Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if the NHS sends you an appointment for a significant surgical procedure, you turn up>

459 replies

XingMing · 13/12/2022 21:51

DH has waited two years for a (complicated) day surgery on his heart. He turned up for it at 7 am this morning and of the six scheduled booked patients, two arrived. There was a surgical team of ten arranged, who stood around waiting. If this is the normal, and the doctors, surgeons and nurses seemed to think it was, then complaints about underfunding the nhs funding needs should be kicked backed to the public. It's reasonable to expect the treatment paid for via taxation, but it is unreasonable to be so cavalier about non attendance. This was a procedure that cost the NHS £20k or more in salary costs... and two-thirds of the list were no shows. Can you tell that I am incensed for the people on waiting lists and the taxpayers funding the waste? For the record, the roads were all clear.

OP posts:
SchoolQuestionnaire · 14/12/2022 21:52

Wholeheartedly agree that people should attend schedules appointments, but my dm experienced the opposite. She was called with a last min cancellation appointment. I had to take a day off work unpaid to attend with herbut didn’t mind as I wanted my dm to be seen as soon as possible. Got there and no one knew anything about the appointment. We were there for an hour while the lovely lady on reception tried to resolve the issue to no avail. We arrived home to a phone call telling us that the person who arranged the appointment had forgotten to book it in on the system and we could return the next week. Fine but I had to take another day off work and my dm had to wait longer for her diagnosis. It wasn’t good and she was dead by the end of the week.

This was an extreme consequence but it wasn’t the first time we had attended nonexistent appointments (and had an apology because of an organisational cock up). I may have some sympathy if the hospitals could manage to resolve their own issues. As it stands they are pissing away public money through incompetence and I think the whole system should be overhauled. My experience isn’t of a system struggling as a result of non attendance by the public, it’s of a thoroughly incompetent system that doesn’t know it’s arse from its elbow.

Littleguggi · 14/12/2022 21:51

@RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway poor excuse, I'd have at least called to cancel the appointment, or emailed if I couldn't get through on the phone. At least then it would be classed a cancellation as opposed to DNA and it could give someone else the chance to be booked in, or staff to be deployed elsewhere for that day.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 14/12/2022 21:46

Perhaps the DNAs had tested positive for covid?

Purplechicken207 · 14/12/2022 21:39

cptartapp · 14/12/2022 14:33

Would that fee apply to everyone, of every age and circumstance? Or would it exempt the usual groups regardless - pensioners, children, those on benefits, penalising the poor sods in the middle yet again.

No idea, that's why I said I don't know how it would work. I'm in that middle bit too (and consider my children appointments to be my responsibility too). Of course many pensioners don't use text alerts and email, so there would need to be a robust system to give people every opportunity. And let's face it, the NHS could say 'you owe us £20' until blue in the face, unless they can easily enforce it, it means nothing. So it's all just hypothetical and would never happen. Just so annoying that we pay tax for a health system (which lets face it hasn't been properly funded for a good decade or in some cases managed properly) and people don't bother turning up. I'd be mortified if it is was me (though I wasn't for the one I missed as who the hell would expect a new section mum could drive to a postnatal appointment 40 mins away, especially when the expectation is that they're usually all home visits)

Dragonskin · 14/12/2022 21:07

*Really? I wouldn't (feel the same that is). Presuming it's important surgery, not a jolly id do anything to get seen sooner. Key to the idea is they would obviously tell the reserve people that they were reserve and it would be voluntary, so they wouldn't be expecting surgery and then going home disappointed but would know from the start they might not get seen - and if they didn't their next date would be definite.

You would need to have 1 day off work anyway, and if it was like ops example the surgery team would know early on whether the original appointees had turned up or not so the reserve people wouldn't be hanging around for hours not knowing.

I dont think you can make overall judgements about "people who work" anymore. So many people are semi-retired or work remotely and flexibly now - for me the inconvenience of making myself available for a few hours would be very minimal given the potential benefit so I wouldn't think twice about volunteering.

Obviously it wouldn't work for everyone or be completely fair for those who can't easily amend their working hours, dont live nearby, sort childcare or take time off, but no systems are equally fair for everyone - even if only a few people could be in the position to jump in last minute or wait around as a reserve that still makes the overall waiting times shorter for everyone and is better than appointments being completely wasted?*

Yes really, because that is not an insignificant list of circumstances that taking a day off 'just in case' you get seen doesn't work

Of course taking a day off for surgery isn't an issue (plus planning recovery time etc), taking a day off/rearranging everything and then finding out you aren't actually getting this long awaited surgery and will need to reorganise everything yet again pissing off work/calling in more favours for childcare and transport is not.

As you say it would only work if people volunteered to be 'on standby' and they gave people the chance to opt out of it

Personally my experience of the NHS is that they couldn't organise a piss up in a brewery so I wouldn't hold out hope either way

JenniferBooth · 14/12/2022 21:00

From the icy pavements thread

musicandpassion · Today 10:33
It's not unreasonable at all. It's dangerous and the paths aren't cleared even nearly enough. I'm going out today to get some grit for my drive and the end of our street.
I work in an NHS hospital and we have about 15-20 patients with fractured neck of femurs waiting to be fixed. We are cancelling elective operations to get these patients done but we're also struggling for beds for them to go to after they've been to theatre. Stay safe

RosesAndHellebores · 14/12/2022 20:55

Oh I don’t know there are tons of empty retail centres that could be converted.

XanaduKira · 14/12/2022 20:44

I agree @XingMing - we need to get the cottage style hospitals back to support getting people out of acute settings and into a step down facility prior to them being able to go to their long term setting (whether that's home or into a care facility etc).

I doubt that will happen though as they've sold off all those hospitals / land and it would cost far too much to get back to that sadly (& that's before you even get onto the point about wages for nurses!).

It needs proper funding and proper management as there are also too many senior managers, along with too many initiatives that don't support the staff or patients but which cost a fortune!

XingMing · 14/12/2022 20:02

@antelopevalley I'm certain the NHS needs enough money to cope with an increasingly elderly population, but there needs to be more attention to social care alongside the NHS. I spent most days in October visiting my late DMIL in a huge acute care hospital's orthopaedic trauma ward, spent in the highest-need bay with six beds occupied by very old women in varying states of physical frailty and dementia. Two doctors told us that it wasn't the right environment for her to get any better (not that she wanted to) and that a gentler recovery nursing care ward a step above the capability of her (excellent, self-funded) care home would have been better, but that such a place no longer exists.

OP posts:
thenightsky · 14/12/2022 19:55

AutumnCrow · 14/12/2022 15:17

I reckon that politically it could be sold that '3,000 more ward clerks are to be recruited to make sure that every patient gets to their appointment on time, ready and prepped, to save the NHS money and shorten waiting lists'.

Call them something old-fashioned like 'ward clerks' or 'traditional doctor's secretaries'. Like bringing back matrons. Anything to (a) improve things, and (b) get the Daily bloody Mail to not rubbish it out of hand.

However, the research needs to be used to pinpoint exactly where these people are needed and for what precise purpose. And for god's sake don't call them 'patient journey facilitators'. Just don't.

We used to have people who only dealt with appointments. They sat in clinics and rebooked follow up appointments with each patient as they left their appointment, thereby giving them an actual choice of date and time.

They were called Appointments Clerks (unsurprisingly). They took all the cancellation calls too and worked Saturdays running off the next week's lists, pulling the casenotes etc.

As these people retired or left for better paying work, they were never replaced and their work was outsourced to faceless companies who don't give a shit about patient care.

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 19:43

Except the reform the NHS needs is to be funded properly.
People forget in 2010 it was judged to be the best health service in the world.

XingMing · 14/12/2022 19:32

capx.co/without-reform-the-nhs-will-never-have-enough-staff/?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=14%2F12%2F2022+

The above is a link to an opinion about NHS productivity and staffing that covers some of the territory this thread has explored, including the shortcomings of appointment admin that was published today. It's not a very long read, so some people may find it interesting.

OP posts:
Moonatics · 14/12/2022 19:11

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/12/2022 04:58

The people suggesting that DNA'ers are charged for missing appointments..

HOW do you think this will work when the system can't currently cope, and is doing all the things multiple people in this thread have mentioned?

The letters arriving after the appointment date, the letters not arriving at all, appointments cancelled but patient not informed which are still recorded as a DNA, patients cancelling in plenty of time but recorded as a DNA, patients unable to attend as held up elsewhere in the SAME HOSPITAL, having informed the relevant department or asked for them to be informed recorded as DNA...

The list of fuckuppery goes on and on, its not one person, its not one area, it is nationwide, everyone I know, every single person, who even semi-frequently attends hospital or has medical appointments, has experienced at least one of these fuck ups.

So what chance they can run a DNA penalty fee properly, without adding to the burden and cost on the NHS?

Absolutely fucking zero.

Absolutely.
I have my first ever DNA last week.
My gp organised physio for me, he was adamant it would be an initial phone consult. Then from the call they would decide about inviting me in.
No phone call, because apparently I was supposed to go to (where I dont know because phone call doesnt need an address) the place to be investigated for my needs.

No letter, no text, no reminders at all which may have given me a clue that what I was expecting wasnt right.

That's just one reason why charging would be futile, unless the plan is to charge literally everyone and send all reminders on the day so everyone gets them too late and is charged. As a money making scheme, it has merit.

Add all the other reasons for people missing appointments (the eye clinic letter is particularly obstructive) it's amazing so many in fact make it to appointments.

2bazookas · 14/12/2022 17:45

I'm sure you're well aware that all patients had to be as well as possible for the best outcome of surgery and general anaesthesia ; normal temperature, no symptoms of infectious diseases like flu or covid.

It's winter, prime time for colds and flu which can affect breathing heart rate etc. There are major transport difficulties atm. Some of those patients may be far away.

Lucky DH that he is well enough for his operation and able to get to the hospital safely.

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 17:18

@AutumnCrow You may be right.

XingMing · 14/12/2022 16:54

I'm delighted that the majority agree that it's shocking to waste costly NHS resources so wantonly. I also hear the caveats about how and why admin processes can be cocked up completely by the post, and the difficulties of getting through to cancel impossible or unnecessary appointments.

And yes, councils should have been gritting pavements to avoid slips, trips and broken bones to protect the NHS.

Heaven knows what the solutions are. It's not all about more money, as the Times wrote this morning, although it might help in some areas. Winter is always tough in hospitals; some people and hospitals are better organised than others. IT seems to be a problem across the entire NHS, yet some of the high-tech procedures are dizzying.

I wouldn't always have been so bothered but my experiences over the last 18 months have made me both grateful and critical, and now I discover myself outraged on the NHS's behalf too.

OP posts:
Marigoldandivy · 14/12/2022 16:22

I attended an outpatients department last week and there was a sign saying that there had been over 300 missed appointments in the previous month. Even allowing for administrative mistakes and genuine reasons for not attending and not cancelling, that is staggering. I only had my appointment because there was a cancellation, and had been waiting since March. It is pretty irresponsible in my opinion.

Florenz · 14/12/2022 15:28

The NHS needs to get their house in order. It shouldn't even be possible to send someone appointment info with the wrong address on it.

AutumnCrow · 14/12/2022 15:17

I reckon that politically it could be sold that '3,000 more ward clerks are to be recruited to make sure that every patient gets to their appointment on time, ready and prepped, to save the NHS money and shorten waiting lists'.

Call them something old-fashioned like 'ward clerks' or 'traditional doctor's secretaries'. Like bringing back matrons. Anything to (a) improve things, and (b) get the Daily bloody Mail to not rubbish it out of hand.

However, the research needs to be used to pinpoint exactly where these people are needed and for what precise purpose. And for god's sake don't call them 'patient journey facilitators'. Just don't.

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 15:00

alloalloallo · 14/12/2022 14:57

Especially when you can blame the ‘feckless’ public for wasting ££££££ for not bothering to turn up for appointments.

Agreed. The tactic is always to blame the public. Always.

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 14:59

@RosesAndHellebores In the seventies my GP practice had receptionists.
They do lots of admin work. So you see the GP or consultant and they say you need tests for x, y and z. Most hospital Drs, and certainly on A and E, record on a voice recorder the tests that need to be ordered and dictate letters. Admin book tests, tell the patient when and where they are happening, write to the GP to keep them updated, including about the consultants diagnosis, and updates medical records. That can be from an 8 minute appointment with a Consultant. When you arrive to see someone for that 8 minute appointment, a referral will have been made so needs to be read and an appointment booked, you need to be informed about it, and then you go to reception to tell them you have turned up. There is a lot of admin if things are going to run properly.

JaggySplinter · 14/12/2022 14:58

You're not alone in the rage you fee about this. My now ex H DNA a surgical procedure because he decided on the day that the timing wasn't convenient for work any more. It was a turning point in my marriage to be honest. I couldn't imagine the selfishness or how he could honestly think what he did was ok. But he really didn't see my perspective at all.

alloalloallo · 14/12/2022 14:57

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 14:39

@RosesAndHellebores Nope. They know admin in the NHS has been cut so much it is a mess and know there is no political will to sort it. Because saying we are going to recruit 3,000 more admin workers does not get the votes that saying we are going to recruit 3,000 more nurses has.
And people bought into the lie that admin does not matter.

Especially when you can blame the ‘feckless’ public for wasting ££££££ for not bothering to turn up for appointments.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 14/12/2022 14:55

I missed a scan due to not getting a letter or notification. Just a call to say I’d missed it and now would have to go the the back of the waiting list.

RosesAndHellebores · 14/12/2022 14:53

@antelopevalley serious question. Why is more admin needed instead of modernisation? My GP surgery seems to have more receptionists, administrators, practice manager, assistant practice manager, than they do Dr's and nurses. I do wonder what the chuff some of them do because it doesn't seem to extend to answering the phone or attaching the correct reports to referrals or even dealing effectively with repeats. In the 60s we had a 2 GP practice. No receptionists. People just queued up and the Dr finished when everyone had been seen. Nice Dr had a long queue; grumpy Dr a short one. We always saw grumpy Dr and my mother made sure we arrived 20 minutes before the star of surgery so there were only two people ahead of us. The system seemed more respectful and more efficient too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread