Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if the NHS sends you an appointment for a significant surgical procedure, you turn up>

459 replies

XingMing · 13/12/2022 21:51

DH has waited two years for a (complicated) day surgery on his heart. He turned up for it at 7 am this morning and of the six scheduled booked patients, two arrived. There was a surgical team of ten arranged, who stood around waiting. If this is the normal, and the doctors, surgeons and nurses seemed to think it was, then complaints about underfunding the nhs funding needs should be kicked backed to the public. It's reasonable to expect the treatment paid for via taxation, but it is unreasonable to be so cavalier about non attendance. This was a procedure that cost the NHS £20k or more in salary costs... and two-thirds of the list were no shows. Can you tell that I am incensed for the people on waiting lists and the taxpayers funding the waste? For the record, the roads were all clear.

OP posts:
lieselotte · 14/12/2022 12:58

I wonder how many of those people were invited for their procedures by post, and did not receive the letters (although presumably some have premeds so know when the operations are due to happen).

But if you need to cancel you can't get through to anyone to cancel. Why does nobody answer the phones?

I find it quite difficult to believe that most people simply don't turn up. Of course there are a few entitled ones.

As for the roads being clear, the weather can be very localised. I have snow, there are people in the same town who do not!

AutumnCrow · 14/12/2022 12:48

MardyMincepie · 14/12/2022 11:20

I’m sure there are some admin mistakes and genuine DNA but there are just so many without any real consequence.

I worked in a maxillofacial day surgery unit when young doing procedures under GA. Well FML the amount of people that just could not comprehend not eating or drinking anything at all. I used to have to do the first round of questioning, no I haven’t eaten anything, well I just had some shreddies sticks in my mind and then getting arsey becuse they couldn’t have surgery.
.
I used to think it would be better to not go in to the long blurb but just write and say if you eat or drink anything you may die on the table, yes actually die and it will be your fault.

I remember back in the day when patients were brought into the ward the day before and 'nil by mouthed' to avoid this kind of (very costly) cock-up happening.

Now there is no ward. To 'save money'. Went the same way as the essential ward clerks. Replaced by a jigsaw of failing databases and contact systems with missing pieces.

Brefugee · 14/12/2022 12:36

I'm not ignoring valid reasons Brefugee. But there are strong opinions on both sides expressed here. Not quite sure why you need to be snarky.

I'm not being snarky, @XingMing but you are ignoring the several reasons why people might not show, and how it might be mitigated. Sure, some people don't turn up. That is bad and they should be pursued to find out why.

But there are many many more reasons and examples here of why people don't show up.

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 11:46

People still keep trotting out uninformed opinions without reading the research or even this thread. Sigh.

JudgeJ · 14/12/2022 11:44

Greensleevevssnotnose · 13/12/2022 21:55

Appalling, I have a hospital appointment on Thursday, albeit private. I had to prepay several months ago and they have emailed me everyday for the last month checking I am coming telling me how long the waiting list is, and I can still get a refund etc. Perhaps the NHS could be more proactive in this respect?

The no-shows should be expected to pay something before any missed appointment is rescheduled. I once had to book an appointement get an emergency passport, naturally the minute I put the phone down I looked for something else and found the passport. When I called to cancel they were surprised, most people didn't bother with that courtesy. Whe.n teaching we had parents not bother with Parents' Evening meetings because of a football match on TV then expected us to see them another day
Many people don't value what's free.

Untitledsquatboulder · 14/12/2022 11:44

AutumnCrow · 14/12/2022 11:14

DP and I both have had this from our GP surgery. They only have our mobile numbers, which have been triple-checked with the surgery.

We have both waited around all day for a phone appointment that never comes. Bang on 6pm (when the surgery shuts and their phone lines go on to recorded message) we've had texts to our mobile phones saying 'we tried to call you twice but you didn't answer so you have will have to ring Reception to make a new appointment'.

But we can see that no-one rang. It's annoying to think that this might wrongly be on our records as 'DNA'. As for fining us - good luck in the magistrates' courts with all the people who can't pay or won't pay inappropriate 'fines'. They can't be refused treatment by the NHS, so it would be a massive administrative shambles. And speaking personally, I'd get the Information Commissioner involved as well regarding inaccurate data being held against my name.

But fining will never happen. I'd bet good money on it, for all the reasons given above.

We've had this an the problem was that our phone contract was set up to screen out "caller with held" numbers which is what our surgery - other than the receptionists - uses.

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 11:37

Have you missed many people saying how hard they found it to cancel? In some cases spending hours trying to tell someone. No wonder many people give up.

CookPassBabtridge · 14/12/2022 11:34

Yes when I was sitting on the hospital bed waiting for my hysterectomy I heard the receptionists ringing round trying to find a no show.. they had just decided they didn't want it anymore, didn't think to tell anyone. We got enough text reminders beforehand saying how much the op cost and to let them know if not needed anymore..
It is fucking DISGUSTING! I spent so many tears of frustration waiting for my op.
Disgusting self absorbed arseholes.

poetryandwine · 14/12/2022 11:34

Premature post —

— we think — only by ringing repeatedly until he can leave a message that, eg, he is overseas on business on the date of a nonurgent appt. (This particular hospital has recently converted to a good text management system)

Like others we have sometimes got postal notice within 48 hrs of an appt. I can well believe others DNA because the notice never arrives. I am still waiting for the postal results of my smear, from August, available online thru the GP since September.

I don’t think there is a viable way to charge some people for some appointments. It quickly becomes a slippery slope: first the DNAs, then smokers, the obese, the merely overweight, those who don’t exercise enough, etc. But I would like to see us do something similar to the French, who are leagues above us in health outcomes, and charge small co-pays for certain types of care. Those on limited incomes get a refund from the state.

Vintagevixen · 14/12/2022 11:29

Yes I do a regular pacing clinic and the DNA rate differs from week to week but can be high.

Having said that the system for letters, admin etc is diabolical so often it's not patients fault. Really wish they would sort it out or start using text messages to remind them the day before.

The NHS IT/admin systems are beyond a joke really and totally lead to this sort of thing happening more than it should.

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 11:25

XjustagirlX · 14/12/2022 11:20

I too have used these tactics as it is the only way. My parents struggle but it is because they assume that the nhs works when it just doesn’t. They think well I have been told that I’m on the list so I must be in the list. Wrong!

you have to constantly chase your referral and appts. You cannot rely on the fact that info is passed correctly between departments.

My DH waited absolutely ages for an important appointment as he refused to do this, even though I kept telling him to. He is now getting excellent multi-disciplinary treatment for this. But it is frustrating it took so long.

olivehater · 14/12/2022 11:24

I’m a sonographer and pretty much all my appointments turn up x Would love a DNA occasionally as my list as overbooked!!

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 11:23

@XingMing It is a very high rate if DNA, way above the normal. So something has gone wrong. That could be issues with hospital transport, letters not being sent out, or no coordination so changed addresses, people already in hospital, or who have phoned to cancel as too ill not to attend, not recorded accurately.

The admin in the NHS has been slashed. The government keeps saying the NHS can save money by slashing "pen pushers". But doing that causes inefficiencies. You need admin workers to make things work properly.

poetryandwine · 14/12/2022 11:22

@XingMing I usually find your posts interesting and thought provoking. This one especially so.

I voted YANBU but only by a whisker. While the care my family has received from the NHS has been excellent, the logistics have been a big problem. DH and I have both had our share of hospital appointments. I DNA’ed once because the date on my letter was weeks after the date they had me down for and there was no further communication. DH has sometimes missed DNAing

XjustagirlX · 14/12/2022 11:20

Buteverythingsfine · 14/12/2022 09:29

One tip I would give is that if you are waiting for a fairly urgent appointment, find out who is the secretary of the relevant consultant who runs the clinic and then call them for cancellations. I never wait years for referrals, I just call the secretary and often they will have had cancellations on the day or for a couple of days time. I am prepared to go on short notice. Another trick is to find out who is the consultant who heads the clinic, go and see them privately for £200 and then they will place you back in the NHS system for further appointments or tests, it just starts the ball rolling quicker, I've done this twice.

That's what I mean about sharp-elbowed middle-class pushy people like me getting better treatment. In a very inefficient system with limited resources, some people do better than others. Quieter, nicer, uncomplaining people, or people who are limited by cognitive capacity, MH, hard of hearing, any reason, being older (which is millions of very needy people) come last in this system. It is not fair, but neither is getting much sicker or even dying whilst waiting two years to be seen.

I too have used these tactics as it is the only way. My parents struggle but it is because they assume that the nhs works when it just doesn’t. They think well I have been told that I’m on the list so I must be in the list. Wrong!

you have to constantly chase your referral and appts. You cannot rely on the fact that info is passed correctly between departments.

MardyMincepie · 14/12/2022 11:20

I’m sure there are some admin mistakes and genuine DNA but there are just so many without any real consequence.

I worked in a maxillofacial day surgery unit when young doing procedures under GA. Well FML the amount of people that just could not comprehend not eating or drinking anything at all. I used to have to do the first round of questioning, no I haven’t eaten anything, well I just had some shreddies sticks in my mind and then getting arsey becuse they couldn’t have surgery.
.
I used to think it would be better to not go in to the long blurb but just write and say if you eat or drink anything you may die on the table, yes actually die and it will be your fault.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 14/12/2022 11:16

Yep totally normal unfortunately. Happened with my elderly parent, I was horrified

AutumnCrow · 14/12/2022 11:14

Sugarplumfairy65 · 14/12/2022 00:28

On the flip side, I travelled for an hour this morning to a hospital appointment. I got the letter for the appointment 4 weeks ago, had the blood tests needed last week, got a text on Friday reminding me about the appointment.
I got there to be told that they'd made a mistake and my appointment was in January and that theyd been trying to ring me for a week to let me know. They hadnt rung me at all. They only have my mobile number, i double checked the number with them and I've had no missed calls and no messages apart from the one on Friday to confirm the appointment

DP and I both have had this from our GP surgery. They only have our mobile numbers, which have been triple-checked with the surgery.

We have both waited around all day for a phone appointment that never comes. Bang on 6pm (when the surgery shuts and their phone lines go on to recorded message) we've had texts to our mobile phones saying 'we tried to call you twice but you didn't answer so you have will have to ring Reception to make a new appointment'.

But we can see that no-one rang. It's annoying to think that this might wrongly be on our records as 'DNA'. As for fining us - good luck in the magistrates' courts with all the people who can't pay or won't pay inappropriate 'fines'. They can't be refused treatment by the NHS, so it would be a massive administrative shambles. And speaking personally, I'd get the Information Commissioner involved as well regarding inaccurate data being held against my name.

But fining will never happen. I'd bet good money on it, for all the reasons given above.

panko · 14/12/2022 11:01

Unfortunately I think the system just doesn't account for humans. It sends out letters without thinking hang on that's been rearranged with only a weeks notice that might he tricky.

XingMing · 14/12/2022 11:01

I'm not ignoring valid reasons Brefugee. But there are strong opinions on both sides expressed here. Not quite sure why you need to be snarky.

OP posts:
user1471505494 · 14/12/2022 10:58

XingMing · 14/12/2022 10:44

OP here. Thanks for all the comments overnight.

@Brefugee, of course there are lots of reasons why people might not attend. But this hospital, which I've got to know pretty well in the last 10 years, with familial experience of A&E, cardiology, orthopaedic trauma, oncology, radiotherapy and dermatology in the last 12 months, is actually very very good and quietly efficient. It serves a low-income city plus a big, low-income rural catchment including a large elderly population.

The administration is generally good. We had two letters, three text messages and a phone to confirm everything, plus a courier delivery of the medication needed in preparation. This clinic has been planned since mid-October, before the mail strike.

It was day case surgery and all patients were told to arrive by 7.30am.

It was cold, but dry and not foggy, the roads were clear and mostly gritted.

The condition being treated is irksome and causes anxiety but it's not life-threatening. It mainly affects people who have undergone and survived quite major heart issues, so while one, even two, could have died waiting the chances of two-thirds doing so are statistically unlikely. Not impossible, but unlikely.

Of course, there are always going to be people with mental health issues and disorganised home lives: I am not sure how the NHS solves all the social ills.

What about me

I had two letters last week from my local hospital. The first I opened was giving me an appointment with the consultant for October 2023. I have been waiting since January. The second letter was telling me that my same appointment in June had been cancelled. The problem being was that I never received the letter about the June appointment. I then spent ages on the phone checking up if I needed further tests before seeing the consultant and was told that it appears a lot of letters go missing or were never sent in the first place. I wohave been marked as a no show for an appointment I never knew about

XingMing · 14/12/2022 10:56

@AliceS1994 your explanation was exactly what the senior nurse told DH. People don't want surgery this side of Christmas.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 14/12/2022 10:45

again - totally ignoring all the reasons people have given here on multiple occasions.
It seems you can't put yourself in other people's shoes?

XingMing · 14/12/2022 10:44

OP here. Thanks for all the comments overnight.

@Brefugee, of course there are lots of reasons why people might not attend. But this hospital, which I've got to know pretty well in the last 10 years, with familial experience of A&E, cardiology, orthopaedic trauma, oncology, radiotherapy and dermatology in the last 12 months, is actually very very good and quietly efficient. It serves a low-income city plus a big, low-income rural catchment including a large elderly population.

The administration is generally good. We had two letters, three text messages and a phone to confirm everything, plus a courier delivery of the medication needed in preparation. This clinic has been planned since mid-October, before the mail strike.

It was day case surgery and all patients were told to arrive by 7.30am.

It was cold, but dry and not foggy, the roads were clear and mostly gritted.

The condition being treated is irksome and causes anxiety but it's not life-threatening. It mainly affects people who have undergone and survived quite major heart issues, so while one, even two, could have died waiting the chances of two-thirds doing so are statistically unlikely. Not impossible, but unlikely.

Of course, there are always going to be people with mental health issues and disorganised home lives: I am not sure how the NHS solves all the social ills.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 14/12/2022 09:58

Pavlova31 · Yesterday 22:27
The local health authority has an online portal where you as a patient can access digitally both letters and test results. Always kept up to date,“

not helpful to elderly patients with no internet and little or no family support.

Swipe left for the next trending thread