Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secondary school not allowing kids to eat lunch inside in cold weather

208 replies

Bananabrain99 · 14/12/2022 20:53

Secondary school not allowing kids to eat their lunch indoors in this cold weather AIBU to feel cross with this as it is detrimental to pupils' health and wellbeing? My child was upset going into school today due to this and less than half the kids are in her class at the moment due to illness. Reasons cited by the school not to open up the hall is building works and needing the hall for flu vaccinations. Obviously I do expect my DC to have fresh air at breaks, but I don't think many adults would like a freezing cold picnic. Don't think there is anything I can do now (and school say will open a hall in January) but just feel upset about it and not sure if AIBU - I had presumed DC had somewhere warm to eat at least (12yrs old)

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 15/12/2022 19:15

Palacepicker · 15/12/2022 16:46

All the justifications for it too, it may be directed by HTs and the SLT but there are teachers on here defending it - telling parents if they don't like it complain - teachers are supposed to care for our kids, you keep telling us you are professionals and yet to stand by and allow this to happen, it shows how little you care. Treating kids poorly does not make them behave better. Poorly behaved kids should not be physically punished but what would you call standing outside freezing every day - it hasn't killed any of them yet - since when did that become the standard we live by when caring for kids.

The problem is there is often no physical space- schools are being crammed ever more full of students, and what was sufficient space to eat, say, 15 years ago now isn't enough for all students. And in this case the hall has been used for another function which is also important.

What really needs to be done is for schools to be given suitable funding to build decent canteens and eating spaces and to have them supervised.

Eating in form rooms isn't always appropriate- would you really want your kid eating in a science lab after it had been used for something like a heart dissection or plating bacteria, for example?

katepilar · 15/12/2022 19:09

Moon22 · 14/12/2022 21:41

My school used to do this. I used to piss off home at lunch time and not bother returning! (Not saying this is right!) Ridiculous to expect people to spend an hour outside in the cold. We didn't even have seating! You could sit on a wall- or the grass!

Spending an hour outside is not a problem. Having to eat in cold or freezing temperatures possibly with now tables/chairs is.

JassyRadlett · 15/12/2022 18:49

It always amazes me how many school leadership teams, and many teachers, expect children to behave to their school and their teachers with respect when they are shown so little in return.

BCBird · 15/12/2022 17:01

There needs to be a rota of paid duty staff to supervise pupils eating. These should be volunteers,not a statutory duty. No one should be expected to eat outside,nor should staff be expected not to have a proper child free break either. As a side issue I am concerned that some pupils may be losing the skill of eating a meal.at a table in company. For some,school might be the only place they get chance to experience this

StarlightLady · 15/12/2022 16:49

I assume all the staff are eating outside as well then? No? You surprise me 😂!

Palacepicker · 15/12/2022 16:46

All the justifications for it too, it may be directed by HTs and the SLT but there are teachers on here defending it - telling parents if they don't like it complain - teachers are supposed to care for our kids, you keep telling us you are professionals and yet to stand by and allow this to happen, it shows how little you care. Treating kids poorly does not make them behave better. Poorly behaved kids should not be physically punished but what would you call standing outside freezing every day - it hasn't killed any of them yet - since when did that become the standard we live by when caring for kids.

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 15/12/2022 16:41

Ridiculous. It's absolutely freezing. They need to eat in a classroom.

Palacepicker · 15/12/2022 16:37

OtterAnimagus · 15/12/2022 14:06

Employers can't do that. The welfare regs exist to stop it.

And imagine defending it by saying it's good for team bonding!

woodhill · 15/12/2022 16:36

Are the pupils supervised when they are turfed outside

I think it is appalling and I have worked in secondary with lunchtime supervisors,or staff doing a duty for canteen vouchers

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 15/12/2022 15:49

I remember eating outside at secondary school. Sitting on a bench in the rain under umbrellas huddled together. It was horrible. We'd have 30 minutes at there freezing. Poor kids. At least open classrooms for them.

Kefleur · 15/12/2022 15:42

Wow. That's absolutely appalling. Is there anything going for the UK school system? No wonder the mental health and morale of this country's young people's is shot.

FlowersareEverything · 15/12/2022 14:36

That’s awful. I was at High School in the seventies and it didn’t even happen back then in my school, at a time when corporal punishment was unfortunately still the norm. I’m really shocked.

Our school allowed pupils to sit in the wider open spaces in the extension, in cloakrooms, in the gym halls, assembly hall etc. the only supervision we had was from the Prefects or an occasional shout from the Rector or one of the Deputes HTs if the noise beneath his office got too loud (there was a balcony outside his offices overlooking a hall outside the main hall where some of the pupils sat around).

It’s about time children were treated more humanely.

poefaced · 15/12/2022 14:33

YANBU, one of my most enduring, miserable memories from secondary school is having to stand outside in the freezing cold at lunch time, every lunch time.

There was a small library but we had to be silent and the librarian was discouraging.

OtterAnimagus · 15/12/2022 14:06

Notcontent · 15/12/2022 02:22

That is really shocking. Only in the U.K…. As others have said, imagine if an employer made employees do that.

Employers can't do that. The welfare regs exist to stop it.

noblegiraffe · 15/12/2022 13:47

Not one secondary school I have worked at or the one my child attends have lunchtime supervisors they are supervised by teachers. School budgets are tight tespecially secondary schools.

Teachers cannot be required to supervise at lunchtime because it is unpaid and not directed time.

Teachers may choose to do a lunch duty in return for extra payment or for a free school meal.

This doesn’t apply to SLT.

RandomUsernameHere · 15/12/2022 13:46

YANBU. I would rather not eat than eat outside in this weather, it's so cold. I think the adults making these rules should consider whether they would want to do what they're making the kids do!

MandarinCat · 15/12/2022 13:39

I always got to sit down for lunch at school but there were only 700 pupils. My old school is now double the size at 1400 so harder to fit everyone in

HappierTimesAhead · 15/12/2022 13:39

This makes me so angry. I remember this from High School and I would have hoped things would have changed since then. It is perishing outside. I would contact the headteacher.

Whatsthestorytomorrow · 15/12/2022 13:35

LiveAndLetLiv · 14/12/2022 21:02

I work in a secondary school. We allow the kids to get lunch in the hall but they only have 15 mins per year group and then they have to go outside.

1200 kids. We can’t keep them all indoors and supervised for the entire lunch period. It’s cold, sure, but the staff on duty in the playground manage! They’ll survive.

It was the same when I was in high school back in the 80’s too.

funtycucker · 15/12/2022 13:31

Bearthepooh · 14/12/2022 21:28

Lack of room shouldn't be an issue, when I was in school, each year and form group had a classroom assigned for form specific classes/morning registration so we would be able to sit in there at lunch to eat if we needed to.

But that then requires a member of staff to sit in each room supervising the pupils. If there are 8 forms in each year, that's 40 rooms need supervising.

ilovesooty · 15/12/2022 11:14

Prettyinpink22 · 15/12/2022 11:00

Teachers are adults that are suppose to set a example to those they teach. You really think it’s fine to say to 11-16 year olds ‘that you have to eat in the cold but I don’t cause I’m a adult and I make the rules’. That’s ludicrous.

That's not what I said, as you'll realise if you read more carefully.

Glwysen · 15/12/2022 11:08

It all comes back to money. Schools should have bigger dining areas, longer lunch breaks, supervised indoor areas, more staff available to supervise. Just more points on the list that they could do if they had more money but can’t because budgets and capital investment have been stripped to the bones

gliiterryballs · 15/12/2022 11:07

I wouldn't have sent my kids in to school if they were expected to stand and eat lunch outside in sub zero temperatures. Barbaric.

NoDramaMama12 · 15/12/2022 11:01

@Palacepicker obviously in circumstances where children are sent to school without the appropriate clothing for this weather, the pastoral team would step in. If neglect is apparent, then SS would get involved. No one in their right mind (teacher or not) would force a child to stay out in the cold under those circumstances.

To address some other points on the thread, even if a school can accommodate students staying indoors during this weather, supervision is necessary. I have worked in inner city schools where behaviour is absolutely appalling.

One morning I was on my way to my form classroom. I spotted two students that I teach getting into an argument. Initially it seemed like it was just some bickering, so I stepped in, asked them to hurry to their forms thinking that would be it. All of a sudden, one student threw a punch at the other and somehow I ended up right between them. Lots of other pupils clamoured round trying to see what was happening. These two students were tall, strong lads. Little 5ft3 me was stuck in the middle of them and I badly damaged my shoulder trying to split these boys up. If another teacher hadn't physically torn them apart, the damage would have been much worse.

I can give worse stories, but it would be outing.

Supervision is necessary to safeguard both students and staff.

Prettyinpink22 · 15/12/2022 11:00

Teachers are adults that are suppose to set a example to those they teach. You really think it’s fine to say to 11-16 year olds ‘that you have to eat in the cold but I don’t cause I’m a adult and I make the rules’. That’s ludicrous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread