Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if the NHS sends you an appointment for a significant surgical procedure, you turn up>

459 replies

XingMing · 13/12/2022 21:51

DH has waited two years for a (complicated) day surgery on his heart. He turned up for it at 7 am this morning and of the six scheduled booked patients, two arrived. There was a surgical team of ten arranged, who stood around waiting. If this is the normal, and the doctors, surgeons and nurses seemed to think it was, then complaints about underfunding the nhs funding needs should be kicked backed to the public. It's reasonable to expect the treatment paid for via taxation, but it is unreasonable to be so cavalier about non attendance. This was a procedure that cost the NHS £20k or more in salary costs... and two-thirds of the list were no shows. Can you tell that I am incensed for the people on waiting lists and the taxpayers funding the waste? For the record, the roads were all clear.

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 15/12/2022 20:55

antelopevalley · 14/12/2022 19:43

Except the reform the NHS needs is to be funded properly.
People forget in 2010 it was judged to be the best health service in the world.

Yes 👏
Funding has not kept up with population growth, ageing and inflation. That’s the real problem. Lack of funding means poor admin. Which means missed appointments.

Onnabugeisha · 15/12/2022 20:43

IndieK1d · 14/12/2022 07:46

Phone up to cancel it if you think you won't make it?

Its still recorded as a DNA when you call on the day of….so that’s not a solution

hollyjolls · 15/12/2022 20:41

panko · 13/12/2022 22:00

That is high. But you don't know the reasons.

It could be they missed a letter. They could have been relying on someone else to transport them to show up. They could have died.

If the patient had died, it will flag up on the patients records. At least in the trust I work for but I'm pretty sure it will be the case in most trusts.

hollyjolls · 15/12/2022 20:39

I work in the community outpatients and the DNA rates are appalling. Despite us now contacting all the patients via telephone a day or so before hand they still don't turn up. (The ones who DNA are always the ones who don't answer their phone, rather than simply letting us know so we can offer the appointment to someone else who is needing to be seen). It's so frustrating.

XingMing · 15/12/2022 20:19

@Moonatics, sanction isn't and wasn't my first thought. I know comms and appointments can be shite but if you read the post directly above, or nearly so, you'll see that I suggest three or five DNAs before asking for an appointment fee, to be refunded on attending. But I would rigidly impose whatever sanction is considered reasonable across the population from newborn to ancient, regardless of excuses. Somehow, we have to impose an understanding that the NHS is not free to abuse.

OP posts:
XingMing · 15/12/2022 20:12

@AutumnCrow, investigations on the scale of national population that we are talking about here suggests a whole parallel NHS to investigate the problems. The NHS is already among the world's largest employers, behind the Chinese Army and Walmart, so replicating it would scupper the whole UK economy. So three (or five?) DNAs would suggest to me that the patient is not taking treatment seriously, and should be sanctioned and perhaps asked for a card deposit payment before further appointments were finalised. Refunded on attendance but forfeited if DNA... for children and everyone else too. My DMIL could not at 93 with dementia have gone to any hospital appointment without a carer's assistance, and locally we were able to book appointments to accommodate carer availability, even if we/DMIL had to pay extra time for the carer. Her GP wanted a chest X-ray, but I booked it to suit us both, so I chose the mini hospital not the big one. And then they were resurfacing the car park!

And, being fortunate, our postal services are functioning well, even with no-delivery strike days. It must be much more difficult if there's a huge backlog, but this is a rural low-income backwater and public sector jobs are considered well-paid here.

OP posts:
Moonatics · 15/12/2022 19:19

XingMing · 15/12/2022 15:54

My original post was born out of indignation and frustration on Tuesday, after the day case surgery that DH attended had 66% DNAs. I don't know that much about it as I'm not involved professionally, so it's based on my experience and what HCPs have said to me. Obviously, I have read the whole thread (only polite). Because we only have one big general hospital within 50 miles, it's the only one I know, but I've had breast cancer and auto-immune ezcema over the last 18 months, and DH has a 15 year history of heart problems, plus we've recently had to assist the residental care unit organising appointments for DMIL (93 with dementia), until she fell and fractured her femur, so I have seen a lot of it recently!

It's well-evidenced that all hospitals' appointment systems are not the same, and no two departments within the same hospital communicate with any of the rest, but either we have been incredibly lucky or the hospital is actually organised enough to send appointment letters out several weeks ahead, followed by text reminders and a live confirmation phone call to check that the patient is attending. The timing often runs late, but sometimes a clinic speeds up too. I can see how difficult transport might be if you can't or don't drive, and that last-minute appointments are a PITA if you work shifts or have an unhelpful employer.

However, as hospitals are for ill people, most people will feel stressed or worried about what's happening to them/the patient.

My experience of mutualised French medicine is that it works better for patients, because it's so much less centralised and the patient is more in control of when and where to seek treatment. And now, the cost is not much higher than the NHS while the outcomes are significantly better. I lived in the US too, and we all know that healthcare there can be either brilliant, if you have solid medical benefits, or dreadful if not.

My instinct says that fining DNAs isn't the right approach and would quickly turn into a bureaucratic collection nightmare. But failures to attend need some form of sanction. I just don't know what would be fair. That's why I asked what the hive thought.

Why is sanction your first thought?
All the many many reasons so many people have put here on your thread and your first idea is let's sanction them.

If we go down the sanction route then the NHS better get used to it too. All the sanctions when they fail to send letters in time, cancel at the last minute, book appointments for a day when who you need to see isnt even in. And on and on. I suspect that inside a month the sainted NHS will be bankrupt.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/12/2022 17:11

Tryingtokeepgoing · 15/12/2022 06:07

I’d be okay with that, assuming that the patient had chosen when the appointment was, and if patients got compensated every time the NHS was late for an appointment or messed up administratively. The number of times we’d turn up for an appointment at 9, along with a dozen other people, and then not be seen until midday. Almost as if they think their time is more important than the patients…

But their time is more important, really. Because they are the people who hopefully are going to find out what ails you, and even more hopefully, how to put it right.
Ive sat in hundreds of clinics etc in the past few years, and it is annoying when your appointment says ‘9.30’ and you realise that actually that means the morning clinic. It’s even more weird when you can’t work out why someone who comes in after you gets seen before you…..but I have also seen all the people who turn up at midday for the morning clinic, who don’t turn up at all ( well, haven’t seen them but been told, obviously) who have not bothered to follow the instructions about bringing medication, or taking their preparations, the people in the lung clinic who stink of smoke…..

So it is tedious, but my relative is still alive eight years later, which would not have been the case without all those visits. So the doctors’ time was more important, really.

ohioriver · 15/12/2022 16:43

What sort of sanction would you envisage for my DNA when I was actually at a hospital at another hospital at the time. An important appointment (more important - it was a surgery review).

cezannesapple · 15/12/2022 16:40

cezannesapple · 15/12/2022 16:39

I’ve had an urgent referral to a breast clinic and got a phone call yesterday that I couldn’t take. She left a message with the time and date of my appointment, no number to call back and when I managed to find a number, no-one answering calls. This is normal as far as I am concerned. I always drop everything to attend my appointments but this time I many not get there because of rail strikes. I don’t know how the hell to inform them if they won’t pick up or allow me to leave a message. It’s just rubbish and adds anxiety to an already anxious time. They need to do better in making themselves available to patients to contact them.

I should add we haven’t had any post for over two weeks in our area and no sign of anything coming through so a letter for an appointment just wouldn’t reach me.

cezannesapple · 15/12/2022 16:39

I’ve had an urgent referral to a breast clinic and got a phone call yesterday that I couldn’t take. She left a message with the time and date of my appointment, no number to call back and when I managed to find a number, no-one answering calls. This is normal as far as I am concerned. I always drop everything to attend my appointments but this time I many not get there because of rail strikes. I don’t know how the hell to inform them if they won’t pick up or allow me to leave a message. It’s just rubbish and adds anxiety to an already anxious time. They need to do better in making themselves available to patients to contact them.

AutumnCrow · 15/12/2022 16:15

Why sanction, OP? Why not investigation?

Busybody2022 · 15/12/2022 16:13

There's so much illness presently I wouldn't be surprised if for important surgery most cancellations are illness related

Itstoocoldoutthere · 15/12/2022 16:12

I have voted that YABU. My reason is that this week my DH was sent (by email that I still have forwrding set up for) details of an NHS appointment that had been arranged for him in March.

He died more than two years ago. I wonder how many other DNAs have died whilst waiting for an appointment.

PearlclutchersInc · 15/12/2022 16:08

The majority of the clinics I attend send text reminders which are great.

The one that didn't sent (allegedly) an appt letter which I didn't receive. Fortunately it was a phone checkup so not much harm was done. That said it really annoyed me as I hate being late or a no show for anything like that.

XingMing · 15/12/2022 15:54

My original post was born out of indignation and frustration on Tuesday, after the day case surgery that DH attended had 66% DNAs. I don't know that much about it as I'm not involved professionally, so it's based on my experience and what HCPs have said to me. Obviously, I have read the whole thread (only polite). Because we only have one big general hospital within 50 miles, it's the only one I know, but I've had breast cancer and auto-immune ezcema over the last 18 months, and DH has a 15 year history of heart problems, plus we've recently had to assist the residental care unit organising appointments for DMIL (93 with dementia), until she fell and fractured her femur, so I have seen a lot of it recently!

It's well-evidenced that all hospitals' appointment systems are not the same, and no two departments within the same hospital communicate with any of the rest, but either we have been incredibly lucky or the hospital is actually organised enough to send appointment letters out several weeks ahead, followed by text reminders and a live confirmation phone call to check that the patient is attending. The timing often runs late, but sometimes a clinic speeds up too. I can see how difficult transport might be if you can't or don't drive, and that last-minute appointments are a PITA if you work shifts or have an unhelpful employer.

However, as hospitals are for ill people, most people will feel stressed or worried about what's happening to them/the patient.

My experience of mutualised French medicine is that it works better for patients, because it's so much less centralised and the patient is more in control of when and where to seek treatment. And now, the cost is not much higher than the NHS while the outcomes are significantly better. I lived in the US too, and we all know that healthcare there can be either brilliant, if you have solid medical benefits, or dreadful if not.

My instinct says that fining DNAs isn't the right approach and would quickly turn into a bureaucratic collection nightmare. But failures to attend need some form of sanction. I just don't know what would be fair. That's why I asked what the hive thought.

OP posts:
AclowncalledAlice · 15/12/2022 14:27

Talaforniababe · 15/12/2022 11:48

If they had to pay, they'd definitely turn up...

So if appointment A clashes with appointment B and despite trying you couldn't get hold of anyone to cancel 1 of those appointments ,they would still have to pay as a DNA....unless you have the ability to be in 2 places at the same time, that's not really going to work is it?

Doormatnomore · 15/12/2022 13:46

I already posted about calling weekly to check on a referral, to eventually be told they’d been trying to make contact and I hadn’t got back to them so a new referral was needed. They called this morning with an appointment next week, I am grateful for the appointment but if I’d kept waiting for the letter it would never have come. I was told ut would be 6 months to 2 years though so I don’t know what to believe.

Itdjgsurchg · 15/12/2022 13:41

I work in a GP out of hours surgery and the amount of people that don’t turn up for appointments is ridiculous and so frustrating, especially when people can’t complain about getting appointments.

AutumnCrow · 15/12/2022 13:36

antelopevalley · 15/12/2022 10:05

I agree chaotic people miss appointments and there is no sense in demonising them. Paying would make zero difference, they would just go without healthcare.

I agree.

There was a thread on here not that long ago where the abusive DH was using the tactic of threatening to withhold transport from the OP to get her to a hospital appointment for surgery the following morning. She couldn't drive herself, had very little access to money, and was rural. The relationship was breaking down but she needed to rely on an unreliable man.

Different people are 'chaotic' in different ways.

It would be almost impossible to weed out the actual arrogant wankers from those who are in some way vulnerable and for whom a fine would be catastrophic.

Moonatics · 15/12/2022 13:19

Talaforniababe · 15/12/2022 11:48

If they had to pay, they'd definitely turn up...

Unless they don't even know about the bloody appointment.
As I already said, only last week I was supposed to have (according to GP who booked it) a phone consult. Which after the fact turned out to be a physical in a set place appointment. One, I would never have made it there being unable to drive or in fact leave the house, two, as it was supposed to be over the phone I had no bloody idea where the place was. Never given an address, why would i for a phone consult?

But if we were going to go down the fining people route, then it has to be two way. Next time i go to the GP for anything at all and I'm waiting an hour past my set consult time, i want to fine them, and then they can phone my workplace to say why I'm so late back.
And if it's a hospital thing I want more money, because it probably will cost me a day off, then another when its inexplicably cancelled.

Spendonsend · 15/12/2022 13:13

Having recieved appointment letters after the date of the appointment and having attempted to cancel appointment by phoning, leaving messages and so on, i have some sympathy that some of these missing people didnt know they were supposed to be there, or had rung and cancelled but the message never got to the right place.

TheOtherHotstepper · 15/12/2022 13:13

My DMIL had dementia and was in the 'care' of her DD. She DNAed all her medical appointments in the last five years if her life because SIL simply hid the letters and ignored them. We found them after DMIL died. Maybe safeguarding reports should extend to elderly people who DNA as well as children.

I have experienced most of what PPs have said, including not receiving the letter confirming my surgery appointment and having an OP appointment cancelled by letter which arrived at home while I was already sitting in the waiting room!

NHS admin has been shocking for years and is getting worse.

notanothertakeaway · 15/12/2022 12:53

Talaforniababe · 15/12/2022 11:48

If they had to pay, they'd definitely turn up...

@Talaforniababe

For some people, Yes

For many, No

mondaytosunday · 15/12/2022 12:33

Yes they should. But my son turned up for a minor operation, taking unpaid leave, only to be told it had been cancelled as no doctor in.
Same thing happened to me last year.
If they cancel they should bloody well inform people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread