Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Title edited by MNHQ at request of OP - Advice pls on labour exploitation law (a minor not being paid at work).

186 replies

Hedgehogscanclimbtrees · 14/12/2022 19:24

This summer after GSCEs my son made a CV and went round our town's local cafes and restaurants asking for work. He was 16 at the time (17 now) and most places said no, he was too young. One place took him on, £5 per hour, mostly kitchen help, washing dishes, helping wherever help is needed, some waiting on tables. He has loved doing this, and he likes the boss ("he's like a friend") and the other members of staff. He has been putting in the hours at weekends and holidays, sometimes doing 10 hour shifts! To be clear this is something he has wanted to do and it helps his self-esteem. We have also kept an eye that his schoolwork does not suffer.
However I have found out that the boss is not paying his staff because of cashflow problems! Apparently payday was always "oh next week" etc. then it came out that the owner is opening another restaurant, so didn't have the cash to pay his (young) staff! My son has been paid some, but we added up his hours and he is owed over £1,000! My husband and I are tempted to go to the restaurant to (politely) tell the owner that he cannot withold our son's earnings but son (understandably) doesn't want us to wade in on his behalf. However he is in a vulnerable position, having been working cash in hand. And being so young (he has tried asking for his wages and keeps getting fobbed off). We told him to say that he cannot continue to work if he is not being paid but now they have simply removed him from the Whatsap group where the rotas were sent out. He went in today to ask why he'd been removed and it seems several people have been removed, apparently because the owner is trying to catch up on his debts to everyone by not rota-ing them... I asked who is serving then and my son didn't know, but he did reveal that Sundays have apparently been busy because sometimes it was just my son and the owner who was juggling cooking and front of house!
I have to say I think any business owner who does not pay his staff is probably going under. What recourse does my son have? Are there laws to protect people like him (and the other young people who have also not been paid)?
I would love to hear from any employment lawyers on here, or re 'Modern Slavery' laws!

OP posts:
SMabbutt · 15/12/2022 06:40

Your son has been naive and you have unfortunately contributed to him being cheated by condoning working cash in hand. An employer who is unethical enough to cheat the system to avoid paying tax and nics cannot be trusted to suddenly behave in an ethical manner towards employees. Any adult who is willing to go along with this has to accept they have no protection and are at risk of being cheated themselves. Your son is not an adult so it was down to you to make sure he didn't put himself in this position and protect him by pointing out the red flags. Try and explain to your son that this shouldn't have happened and that he needs to find proper employment with an employer who does things properly. He sounds like a hard worker and you can be justifiably proud of how determined he was to find a job but he deserves better than being exploited by a scam artist and tax cheat. Report the employer and try to get his outstanding wages but don't be surprised if it's a lost cause.

Mummyoflittledragon · 15/12/2022 06:37

Just by working at the restaurant, your ds has a contract of employment. A verbal one. The employer is acting appallingly, no contract isn’t great, cash in hand, illegal. Ditto 10 hour days as your ds is only allowed to work for a max of 8 and 40 a week. In your position, yes, I absolutely would intervene. Either go in with the details of all hours not paid and tell the owner your ds wants immediate payment otherwise you will start legal proceedings or write a letter together from your ds, which your ds can hand deliver. At just 17, there is a very unequal relationship and by the sound of it, your ds doesn’t understand the extent to which he’s being exploited. This is probably one of the examples, where showing him the thread may be useful. I’m sure the owner won’t be his friend anymore if your ds actually asks for what he is is owed. But then the owner was never really his friend in the first instance.

panko · 15/12/2022 06:25

MyOpinion1978 · 14/12/2022 19:31

Nope. NMW at 16 is £4.81ph.

Thats shockingly low

Catspyjamas17 · 15/12/2022 06:16

I would ask him to quit asap then help him pursue the owner for unpaid salary. DD1 has worked pt for a restaurant chain since she was 16, is only 17 now and gets paid £10+ an hour, same as the staff in their 20s. There are much better jobs out there where they do not exploit youngsters and you get paid on time every week.

Greensky90 · 15/12/2022 06:11

Presumably your Son lives at home, he is not a slave he has a choice.

Why didn't your Son stop working after 2 weeks of no wages. Obviously the company isn't very good.

cocktailclub · 15/12/2022 06:06

He's definitely not a modern slave. He's free to go.
Have you any idea of true modern slavery? And it's not just not being paid.

Luredbyapomegranate · 15/12/2022 01:26

Of course he isn’t a slave, he can leave.

Talk to citizens advice about helping you draft a letter, and small claims court if that doesn’t work

Volhhg · 15/12/2022 01:16

You and your son need to contact acas asap and follow their guidance or he may never see his pay. There's nothing wrong with accepting payment in cash, however it is up to the employer to provide a pay slip with tax details. Your son has broken no law here and I would contact HMRC. Please do not let people scare you into thinking your son is the tax avoiding party. This is a bad employer and your son should find another

starfishmummy · 15/12/2022 00:49

Please advise him not to accept cash in hand again (unless its for something one off and he gets the cash when he leaves.)

Verbena17 · 15/12/2022 00:20

Askinforabaskin · 14/12/2022 19:28

If he’s getting paid cash in hand then he is in a precarious position and he might not have much protection.

is there any reason why he choose to do it cash in hand? I doubt he’d be earning enough to pay any tax anyway. Also even for a16 year old, is £5 per hour not massively under the minimum wage?

But the employer is supposed to be doing it through the books properly so that OP’s DS is accruing NI years, which starts at 16.

DreamingOfAGreenChristmas · 15/12/2022 00:19

OP: listen to PRH47bridge above, who is a lawyer.

Your poor hardworking sim is being badly exploited.

If you want a job to be good for his self esteem make sure that he had a contract, is paid and knows his worth, working 200 hours unpaid over 6 months is being exploited.

Save and collate all the messages rota-ing your son.

I would then approach the restaurant owner and say you have the evidence, and you have legal advice that you can successfully take action but would invite him to pay what he owes before making things difficult, given that your son enjoys his work etc.

And meanwhile talk to your son about what friendship is and how exploitation doesn’t fit. Tell him how you have admired his work ethic, he has done really well, but he deserves to be paid and has a right to be paid.

GoT1904 · 15/12/2022 00:18

Cba to read all the comments but I was a victim of modern day slavery and sexual trafficking in my teens and think it's disgusting you've equated your sons predicament, to modern day slavery.

nettie434 · 15/12/2022 00:13

Should have put 16 olds not people on the sentence about personal allowance - I did actually work out how many hours at £4.81 you would need to work over a year to reach the tax threshold. It's more than most 16/17 year olds working part time would do.

nettie434 · 15/12/2022 00:02

Nope. NMW at 16 is £4.81ph.

This seems key to me - the owner could have cynically realised that offering £5 cash in hand might seem much more tempting than £4.81, assuming that most people will not work out that they are very unlikely to exceed their personal allowance if they are only earning £5 an hour and would probably only end up with deductions of 12% for National Insurance.

As others have said, modern slavery is a very real and shocking phenomenon. There are plenty of bad and/or inefficient employers without calling them modern slavers.

prh47bridge · 14/12/2022 23:51

Tessabelle74 · 14/12/2022 23:02

@CredibilityProblem work experience, volunteering any number of reasons why he was there doing unpaid work. He's been removed from the WhatsApp group so no proof of shifts booked. Industrial tribunals/ court action is ridiculously hard to prove and very costly. Better to just get down there and demand the money and stop him working any more shifts

Completely wrong.

Industrial tribunals, like the courts when dealing with civil cases, decide on the balance of probabilities. They do not look for proof beyond reasonable doubt. Removing someone from a WhatsApp group simply means they can't see any new posts. Old ones are still available, so there is proof of shifts booked along with all the other things mentioned by@CredibilityProblem. The employer would find it impossible to convince the tribunal that OP's son hadn't worked there.

As for industrial tribunals being very costly, it costs absolutely nothing to make a claim and, unlike most civil cases, you do not have to pay the other side's costs if you lose.

Some people have mentioned the small claims court. Industrial tribunal would be the right place for this case. However, for completeness, small claims are also decided on the balance of probability. Bringing a claim for between £1000 and £1500 would cost £80. As with industrial tribunal, you don't have to pay the other side's costs if you lose.

Walkaround · 14/12/2022 23:36

@Tessabelle74 - read the thread. He’s not in the group because he is no longer getting shifts. That doesn’t stop him being owed money for shifts he was rostered for.

Ruffpuff · 14/12/2022 23:36

I don’t have much helpful advice. This happened to my dp when he was 16 (10 yrs ago). His grandfather walked into the restaurant and threatened to take the coffee machine in leu of wages if it wasn’t paid. He was given the money there and then. I have studied law, actually it is legal to honestly take something if you believe it makes up for something owed (though I don’t recommend if possible- depends on the community!).

Walkaround · 14/12/2022 23:35

Small claims court is not expensive to bring a claim, and self-representation eminently possible. Just starting the process is normally enough to get the guilty party to cough up if the money is available in the first place.

Tessabelle74 · 14/12/2022 23:33

@Walkaround he's no longer IN the WhatsApp group though, read the posts! He has no proof whatsoever now

Walkaround · 14/12/2022 23:29

Tessabelle74 · 14/12/2022 22:53

@CredibilityProblem please explain how he proves he's employed there? No contract, no payslip, no receipt for payment. Good luck in court

@Tessabelle74 - it’s a bit hard to wriggle out of the evidence provided by a Whatsapp group where the boss shares everyone’s roster.

Gildedbrooks · 14/12/2022 23:18

MY daughter had this but to the tune of only aorund £380-£400 - she was 17, wanting to be indepedent and didn't want to speak up to the business owner.

I messaged this guy once asking when she would be paid what she was owed, he didn't respond or pay her, I pulled my daughter out of there. £400 is a relatively cheap lesson not to work cash in hand for people who will willingly exploit you.

£1000 is a lot though and should be pursued.

MichaelFabricantWig · 14/12/2022 23:11

PacificallyRequested · 14/12/2022 19:33

He's a mug maybe but definitely not a modern slave. FFS.

This

report them to HMRC for non national minimum wage compliance though. You can do it anonymously

they are breaking the working time regulations as well by having a 17 year old work 10 hour days.

alwaysmovingforwards · 14/12/2022 23:07

@SnackSizeRaisin
I'd rather a potentially 'cringy' situation than my 17 year old be in a vulnerable position, working for a shark and over £1,000 out of pocket.

The kid in the OP is being taken advantage of. If you'd not step in as the parent and support the situation by making your presence be known because it's 'cringy', well that's up to you and what you consider support I guess.

decayingmatter · 14/12/2022 23:05

I would probably threaten to make a show of him and his business all over the local Facebook groups and every other arena if he didn't pay up

KAYMACK · 14/12/2022 23:03

My suggestion: contact your MP. That means that you will have the protection of the MP, especially as the MP or his/her staff will be very careful to adhere to the law. You need to think about other people who might be exploited by this person. This way will guarantee that you are both pursuing the proper legal route and will receive the proper protection.

Your son sounds like a hard worker. Maybe I suggest he channels his talents/desire to work into creating his own website offering some sort of service? Or I suppose it can be done through a Facebook website. Someone willing to work in these difficult times might do very well for themselves.