Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

TA doesn’t like my child and made her really upset today.

442 replies

BelleandH · 14/12/2022 17:43

One of the TA’s quite obviously doesn’t like my child. I’ve had a feeling there is a problem for a while but it’s so difficult to approach firstly because she’s sligh about it and secondly because I don’t want her to treat my DD any worse.
I’ve witnessed it myself, the way she spoke to my daughter so abruptly and then to another child about the same thing straight after ina much kinder way. She avoids any eye contact with me, and will stand talking to other mothers for ages about their children (one in particular who’s children a far more trying than mine)
today it came to a head when she tried to wrestle her coat on and stormed her down the corridor to me - at this point my DD burst into tears.
I contacted the head who was straight away on the defence with his staff rather than listening to the facts.
DD is only 4, she is a lock down child from a shielding family so didn’t do any socialising from around 18 months. She’s not unruly but is strong willed. I’ve had so many compliments about her when she’s out with me so she’s not completely awful.

AIBU so put in a formal complaint about her?

OP posts:
mam0918 · 14/12/2022 22:04

PissedOffAmericanWoman · 14/12/2022 21:51

OP I would just move on as this thread had been derailed horribly and frankly all parties involved are behaving poorly. The people on this thread are being unfair to you. But you are also being very unfair to bring up aging, menopause and pension when talking about the TA. I can forgive you though because sometimes getting bullied brings out the worst in people. But the conversation only devolves from here. But even if you are a horrible human being, scum of the earth even, it is NEVER okay for an adult to bully a child to tears and you are a good mother for trying to protect her. Us parents need to protect are children no matter what. These parents are probably just projecting because they have also treated children badly because they can't control their temper and your post makes them feel guilty and defensive because they know they were wrong to do that.

but OP started out as a bully and has just doubled down on it.

OP is the one insulting her child classmates which has nothing to do with anything and she started that in her opening post.

The story here is:

OP doesnt agree with schoold
School have a rule that kids put on coats before leaving in cold weather
OP doesnt think HER child should follow rules
TA put childs coat on in line with rules
OP is mad her child cried because she has been taught not to follow rules

No one bullied a child to tears

Mydogatemypurse · 14/12/2022 22:04

MadameMackenzie · 14/12/2022 21:59

You've just made all that up and applied it to OP's DD, simply because she used the term "strong willed". You've decided that this means the child is badly behaved and ran away with it. Total fabrication

100% did not make it up ha 🤣 why would you make this up? But then why would you make up that the ta hates your child, strange isnt it.

MadameMackenzie · 14/12/2022 22:03

@Mydogatemypurse The ta did nothing wrong. You weren't even there! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

healthadvice123 · 14/12/2022 22:02

@MadameMackenzie well we only have what is written on here to go by and op hasn't covered herself in glory with her comments and has happily put down other peoples children.
Also posters who have sided have jumped on that the ta is awful and is a bully rtc etc on one side of a story and because the child was made to put her coat on before leaving to go outside in the freezing cold
But of you post on here you have to accept all answers good and bad and they won't always agree with the op

Doubtmyself · 14/12/2022 22:02

Gonna put my neck out here, any fucker can be a TA, my niece left Uni, rang an agency, paid for DBS and was in a classroom within a few weeks. No teaching experience, only a 2.1 from a high ranking Uni.

Hold your ground OP, if you feel there's an issue, don't let it go.

Mocara · 14/12/2022 22:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mydogatemypurse · 14/12/2022 22:01

MadameMackenzie · 14/12/2022 21:51

Just ignore them OP. They're mostly Teachers who feel they need to 'defend the profession'. Those of us who have witnessed TA's like this, we get you. We know you're telling the truth and that this is sadly, not uncommon.

Just completely ignore them Flowers

Ps, I'd consider a formal complaint in writing. If this is not handled sufficiently then complain to OFSTED.

Im absolutely not a teacher, i couldnt be further from it. Im a parent and have witnessed enabling fussy parenting like this and the detrimental impact it has on the class, staff and other pupils. The ta did nothing wrong.

healthadvice123 · 14/12/2022 21:59

@PissedOffAmericanWoman how did the ta bully the child to tears , she made her put her coat on ?

MadameMackenzie · 14/12/2022 21:59

Mydogatemypurse · 14/12/2022 21:56

In my experience parents who enable like this rear children who take time away from other pupils due to excessive classroom management, tantrums and babyish demands. The school are there to educate you are there to raise
In my oldests year, by the time they reached year 5 similar children to this had no friends and was feared and avoided, they turned into a bully because they expect to have their own way. Aside from the incident with the teacher, think about the future if they get their every whim and dont do what they are told.
Im all for spirited and genuinely strong willed children. But spoilt brats who are never challenged and enabled by parents make everyone elses life a misery.

You've just made all that up and applied it to OP's DD, simply because she used the term "strong willed". You've decided that this means the child is badly behaved and ran away with it. Total fabrication

BelleandH · 14/12/2022 21:59

first, this is based on the way she presented herself in front of me and another parent towards my child and it’s not the first time.

if DD is not being well behaved, I do expect her to be reprimanded in a kind, educational and respectful manner…she is 4. As she gets older, the goal post of expectation will change.

OP posts:
naturemumma · 14/12/2022 21:58

Does your daughter have any kind of sensory issues? Or any other sensitivities? My daughter has always been very “good” at school - I hate that phrase, but can’t think of a better one - and lives in terror of not doing exactly what the teachers say because she doesn’t want to get into trouble (which has caused its own issues, but that’s another story). But in reception she had a couple of incidences of getting very upset when a teaching assistant put a coat on her that she didn’t want to wear. They were quite frustrated with her because she was so upset and would usually always do what she was told. I only knew about it because they came to talk to me about how out of character it was. We never quite got to the bottom of what it was and she grew out of doing it, but I think it’s because she’s not mad about people touching her and I guess it all felt a bit much. Not sure…

Anyway, I can believe that a teaching assistant might roll their eyes because it makes their life more difficult, but it doesn’t necessarily mean they don’t like your child. I also think a child can not like having someone put a coat on them without being “naughty”. She’s only 4, it sounds like most 4 year olds to me.

That said, do you think the school are a bit touchy about your daughter going home earlier? And the homeschooling aspect? Is it a village school? Sometimes the relationships with parents can alter a lot simply because they know some of the parents very well and that can then seem like they’re treating your child differently. I do think things can sometimes seem a little different at small village schools (and I’m saying that with the experience of our children going to both very large, impersonal schools and small, village, everyone knows everyone schools). Things seem much more “professional” at a bigger school, though it’s hard to know if that means better.

I would agree with prior posters who say about being objective when you speak to the school though. It’s such a hard thing to do, but I do think it helps to get the best out of them. I think in the end you have to advocate for your child and do what you think is best.

I don’t know why, but it has surprised me quite how much vitriol there’s been on this thread. I hope you manage to get it sorted and your daughter is okay and enjoys school generally.

Mydogatemypurse · 14/12/2022 21:58

BelleandH · 14/12/2022 21:55

Thank you. I absolutely feel that most of these are teachers too or parents who are happy for their children to be abused on any level just to not have to deal with them.

I have made a formal complaint to which I’ve had a reply already; already refusing to take it as a formal complaint. This really speaks volumes already but I’m willing to listen to what the Heads solution is if he will not act upon a formal complaint.

Although this can be a stressful time of year due ti how busy it is, it’s also a really joyful time of year so why can’t people just have fun at the end of term.

It does speak volumes, I agree.

MadameMackenzie · 14/12/2022 21:57

@Hobbi Laugh all you like but the fact that you can laugh at a 4yr old being abused, says more about you than it does about me Hmm

Mydogatemypurse · 14/12/2022 21:56

In my experience parents who enable like this rear children who take time away from other pupils due to excessive classroom management, tantrums and babyish demands. The school are there to educate you are there to raise
In my oldests year, by the time they reached year 5 similar children to this had no friends and was feared and avoided, they turned into a bully because they expect to have their own way. Aside from the incident with the teacher, think about the future if they get their every whim and dont do what they are told.
Im all for spirited and genuinely strong willed children. But spoilt brats who are never challenged and enabled by parents make everyone elses life a misery.

Hobbi · 14/12/2022 21:55

"Ps, I'd consider a formal complaint in writing. If this is not handled sufficiently then complain to OFSTED."

Ooh, yes, please report this event to Ofsted. Let us know how you get on. 😂

BelleandH · 14/12/2022 21:55

Thank you. I absolutely feel that most of these are teachers too or parents who are happy for their children to be abused on any level just to not have to deal with them.

I have made a formal complaint to which I’ve had a reply already; already refusing to take it as a formal complaint. This really speaks volumes already but I’m willing to listen to what the Heads solution is if he will not act upon a formal complaint.

Although this can be a stressful time of year due ti how busy it is, it’s also a really joyful time of year so why can’t people just have fun at the end of term.

OP posts:
pleasehelpwi3 · 14/12/2022 21:53

BelleandH · 14/12/2022 18:20

My child certainly isn’t a robot, she won’t be told by a grumpy adult and respond. However, she will be spoken to like a four year old should and then always does as she’s told. She stood in a long queue having a lovely conversation with a polite and friendly adult just yesterday.

The problem seems that the TA isn’t happy in her job and she’s letting affect the way she treats the children.
I do t think that my child is the only one but what is clear from this thread is that there a far more parents willing to turn a blind eye to bad treatment of their children for a quite life!!

As a primary school teacher and a parent, I am astonished that you can arrive at that judgment based on the say so of a four year old. It's irrelevant that your child can behave well if she's the centre of attention and talking to a family friend out of school. By all means listen to your child, but realise that based on your posts on this thread it is likely you are wrong about your judgements. Adults who work in schools are allowed to tell children off you know.

MadameMackenzie · 14/12/2022 21:53

@PissedOffAmericanWoman Well said! 👏🏻

Wannago · 14/12/2022 21:52

The very difficult problem we have is that it is sometimes so hard to unravel the rights and wrongs in these situations.
But I do think it is important to remember that while some people go into teaching (or being a TA) for the best of reasons and love children, some do it for other reasons. Miss Trunchbull resonates for so many people because most of us encountered at least one mini Miss Trunchbull at school, as well as hopefully at leat one Miss Honey.

Once upon a time not that long ago I would tell my DC that if they were lost, they should trust a policeman. I am not sure I feel confident telling my DDs that anymore, and certainly I know that people who are black often don't. Because some of the revelations that have been coming out recently are horrific. Does that mean that many, if not most, policemen do not go into it to serve the community and support the law? I don't think that either. But once upon a time people would dismiss anybody describing police misbehaviour (and the bad apples know it - "who is going to believe you?"). It is now clear that some policemen go into policing because of the power that it gives them over others, and their relative immunity. And, I am afraid, the same has to be said for teachers and TAs. Many, many go into it because they love children and want the best for them and do their very best for a pittance. But there are definitely some there because it is a way of having power and control over the vulnerable in a way that nowhere else affords, as nobody is as vulnerable as a child. And working out the rights and wrongs in these situations is very hard, just as it is with the police. But the instincts of any institution is going to be to dismiss it, regardless of whether it is serious or relatively trivial, and try and push it under the carpet, because it is the last think that they want to be dealing with when they are actually trying to run a police force or a school so they just want any such allegations to go away, and thus they try and make them go away, unless and until they are absolutely forced to confront or investigate them. When the DC is older one can have a discussion with the DC and the two of you can decide whether it is something that the DC feels they can put up with and they prefer that to the extra problems that will come with reporting (just as a woman can and often does decide not to report sexual assult to the police as she doesn't want the consequences of an investigation), and you can support them and believe them without necessarily doing anything. At four that is difficult, and you have to make the decision more on your own (although your four year old might have a view, I think it is worth talking to them). I personally think in this circumstance I would watch and wait, but that doesn't mean that your observations are not valid and your instincts not right.

BelleandH · 14/12/2022 21:52

Unfortunately children are always going to be said to have read the situation wrong or that they are lying because it’s easier than dealing with the complaints process and someone who is bad at their job. It’s easier to keep rubbish staff than recruit new ones.

I get the impression that she is quite a bully in general, even towards the teacher who is young but because the TA has been there so long, she has the upper hand and also because of what I have said above.

OP posts:
MadameMackenzie · 14/12/2022 21:51

BelleandH · 14/12/2022 21:46

Examples of my responses to other posts!

Just ignore them OP. They're mostly Teachers who feel they need to 'defend the profession'. Those of us who have witnessed TA's like this, we get you. We know you're telling the truth and that this is sadly, not uncommon.

Just completely ignore them Flowers

Ps, I'd consider a formal complaint in writing. If this is not handled sufficiently then complain to OFSTED.

PissedOffAmericanWoman · 14/12/2022 21:51

BelleandH · 14/12/2022 21:45

Why should I take my child out of school whilst she’s generally happy, has friends, is doing well in all areas, has an amazing teacher just because of one person who can’t be kind and respectful to a 4 year old little girl.

OP I would just move on as this thread had been derailed horribly and frankly all parties involved are behaving poorly. The people on this thread are being unfair to you. But you are also being very unfair to bring up aging, menopause and pension when talking about the TA. I can forgive you though because sometimes getting bullied brings out the worst in people. But the conversation only devolves from here. But even if you are a horrible human being, scum of the earth even, it is NEVER okay for an adult to bully a child to tears and you are a good mother for trying to protect her. Us parents need to protect are children no matter what. These parents are probably just projecting because they have also treated children badly because they can't control their temper and your post makes them feel guilty and defensive because they know they were wrong to do that.

EmmaDilemma5 · 14/12/2022 21:50

thewayround · 14/12/2022 17:46

I highly doubt she dislikes your child.

She may well be a poor TA though

What makes you say that?

I work in a school and our reception class teacher has openly said a few students she "doesn't like". I think it's awful, but it happens. And I'm pretty sure it will affect how they're treated, I think that's pretty inevitable if you don't like someone.

ancientgran · 14/12/2022 21:50

Pumperthepumper · 14/12/2022 20:22

I’m a teacher. I don’t do it for the love of children, I do it for money and holidays.

I admire your honesty. I don't think I know anyone who would go to work if they weren't getting paid. I suppose there might be some and I hope people can find work they enjoy but we need to be realistic and accept that TAs, teachers and nurses are human and although as professionals most of them do a good job some of them aren't great, I'm sure you've met some.

donttellmehesalive · 14/12/2022 21:49

"Go to see the Headteacher and speak to them in a calm, polite manner and give the full facts. Make sure you put it in writing too. "

What full facts? That the TA once spoke to her in an abrupt way and today tried to get her into her coat?

School staff are allowed to be human. Their patience is not limitless. There is nothing here worthy of a complaint which is why op got nowhere with the head.