Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if we should sleep train for our sanity?

82 replies

newmumtopreciousbaby · 14/12/2022 13:56

I saw the controlled crying thread and some people are so judgmental about sleep training methods, but what if you are worried you are going to go insane or have an accident because you are so tired? Surely then it can be in the baby’s interests?

Our nine month old - previously a brilliant sleeper - is waking about eight times a night after a period of sickness. It’s doesn’t seem to be hunger (has always tanked up before bed), developmental (he barely opens his eyes, cries out in his sleep like he’s having a nightmare, immediately settles with boob, or DH patting/singing). The patting and singing works for me sometimes but he usually ends up in bed with me and wants to use me as a dummy. I think it’s a comfort/separation anxiety thing. He has been in hospital.

Both our mental health is suffering and we are arguing, which I hate, especially in front of the baby. I feel like we are getting there on him settling himself again and night weaning, especially as my husband will take him more soon when he’s off (splitting the nights is what helped the baby learn to sleep before I think).

Do we need to bite the bullet and do cry it out? I don’t really care what people think, as babies need mums who can function most of all. But are we missing something? Do you really need to be able to put your baby down and walk out of the room at bedtime?

At bedtime he goes down easily, sometimes during a feed (I try and pop him off and put him down when he’s still drowsy but awake but it’s hard!), sometimes with a cuddle or a song, sometimes in his bouncer, sometimes just by crashing out. So he’s not dependent on one thing at all.

TL; DR: I’m worried we will go insane from sleep deprivation as baby is waking all night. Should we just do cry it out?

OP posts:
Merrow · 14/12/2022 14:38

There's plenty of sleep train options that aren't cry it out if you don't want to do that.

When we did night weaning DP (who was breastfeeding) slept in another room and I had a bed in DS' room. We had everything positioned so that I could soothe him in his cot without leaving my bed! Obviously he was upset, but I was there and so I didn't feel guilty about it (which I had in our brief "leave him to cry" foray), and since I stayed in bed it was much less disruptive for me. Obviously he felt I was useless as within a week he was sleeping through. He was older than 9 months though, so depends a bit on whether you are still feeding overnight I imagine.

SherbetDips · 14/12/2022 14:34

I’m a Nanny with over 20 years experience and I am a massive advocate for sleep training. Good sleep breeds good sleep.

I’ve sleep trained all the babies I have cared for and the parents were always grateful at the end. It’s not easy and it can feel like you’re the worst person in the world but once it’s done it just makes life so much better.

Lullabies2Paralyze · 14/12/2022 14:31

I would give it a go if you think it will help.

I will probably have to do it eventually, currently doing “moan it out” where I leave my baby if he’s just moaning with occasional woe is me style sob but if he starts crying loudly and for long period then I do get him up and feed (human dummy) him back to sleep.

his room will be sorted soon so he will be moved so I’m probably going to be more relaxed with cry it out once he’s not right next to me

Chumbibi · 14/12/2022 14:31

For those that did sleep train, what did you do about naps/night wakings?

Puppyseahorse · 14/12/2022 14:30

Read Emily oster, cribsheet. She’s looked at research into whether sleep training works (it does) and whether it’s harmful (it’s not.)

everybody has so many opinions about motherhood- I’ve found it really helpful to have one resource I can go to that has data, not just opinion or theory.

Circe7 · 14/12/2022 14:29

I do think the point about driving is a big one I know a lot of mums who have children who barely sleep and are anti any form of sleep training but are driving them around. They wouldn’t drive without a car seat or while drunk but driving with chronic sleep deprivation must be just as dangerous. I don’t know what the answer is as haven’t had to sleep train myself but I do think getting enough sleep that you can drive safely if you need to should be very high priority and come ahead of concerns about a child crying for a few minutes.

Chumbibi · 14/12/2022 14:29

OP it’s so hard. I’m currently in the throes of a mental breakdown due to such severe sleep deprivation. Spoke to my GP who actually recommended sleep training in the form of controlled crying.

I just don’t have the energy to start it but I don’t feel there’s any other option for us.

Twizbe · 14/12/2022 14:27

I used controlled crying with both mine at around 10 months. Before that I'd fed to sleep as it worked. When it stopped working we sleep trained.

I'd go in and reassure them with a tummy rub and saying it's ok then leave for 2 mins, repeat the reassurance and leave for 4 mins, then 6,8 10 mins. After that it was 10 min intervals until they went to sleep.

Took between 3 and 4 nights for both and got them off the boob at night time.

No regrets and 2 very happy, well adjusted, attached, wonderful children.

EndlessRain1 · 14/12/2022 14:23

fairgame84 · 14/12/2022 14:22

I did sleep training with DS, he's now 18.
I didn't do cry it out but it was a controlled crying method where he was left for 1 minute then consoled then 2 minutes then consoled up to a maximum time, I think 5 minutes max. We never got to the max time and he slept through from maybe 3 months old. He was never left, I stayed at his bedroom door.
Obviously it was a long time ago and I don't know what it recommended now.

sleep training is not recommended for babies younger than 6 months.

EndlessRain1 · 14/12/2022 14:22

Kabalagala · 14/12/2022 14:20

I just cosleep. That way nobody is crying and everyone gets plenty of sleep.
Sleep train if you want to, but you definitely don't need to.

That's what I did with my second. We got loads more sleep that way and I didn't need to sleep train (which I didn't feel very happy with for me).

newmumtopreciousbaby · 14/12/2022 14:22

Kabalagala · 14/12/2022 14:20

I just cosleep. That way nobody is crying and everyone gets plenty of sleep.
Sleep train if you want to, but you definitely don't need to.

Cosleeping doesn’t lead to better sleep for us unfortunately, he just wants to breastfeed all the time and I can’t relax as I subconsciously think I’ll squash him. It isn’t for us.

OP posts:
upfucked · 14/12/2022 14:22

Cry it out is neglect. It’s abuse. There are plenty of ways to sleep train which aren’t abusive. Controlled crying is not recommended before 12 months but your HV should be able to advise you of suitable methods.

fairgame84 · 14/12/2022 14:22

I did sleep training with DS, he's now 18.
I didn't do cry it out but it was a controlled crying method where he was left for 1 minute then consoled then 2 minutes then consoled up to a maximum time, I think 5 minutes max. We never got to the max time and he slept through from maybe 3 months old. He was never left, I stayed at his bedroom door.
Obviously it was a long time ago and I don't know what it recommended now.

EndlessRain1 · 14/12/2022 14:21

newmumtopreciousbaby · 14/12/2022 14:19

Was your issue also separation/breastfeeding related? I did read this is the prime age for separation anxiety

It is. Its' up to you to choose how you need to respond.

Personally I bit the bullet and offered extra closeness and it passed. But only you will know your own limits and what extent of sleep training you are happy with.

Honestly, I wouldn't have posted about this in AIBI because you are not only going to get advice , but you are likely also going to get people telling you it's mean and you will feel rubbish. These things matter so much when you are in the throws of it, and very little when you are not.

newmumtopreciousbaby · 14/12/2022 14:21

EndlessRain1 · 14/12/2022 14:19

Well you got to look after yourself too don't you. Sleep is an important factor in that. As I said, take a google or speak to your HV. As I recall they recommend the moving chair technique or whatever it's called now, there are lots of variants of it. Don't let your baby "cry it out" (which as Pp suggested generally means leaving them to cry as long as it takes without offering any comfort), that's pretty mean.

Yes I don’t want to do that. Obviously don’t know the proper lingo!

OP posts:
Kabalagala · 14/12/2022 14:20

I just cosleep. That way nobody is crying and everyone gets plenty of sleep.
Sleep train if you want to, but you definitely don't need to.

newmumtopreciousbaby · 14/12/2022 14:20

BabyYoZenZen · 14/12/2022 14:18

But isn't it understandable that your baby needs more closeness and reassurance after being unwell and in hospital? Imagine what he would say about the current situation if he could understand and speak. I think sleep training has its place when parents' mood is very affected otherwise, but I don't think I'd consider it at a time when baby had been unwell. His sleep should get better again on its own once he's fully better.

He is fully better now, I think he got used to boob/cosleeping for comfort. That’s why we have been comforting him when needed, but we are both so exhausted and fraying at the edges. He seems well and happy in the daytime, albeit very tired. He has bags under his eyes.

OP posts:
EmmetEmma · 14/12/2022 14:20

I used sleep training - I don’t regret it - nor do I think it’s barbaric and I would do it again in a heartbeat.

I love my babies and would endlessly cuddle and hold them - but night time is not the time for that, unless there is something wrong. Everyone is happier after a good night’s sleep

EndlessRain1 · 14/12/2022 14:19

newmumtopreciousbaby · 14/12/2022 14:16

Ok thank you. I suppose what I was saying is that I’m not really interested in the sleep training culture wars, I just want to do what’s best for our family as I am on the verge of falling apart and my poor baby is exhausted too.

Well you got to look after yourself too don't you. Sleep is an important factor in that. As I said, take a google or speak to your HV. As I recall they recommend the moving chair technique or whatever it's called now, there are lots of variants of it. Don't let your baby "cry it out" (which as Pp suggested generally means leaving them to cry as long as it takes without offering any comfort), that's pretty mean.

newmumtopreciousbaby · 14/12/2022 14:19

MolliciousIntent · 14/12/2022 14:17

We did CC at this age with both kids and it worked in a few days. Saved my life.

Was your issue also separation/breastfeeding related? I did read this is the prime age for separation anxiety

OP posts:
BabyYoZenZen · 14/12/2022 14:18

But isn't it understandable that your baby needs more closeness and reassurance after being unwell and in hospital? Imagine what he would say about the current situation if he could understand and speak. I think sleep training has its place when parents' mood is very affected otherwise, but I don't think I'd consider it at a time when baby had been unwell. His sleep should get better again on its own once he's fully better.

MolliciousIntent · 14/12/2022 14:17

We did CC at this age with both kids and it worked in a few days. Saved my life.

newmumtopreciousbaby · 14/12/2022 14:16

EndlessRain1 · 14/12/2022 14:14

There's loads of middle ground. Google gentle sleep trainign techniques. Even the NHS now recommend gradual retreat rather than elimination methods.

Ok thank you. I suppose what I was saying is that I’m not really interested in the sleep training culture wars, I just want to do what’s best for our family as I am on the verge of falling apart and my poor baby is exhausted too.

OP posts:
FourChimneys · 14/12/2022 14:16

We did it in a fairly firm but gentle way. We were completely shattered by lack of sleep, DH wasn't safe to drive.

The baby in question is now a perfectly happy and well adjusted adult. The response to knowing what we did : "Am I supposed to be, like, damaged by that then?"

newmumtopreciousbaby · 14/12/2022 14:15

rosegoldivy · 14/12/2022 14:06

I done sleep training for this reason. I nearly crashed my car with whole family in it because was that tired.

Twins were up and down 20-30 times a night. Every night. Then up for the day at 4am. Was genuinely sooooooo close to a mental breakdown, marriage was on the rocks because of the sleep deprivation.

Sleep trained them about 9-10months. Was the best thing I ever done. They both started sleeping through the night within 3 nights using the disappearing chair method. Would do it again in a heartbeat.

Thank you. I will look at this method. That sounds so tough. I think 99% of our relationship issues are because lack of sleep makes you short tempered and irrational! It’s causing a lot of tension.

OP posts: