Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Forced to invite in-laws who hate us ?!

181 replies

WorriedandScared93 · 13/12/2022 23:40

Sorry for the long post. Hand hold also needed. Really would like any thoughts on this. I don’t know if people would agree with this or not.

DP has a brother who he has not spoken to for about 3 years, nor seen. Due to a big family fall out with myself, DP, BIL and SIL- we have not spoken. We fell out due to apparently me making up a story of how SIL spoke to me rudely (very stupid and she has taken it so personally and will not allow this to drop). I told DP who bought it up with his mum (MIL) and then MIL went and confronted SIL about it. Fireworks erupted, apparently I was lying and I have twisted it. I didn’t lie- it happened but SIL I don't think could remember. I think MIL may have made it out to be worse than what it was! I apologised to her and it seemed to make things even worse?

Apparently I have not apologised ‘properly’ and organised a family meeting for myself to sit in front of basically everyone in the family and apologise for what I have said to her?

Apparently I was not forthcoming enough with my apology, I control DP and I make him miserable and I have ruined the family? They said they give our relationship a year (its now been 3 years later and 1 child!)

FIL and MIL have said they feel in the middle of this. MIL lies to try and keep everyone happy.

Very aggressive messages were sent from SIL to myself 3 years ago, pages and pages of abusive messages that resulted in threats to me. Since- we have not spoken. Her messages consisted of her children not being part of me by any means (as I am not married to DP I am basically nothing to the family), she has also stated that herself and her family are nothing to do with us and wish to be left alone, never to contact them again etc. Which of course myself and DP have respected their wishes.

Me and DP have a DS who is turning 1 in March. We are planning him a first birthday party end of March with family and close friends, nothing massive just personal. We are due to send the invites out ASAP, due to the bad post at the moment this gives people time to RSVP and plan what they are doing for then. This is the first event myself and DP have organised ourselves- hence the issue we are facing where we are not wanting to invite SIL and BIL with their kids.

MIL has been begging me and DP for weeks to send the invite to them, to basically just keep THEM happy. We haven’t spoken to them or seen them for 3 years. Although they are DP’s brother and SIL- MIL sees them as family and they should be invited. I would feel the same if perhaps such hurtful things were not said to me from SIL.

MIL has said BIL has asked about DS and that he would like to meet him. Myself and DP have not seen this at all in him, so we think this is a lie just to keep the peace and for us to send the invite. A lot of lies are being told by MIL and it is overall just very toxic.

This stems from years of abuse gaslighting and serious deep-rooted issues between DP and BIL, as well as SIL and me. It’s to a point where im dreaming about it so much and it’s making me ill. Especially postpartum, it caused some PND with me- they did not try to reach out to us when we had DS to see how we were getting on, we really thought they would have tried to build a bridge with us. They did not congratulate us on the pregnancy or birth of our first child. SIL has blocked me on all messaging services and social media and BIL is ignoring DP completely. This is stonewalling to the extreme x100.

They have ignored all olive branches we have sent out in the past such as kind messages asking for them to see our new DS and any phonecalls we have tried to call them. We have stopped trying the past 6 months I would say.

FIL apparently told MIL he has threatened that he likely wont come to the party if BIL isn't invited. Even though it is his own grandson’s birthday party. I am so sad they are putting their feelings before myself and DP’s.

Surely it is up to us who we want to come? My issue was only wanting people around DS who love him, want to know him and have made every effort to be in his life.

Do I bite the bullet and invite or do I just not invite them and really feel everyone’s wrath. but keep MYSELF sane and happy, and allow myself to enjoy the day without being miserable at my son’s party just to keep MIL and FIL happy?

To be honest I know what I would like to do- that is completely get rid of them from my life, not invite them to the party and just keep myself happy for once and move on without anymore attempts of olive branches and totally soul crushing of my self esteem.

If I fall out with inlaw’s so be it- but sadly that is the only way I would like be happy. DP feels we should invite them to keep the peace (he likes a quiet life).

Thanks to anyone who has got this far!

OP posts:
bumpytrumpy · 14/12/2022 11:07

Why would not inviting them actually cause a shit show, when they have ignored your other attempts at contact? You're being dragged into their illogical way of thinking. Stay clear headed about what normal relationships look like.

I think you need some stock phrases for MIL / anyone who asks

"The party is for DS and people he knows"

"We have invited / text them x number of times and had no response. I don't think they want to know us anymore"

"I'm not inviting someone who ignores me for 3 years"

"They have made their choice to distance themselves from us. That's fine. If they want to change it they can give me a call"

Just repeat with no emotion.

WorriedandScared93 · 14/12/2022 11:07

@Brefugee you are right there and that's the approach I'm taking now.

I really wish I could be friends with people on here in real life, I literally have no one telling me this. Just reading comments on here has made me feel so much better. Xx

OP posts:
SinnerBoy · 14/12/2022 11:06

WorriedandScared93 · Today 11:05

@SinnerBoy they are older than us and had their kids first and are able to throw demands at everyone in the family. If MIL doesn't obey what they want they have threatened she will never see kids again.

Oh god, what an awful person she is. I don't envy you in your situation.

Ellie56 · 14/12/2022 11:06

billy1966 has nailed it. Wise words. Listen to them and take note.

WorriedandScared93 · 14/12/2022 11:05

@GetThatHelmetOn you are right!

OP posts:
Pipsquiggle · 14/12/2022 11:05

Reconciliation should not happen at 'events' - weddings / parties etc. It's just too much drama and extra stress you don't need.

If you do want to reconcile, do it privately. It sounds like you don't want to though. Leave it up to your DP

WorriedandScared93 · 14/12/2022 11:05

@SinnerBoy they are older than us and had their kids first and are able to throw demands at everyone in the family. If MIL doesn't obey what they want they have threatened she will never see kids again.

OP posts:
WorriedandScared93 · 14/12/2022 11:04

@SinnerBoy thank you- that's what I will suggest to him. DP is very 'us' or nothing sometimes though. He is weak at times and probably would not have a relationship with SIL and BIL without me. They are very strong characters who likely would turn his head against me which they have done before very swiftly.

OP posts:
WorriedandScared93 · 14/12/2022 11:02

@Lampshadered yes me and DP have not been invited to birthday parties!

I will no longer be speaking to MIL regarding this. Also I have spoken to DP and he agrees not to invite them- he wants to see if any effort is made within the next 2 months or if we could meet but neither of us are betting on this!

Not inviting them will cause a shit show but to be honest I am past it and a lot of the comments on here have MASSIVELY helped me out things into perspective! I wish I could print some of these out and shove them on my mirror I look at every day to remind me!! Thank you so much.

OP posts:
SinnerBoy · 14/12/2022 10:51

Brefugee · Today 10:41

Tell your DP that you don't want them at an event you are hosting, even if he's hosting it with you. But that you are happy for him (and DS if he wants) to develop a relationship with SIL and her DH. Then step back.

I think that's very good advice.

caringcarer · 14/12/2022 10:45

It is your party you invite who you want there.

GetThatHelmetOn · 14/12/2022 10:44

WorriedandScared93 · 13/12/2022 23:54

@billy1966 you have no idea how much better you've just made me feel by that, thank you so much.

My issue is- if I don't invite them I am the nasty one and will likely be stonewalled by everyone else in the family now. DP also mentioned I am going to make them 'even more pissed off with us' as I think MIL may have mentioned we were going to invite them... I'm not sure what has been said.

I want to move on from them and start our own life away from BIL and SIL totally. But MIL and FIL are the types to disown DP completely if we don't respect what THEY want.

For them, no matter what you do or not do, you are the nasty one anyway so just ignore and do what you please.

Brefugee · 14/12/2022 10:41

Tell your DP that you don't want them at an event you are hosting, even if he's hosting it with you. But that you are happy for him (and DS if he wants) to develop a relationship with SIL and her DH. Then step back.

Stick to your guns about not inviting them to events you are hosting, but leave the other stuff up to your DP. You don't have to have a relationship with these batshit grudge holders.

I don't like most of my ILs and i don't see them, i don't visit and i don't send cards or whatever. It works for me. I know they are rude about me behind my back: I don't care. Life is too short to spend time with people who are horrible to you.

SinnerBoy · 14/12/2022 10:35

*billy19668 · Yesterday 23:46

Excellent advice.

I'd say don't invite the SiL.

Mine's Hell as well. I've had very little to do with her for 3 years, but we have a family Whats App group and at the weekend, her brother asked about the cold. I told him the back of the house is lacking cavity wall insulation, but I'm waiting for a grant to get it done.

She weighed in that, as it was built before 1920, the walls are solid and that I'm talking rubbish. I had my hand inside the bloody wall in April, when we were having building work done and the builder said, "No wonder it's cold, look at this."

She's absolute poison, lies to me and about me.

I pointed out that I'd had a grant for the last house, again, she called me an idiot. I pointed out that the surveyor had showed me the cavity, using an endoscope. I needed wall ties replacing, so had that done first. She just kept on that I'd been ripped off and had solid walls, so I just wrote "Bollocks. You have no idea what you're on about."

My wife had a go at me for being rude to her!

keepcalm11 · 14/12/2022 10:30

Agree with PP's not to involve MIL as an intermediary, she's twisting the messages as she passes information along and causing drama.

I would suggest don't invite BIL/SIL. Do invite PIL's but don't engage in conversation about invites other than thier own.

Also give it a rest until nearer the date as it's too soon. Could you make it more casual rather than formal written invitations and RSVP's ?

ehb102 · 14/12/2022 10:24

My only additional input is that you need to start being the angry and aggrieved party to your DH. No more Mrs Doormat, get on your high horse and be offended. People pleasers need to know that they need to please you too, instead of expecting you to be the person without boundaries or feelings.

EndlessRain1 · 14/12/2022 10:19

The whole situation sounds ridiculous. It's unclear to me how much of a part you'e contributed to the drama, but it sounds like at least a bit.

What's done is done though and in your shoes I would not invite them. MiL should have considered this before caused the issue in the first place. If Fil doesn't show up, ignore it.

BattenburgSlice · 14/12/2022 10:04

RampantIvy · 14/12/2022 06:50

So now, I would cancel the party …let MIL know that it’s cancelled. If she asks why it’s cancelled say because it is ridiculous that a birthday party is causing too much family upset which is getting everybody down.
Then, just before your DS’s birthday organise a smaller, more spontaneous, more discreet get-together without any fuss or drama, just for those you really want there, so that the people you don’t want there won’t even know it’s happening or has happened.

I agree with this ^^ and everything @billy1966 said.

This

saraclara · 14/12/2022 09:56

Your DH and his brother are the ones who should be talking at this stage, if anything is ever to be resolved. Not necessarily mentioning the party, but to find a way forward for family relationships long term. I'd suggest that your DH contact his brother to invite him to the pub or something. They are the siblings who are having to live with the result of a spat between their partners.

I have some sympathy with MIL. I'd struggle to bear it if my DDs fell out so spectacularly. It would be heartbreaking. And even more frustrating if my family had fallen apart due to an argument between their partners.

The PILs might not be handling it well, but nor are any of you. But I do think that of things are ever to be fixed, then the brothers are the only ones who can sort it. They need to talk, and you and SIL need to reflect on the fact that your actions have broken up someone else's family. Personally, however unfair it might be, in yours or SILs position, I hope I'd be able to let go of my stubbornness for the sake of the PILs and their sons.

I hope that some kind of compromise on this 'apology' can be brokered by your DH and BIL.

Wibbly1008 · 14/12/2022 09:43

Do not invite them. It will be another slap for them to give to you when they don’t come. Your MIl has stirred the pot, she has thrown granades and you have been blamed for them. Tell her to now butt out as she has caused enough trouble already. Cut these people off permanently and stop feeding the family drama that Mil has created . Good luck OP!

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 14/12/2022 09:38

Sorry, pressed send way too early by mistake there!

Your MIL and FIL are batshit crazy, and they sound very much like a lesser version of my stepfather, although the effect will eventually be similar.

Having said that, they're not actually batshit crazy, they're manipulate, coercive, controlling and self-centred individuals who believe that the world revolves around them. It doesn't. It takes a lot of hard work and courage to get away from that sphere of influence but it needs to start somewhere. Starting with refusing to invite BIL and SIL to the party would be a good start. You and your partner have absolutely nothing to gain from the invite except a load of grief. By refusing to acquiesce to their demands, you would be taking a step towards demonstrating that they're NOT the ones in control of your lives.

I would also recommend the book below, for both of you. That's the book Mrs Unicorn got me to read and started my journey off to being able to get away from the suffocating, draining and life extinguishing environment I was in, even as an adult. You may both find it useful as a starting point and access other resources afterwards.

Good luck.

Forced to invite in-laws who hate us ?!
SnowlayRoundabout · 14/12/2022 09:25

Your DP needs to tell his parents that BIL has ignored invitations to see your child in the past so unless and until he replies there is no point inviting him. At least that should put the ball in BIL's court.

But really it sounds as if you are better off with the whole lot of them out of your lives.

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 14/12/2022 09:18

Your MIL and FIL are batshit crazy, and they sound very much like a lesser version of my stepfather, albeit

Comeonbarbiebrianharvey · 14/12/2022 09:17

It sounds like MIL is trying to stir it up. Why isn't she this obsessed with Christmas? Why would they want to come to his party if you're blocked?

I'd say to her, I've apologised, they didn't accept it, so I'm respecting their wishes. Although if she s text you such vile stuff you're owed an apology too!

If your MIL is the real problem, and if SIL isn't as bad, and you want to keep it civil, phone SIL and say MIL wants you to come, is this want you want? You don't know what MIL is saying to her. It's best to avoid texts, and just phone, texts get misread.

It sounds like she's sent some nasty stuff, so I personally wouldn't bother. I'd show MIL the nasty texts and say this is why I'm not inviting them so sod off!!

CrownTheTurkey · 14/12/2022 09:10

You don't have to do anything that you don't want to.
You have a voice, use it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread