Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect gift lists to be followed?

136 replies

areweungrateful · 14/12/2022 15:54

My DH and I have one DC, who is 3 months old. We have an issue with one set of GPs buying inappropriate/ unwanted gifts. This isn’t just for DC, but us as well… think things like buying a height adjustable stand up desk when the office room is in the attic and has sloping ceilings.

As they have form for this, we made a list for Christmas presents for DC, split it and circulated it to those who wanted to buy, making sure there were a variety of options and price points. GPs have gone out and bought something outside of the list we gave to their side of the family, and is actually something we know someone else has already bought, but a brand/type that we looked at and decided we didn’t want due to reviews/ possible safety issues.

How do we manage this moving forward! Neither DH or I want to appear ungrateful when we receive these things that we just don’t want or need, as we do appreciate they would like to gift us things, nor do we want the confrontation of asking them to return it and get something else. Do we just regift/ sell things on? But then they’ll probably notice when they come to visit.

Are we being unreasonable to expect people to use the lists given to buy presents from?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChildcareIsBroken · 20/12/2022 17:24

strawberrysea · 20/12/2022 14:20

My SIL gives me a gift list every year for birthdays and Christmas for her two DC and always has done since their births. Never followed it, never will. I buy age appropriate gifts that I'm confident that no one else will think to get. It really rubs me the wrong way.

But why? Isn't it better to give something that they'll enjoy rather than something that probably will be regifted and possibly will end up in the landfill. If you refuse to follow a list at least give things like experiences which are environmentally friendly.

AdobeWanKenobi · 20/12/2022 16:42

lynthesearesexpeople · 20/12/2022 16:18

But why, if the child would really love something on the list?

You might buy something they don’t like and will never used and they will have missed out on something they would have enjoyed more.

Weird isn't it?
Gift probably ends up in the charity pile year in year out.

lynthesearesexpeople · 20/12/2022 16:18

strawberrysea · 20/12/2022 14:20

My SIL gives me a gift list every year for birthdays and Christmas for her two DC and always has done since their births. Never followed it, never will. I buy age appropriate gifts that I'm confident that no one else will think to get. It really rubs me the wrong way.

But why, if the child would really love something on the list?

You might buy something they don’t like and will never used and they will have missed out on something they would have enjoyed more.

BaileySharp · 20/12/2022 15:32

Ha I have in laws that know we keep an amazon list for DD and sometimes following sometime don't. They've already told us they haven't for Christmas and DD will be getting something that is basically a duplicate to something she already has (same toy different character theming). It's mildly annoying but I'd rather keep the peace and its nice they want to get her presents so I'll be polite and thankful and I guess move one of the similar toys on. I know DD would rather have something on the list though, she's 4 and old enough to ask for some things!

Saxiee · 20/12/2022 15:27

We get asked if there is anything specific DD would like and also for ideas. I just said "art and crafts" this year for Christmas and also a very specific thing for her birthday which GPs will get. We don't want lots of things that song be used filling up space.

That's what me and my partner do also. We send pictures/screenshots of about 10-15 things that we would like and then we buy each other a few things from that list and a few surprises too

LolaSmiles · 20/12/2022 14:56

YANBU Much as I find having a range of lists for a young baby a bit 🙄, if they've asked for a list and then have ignored it then and it's part of a long standing habit to give inappropriate gifts, then it's understandable that you're frustrated.

I doubt you'd have the same response if they were usually very thoughtful and this time they've gone off the list with good intentions and it happens to be something you've got safety concerns over.

Duplocrocs · 20/12/2022 14:50

Say thank you, smile and give to your next pal who has a baby!

Stressfordays · 20/12/2022 14:24

I've never made a specific list but if someone asks, I usually just give a few ideas. For example 'dc1+2 are into football so something like goalie gloves/shin pads/new ball would be good and dc3 loves anything barbie or lol dolls'

Some of my family send me the cash and tell me to get it and wrap it up from them which tbh, I much prefer 🤣

strawberrysea · 20/12/2022 14:20

Yerroblemom1923 · 15/12/2022 07:55

A 3 month baby with a list?! Wow. Bet you guys had a wedding list too didn't you.....?🙄

My SIL gives me a gift list every year for birthdays and Christmas for her two DC and always has done since their births. Never followed it, never will. I buy age appropriate gifts that I'm confident that no one else will think to get. It really rubs me the wrong way.

lynthesearesexpeople · 20/12/2022 14:11

My PIL do this.

They ask for one thing the children want for around £30 each. Which is great. Only, they won’t wrap it and begrudgingly buy it, usually telling us that it’s a waste and the children will hate it - it’s things they have asked for.

What isn’t great is the huge amounts of other tat they also buy them.

Dd is 8. Last year she got massive amounts of toy make up sets - she doesn’t use any. Piles of clothes that she will never wear as they aren’t her style, it’s all pink and sequins, sparkly dresses - that’s not what she likes. Loads of random china Disney characters - she’s never expressed an interest in Disney or any of the characters in her life. Sets of books she has no interest in. So much waste that just gets taken to the women’s refuge for the next christmas (so great for them), huge piles of stuff that my children have no want or need for.

They must spend about £150 each child on this extra stuff.

Thing is, we don’t have much money. If they really wanted to spend that on the children, I could give them a list of things they really need and would love. Dh has tried speaking to them about it. But he gets told that they will get her what she likes as they know she loves it all. He had explained that it’s not what she likes, they say they know better. It’s part of a wider form they have for control though.

So there is the thing of presents should be great fully accepted, but what if it’s things that are wildly different to what someone likes?

Jimboscott0115 · 20/12/2022 14:05

I think you're taking the gift business far too seriously and are being totally unreasonable.

I mean - come on, who didn't have a grandparent, uncle etc who constantly bought them shit presents growing up and even as an adult? It's sometimes part of the fun working out how to keep a straight face, show them the present being used but secretly putting it in storage/to charity etc. I remember a few years ago my ex's step mum buying me (really randomly!) A bottle of Archers for Christmas, and my brother in his teens getting some sort of God awful plasticky bomber jacket and having to wheel it out occasionally.

A Christmas list that you're expecting to be strictly adhered to is slightly ridiculous IMO.

CannonCaboodle · 20/12/2022 13:57

TinaYouFatLard · 14/12/2022 16:22

Grabby and grubby.

Couldn’t agree more. I dislike gift lists in general, but it is so incredibly entitled to create a gift list for a 3m old and distribute it to family! Tacky as hell. Let people buy your kid what they want, smile and accept graciously, and then regift or donate stuff you don’t like.

MamaBearBean · 20/12/2022 13:19

Do you realize that Christmas is about giving, not demanding? How entitled you are to expect that anyone adhere to your EXACT gift including manufacturer and brand. Do you actually hear yourself as you're writing this self-entitled post? If I were demanded to give an exact gift, I would be inclined to tell you exactly where to go. I don't know what the deal with this entitled generation is. This is absolutely disgusting behavior. You should quit the controlling gift lists and let the spirit of the season come back. You have single-handedly ruined the while idea of Christmas. You have no right to the season at all, you just don't deserve it. And...what are you teaching your child? That's the saddest part. Personally, I am grateful for anything I am given and I sure as honey don't expect anything. To me, it just sounds like it's evil.

Moonlightsonatas · 16/12/2022 12:05

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 16/12/2022 05:53

Why do MNers always reply with it's the thought that counts when the buyer has done zero thinking?

Because they always think they are better at gifting than they actually are 🤷🏼‍♀️

ChildcareIsBroken · 16/12/2022 05:54

areweungrateful · 15/12/2022 12:34

@pompomsandtinsel I think @RunDownRita is right. The title isn’t great, but I spent ages trying to think of another way to word it and couldn’t! I also spent ages trying to put all the right details in to the post as I’ve seen other posters get torn apart for missing a detail or for a particular choice of word. I obviously didn’t do very well! 🤣

I did however get some great ideas, and will be keeping stuff at my parents house moving forward as we’ve not the space for it or if it’s duplicate. The gift of child free time via babysitting is also ideal. I also spoke to someone in real life about it, who suggested that we ask GPs to considering gifting their time to DC as they get older in things like a trip to the park, petting zoo or little local aquarium, which I think is a super nice idea and hopefully will work to reduce the off piste gifts and waste!

FWIW, both sides of the family are gift list users; and years ago when I didn’t give my mum a birthday list I didn’t get anything at all! 🤣 so I don’t know what’s changed so much over the last couple of years, so I suppose I’m very surprised about the lack of list following as well!

I just read all your updates and am even more convinced you're not unreasonable. These all sound like good solutions.
And I agree with you, plenty of things that are sold are unsafe. And I also wouldn't want just any car seat, some are quite bad. I think for items like that I would ask your parents to return it - it's too much money to waste.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 16/12/2022 05:53

Why do MNers always reply with it's the thought that counts when the buyer has done zero thinking?

ChildcareIsBroken · 16/12/2022 05:41

I disagree with most. I think people missed the point how wasteful it is to buy expensive gifts that will not be used. And even returning them to the manufacturer doesn't guarantee they'll be sold again.
You have to have a conversation about it and come up with a solution that's acceptable to both. A list may seem to them like their gifts are no longer a surprise and that's probably why they don't like it. Maybe a more general list would be better? E.g. clothes, wooden toys etc. This way they can still chose what to get but you nudge them in the right direction.

Mamai90 · 16/12/2022 00:21

My DD was 6 weeks old last xmas. I told everyone they weren't to but her anything, what could she have possibly needed? We'd already got everything that we needed before she was born, then all the gifts that people bought us.There was literally nothing to get her that first Christmas, I got her a bauble for the tree, that was it.

Eughsame · 16/12/2022 00:09

Not at all ungrateful. We have the exact same issue. It’s not generous to bomb your family with an excess of gifts and things they don’t want or need. Buying thing you want to buy or without thought for the recipients is thoughtless and self-serving. Our DC are now 4 and 2 and after 4 OTT Christmas/birthdays/Easter/Halloween/bringing a sack of toys/clothes to visit for the weekend - our house is literally full to bursting with things GPs have bought. I can’t stand it. We can honestly barely move for plastic crap and our kids don’t even know where to start. Last year we got 3 of the same toy from different people. We want to enjoy Christmas time as a family, some peace and food and rest, and would really appreciate some small thoughtful and useful gifts - not be bogged down with more stuff that we have to get around to donating/binning/organising. Not to mention the sacks of wrapping paper.

NameChange30 · 15/12/2022 22:54

areweungrateful · 15/12/2022 10:47

People just love to make assumptions don’t they!

We didn’t have a wedding list, because we eloped as couldn’t afford a big wedding and didn’t want to have to make the decisions to leave any of our large extended family members out.

A PP was right; it’s a follow on car seat. Someone on DH’s side said they wanted to help us out with a big ticket item as DH was made redundant the week DC was born and we’ve been struggling to put money aside to get it when the time comes to move out of the current seat. And why wouldn’t we want to try and get the best version available that we possibly can.

And it’s actually my parents, so not another in laws thread, but I didn’t think that was in any way relevant.

I’m glad so many of you have big houses to store loads of things you don’t use as well as pots of gold to sit on that you can afford to throw unwanted gifts in the bin - and we’re talking about being ungrateful! What a suggestion. Just what the planet needs, more wasteful stuff going to landfill.

And of course I’ve replied to the people who “agree”, as they’re the ones who have actually made helpful suggestions instead of name calling 🤷🏼‍♀️

Oh OP. This thread would have gone very differently if you'd spelled out the actual issue to begin with. Of course YANBU to want to choose your child's car seat. I think you should ask your parents to return the one they've bought.

IglesiasPiggl · 15/12/2022 22:01

OP, I think it would have helped if you had said it was a car seat in your initial post, as that changes things a lot in my opinion. It isn't really about the gift list, but more that you're not comfortable with it from a safety perspective. I think people would have been a lot more understanding if you had said "My mum has bought us a car seat I don't like because it has poor safety reviews".

Heartsofstone · 15/12/2022 20:06

Jeez you’re hard work. You don’t have the right the get something you want. Stop micro managing everything and everyone. Vulgar to have a list of expectations for a 3 month old.

blackberrytea82 · 15/12/2022 19:59

SleeplessWB · 14/12/2022 17:39

Surely a list of suggestions just reduces waste and means everyone gets something they actually want?

The only comment with an ounce of sense on this thread.

I don't understand why so many people on here want their friends and family to waste money on things they won't want - things that will most likely clutter up charity shops and landfill when the recipient inevitably gets rid of it.

I will happily accept gift lists from friends and family.

Notimeforaname · 15/12/2022 19:35

we made a list for Christmas presents for DC, split it and circulated it to those who wanted to buy, making sure there were a variety of options and price points.

This is ridiculous. And controlling. Let people spend their money on what they want.

pompomsandtinsel · 15/12/2022 19:26

custardbear · 15/12/2022 17:17

I don't bother these days as I've put specific things like a nice wash bag I'd never buy myself (about &25), only to receive a bumper bag of cheap wash bags of all sorts of sizes and was told they'd found these instead of the one I wanted as they liked them and there were loads for all sorts of occasions 🤯 I also suggested a perfume as easy to buy and not too pricey (albeit they're millionaires) to get fingerless gloves so I didn't have to turn the heating on when WFH .... from the shop next door to Boots 😳
Hey ho so I make suggestions now and don't give the asked for list

That's how the are millionaires then!