Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry and upset to receive Christmas Cards?

304 replies

Evanted76 · 14/12/2022 16:28

My 24yr old son brutally took his life just before Xmas three years ago.

As you can imagine, we have all (me, DH and DS2) been a mess. We have all been diagnosed with PTSD and major depression. Both me and DS2 have been receiving trauma bereavement counselling.

We are now at a place where the pain is softening and I have a mixture of good and bad days. However, as you can imagine, Christmas, is hard. Very hard. We have the double whammy of it being Xmas plus the awful anniversary of our eldest son's suicide.

Despite this, my in laws (he has two sets of parents as his Mum and Dad divorced and remarried years ago) insist on sending us, and my own parents (who are still very much affected by their grandson's shocking death) Xmas cards! Even the first year, we received a card from them telling us to Have a Wonderful Xmas and Happy New Year! At the time, our living room was still filled with sympathy cards!! and enough flowers to make a florist jealous!

I've just been binning any cards that have been pushed through by neighbours and acquaintances who don't know what happened to us (we moved not long after he died) but I've just angrily binned another card from my father in law and step mother in law. I've told DH to have a word with his family as it hurts. He said he didnt want to as he doesnt want to upset them and told me just to throw them away. Surely they should understand its inappropriate? AIBU?

OP posts:
ComfortablyDazed · 14/12/2022 23:21

I really hope people can stop comparing the loss of a parent with the loss of a child. It is not even in the same ballpark.

I say this as someone who lost both parents relatively young.

Evanted76 · 14/12/2022 23:18

ancientgran · 14/12/2022 23:02

Her husband has also lost a child, is he allowed to grieve in his own way? He might like getting Christmas cards, he might find it too difficult to raise it with his father but whatever the reason his feelings should also be respected.

It can be hard to reconcile everyone's needs, if the husband wants the cards maybe he could have them somewhere that won't upset the OP, his office, his garage or whatever. Personally I would be very upset if my husband decided to throw away something my family sent me.

My DH doesn't care one bit about Xmas Cards. We have only put our Xmas tree up because I suggested it and said it would be a nice thing to do in honour of our son. Otherwise we wouldn't have any decorations up at all.

He doesn't like having awkward conversations involving our grief with his dad. At the end of a gruelling inquest, he tried to talk to his Dad on the phone about things when asked "how is everyone?" When DH answered "actually Dad things are shit right now" his Dad promptly changed the subject and started talking about the weather.

OP posts:
ComfortablyDazed · 14/12/2022 23:17

I’m so sorry for your loss, OP - it is unimaginable. 🕯️🤍 for your son.

YANBU - of course you’re not.

In the interests of helping you feel less ill-will towards your DH’s family, it could be a case of them thinking they’re genuinely doing the right thing, and that - to them - not sending a card would be unimaginable, as they need to know you’re in their thoughts.

It is so often the case that people don’t always know what a grieving person wants or needs, and the risk of getting it wrong is high.

There will be other families out there who’ve experienced (similar) loss, who would absolutely hate the Christmas cards to suddenly stop. This would be incredibly hurtful to them, as they’re left thinking people don’t care, or worse, just want to distance themselves from them.

The point is though, that receiving cards is incredibly hurtful for you. So you, or your DH, are well within your rights to politely ask family members to simply stop.

I don’t understand why your DH can’t say to his parents that he acknowledges the thought behind the cards, that he knows they’re sent with love and care, but that they’re a very painful reminder of what you’ve lost, and as such you’d be very grateful if they could stop sending cards at Christmas. It’s a small ask, and one that you would hope - given how much you know they love you all - they would be happy to accommodate.

I can’t understand why anyone would have an issue saying this to family.

Because anyone who - on hearing that - would default to defensive anger ahead of the grieving person’s simple wishes - is not someone whose feelings even need to be considered. Flowers

Livelovebehappy · 14/12/2022 23:15

I lost my father on Xmas day a few years ago. I never thought bad of anyone for sending me Xmas cards etc on subsequent Christmas’s. Never gave it a thought. Yes, I still have a sad moment on Christmas Day, but I don’t expect others to second guess what is appropriate. I think people are probably thinking of what you might be going through, and just want to show that they care. It must still be very raw for you OP, but please just accept the cards graciously, knowing that they’re coming from a place of good.

dontknowwhatisbest · 14/12/2022 23:09

My god OP, I am so very sorry for the loss of your son. For what it's worth, I don't think you are being even the tiniest bit unreasonable. A typical Christmas card from such a close family member is just unbelievably thoughtless.

MrsSkylerWhite · 14/12/2022 23:07

So very sorry for your loss.

healthadvice123 · 14/12/2022 23:05

Have you asked them not to ?

ancientgran · 14/12/2022 23:02

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/12/2022 21:01

What a devastating, unimaginable loss. I'm so very sorry, OP.

You are entitled to feel as you feel. It doesn't matter if the cards are well-meaning; what matters is their effect. They are emphasising the usual joy and sentimentality of Christmas with no acknowledgement of what a painful time this is to the bereaved, especially those whose losses are so shocking and so recent.

Christmas is a hard time for many; for you the pain must be almost unendurable. And whilst people can't claim to understand how this feels, it doesn't take a great deal of imagination, empathy or tact to comprehend that bulldozing on as though it never happened isn't perhaps the ideal response. A simple 'thinking of you' card, with a sincere message that they are there for you (and mean it) would likely cut a great deal less. It's the complete lack of any thought that must hurt.

I think your husband needs to talk to them. Needless to say I am not with the numerous 'gentle' YABUs. No one can walk this path for you, or know how you need to grieve, and this isn't something at all helpful for you to hear.

YANBU. I hope you get through this incredibly tough season, one day at a time, and find some form of peace. 💐💐💐💐

Her husband has also lost a child, is he allowed to grieve in his own way? He might like getting Christmas cards, he might find it too difficult to raise it with his father but whatever the reason his feelings should also be respected.

It can be hard to reconcile everyone's needs, if the husband wants the cards maybe he could have them somewhere that won't upset the OP, his office, his garage or whatever. Personally I would be very upset if my husband decided to throw away something my family sent me.

Evanted76 · 14/12/2022 23:01

Opaljewel · 14/12/2022 18:43

I understand your loss. It's not one many understand.

My brother committed suicide at 24 when I was 18. He did it on the early jan so just after Christmas. I remember thinking selfishly, I am so glad he didn't do on Christmas as it would have forever ruined it for us. Apparently he did try before Christmas and never succeeded then.

Christmas is a stark reminder of all things families and is a very stark reminder that yours will never be the same again.

Time stops for us and everyone else seems to be moving on normally like nothing has happened. How can they live their normal lives when ours has been rocked to the core.

We too spent years in a frozen state. Eventually we started to thaw out as the years went on.

Suicide is one those topics that no one knows what to say to you on. Suicide leaves you with more questions than answers.

We all ended up with ptsd afterwards. My mum is having a bad patch currently and is having therapy again. You never get over losing your child. No parent should bury their child.

Bu in the midst of that, when these people don't know what to do, they just try to do what they've always done. They've sent cards because they want you to know they are thinking of you kindly. Not to poke you where it Huts as a stark reminder of your horrific loss.

Those cards represent to you what you've lost and how Christmas will never be the same again without your son.

It's true it won't but as the years gone by and I am now in my 30s, they are different but i can enjoy Christmas again. You will too one day even if it feels impossible right now.

Remember they will never know how it feels to be a survior of someone's suicide. Let us be glad they do not. A part of us died that day with them and we buried it with them.

You have my full heart felt sympathy. If you need to talk to someone who understands My inbox is open.

Again I am truly sorry for your loss.

Thank you for your kind words. I'm so sorry about your brother.

OP posts:
Evanted76 · 14/12/2022 22:57

Georgina125 · 14/12/2022 19:46

Sorry, sent too soon.

I've lost 2 children, albeit under different circumstances, and I hate Christmas. It's so fake and commercialised and forced on those who just can't feel it. I communicate my wishes very openly yet still get cards because apparently I can't "not do Christmas". I tried a different tact and said people could at least acknowledge my sons names "Thinking of X and Y at Christmas". Not a single person can even manage that! They are so caught up in "the spirit of Christmas" that they can't consider my feelings. They simply HAVE to send a card but the subject of my children is too sad to include. So I bin the cards and ignore the whole thing. I'm not stopping anyone else doing it so it annoys the hell out of me that people can't leave me be.

I'm so sorry for your losses. I can't imagine your pain as losing one son has nearly broken me.

OP posts:
Evanted76 · 14/12/2022 22:53

Theydoyaknow · 14/12/2022 19:35

I cannot even begin to understand the pain of losing a child to suicide. When I close my eyes and even try to imagine it my mind can't even go there. To lose him at Christmas time aswell is just heartbreaking. I can totally understand you hating the happy clappy, Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays, Joyous Noel cards plopping on your mat. I would feel like ripping them up into tiny little pieces and fucking them in the bin. YANBU OP, my heart goes out to you. Christmas time has changed forever in your house and how people can be so insensitive to that is beyond me no matter how well meaning they are. It's really disrespectful.

Thank you for your reply.

OP posts:
Evanted76 · 14/12/2022 22:52

gogohmm · 14/12/2022 21:53

Another yabu, unless you have explicitly said never to send a card people do not know your thoughts. Unfortunately bad things happen at Christmas to many people, some would be offended by friends NOT sending Christmas cards.

I'm so sorry for your loss but remember people cannot know how you feel

I don't understand your reply at all. None of what you have written relates to my situation. I am not talking about friends sending Xmas cards, but grandparents who are considered close family members. And also lost a grandson. And "bad things happen to many people at Xmas" seriously??

OP posts:
Ch3wylemon · 14/12/2022 22:08

YANBU - I often say that you can't grieve wrong, you can only do it your way. I'm sorry about your DS.

I don't think it's unreasonable for your DH to ask people not to send them - perhaps he could ask them to make a donation to a charity to remember your DS.

Wishing you peace.

DesertIslandCondiment · 14/12/2022 22:00

It is heartbreaking to recieve Christnas cards with all the families names on apart from the one who has died recently. Especially when it is a child or young adult.

KateofGhent · 14/12/2022 22:00

I'm so sorry for what you are still going through. Haven't read the full thread, but I have bought cards last Christmas for bereaved people with "Thinking of you at Christmas" and any families in similar circumstances are often remembered in Christmas church services and prayers.
I sincerely hope that the pain will ease in years to come.

gogohmm · 14/12/2022 21:56

Also remember 3 years on people do differ on how they want others to be with them - one of my good friends doesn't like people to bring up his son's name apart from on set days, whereas I know a lady who like you to talk about her dd. I want to be kind and empathetic to everyone but because we are all different it can be hard to get it right

gogohmm · 14/12/2022 21:53

Another yabu, unless you have explicitly said never to send a card people do not know your thoughts. Unfortunately bad things happen at Christmas to many people, some would be offended by friends NOT sending Christmas cards.

I'm so sorry for your loss but remember people cannot know how you feel

abblie · 14/12/2022 21:50

Are they your sons grandparents also?? People deal with grief differently especially at Christmas, some try and keep it normal and some just forget it all together and try to avoid it but unless you say to people thank you for thinking of us but I would appreciate no cards at Christmas you can't really blame them. I've also lost a child at Christmas is so difficult and I know family and friends don't know what to do or send xx sorry about your son xx

DeepDown12 · 14/12/2022 21:45

I am so very sorry for your loss and I completely understand that pain is still very raw and strong...

As far as I am concerned YANBU. You are not complaining about acquaintances/friends/neighbours who don't know what happened or do not understand the full extent of your trauma. You're talking about family members who should know better. I would never, in a thousand years, send 'happy Christmas' message to someone who suffered a loss or had a life altering (negatively) event near the holidays. It is not really rocket science, is it?!

Sakura7 · 14/12/2022 21:35

I think the people saying YABU are answering the question of whether it's reasonable to be angry with people for sending Christmas cards.

Of course it's reasonable to grieve however you need to grieve, and if the cards upset you that's a valid feeling. I think you should let people know it's a trigger for you, or just let your DH deal with the post during this time.

I'm very sorry for your loss.

iklboo · 14/12/2022 21:34

@Evanted76 - I would like to sincerely apologise. On reflection you are NOT being unreasonable and the people around you should think and respect you. I'm so sorry.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/12/2022 21:01

What a devastating, unimaginable loss. I'm so very sorry, OP.

You are entitled to feel as you feel. It doesn't matter if the cards are well-meaning; what matters is their effect. They are emphasising the usual joy and sentimentality of Christmas with no acknowledgement of what a painful time this is to the bereaved, especially those whose losses are so shocking and so recent.

Christmas is a hard time for many; for you the pain must be almost unendurable. And whilst people can't claim to understand how this feels, it doesn't take a great deal of imagination, empathy or tact to comprehend that bulldozing on as though it never happened isn't perhaps the ideal response. A simple 'thinking of you' card, with a sincere message that they are there for you (and mean it) would likely cut a great deal less. It's the complete lack of any thought that must hurt.

I think your husband needs to talk to them. Needless to say I am not with the numerous 'gentle' YABUs. No one can walk this path for you, or know how you need to grieve, and this isn't something at all helpful for you to hear.

YANBU. I hope you get through this incredibly tough season, one day at a time, and find some form of peace. 💐💐💐💐

ihatesoaps · 14/12/2022 20:56

No
I agree with the OP
People sending cards could be saying we wish you a peaceful
Christmas and just to say we are thinking of you at this sad time!

What has happened to sympathy?

Vallmo47 · 14/12/2022 20:50

I am so very sorry OP.

Having read your updates about these people, they are not the sort I’d maintain a relationship with. They clearly aren’t thinking about you at all. I would likely not approach them about it now, if anything I would mention in the height of summer that you do not send or wish to receive Christmas cards because it’s such an awful time for you, hope they understand and you won’t be offended at all if they send them to everyone else but you. I have family members who say it’s Beyond rude to send Christmas cards to SOME but not ALL people you know. So opting to tell everyone you’re not doing it full stop, at a non festive time, seems to be the way forward.

Sending love ❤️

user1471507930 · 14/12/2022 20:48

UsingChangeofName · 14/12/2022 20:28

My heart goes out to you. An awful thing to live with, when a loved one takes their own life. I know from experience.
That said, in the gentlest way possible, I agree with most that YABU. I get it. The 'anger stage of grieving' probably stays longer in these circumstances, and you are hitting out, but it really isn't the fault of the people sending cards, and hoping you can gradually begin to find a way to get through this time of year again.
I agree with the poster who said that people often don't know how to respond to a bereavement, and more so when it is a suicide and also when it is a young person. So many people feel so alone after a bereavement because others stop including them and avoid speaking to them and spending time with them. Whatever people do it is likely to be wrong in your eyes as - quite understandably - you are angry with the world.

Trying not to sound like I'm picking on your post , but just to say that the popularised 5 stages of grief aren't actually that at all and were originally 5 stages of coming to terms with dying and then popularised as grief stages and rarely fit - take it from one who has done extensive grief counselling-one may never truly ' accept ' but will learn to live.
I don't agree that op should have to accept those cards because the sender can't engage themselves in a small semblance of empathy. The fact that people cannot deal with their own discomfort about the death of her son is , quite frankly, not her problem- she has enough of her own problems. I hate this mantra of 'oh but they mean well' so we should put on the mask and just blindly accept - no sorry people need to do better.
How alone do you think it makes her feel when people just disregard the most devastating major event in her life? That she has to pretend everything is grand to her actual family to save their feelings?
Not just picking on you because so many said it but I really think this is a sad thread to show the deep misunderstanding of child loss and its devastating effects.