities to accommodate every growing pupil numbers.

Reason why my child isn’t learning enough in “X”? Their teacher is unqualified doesn’t have a GCSE in that subject. (Yes that’s me, teaching A-level psychology).

Reason why there’s no lockers? The cloakroom has been turned into a classroom.

Reason why the data manager is teaching KS3? No supply teachers.

These are all true for my school.

Who to blame? 12 years of Tory underfunding.

Quite. I don’t think the general public has any idea about how bad things have got.

Palacepicker · 15/12/2022 07:27

MrsMurphyIWish · 15/12/2022 07:20

I would be all in favour of this …

Reasons why pupils eat outside? No facilities to accommodate every growing pupil numbers.

Reason why my child isn’t learning enough in “X”? Their teacher is unqualified doesn’t have a GCSE in that subject. (Yes that’s me, teaching A-level psychology).

Reason why there’s no lockers? The cloakroom has been turned into a classroom.

Reason why the data manager is teaching KS3? No supply teachers.

These are all true for my school.

Who to blame? 12 years of Tory underfunding.

Why are kids not allowed to wear coats/ fleeces in class, appropriate winter footwear aka boots to school. Why did our school insist that the kids took their coats off whilst Carol singing in the town square. Were the Tories responsible for this? The A' Level Psychology teacher at my kid's school has been incapable for over 10 years, he's a running joke - that's not the Tory's fault either. Not that I'm trying to give the Torys an out but everything isn't their fault.

Choconut · 15/12/2022 07:26

At ds's (state) school the kids eat in the dinner hall and can stay in all lunchtime if they want in computer rooms/the library or the 6th form in their common rooms - most want to go out though. There are more problems with toilets being vandalised than anything else because they are the unsupervised areas - but you can't stop kids going toilet at lunchtimes!

PortiasBiscuit · 15/12/2022 07:22

It’s the only time my DD gets any fresh air. They can all have a whinge together, it’s bonding,
I will reconsider my stance if anyone actually dies from this policy.