Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Title edited by MNHQ at request of OP - Advice pls on labour exploitation law (a minor not being paid at work).

186 replies

Hedgehogscanclimbtrees · 14/12/2022 19:24

This summer after GSCEs my son made a CV and went round our town's local cafes and restaurants asking for work. He was 16 at the time (17 now) and most places said no, he was too young. One place took him on, £5 per hour, mostly kitchen help, washing dishes, helping wherever help is needed, some waiting on tables. He has loved doing this, and he likes the boss ("he's like a friend") and the other members of staff. He has been putting in the hours at weekends and holidays, sometimes doing 10 hour shifts! To be clear this is something he has wanted to do and it helps his self-esteem. We have also kept an eye that his schoolwork does not suffer.
However I have found out that the boss is not paying his staff because of cashflow problems! Apparently payday was always "oh next week" etc. then it came out that the owner is opening another restaurant, so didn't have the cash to pay his (young) staff! My son has been paid some, but we added up his hours and he is owed over £1,000! My husband and I are tempted to go to the restaurant to (politely) tell the owner that he cannot withold our son's earnings but son (understandably) doesn't want us to wade in on his behalf. However he is in a vulnerable position, having been working cash in hand. And being so young (he has tried asking for his wages and keeps getting fobbed off). We told him to say that he cannot continue to work if he is not being paid but now they have simply removed him from the Whatsap group where the rotas were sent out. He went in today to ask why he'd been removed and it seems several people have been removed, apparently because the owner is trying to catch up on his debts to everyone by not rota-ing them... I asked who is serving then and my son didn't know, but he did reveal that Sundays have apparently been busy because sometimes it was just my son and the owner who was juggling cooking and front of house!
I have to say I think any business owner who does not pay his staff is probably going under. What recourse does my son have? Are there laws to protect people like him (and the other young people who have also not been paid)?
I would love to hear from any employment lawyers on here, or re 'Modern Slavery' laws!

OP posts:
Sp0rk · 15/12/2022 13:23

www.gov.uk/part-time-worker-rights

His employer should not have taken someone on as "cash in hand"

His employer should have gone through PAYE, which includes National Insurance contributions, sick pay, holiday pay

OriginalUsername2 · 15/12/2022 13:13

alwaysmovingforwards · 14/12/2022 19:36

Personally I'd 'build a relationship' with the boss.
Just drop in and order something, let him know you're DS parents, ask how he's getting on.
Good at the job?
Are you happy with him?
All ok with wages etc?
Let's swap numbers in case of an emergency...

Basically politely let the owner know that your DS isn't alone and that you're now on the scene and you've now got a direct line.

I think this is your best bet.

Volhhg · 15/12/2022 13:10

Ahsoka2001 · 15/12/2022 12:13

If he's under 18 he probably doesn't do enough hours to warrant paying tax.

And anyway the ops Son is the employee not the employer. It's up to the Employer to pay through PAYE and provide a pay slip and take national insurance contributions. He is not self employed so cannot do a self assessment. Nothing wrong with cash payment if employer declares it and since he is the employee he can say he is awaiting his payslip

Ahsoka2001 · 15/12/2022 12:13

LikeTearsInRain · 14/12/2022 22:36

No but your son and you as his parents who have facilitated this are willing tax evaders. You should report yourselves.

If he's under 18 he probably doesn't do enough hours to warrant paying tax.

Gildedbrooks · 15/12/2022 11:30

KettrickenSmiled · 15/12/2022 11:27

Well you're clearly not "triggered", so that's nice dear.

Not sure you can claim the same for "obtuse".

🙄

KettrickenSmiled · 15/12/2022 11:27

Gildedbrooks · 15/12/2022 11:03

The title isn't offensive at all. The OP asks "Is my son a modern day slave?"

Which would seem to mean she doesn't know if he would count as one or not, hence the question.

People being deliberately obtuse and triggered on MN honestly do my head in.

And yes google is free blah blah whatever.

Well you're clearly not "triggered", so that's nice dear.

Not sure you can claim the same for "obtuse".

Gildedbrooks · 15/12/2022 11:03

The title isn't offensive at all. The OP asks "Is my son a modern day slave?"

Which would seem to mean she doesn't know if he would count as one or not, hence the question.

People being deliberately obtuse and triggered on MN honestly do my head in.

And yes google is free blah blah whatever.

KarmaStar · 15/12/2022 10:40

Your title is going to be offensive and upsetting for many people.
How you've allowed such a young man to work so many hours and not notice he has no money is ...questionable.
Tell them straight that they must pay up or you will take legal action.
I would be informing the relevant authorities also.

EndlessRain1 · 15/12/2022 10:36

Not read the full thread, but wow op your post is so offensive to people who have genuinely experiened modern slavery. That deserves a 🙄

That said your son has been exploited and you should seek help from an employment solicitor, out of principle if nothing else!

cupofdecaf · 15/12/2022 10:34

Report it to HMRC. He should be being paid the minimum wage and he's not (with holding wages like that counts).

Naunet · 15/12/2022 10:18

paintitallover · 15/12/2022 10:15

@Naunet Not all modern slaves are in the sex trade. Many are in takeaways, small shops, businesses and some still in agriculture.

Yes I’m aware of that, I was using the sex trade as an example, I didn’t say it was the only form.

paintitallover · 15/12/2022 10:15

@Naunet Not all modern slaves are in the sex trade. Many are in takeaways, small shops, businesses and some still in agriculture.

Naunet · 15/12/2022 10:09

The title of your thread is really offensive, your sons situation is not comparable to a woman trafficked into the sex trade and raped daily, please keep some perspective.

Having said that though, his employers treatment of him is disgusting and id want to seek legal advice, or go and speak to his boss too, but it’s difficult if your son doesn’t want you to get involved. Ultimately at 17, I think this is one of those things he needs to learn to navigate, I think you should explain to him that he has avenues to explore if he wants to get what he’s owed, and you’ll support him in exploring them, but it’s his choice as to if he wants to do that or not.

Candlemas · 15/12/2022 09:53

He shouldn't have accepted a job where there is no record of his earnings. Lots of cafe / restaurant type businesses are struggling just now, people don't have much spare money with bills going through the roof.

Making a claim in the small court might not result in back payments being made as his boss probably hasn't got the money.

He isn't a slave as he is completely free to move on, and he should chalk this up to lesson learned and find another job where he is paid correctly. Jobs are easy to find right now.

Bluerisotto · 15/12/2022 09:49

Catslovepies · 14/12/2022 19:37

This actually happened to me when I was that age. I told the boss that unless he paid me what he owed I would report him to the taxman. It was quite scary as he started shouting and swearing but in the end he paid up pretty quickly.

This put a huge smile on my face, good for you, being that age and standing up for your rights!

ghjklo · 15/12/2022 09:48

you need to go stick up for your son, people like this boss guy are selfish idiots taking advantage of young people. If he can't manage his cashflow without not paying people he doesn't deserve to be in business to be honest.

messybutfun · 15/12/2022 09:44

Tessabelle74 · 15/12/2022 07:31

@messybutfun 🤣🤣🤣 you really think this is going to court? Over a grand? It'll cost more than that in solicitors fees, ah you're funny though, brilliant

Court, tribunal, acas - perhaps focus on the relevant info the message conveys rather than unnecessary detail.

prh47bridge · 15/12/2022 09:13

On the contract question, to correct myself slightly, he works and is supposed to be paid for it. That is the contract.

It is a common mistake to think that a contract must be written. The law does not require that. Every time you buy something from a shop, you enter into a contract with the shop even though there is nothing in writing, let alone a signed document. In this case, in the absence of a written contract, the contract consists of the agreement between OP's son and the boss (regardless of whether that was written or verbal) that he would work and be paid £5 an hour plus those terms implied or stipulated by law. This is basic contract law.

In addition to my legal knowledge, I have personal experience of this. My son's first job while he was at college a few years ago was at a local pub. He did several shifts for them over Christmas and New Year. There was no written contract, no payslips and he was not paid. According to @Tessabelle74, taking the pub to tribunal would be hugely expensive and he would lose. In reality, it cost him nothing and he won. He did it entirely himself. My only involvement was to advise him that he should go to tribunal rather than small claims.

prh47bridge · 15/12/2022 08:27

@Tessabelle74 Continuing to display your lack of legal knowledge.

No need for solicitors in either the small claims court or industrial tribunal.

There is a contract. It may not be written but it clearly exists. He works and is paid for it. That is the contract.

You are completely wrong in thinking that the lack of a written contract would be fatal to his case. Far from it. It would actually help him as it shows the employer has failed to fulfil the legal requirement to give employees written particulars of their employment.

He is not working illegally. Cash in hand work is not automatically illegal.

Contrary to what you think, this would be a straightforward win for OP's son. Getting the judgement would cost nothing.

Tessabelle74 · 15/12/2022 08:09

@Walkaround there is NO CONTRACT. The court will require a copy of it, and also your son's payslips, oh hang on he's working ILLEGALLY cash in hand. Good luck in court, do update us 🤣

Title edited by MNHQ at request of OP - Advice pls on labour exploitation law (a minor not being paid at work).
Walkaround · 15/12/2022 07:58

@Tessabelle74 - no need for solicitors in a small claims court. No idea about industrial tribunal.

Tessabelle74 · 15/12/2022 07:31

@messybutfun 🤣🤣🤣 you really think this is going to court? Over a grand? It'll cost more than that in solicitors fees, ah you're funny though, brilliant

messybutfun · 15/12/2022 07:23

@Tessabelle74 Have you not followed the Wagatha Christie trial. The court will ask the owner to provide the whatsup messages. The owner will say he dropped his phone in the Irish Sea. The court will decide he lied.

ShamedBySiri · 15/12/2022 07:16

Also, I'm afraid I think it is highly unlikely your son will get his full wages owed paid to him and maybe none. The business is going under. He should atop working there now and concentrate on his studies and getting another job.

Re NHS employment the NHS is now offering a variety of apprenticeships in different areas from HR and IT to the labs and nursing. Two of the trainee radiographers in my department who are on the apprenticeship scheme started off as porters in the department. So it's really worth taking a look at what is on offer at your local hospital.

ShamedBySiri · 15/12/2022 06:58

Firstly congratulations to your son for his great work ethic. It's difficult these days for teenagers to get jobs but it's a great start to future employment. My DD started pub work at 17 and it was as such a good job for her with excellent employers and all through uni whenever she has been home she's just gone back and picked up shifts whenever she's around. It gave her confidence and a good reference for getting other jobs through uni and going on to post uni employment.

Unfortunately times are bad and many in the hospitality business are struggling and this is reflected by your son's employer not paying wages or paying cash in hand (and not paying PAYE etc although your son is unlikely to be earning enough to pay tax). Has he ever had a wage slip?

This won't improve, it's only a matter of time until this business goes under.

He should look for another job, hopefully be able to get a reference from his current employer. Then contact citizens advice regarding making a claim for unpaid wages.

I'm sorry his first job won't have been a positive experience for him but put it down to learning and he will appreciate better working conditions in another job.

He's not a slave but he is being exploited and no doubt there are many businesses doing this in the current economic situation.

I'm not sure if you have to be minimum 18 to work in the NHS but my hospital has plenty of young people working in jobs like portering and cleaning before going to uni. One of my DD2 friend's loves her portering job taking meal trolleys and delivering laundry etc, she's studying now but keeps up her work at the local hospital. Take a look at the NHS job site, it might be a better route than hospitality at the present time.