Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if the NHS sends you an appointment for a significant surgical procedure, you turn up>

459 replies

XingMing · 13/12/2022 21:51

DH has waited two years for a (complicated) day surgery on his heart. He turned up for it at 7 am this morning and of the six scheduled booked patients, two arrived. There was a surgical team of ten arranged, who stood around waiting. If this is the normal, and the doctors, surgeons and nurses seemed to think it was, then complaints about underfunding the nhs funding needs should be kicked backed to the public. It's reasonable to expect the treatment paid for via taxation, but it is unreasonable to be so cavalier about non attendance. This was a procedure that cost the NHS £20k or more in salary costs... and two-thirds of the list were no shows. Can you tell that I am incensed for the people on waiting lists and the taxpayers funding the waste? For the record, the roads were all clear.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 16/12/2022 03:39

Here's another as this happened today (well, yesterday now)...

Physio appointment not at hospital, private clinic being used by the NHS (i dont know how that works, I am an NHS patient, not paying for private treatment)...

I had made it clear when the referral was made, that the referring doctor needed to spell out I am a wheelchair user. I need an accessible venue, and due to my size and my disabilities, my power chair is pretty large.

This was apparently understood, I was sat in front of the referring doctor IN said chair at the time.

I was assured the venue was indeed accessible.

I trundled along there today - guess what?

No. It wasn't accessible, nor would it have been accessible had I been in a tiny narrow manual chair, never mind a hulking power chair. The ramp offered was also not fit for purpose (too short and steep, not nearly strong enough for the weight of me + chair, I declined to try it), and in any case when someone got out a measuring tape, the door not wide enough to get through.

I sat, in the freezing cold on the street, during this humiliation.

Then I was told 'we'll have to record this as 'did not attend, tell your GP to refer you elsewhere'. I wouldn't bet that the reason why I could not attend was actually noted anywhere, just a DNA box ticked.

I actually don't give a fuck whose fault this was, it wasn't mine. But this is NOT a one off, not by a long shot.

I have had to wait in corridors rather than waiting rooms - waiting room not accessible (to any wheelchair user, not just one with my specialist needs) and been missed because I was called in the waiting room, and no one came out into the corridor as promised.

I have had to have CONSULTS in corridors or jammed in a doorway, rather than in the room in private... and been refused on a couple of occasions as the consultant wasn't comfy with that, but again, recorded as DNA.

I have been left without my chair (A&E then admitted to ward, you can't take a wheelchair in an emergency ambulance) and huffing and puffing when I ask someone to read my notes rather than bark 'surely you can manage it, it's not far', at me pointing out i CAN'T WALK and do not have my chair... I missed an appointment in the same hospital that way too, told a porter would fetch me. They didn't, and no one informed the department two floors down where I was and why I wasn't there.

I have missed countless appointments because they were not in ANY way accessible to me, because hospitals and other venues are NOT accessible.

So before we start sanctioning DNA's, a huge overhaul is necessary - and it won't happen, because beating patients with the 'well you lot waste our time' is far easier and a great way to suggest the NHS is a poor system and could be sold off and run better privately.

RunLolaRun102 · 15/12/2022 23:40

XingMing · 13/12/2022 21:51

DH has waited two years for a (complicated) day surgery on his heart. He turned up for it at 7 am this morning and of the six scheduled booked patients, two arrived. There was a surgical team of ten arranged, who stood around waiting. If this is the normal, and the doctors, surgeons and nurses seemed to think it was, then complaints about underfunding the nhs funding needs should be kicked backed to the public. It's reasonable to expect the treatment paid for via taxation, but it is unreasonable to be so cavalier about non attendance. This was a procedure that cost the NHS £20k or more in salary costs... and two-thirds of the list were no shows. Can you tell that I am incensed for the people on waiting lists and the taxpayers funding the waste? For the record, the roads were all clear.

You’ll be surprised how many of then would have died / been admitted to A&E while they wait for their op & the consultants / nurses have no idea.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 15/12/2022 23:34

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/12/2022 17:11

But their time is more important, really. Because they are the people who hopefully are going to find out what ails you, and even more hopefully, how to put it right.
Ive sat in hundreds of clinics etc in the past few years, and it is annoying when your appointment says ‘9.30’ and you realise that actually that means the morning clinic. It’s even more weird when you can’t work out why someone who comes in after you gets seen before you…..but I have also seen all the people who turn up at midday for the morning clinic, who don’t turn up at all ( well, haven’t seen them but been told, obviously) who have not bothered to follow the instructions about bringing medication, or taking their preparations, the people in the lung clinic who stink of smoke…..

So it is tedious, but my relative is still alive eight years later, which would not have been the case without all those visits. So the doctors’ time was more important, really.

I disagree. Getting 10 or 12 plus people to turn up and hang around from the beginning of a clinic time, many with parters/relatives, means that 50 plus hours of peoples time is wasted to keep 3 hours of a doctor happy. That’s bonkers. Those 50 contribute more to GDP in that morning than the doctor, though they can’t work independent of each other of course. The doctor is there for the same amount of time whether people have 20 minute slots that they’re asked to arrive to, or all in a herd The clinic model is purely to cover up inefficiencies elsewhere. It shouldn’t be tolerated by patients, and wouldn’t be in any other developed country. It also in part I am sure explains the no shows. Regulars know that 9am doesn’t mean 9. It means somewhere between 9 and 12. And if the hospital doesn’t care enough to be precise, why should a patient be precise about when they turn up?

Rushingfool · 15/12/2022 23:26

My df tried to cancel an appointment recently because he'd just come out of hospital after a heart bypass operation and was unable to manage; would have tried to reschedule for a few weeks later but after waiting for 90 minutes on the phone, yes 90, he gave up. Maybe that's why some are DNAs - they've actually tried to cancel but been unable.

IAmADancer · 15/12/2022 23:17

@XingMing thanks for starting a great thread, that hasn’t gone down the usual route of it’s all the Tories fault.

I think there are so many valid points on this thread about the NHS. I think that it’s become so scared that it is very hard to have an honest conversation about it and there are, unfortunately, many many cases of wastage, mismanagement, DNA’s, an very elderly population with lots of co-morbidities, an obesity epidemic costing the NHS millions every year , etc. I do think Dr’s and nurses should be paid more for the job they do but I do wonder how much money could be saved and used to pay staff properly if the public didn’t take it for granted and if we started to look after ourself a bit better and take more responsibility.

blameless · 15/12/2022 22:41

melj1213 · 15/12/2022 11:47

I think everyone should contribute something towards the NHS

Sort of like a tax?

There's some accounting chicanery around the additional National Insurance that goes to the NHS. It always gets spent first, so savings are always against other lines in the accounts.
Underspends were more than the money on the side of the bus in the last published accounts - almost £400m per week.

GimmeBiscuits · 15/12/2022 22:40

Not quite the same as your DHs situation, but just to offer an interesting dimension - a friend of mine has some significant MH issues and is on a lot of mediation, as well as having some chronic health conditions which require monitoring etc.
Friend recently sustained an injury and phoned to cancel a health check. When they spoke to the relevant person, they were asked if they nweded to cancel their medication review.
The thing is, they knew nothing about the medication review. Someone in the MH team had made an appointment for them, but they hadn't been informed.*
The process is such that if you simply don't turn up, you are then 'blacklisted' and go to the back of the appointments queue.*

*This is how my friend described it to me, from their own experience

Onnabugeisha · 15/12/2022 22:36

XingMing · 15/12/2022 22:20

@Onnabugeisha I would be happy to turn that dimension over to you to run and organise, because it's not something I know anything about. If you thought it could be done with a sample size of 5, or 500, once I understood your qualifications, I'd tell you to get on with the task. Come back with a solution, please.

And I don't think the two situations are poles apart as you suggest. Most of us, and I include myself, could probably live healthier. I could be 5kg thinner which wouldn't hurt. But I think we need to consider health and nutrition more wholistically, but still with an eye on what's realistic, affordable and accessible to most of the people, most of the time. Food production and consumption play directly into public health.

Well, as I said it would use multiple threads of inquiry:

  • data mining could be done to find # missed appointments and # cancellations with a few key strokes and that could cover all appointments NHS wide. Probably could go back 5yrs at least. This would give you an initial DNA rate. Your 66% rate is on a sample size of too tiny to mean anything, but I’m sure you know that already.
  • then you could do Trust cases which would be all appointments in representative trusts get reasons for DNAs for past 30 days. Sample size would be at least 5,000 I would say.
  • then you’d do a You.gov survey which would run itself and probably be a few thousand minimum, more if well advertised.
  • you could add a question to the NHS patient satisfaction surveys that already go out, and then those survey managers would then feed the team the responses for that one question & demographics. This piggybacking would get you another 5,000 or so.

Not sure what you mean about qualifications….been Director level in civil service so very familiar with the FTEs needed to get this sort of task done. It’s not as unusual as you think. We’d often get the Ministers office sending such a question on the fly just for a debate in the Commons. Or do you not know how political footballs result in a constant snowfall of data requests? Running a government organisation is nothing like running a business (done both) as you have more top down demands for data due to the need for public transparency and to justify every penny spent.

So, yes 5 people for a few months could do a very thorough job of answering why DNAs happen. I suspect it’s not happening because the current government knows the answer would not be the narrative you have bought of lazy, entitled patients not bothering to show up… and that these DNAs being CBAs are actually isolated incidents.

XingMing · 15/12/2022 22:35

Signing off for tonight. Please keep adding to the conversation.

OP posts:
XingMing · 15/12/2022 22:31

Jonnypiratesfriend, your situation with a very ill child is absolutely NOT what is being talked about here. You clearly have more urgent things to worry about. Sending my best for your lad xx

OP posts:
Johnnypiratesfriend · 15/12/2022 22:26

My son is often in hospital - more time in hospital than out of hospital. He has lots of missed appointments.
One if which they actually rang at 10am to check he was well. I said he was well and I was packing his bag. We have a SATs machine at home so all good. We missed his 3pm procedure because at 2pm we were blue lighted to hospital. This was the 4 time he had missed it. I genuinely wish things could be different.

XingMing · 15/12/2022 22:23

I have NOT on this thread ever suggested that people CBA'd to atteb=nd, although I think some can't. My OP asked why the no-show rate could be so high. 66% in the example I gave.

OP posts:
XingMing · 15/12/2022 22:20

@Onnabugeisha I would be happy to turn that dimension over to you to run and organise, because it's not something I know anything about. If you thought it could be done with a sample size of 5, or 500, once I understood your qualifications, I'd tell you to get on with the task. Come back with a solution, please.

And I don't think the two situations are poles apart as you suggest. Most of us, and I include myself, could probably live healthier. I could be 5kg thinner which wouldn't hurt. But I think we need to consider health and nutrition more wholistically, but still with an eye on what's realistic, affordable and accessible to most of the people, most of the time. Food production and consumption play directly into public health.

OP posts:
Invisibleeye · 15/12/2022 22:03

That is shocking OP! They should be ashamed of themselves. I was recently 10 mins into a appointment the staff very apologetically asked if I could please step outside for a moment so they can do the height and weight of another patient. No problem for me at all and they were very apologetic saying “sorry to be so unprofessional”. Anyway it transpired that the lady they needed the stats for was meant to have her appointment at 1pm but had just sauntered in at gone half 2! Then when I left she was outside insisting she just needed to pop to the loo quickly instead of fill out the paperwork she was meant to have brought with her already completed. I couldn’t believe it! It was just plain disrespectful of the NHS professionals’ time and resources. I don’t know if it’s a sense of entitlement or they just don’t care but I can’t get my head around people who behave this way!

Onnabugeisha · 15/12/2022 21:59

XingMing · 15/12/2022 21:43

Across the population of 70 million people? Somehow I dont see five people digesting that and getting to a recommendation. Public inquiries run for years and end up costing millions. I am not even suggesting that patient abuse is a serious problem because most people in contact with the NHS are at least concerned if not ill.

Most low to mid income taxpayers do not pay enough in tax to cover what they take out of the "system" and I wouldn't expect them to. Society takes more from those who earn much more to subsidise them; it's over a lifetime, rather than year by year. I think that's fair and reasonable.

When I write "not free to abuse", I'd like you to understand that I mean nothing worse than trying a salt water gargle for a child's sore throat, and then visiting the pharmacist, before rushing to the GP for an antibiotic prescription for something that a healthy immune system will deal with in a few days. We are rushing into a situation where there will not be antibiotic remedies for major health issues because too many people over-medicate childhood ailments and cause microbial resistance to much more serious problems. And because industrial meat production uses too many antibiotics to rear cheap meat under unhealthy conditions.

Well, you wouldn’t be asking all 70 million people. 🤨
So yes a 5 person team could do it in a few months if you wanted to be thorough. It would involve a bit of data mining. Then a patient survey of a decent sample size- you’d select various Trusts in representative regions for England, Scotland and Wales to cover urban and rural so you could get some granularity in the data. Could even do a You.gov survey to augment the results and get a feel for whether demographics and digital divide played a part.

When I write "not free to abuse", I'd like you to understand that I mean nothing worse than trying a salt water gargle for a child's sore throat, and then visiting the pharmacist, before rushing to the GP for an antibiotic prescription for something that a healthy immune system will deal with in a few days.

Thats a completely different context to your comments about patients who “can’t be arsed” to attend appointments and your comments on sanctions/fines after 3-5 DNAs for every patient from newborn to elderly. I’m not sure why you’re trying to say that your comments & agreement with others comments along this line was really about the over use of antibiotics (which doesn’t even happen anymore and hasn’t for a decade at least both in the NHS and in livestock farming). The Strep A crisis is a clear case of reluctance to prescribe antibiotics.

XingMing · 15/12/2022 21:55

If we were ever given trust-specific stats, it would be a lot more straightforward to see which trusts performed well and which didn't. And then, the public like you and I could ask that the underperformers followed the systems that got the best results. How is that controversial?

OP posts:
romdowa · 15/12/2022 21:48

In the trust that I lived in , it was nearly impossible to re schedule and appointment. Nobody answered the phones. I'm guessed my trust had a high number of dnas because people couldn't cancel. My appointment was for when I was on holidays and I tried for 2 days to cancel. So in the end I gave up.

XingMing · 15/12/2022 21:47

I am not viewing this through a political lens.

OP posts:
XingMing · 15/12/2022 21:43

Across the population of 70 million people? Somehow I dont see five people digesting that and getting to a recommendation. Public inquiries run for years and end up costing millions. I am not even suggesting that patient abuse is a serious problem because most people in contact with the NHS are at least concerned if not ill.

Most low to mid income taxpayers do not pay enough in tax to cover what they take out of the "system" and I wouldn't expect them to. Society takes more from those who earn much more to subsidise them; it's over a lifetime, rather than year by year. I think that's fair and reasonable.

When I write "not free to abuse", I'd like you to understand that I mean nothing worse than trying a salt water gargle for a child's sore throat, and then visiting the pharmacist, before rushing to the GP for an antibiotic prescription for something that a healthy immune system will deal with in a few days. We are rushing into a situation where there will not be antibiotic remedies for major health issues because too many people over-medicate childhood ailments and cause microbial resistance to much more serious problems. And because industrial meat production uses too many antibiotics to rear cheap meat under unhealthy conditions.

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 15/12/2022 21:37

XingMing · 15/12/2022 21:07

The NHS has 200,000 more staff than in 2010. That's in the article I linked yesterday @antelopevalley . Population growth, ageing and inflation are all factors making it tougher, but it isn't quite as simple as starving the NHS of funds. Some of it is the failure to use the resources properly. And, please, don't come back with the PPE corruption trope. We all understand that in a crisis (which it was) some money is wasted, because nobody knows what will work best or most efficiently. Haul Mone over the coals by due process as and when; recover any ill-gotten gains. Happy to see that happen.

It is that simple actually.
The failure to use resources “properly” is due to chronic underfunding leading to chronic under-staffing. You need sufficient staff in order to be efficient with resources.

This thread is a small survey, but even so the vast majority of DNAs recounted here are not due to patient abuse of the NHS because they “can’t be arsed” to attend appointments.

I’d suggest you have a look here to start btw:
nhsfunding.info

Onnabugeisha · 15/12/2022 21:18

I think @Moonatics is correct some sort of investigation or public inquiry should first be done to find the reasons for the DNAs. Because your statement:
Somehow, we have to impose an understanding that the NHS is not free to abuse. Is a gross assumption that the cause of the DNAs is due to patient abuse. How do you even know this is the cause without some sort of study? And only, it wouldn’t require a ‘parallel NHS’ to do this. A five person investigation team working for a few months could do it.

XingMing · 15/12/2022 21:10

Apologies, the post above should have been addressed to @Onnabugeisha , not @antelopevalley .

OP posts:
XingMing · 15/12/2022 21:07

The NHS has 200,000 more staff than in 2010. That's in the article I linked yesterday @antelopevalley . Population growth, ageing and inflation are all factors making it tougher, but it isn't quite as simple as starving the NHS of funds. Some of it is the failure to use the resources properly. And, please, don't come back with the PPE corruption trope. We all understand that in a crisis (which it was) some money is wasted, because nobody knows what will work best or most efficiently. Haul Mone over the coals by due process as and when; recover any ill-gotten gains. Happy to see that happen.

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 15/12/2022 21:01

SoShallINever · 14/12/2022 22:06

Of course it wouldn't. Provision can be, and already is, arranged for that.

Such as? I’ve seen no such thing for my friends DM who has suffered several strokes and has memory issues due to them.

AutumnCrow · 15/12/2022 20:56

hollyjolls · 15/12/2022 20:41

If the patient had died, it will flag up on the patients records. At least in the trust I work for but I'm pretty sure it will be the case in most trusts.

Just on this thread there have been posts saying that this 'flagging' isn't happening, and the bereaved relative has been contacted about a 'DNA' of someone who died six months prior.

The way that data is held by the NHS is a patchwork of inefficiency, alas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread