Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect gift lists to be followed?

136 replies

areweungrateful · 14/12/2022 15:54

My DH and I have one DC, who is 3 months old. We have an issue with one set of GPs buying inappropriate/ unwanted gifts. This isn’t just for DC, but us as well… think things like buying a height adjustable stand up desk when the office room is in the attic and has sloping ceilings.

As they have form for this, we made a list for Christmas presents for DC, split it and circulated it to those who wanted to buy, making sure there were a variety of options and price points. GPs have gone out and bought something outside of the list we gave to their side of the family, and is actually something we know someone else has already bought, but a brand/type that we looked at and decided we didn’t want due to reviews/ possible safety issues.

How do we manage this moving forward! Neither DH or I want to appear ungrateful when we receive these things that we just don’t want or need, as we do appreciate they would like to gift us things, nor do we want the confrontation of asking them to return it and get something else. Do we just regift/ sell things on? But then they’ll probably notice when they come to visit.

Are we being unreasonable to expect people to use the lists given to buy presents from?

OP posts:
custardbear · 15/12/2022 17:17

I don't bother these days as I've put specific things like a nice wash bag I'd never buy myself (about &25), only to receive a bumper bag of cheap wash bags of all sorts of sizes and was told they'd found these instead of the one I wanted as they liked them and there were loads for all sorts of occasions 🤯 I also suggested a perfume as easy to buy and not too pricey (albeit they're millionaires) to get fingerless gloves so I didn't have to turn the heating on when WFH .... from the shop next door to Boots 😳
Hey ho so I make suggestions now and don't give the asked for list

Sceptre86 · 15/12/2022 17:09

I have similar issues and I just regift or donate to charity. There isn't really a way in which to have the conversation without someone getting offended. I've tried to explain that we want to limit the amount of stuff we have but it falls on deaf ears. My mum would rather big a cheaper version of what I have suggested and then get extra stuff. How many times can you say its not the quantity that matters? Yanbu!

Stomacharmeleon · 15/12/2022 16:47

I agree it's the title... I feel mean now so apologise. Could you not explain to your parents why you would like the particular car seat?

areweungrateful · 15/12/2022 12:34

@pompomsandtinsel I think @RunDownRita is right. The title isn’t great, but I spent ages trying to think of another way to word it and couldn’t! I also spent ages trying to put all the right details in to the post as I’ve seen other posters get torn apart for missing a detail or for a particular choice of word. I obviously didn’t do very well! 🤣

I did however get some great ideas, and will be keeping stuff at my parents house moving forward as we’ve not the space for it or if it’s duplicate. The gift of child free time via babysitting is also ideal. I also spoke to someone in real life about it, who suggested that we ask GPs to considering gifting their time to DC as they get older in things like a trip to the park, petting zoo or little local aquarium, which I think is a super nice idea and hopefully will work to reduce the off piste gifts and waste!

FWIW, both sides of the family are gift list users; and years ago when I didn’t give my mum a birthday list I didn’t get anything at all! 🤣 so I don’t know what’s changed so much over the last couple of years, so I suppose I’m very surprised about the lack of list following as well!

OP posts:
RunDownRita · 15/12/2022 12:00

I think OP maybe put people's backs up with a poorly chosen title.

OP, I do understand the frustration of people asking what you would like then ignoring what you say. My mother does this- she even says specifically "I will be getting item X" then gets something different, which is annoying when you have lots of people asking for suggestions who might have actually bought X.

She also has a tendency to get something a bit like the thing- so teenage DD asked for a Tshirt of a band she likes, DM said she'd happily buy her it, then bought a Tshirt of a completely different band on the basis that she (DM) doesn't like the first band. So lucky DD now has a Tshirt with a picture of a band her 65yr old grandmother likes, that she has never heard of

pompomsandtinsel · 15/12/2022 11:41

I honestly don't know why people are having ago at you here OP.

We have family who ask what to get our kids, we make a text message list of suggestions for them choose from including book vouchers and the NEVER EVER buy what we've asked for yet ask again at the next birthday and next Christmas. What's the point of asking!?

We always buy what they ask for and more.

areweungrateful · 15/12/2022 10:47

People just love to make assumptions don’t they!

We didn’t have a wedding list, because we eloped as couldn’t afford a big wedding and didn’t want to have to make the decisions to leave any of our large extended family members out.

A PP was right; it’s a follow on car seat. Someone on DH’s side said they wanted to help us out with a big ticket item as DH was made redundant the week DC was born and we’ve been struggling to put money aside to get it when the time comes to move out of the current seat. And why wouldn’t we want to try and get the best version available that we possibly can.

And it’s actually my parents, so not another in laws thread, but I didn’t think that was in any way relevant.

I’m glad so many of you have big houses to store loads of things you don’t use as well as pots of gold to sit on that you can afford to throw unwanted gifts in the bin - and we’re talking about being ungrateful! What a suggestion. Just what the planet needs, more wasteful stuff going to landfill.

And of course I’ve replied to the people who “agree”, as they’re the ones who have actually made helpful suggestions instead of name calling 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 15/12/2022 10:42

StaceySolomonSwash · 15/12/2022 10:15

We don't do Christmas but omg! How entitled are you @areweungrateful to expect presents to the extent that you give a shopping list to the potential givers? Wow.

I'm astounded that anyone could be so ill mannered as to do this! SMH.

They asked for the list.

Moonlightsonatas · 15/12/2022 10:30

My family has always done wishlists, you’re allowed to be annoyed but you should accept the gifts and thank them graciously.

People always think they are better at gift buying than they actually are. It’s annoying and wasteful but they won’t change.

boredOf · 15/12/2022 10:23

PFB 🤔

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 15/12/2022 10:19

Just because a list is requested doesn't mean they are obliged to stick to it.

It's not a merchandise order.

If generosity is so troubling, just make a standing request for books to build the child's library.

paintitallover · 15/12/2022 10:18

You are stupendously entitled, judging by the thread title alone.

StaceySolomonSwash · 15/12/2022 10:15

We don't do Christmas but omg! How entitled are you @areweungrateful to expect presents to the extent that you give a shopping list to the potential givers? Wow.

I'm astounded that anyone could be so ill mannered as to do this! SMH.

AdobeWanKenobi · 15/12/2022 10:07

Hugasauras · 14/12/2022 16:04

Also I'm a bit agog at a gift list for a 3mo! DD2 is 6mo and is getting some hand puppets and that's it! Grin

I’m a bit agog that you’re agog at grandparents and aunts and uncles etc wanting to buy gifts for a baby’s first Christmas.

there is great tendency to gift clothing and noisy plastic crap to babies of OPs child’s age. Child probably has a mountain of clothes to grow into already and plenty of stimulating toys so telling family exactly what the child would benefit from seems eminently sensible to me.

Stomacharmeleon · 15/12/2022 09:59

I don't think the list is a bad idea in general as people do ask.
But your post comes across as somewhat uptight.... especially the twee ' it's not a brand we find acceptable'
Some relatives do buy plastic crap or deviate from the list just smile and donate or recycle in some way.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/12/2022 09:49

A gift list for a 3mo 😂😂😂

Handle it moving forward by being a bit less precious and uptight - if someone goes off piste then so what.

I will never get over this MN trend of FURY over family buying children presents.

Baaaaaa · 15/12/2022 09:47

But to answer the AIBU, I think gift lists are perfectly fine and not unreasonable, they reduce waste and help if people if they are short on inspiration, but it is unreasonable to get annoyed that someone doesn't stick to it. It's suggestions.

Baaaaaa · 15/12/2022 09:39

areweungrateful · 14/12/2022 16:30

Hahaha. We’re not ungrateful at all! Some of you are having bad days! Thanks for all the nasty comments though, super helpful 🤦‍♀️

Yes, the list was asked for on this occasion - by both sets of GPs as well as more extended family. In fact we are often asked if there are things we want/ need when birthdays or other festivities come around. Being asked for a list was why we made it and gave it out. We don’t just have huge wish lists of stuff for either the baby or ourselves!

The only reason we wanted this particular item to be specific is due to the safety aspect of it. The rest of the list was as a PP said, stackable blocks, sensory toys, bath toys, soft books etc etc.

To everyone who has given actual advice, thank you.

But this is AIBU.

You asked, they told you.

Much like that Christmas list.

FrownedUpon · 15/12/2022 09:38

You sound crazy & self absorbed. Perhaps just ask for them to donate money to charity instead.

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 15/12/2022 09:37

Yanbu the whole point of a list is to avoid duplicates and wastes of money.
If your a child there is nothing exciting about opening a duplicate or a toy you've already got.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 15/12/2022 09:24

I love a passive aggressive OP with absolutely no self-awareness. It must be a lot less entertaining when you know them in real life though.

CousinKrispy · 15/12/2022 09:02

The reality is that you can't control what people do. I love a wishlist myself, but some people find them really off-putting and want to choose their own gift and that's just the way they are.

Just give the item to charity or resell (or if it's a duplicate, tell them it needs to stay at their house for visits or else ask if they have receipts for a return).

Eventually they might notice that their gifts aren't in use at your house and try following the list!

catsandkid · 15/12/2022 08:47

.... And I'm having a good day, thank you

catsandkid · 15/12/2022 08:46

I get that duplicate pressies are annoying, but if this ever happens we just say that one can be kept at Grandma's and the other at ours. It actually worked out well as the DCs now have a nice selection of toys (that we know they love to play with) at Grandma's to keep them busy when we visit.

I might be an outlier here... but I hate gift lists. My cousins are similar to you and present the gift list for their kids that we MUST buy from for birthdays/xmas and it just winds me up. I quite enjoy gift giving and love thinking about what people might want and finding different cute gifts for them (stuff they'll use, but may not have thought about..... I'm not talking a bog basic smellies set) so it kind of sucks all the fun and point out of gift giving for me and it all becomes very transactional.

FWIW.... a gift list for a 3mo seems bloody bonkers! They can barely hold thier heads up at that age and for the next year will likely prefer to play with a spatula from the kitchen and a bog roll instead of all the wonderful toys they have!

imnottoofussed · 15/12/2022 08:42

I have this with my family. I'll say to one family member what sort of thing might they like and he sends me a list of actual items that I can choose from. Another family member would say barbie dolls and not tell me a specific one. I much prefer to choose my own present once I know the type of thing than to be given a list of selected items.