Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Title edited by MNHQ at request of OP - Advice pls on labour exploitation law (a minor not being paid at work).

186 replies

Hedgehogscanclimbtrees · 14/12/2022 19:24

This summer after GSCEs my son made a CV and went round our town's local cafes and restaurants asking for work. He was 16 at the time (17 now) and most places said no, he was too young. One place took him on, £5 per hour, mostly kitchen help, washing dishes, helping wherever help is needed, some waiting on tables. He has loved doing this, and he likes the boss ("he's like a friend") and the other members of staff. He has been putting in the hours at weekends and holidays, sometimes doing 10 hour shifts! To be clear this is something he has wanted to do and it helps his self-esteem. We have also kept an eye that his schoolwork does not suffer.
However I have found out that the boss is not paying his staff because of cashflow problems! Apparently payday was always "oh next week" etc. then it came out that the owner is opening another restaurant, so didn't have the cash to pay his (young) staff! My son has been paid some, but we added up his hours and he is owed over £1,000! My husband and I are tempted to go to the restaurant to (politely) tell the owner that he cannot withold our son's earnings but son (understandably) doesn't want us to wade in on his behalf. However he is in a vulnerable position, having been working cash in hand. And being so young (he has tried asking for his wages and keeps getting fobbed off). We told him to say that he cannot continue to work if he is not being paid but now they have simply removed him from the Whatsap group where the rotas were sent out. He went in today to ask why he'd been removed and it seems several people have been removed, apparently because the owner is trying to catch up on his debts to everyone by not rota-ing them... I asked who is serving then and my son didn't know, but he did reveal that Sundays have apparently been busy because sometimes it was just my son and the owner who was juggling cooking and front of house!
I have to say I think any business owner who does not pay his staff is probably going under. What recourse does my son have? Are there laws to protect people like him (and the other young people who have also not been paid)?
I would love to hear from any employment lawyers on here, or re 'Modern Slavery' laws!

OP posts:
threatmatrix · 16/12/2022 13:10

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 11:35

Well said Shol.

I wonder if OP is ever coming back. Let alone going to apologise for her tone-deaf thread title.

Jesus Christ people just looking for something to pick in. Modern day Slavery is mainly rampant in non western countries and when it does happen here it’s usually by foreigners. Western born people don’t really partake.

threatmatrix · 16/12/2022 13:08

The thing is my accountant deals with all that so I can assure you I have no need to ‘make sure’ of anything. Bloody hell do you jump on everyone’s comment or was I special.
he wasn’t old enough when he started. I misunderstood and thought he was 15 I beg for your forgiveness.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 12:19

it doesn’t matter that he got cash as he’s too young to pay tax
He's not too young to be paying NI.
And the only reason he won't pay tax is he won't be earning enough to meet the threshold.

If your young staff earn anything over £123 a week, you;d better make sure you're not falling foul of PAYE law @threatmatrix - HMRC would take a very dim view, & nobody wants a visit from the men in tricorn hats ...
www.gov.uk/child-employment/paying

threatmatrix · 16/12/2022 12:14

I am a restaurant owner. First of all I wish he worked for me.
it doesn’t matter that he got cash as he’s too young to pay tax and that would also be up to the owner so not a problem for your son. I would definitely go and have a strong word with the owner. How fevking dare he. This does happen in the catering industry and it really annoys me. Never let your son go even one week past his wage day. Threaten him with the tax people and he will don get his money. He now has experience so should get a job in lots more places. Wish he lived in Southampton.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/12/2022 11:35

Shol · 16/12/2022 10:51

Pretty offensive to compare your son’s situation to modern slavery OP. There are right now people in Britain who are held in captivity, forced to work for free, often beaten, and in the case of women often raped. No, your son is not a slave. He’s a gullible child who took a shitty job, engaged in tax dodging, and trusted its dodgy owner, and you are the parent who failed to stop it.

If your son is owed £1k, pursue it in the small claims court.

Well said Shol.

I wonder if OP is ever coming back. Let alone going to apologise for her tone-deaf thread title.

Mistlewoeandwhine · 16/12/2022 11:02

Go to your local paper. Name and shame.

Shol · 16/12/2022 10:51

Pretty offensive to compare your son’s situation to modern slavery OP. There are right now people in Britain who are held in captivity, forced to work for free, often beaten, and in the case of women often raped. No, your son is not a slave. He’s a gullible child who took a shitty job, engaged in tax dodging, and trusted its dodgy owner, and you are the parent who failed to stop it.

If your son is owed £1k, pursue it in the small claims court.

VenusClapTrap · 16/12/2022 10:46

This happened to a school friend when we were 16. Her father had recently been released from jail (GBH). He rang the employer, and the conversation went like this:

”Do you like hospital food?”
”What?”
”Cos that’s what you’re gonna get, if you don’t pay Jane Bobbins right now”
”Who is this? Is this a threat? I’ll call the police!”
”You do that. You call the police and tell them you’ve been threatened by Bob Bobbins, and they’ll confirm it’s a genuine threat”

She got her money.

BabeRuthless · 16/12/2022 09:43

Fiddledeedeeee · 14/12/2022 19:32

Does he have a contract? Definitely contact Acas to find out for certain his position.

As far as the ‘employer’ goes, he shouldn’t be allowing your son to work 10 hours a shift at his age - it’s a breach of WTD
https://www.gov.uk/maximum-weekly-working-hours

What this poster said. We have a 17 year old at my work who we had to do a separate risk assessment for. There are very strict rules about what shifts he can do and the breaks he needs in between shifts. Unfortunately the cash in hand situation is a common way of exploiting employees, especially in the hospitality industry. My husband works in that sector and has had more than one employee leave to take what they think is a lucrative cash in hand job only to find themselves with no safety net when it comes to sick pay, holidays or hr situations.

Notthetoothfairy · 16/12/2022 08:05

If the owner is opening another restaurant, then he certainly does have the cash to pay your son the £1,000 owed. He has acted in bad faith and your son needs to stop working there.

In the meantime, I would suggest sending a WhatsApp/e-mail reminding the owner of the amount owed and asking when it will be paid. You could set a deadline of, say, a month to pay after which you will take this up with the small claims court and the tax authorities.

someonecookmydinnerplease · 15/12/2022 23:09

chocolatecupcake · 15/12/2022 23:01

Modern Slave.... ffs. I work with actual victims of modern slavery and they'd be willing to trade places with your son in a heartbeat. How pig ignorant.

This.

Your son isn't a slave as he can choose to leave at anytime. Your post is really quite offensive. Do you have any idea what a huge issue actual real modern slavery is in the uk? Please don't minimise the term by using it to describe your son's scenario.

chocolatecupcake · 15/12/2022 23:01

Modern Slave.... ffs. I work with actual victims of modern slavery and they'd be willing to trade places with your son in a heartbeat. How pig ignorant.

pinkpantherpink · 15/12/2022 21:40

Hedgehogscanclimbtrees · 14/12/2022 19:24

This summer after GSCEs my son made a CV and went round our town's local cafes and restaurants asking for work. He was 16 at the time (17 now) and most places said no, he was too young. One place took him on, £5 per hour, mostly kitchen help, washing dishes, helping wherever help is needed, some waiting on tables. He has loved doing this, and he likes the boss ("he's like a friend") and the other members of staff. He has been putting in the hours at weekends and holidays, sometimes doing 10 hour shifts! To be clear this is something he has wanted to do and it helps his self-esteem. We have also kept an eye that his schoolwork does not suffer.
However I have found out that the boss is not paying his staff because of cashflow problems! Apparently payday was always "oh next week" etc. then it came out that the owner is opening another restaurant, so didn't have the cash to pay his (young) staff! My son has been paid some, but we added up his hours and he is owed over £1,000! My husband and I are tempted to go to the restaurant to (politely) tell the owner that he cannot withold our son's earnings but son (understandably) doesn't want us to wade in on his behalf. However he is in a vulnerable position, having been working cash in hand. And being so young (he has tried asking for his wages and keeps getting fobbed off). We told him to say that he cannot continue to work if he is not being paid but now they have simply removed him from the Whatsap group where the rotas were sent out. He went in today to ask why he'd been removed and it seems several people have been removed, apparently because the owner is trying to catch up on his debts to everyone by not rota-ing them... I asked who is serving then and my son didn't know, but he did reveal that Sundays have apparently been busy because sometimes it was just my son and the owner who was juggling cooking and front of house!
I have to say I think any business owner who does not pay his staff is probably going under. What recourse does my son have? Are there laws to protect people like him (and the other young people who have also not been paid)?
I would love to hear from any employment lawyers on here, or re 'Modern Slavery' laws!

Pay rate is legal. Speak to ACAS and report to HMRC

National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rates - GOV.UK www.gov.uk/national-minimum-wage-rates

Pay and work rights helpline and complaints - GOV.UK www.gov.uk/pay-and-work-rights

It is his employer that has not been operating paye. That he is being cash is not a crime. Once you get advice from ACAS advise HMRC that £ receivedbut employer has declined to provide payslip etc.

. He needs to leave this job. He owes them nothing.

rosemarysalter · 15/12/2022 20:59

A threat of some bad press may help
Too

rosemarysalter · 15/12/2022 20:59

Write a letter stating what they owe and threaten small claims court

See what that throws up

icelolly99 · 15/12/2022 20:21

Had a similar situation with my child. Went to ACAS for advice and raised an official tribunal case through the gov website.

prh47bridge · 15/12/2022 20:04

@MrsPinkCock At £5 per hour he would have to be working over 48 hours a week before he needed to pay tax or NI. At his age, I suspect the tribunal wouldn't expect him to think about whether the employer was avoiding NI by paying cash in hand. My son was also being paid cash in hand (or would have been if they had ever paid anything) and he tells me the tribunal in his case didn't appear to consider whether the contract was illegal. However, I agree that there is a possibility that the tribunal would hold that OP's son does not have clean hands.

qtpa2t · 15/12/2022 19:08

Sounds like you didn't advise him to be more careful about getting a proper contract, and no, he's getting taken advantage of. Please look up the definition of slavery, which to this day is an actual issue

MrsPinkCock · 15/12/2022 18:42

Whilst most of what you’ve said is correct, I actually disagree with you @prh47bridge when you say it would be a straightforward win.

OP, your son could potentially claim for unlawful deductions from wages, failure to provide a s1 statement of particulars (an employment contract), and failing to provide wage slips.

However, the difficulty with cash in hand work is whilst he CAN potentially demonstrate that a contract exists as stated upthread (because it is automatically implied), the problem he could face is that the contract in question could be illegal (cash in hand to avoid tax/NI payments) which means he would lose any statutory right to sue under it. The law requires you to have clean hands, so it will boil down to whether he knowingly/willingly entered into an illegal contract (assuming that it is indeed illegal and that the employer didn’t pay tax/NI if relevant).

If the contract isnt illegal then as @prh47bridge correctly says, I don’t think he will find it difficult to demonstrate that a contract exists.

If he has kept the rotas on WhatsApp, he should be able to demonstrate his hours worked - but without that, he’s effectively asking the employment tribunal to guess what he is owed, which they won’t be willing to do.

He should raise a formal grievance about his unpaid wages in the first instance and follow that procedure, although he might be able to get round that point.

Then there’s the added problem that even if he won, he’d probably never see the money if the company simply doesn’t have it. They will go bust and he will become just another unsecured creditor receiving pennies.

But yes, it’s theoretically possible to sue for lost wages and no, he wouldn’t meet the definition of a modern slave.

EsmeSusanOgg · 15/12/2022 18:39

You can report failure to pay minimum wage here - www.gov.uk/government/publications/pay-and-work-rights-complaints

Also worth calling Acas for advice.

2bazookas · 15/12/2022 18:35

I doubt your son will ever get paid; sounds like the owner is going bust

The business is on its knees . I'd call Environmental health and put it out of its misery.

prh47bridge · 15/12/2022 18:31

SD1978 · 15/12/2022 13:29

He's being getting paid (or not) off the books- with no proof of hours, tax, etc will be a hard one to follow up.

It really won't. As I've explained up thread, if he takes this to tribunal it will be a straightforward win.

csigeek · 15/12/2022 18:31

I would speak to ACAS as this is 100% illegal and a breach of NMW.

i suspect the employer doesn’t pay through a proper payroll to avoid tax and NI and any pension liability. Does your son even have a contract?

SD1978 · 15/12/2022 13:29

He's being getting paid (or not) off the books- with no proof of hours, tax, etc will be a hard one to follow up.

Snazzysausage · 15/12/2022 13:26

If after requesting wages owed it's clear he's not going to pay willingly, I would happily stand outside with a sign saying he owes £1000 in unpaid wages to my son,shame him, hopefully a local paper does an article which nudges him into paying. It's not illegal to stand peacefully outside. Your son has been exploited by this business owner and I wouldn't hesitate if all else fails.