Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if the NHS sends you an appointment for a significant surgical procedure, you turn up>

459 replies

XingMing · 13/12/2022 21:51

DH has waited two years for a (complicated) day surgery on his heart. He turned up for it at 7 am this morning and of the six scheduled booked patients, two arrived. There was a surgical team of ten arranged, who stood around waiting. If this is the normal, and the doctors, surgeons and nurses seemed to think it was, then complaints about underfunding the nhs funding needs should be kicked backed to the public. It's reasonable to expect the treatment paid for via taxation, but it is unreasonable to be so cavalier about non attendance. This was a procedure that cost the NHS £20k or more in salary costs... and two-thirds of the list were no shows. Can you tell that I am incensed for the people on waiting lists and the taxpayers funding the waste? For the record, the roads were all clear.

OP posts:
AclowncalledAlice · 13/12/2022 23:44

I tried to cancel an appointment but couldn't get through despite numerous attempts. I couldn't go as it was scheduled for the day of my best friends funeral so not something trivial.

Buteverythingsfine · 13/12/2022 23:43

But you are continuing to be cross at the minority of just shit people who don't care, when you've been told there are a lot of systemic reasons why people don't attend.

Equally, we attend on time, but don't get the NHS service because it's late or not happening. We've had four hospital appointments in the past two weeks (unlucky). One happened, but the consultant wasn't there, no idea why so no decision could be taken without him so fairly pointless to go. One was a telephone appointment with CAMHS and they never phoned, no idea why. I know their whole database packed in about 6 months ago, so they don't know who has appointments. One was a clinic, the appointment was one hour and 30 minutes late. One happened within ten minutes and was what was promised. So one out of four happened within a reasonable timescale and was what was supposed to occur. It is not just patients who are not there and not on time (not that I blame the individual staff, I blame the whole NHS underfunding!)

The system is creaking. In a creaky system, the poor (depending on public transport, lifts, hospital transport), the elderly, the disabled, the mentally ill all lose out because they struggle with the system. Blaming a few individuals who don't care (and for sure they exist) is not entirely fair at all.

melj1213 · 13/12/2022 23:42

There are so many reasons why people might DNA and only a small minority will be people who CBA, a lot is down to NHS admin and lack of communication and continuity of care. Letters not being sent out on time or with exceptionally short notice (post marked less than 48hrs before the appointment); letters getting lost in the post (especially atm with postal strikes); no transport (cancelled public transport due to strikes/weather; lifts just not turning up etc); emergencies with children/family that take precedence (once missed a physio appointment because DD had had an accident at school and I was in A&E with her and I'd totally forgotten to call them); no or limited ways to cancel appointments (the phone just rings out and there's no way to even leave a message, if there's a contact number at all, or there's only someone in the booking office Monday and Tuesday so if you get a letter on Wednesday for a Monday appointment there is literally no way to cancel); messages not being passed on; different departments in the same hospital sending out appointments for the same time or overrunning (I once had 2 appointments in two different departments in the same hospital about 3hrs apart, I DNAed the second one because the first clinic was so behind I was called in for my 1st appointment 10 mins before I was supposed to be at the 2nd, and nobody answered when I tried to call the 2nd clinic reception when it was clear I wouldn't make both appts); patients being taken into hospital for another medical issue and informing their doctor of an existing appointment and then not passing on the message (happened to my great uncle a few weeks ago - was due to see rheumatology on a Tuesday afternoon but fell and broke his arm at work on Monday morning. It needed pins so they operated Monday afternoon and kept him on a ward. He explained he had an appointment on Tuesday afternoon and they promised they would inform the other dept that he was an inpatient. 2 weeks later he got a discharge letter from rheumatology for DNAing and he had to go through a whole string of phone calls and send them an email with his orthopedic discharge papers before they would accept that he had a valid reason for not attending and added him back to their list)

I had surgery in April this year ... And there were so many places where communication was lacking due to the non joined up nature of the NHS systems. It should have happened in January but due to another health issue it was postponed to March. In March, on the day of surgery it was cancelled (due to theatre staff having COVID they cancelled anything except emergency procedures due to staffing levels) and postponed till April.

Firstly for each surgery date I had to do a 2 week COVID isolation at home to make sure I didn't have it before my surgery ... For my January 19th surgery they called me on January 3rd to say my surgery date was the 19th and I needed to go into isolation as of the 5th. I work in retail so fortunately January is a pretty quiet month but even so it was massively short notice (I had told my boss that I was having surgery and knew it would be the start of the year, but not exactly when, but I expected I'd get more than 2 days notice).

When it was cancelled the first time I asked them to give me more notice for the second one ... Same thing happened, got a call on Friday saying I had to go into isolation from Monday ... two weeks later it ironically was cancelled due to staff having COVID. By the 3rd date at the end of April I knew I would t have much notice and again was told 4 days before I had to go into isolation, only to get to the hospital on the day to be told "Oh you don't have to do 2weeks now, just 48hrs from your COVID test ... did nobody tell you they'd changed things at the start of April?"

For each surgery date I had to arrange for the District Nurse to come 15 days after surgery to remove my staples as it apparently couldn't be done by my GPs practice nurse (Op was done at a hospital 3hrs away so not practical to return just for a few staples to be removed). Because the op was done in a different NHS trust they couldn't liase directly with the DN so I had to call them and leave a message saying when my op was and when I would need to see them but since they are only in the office Tuesday and Thursday 9-11am it took over a week for them to get back to me and confirm the appointment to come and visit me.

When the first two dates were cancelled I left multiple messages on the phone and email saying my surgery had been postponed and therefore no longer needed the appointment (both with at least a weeks notice) and could someone call me to confirm they had received the messages. Both times I had a DN turn up at my house on the appointment day and then act annoyed that I hadn't cancelled despite the evidence I had of calling/emailing to cancel.

My favourite miscommunication though was that after surgery I have follow up calls with the surgeon booked for 3 weeks post op, 6weeks post op, 12 weeks post op and then every three months for the first year. When I recieved the email with my surgery date (following the late notice phone call) I also received the dates for my follow ups. When my first two ops were postponed I asked if they were going to cancel my post op appointments and they said they would automatically be cancelled. I still recieved reminder texts and emails for each one and then messages saying I had DNAed so I had to call the office each time to be told "Oh sorry it's still in the system, I've sorted it so it won't happen again" (reader, it happened again and again and again). For my 3rd date I was booked in at the end of April which was 12 weeks after my original date. I'm day 2 post op and lying in my hospital bed when my phone rings so I answer it only to hear my surgeon introducing himself on the other end.

When I ask why he's calling me, considering that I'd seen him only an hour previously on his rounds, he was utterly confused as he was calling his January patients for their 3month follow up and he apologised as he assumed my file had got mixed up on his desk. Somehow my name was still on his January surgery list despite the fact I was physically in the hospital and he had operated on me less than 48hrs previously!

There are so many ways that things can be mismanaged when everyone on a supposedly National service cannot fully access all the information they need, and patients are blamed for things outside their control.

XingMing · 13/12/2022 23:42

OP, going to sleep as I have been up since 5.00 am to get DH to the clinic that prompted this thread. Bookmarking and will read new posts in the morning. Night night, sleep well

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 13/12/2022 23:41

XingMing · 13/12/2022 23:32

By standardised, I mean an initial appointment letter to the address at which you registered with your GP, followed up by an SMS reminder if you have a mobile phone a week ahead if the procedure is routine and scheduled, or a personal call if it's an urgent situation. Or, perhaps, it's not really serious, will resolve and does not require a follow. I know I sound shrill here, but I have a huge anger at people not attending appointments, for their personal health, that the taxpayer is funding. And to be completely frank, I do not think that "mental health" issues should be an easy automatic get out clause.

No one who uses mental health reasons as a "get out clause" feels good about it.
Do you think they just use the date for their procedure to come round, and they shrug and get on with their day?
If you are having a procedure that might end up telling you that you have something really bad, then if you have bad health anxiety already, you might not show up to the appointment.
If you are anxious about the procedure itself, the build up to it can make you so stressed, you feel very sick. You can literally freeze and not be able to move to get there.
There was a thread here recently about a mum struggling to get her DS to the dentist. She literally had to spring the appointment on him to get him to go. If he hid in his bedroom an hour before the appointment and refused to come out, then he would be DNA too.
I have gone DNA (I am better nowadays though.. I try to cancel) for simple things that involve needles. I have a crippling phobia. It takes a huge amount of effort to get to any appointment.

latetothefisting · 13/12/2022 23:41

There's also a huge issue in trying to get through if you can't make your appointment -I was on the phone for over half an hour the other week just trying to get through to cancel a completely routine physio check up with several days notice. I was so tempted to just not up. They don't provide any sort of email contact so the only option is to ring yet nobody answers the phone. Why stuff like this can't be automated in 2022 is ridiculous.

If people can actually get through to cancel you could move people up from the wait list.

Also, if they know there's a very high likelihood people won't show up why don't they overbook surgeries so for every 6 slots book 8 people in (like they overbook flights). They could warn slots 7 and 8 there is a possibility they won't be seen but if so they will go to the top of the list for the next date. Or just have a waiting list of people who are prepared to get there last minute. It would even be cheaper to pay for hotels or whatever overnight for the "reserve" people than pay staff to do nothing!

tectonicplates · 13/12/2022 23:41

The current triage systems benefit the sharp-elbowed middle aged pushy people like me who insist on getting what they need from the system, a lot of older/less pushy/cognitively impaired/hard of hearing people can't do that.

Oh tell me about it! I've had appointments about things that seemed very serious and scary, but the letter was very sparse and left me very worried about what would happen on the day. I needed way more detail than they'd provided, to set my mind at rest, because I was really nervous about the whole thing. I had to be very active in phoning the department and perservering in getting to speak to someone to ask them some questions. I'm very motivated and I'm the sort of person who'd perservere with these things, and I've also had to put a lot of pressure on PALS on a couple of occasions. But I'm sure a lot of people out there just wouldn't have the energy or time to do so, and would end up chickening out and not attending. The way to avoid those DNAs would be to send much better leaflets about the procedure, detailing exactly what would happen on the day and what the timetable would be etc.

EmmaAgain22 · 13/12/2022 23:40

funnelfanjo · 13/12/2022 23:37

The variety of systems doesn’t help. I manage all my elderly mums appointments. Her GP and her hospital appointments are on different nhs systems with different logins. She dropped out of regular gp visits a couple of years ago because it was just too complicated for her to get an appointment, and her has health suffered permanently because of it. I realised what was happening and stepped in, and now it takes a lot of my mental energy to keep on top of it.

She attends a regular eye clinic for macular degeneration, and a couple of times she has been during too unwell on the day to attend, and there is just no way of getting through to them to let them know. I had to leave a voicemail at another hospital in the same network, I doubt the message got through in time. Another time I went to the clinic anyway on my own to let them know and apologise as I understand the DNA problem, and they could not have been less bothered. On the other hand the most recent appointment was last week and I managed to get her through the door only to find they’d cancelled the appointment 90 minutes beforehand while I was travelling to her and phoned the wrong number to let us know. So there are frustrations on both sides.

The clinical care itself is great, when you can get it (60 week waiting list for a neurology referral for a new urgent problem), but the interface between admin and patients can be poor. I suspect it’s so variable across the whole nhs due to differences in systems, processes, the way the doctors want their clinics to run and even the number and/or ability of the admin staff. I do wonder how much improvement in the efficiency of clinics and reduction in waiting lists could be achieved through investment in the administration - even something simple like enough time for someone to be able to ring all the patients on the next days list to speak to them in person would catch many of the issues raised by previous posters on this thread.

Another great post.

all the computerisation has caused havoc for people who were able to manage when they could talk to humans.

antelopevalley · 13/12/2022 23:38

@FlissyPaps It would cost a fortune to provide paid support to everyone with cognitive issues. Cognitive issues are very common with lots of serious physical illnesses or treatment.

EmmaAgain22 · 13/12/2022 23:37

XingMing · 13/12/2022 23:32

By standardised, I mean an initial appointment letter to the address at which you registered with your GP, followed up by an SMS reminder if you have a mobile phone a week ahead if the procedure is routine and scheduled, or a personal call if it's an urgent situation. Or, perhaps, it's not really serious, will resolve and does not require a follow. I know I sound shrill here, but I have a huge anger at people not attending appointments, for their personal health, that the taxpayer is funding. And to be completely frank, I do not think that "mental health" issues should be an easy automatic get out clause.

From my experience, that is the standardised procedure already...but I've lived in the same place for years. I know people who have experienced a lot of problems due to change of address and phone number.

the last text I had from my GP said "we don't seem to have a mobile number for you, can you ring us, we have a query about your repeat Rx". 🤔 The receptionist was so frazzled, when I called, she couldn't compute what was odd about it. I don't even have a landline either! But jokes aside, I am a regular with my GP so for my phone number to fall off their system was odd...but clearly it hadn't fallen off as they texted it.

aren't they logging in to about 14 different systems every day in hospitals?

funnelfanjo · 13/12/2022 23:37

The variety of systems doesn’t help. I manage all my elderly mums appointments. Her GP and her hospital appointments are on different nhs systems with different logins. She dropped out of regular gp visits a couple of years ago because it was just too complicated for her to get an appointment, and her has health suffered permanently because of it. I realised what was happening and stepped in, and now it takes a lot of my mental energy to keep on top of it.

She attends a regular eye clinic for macular degeneration, and a couple of times she has been during too unwell on the day to attend, and there is just no way of getting through to them to let them know. I had to leave a voicemail at another hospital in the same network, I doubt the message got through in time. Another time I went to the clinic anyway on my own to let them know and apologise as I understand the DNA problem, and they could not have been less bothered. On the other hand the most recent appointment was last week and I managed to get her through the door only to find they’d cancelled the appointment 90 minutes beforehand while I was travelling to her and phoned the wrong number to let us know. So there are frustrations on both sides.

The clinical care itself is great, when you can get it (60 week waiting list for a neurology referral for a new urgent problem), but the interface between admin and patients can be poor. I suspect it’s so variable across the whole nhs due to differences in systems, processes, the way the doctors want their clinics to run and even the number and/or ability of the admin staff. I do wonder how much improvement in the efficiency of clinics and reduction in waiting lists could be achieved through investment in the administration - even something simple like enough time for someone to be able to ring all the patients on the next days list to speak to them in person would catch many of the issues raised by previous posters on this thread.

FlissyPaps · 13/12/2022 23:36

antelopevalley · 13/12/2022 23:30

It would simply mean anyone with memory or cognitive problems would not get care.

So all the people without memory or cognitive problems should suffer? People who are absolutely desperate to see a specialist and have to wait years on waiting lists? We should just accept there are hundreds of no shows every week in every Trust, but it’s ok the no-showers have cognitive problems and don’t take any responsibility.

If patients do not have the mental capacity to be able to attend appointments then they should be assigned to a community MH team who can support them.

WibblyWobblyTimeyWimeyStuff · 13/12/2022 23:34

IloveJudgeJudy · 13/12/2022 23:08

I have a different side to tell. A colleague took a day off to take his wife to a difficult to get to hospital for a procedure. Got there, oh no dr is ill next appointment November 23. Why no text/message to save them the journey?

DD and I have both either not received a letter telling us of an appointment or it's arrived after the appointment. Also, trying to cancel is rubbish.

This has happened a few of times to us. Halfway to the 'specialist' or 'consultant' on a day we have both booked off. (Both needed as the one going to the appointment may not be able to drive back,) So we are 15-25 miles into the journey and the receptionist/assistant rings and says the consultant is unable to see us today due to 'unforeseen circumstances.'

Some consultants are a law unto themselves and really do think the world revolves around them. They think NOTHING of cancelling an appointment on the day if it inconveniences them, or something else comes up. Never mind the fact one (or two if the partner is going) people have taken holiday leave or lost money from having time off, to GO to the appointment! They get paid six figures no matter what, and are clueless and ignorant as to what bother they cause the 'nobodies' like us!

When DH went for an appointment in 2019 to a particular consultant, his appointment was 9.15am. We live 40 miles away, so had to leave at 8am because of the rush hour. 10.45am my DH got in. Only the second appointment in and it was an hour and a half late. Turned out later, that the consultant hadn't even come in til 10am. His first appointment got called in at 10.15am (after said consultant had had a coffee and a chat to his peers,) and came out at 10.30am.

DH didn't get called in for another 15 minutes after that! AN hour and a HALF after his appointment time. No apology or anything! DH came out at 11am, and the receptionist was phoning people due in that afternoon after 2.30om CANCELLING their appointments, due to unforeseen circumstances! The unforeseen circumstances were the Consultant was lacklustre, lazy, sloppy, and was nearly an hour late getting in!!! And THEN didn't see anyone for another fifteen minutes!!!

So whilst there ARE people who CBA to turn up, there IS another side to it all. Many of the specialists and consultants and hospital staff are at fault too sometimes.

Florenz · 13/12/2022 23:34

SoShallINever · 13/12/2022 23:26

Absolutely agree with charging for missed appointments, a £40 fee would put most people off failing to attend. Vets, and dentists do this and my hairdresser demands a £20 deposit for every appointment.

It wouldn't work. There'd have to be "exceptions" and the people with exceptions would be the vast majority of the no-showers. And what would you do with the people who just refused to pay? Deny them NHS service? There'd be uproar.

antelopevalley · 13/12/2022 23:34

Friend failed to take her DD to a hospital appointment. She forgot about it. Her husband had died two weeks before.

SoShallINever · 13/12/2022 23:32

JustLyra · 13/12/2022 23:26

If that many people are not showing there is a flaw in the system. That’s massively above normal no show levels.

My DD has “missed” 5 important appointments in the last six months.

2 she was in hospital already and I was assured that they’d let the relevant department know. Dept said they were never told.

1 letter arrived three days after the appointment.

1 letter simply never arrived.

1 she had Covid - we tested her the day before as requested (due to the type of ward she was going to). She tested positive. I rang the number on the letter 146 times that day and the next morning and never once got through. I tried the hospital switchboard, even asked the Secretary of her main specialist for advice. We finally managed to speak to someone the afternoon of when she was due in, sadly after a slot had been wasted.

Every other appointment she’s had in that hospital (which is many) has gone smoothly. Those 5 were all the same department…

Good Lord, we would have referred your child to safeguarding after 2 "was not brought" appointments. Which would have at least flagged up the issue with you not getting the appointments.
That dept wants a shake up for sure.
146 unanswered calls is outrageous.

XingMing · 13/12/2022 23:32

By standardised, I mean an initial appointment letter to the address at which you registered with your GP, followed up by an SMS reminder if you have a mobile phone a week ahead if the procedure is routine and scheduled, or a personal call if it's an urgent situation. Or, perhaps, it's not really serious, will resolve and does not require a follow. I know I sound shrill here, but I have a huge anger at people not attending appointments, for their personal health, that the taxpayer is funding. And to be completely frank, I do not think that "mental health" issues should be an easy automatic get out clause.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 13/12/2022 23:30

SoShallINever · 13/12/2022 23:26

Absolutely agree with charging for missed appointments, a £40 fee would put most people off failing to attend. Vets, and dentists do this and my hairdresser demands a £20 deposit for every appointment.

It would simply mean anyone with memory or cognitive problems would not get care.

DonegalGhirl · 13/12/2022 23:29

I recently had a small procedure carried out by an NHS dermatologist , I didn’t receive an appointment letter but thankfully received a text msg from NHS 2 days before reminding me of my appointment. Had I not signed up to receive txt reminders I’d have been a DNA stat. I still don’t know if it was an NHS admin or Royal Mail error.

Goes to show it’s not always the patients fault if they miss a hospital appointment.

endofthelinefinally · 13/12/2022 23:27

When I started my last hospital job there were 3 consultants in the department and 3 secretaries. When I left there were 5 consultants and one secretary. Management were busy trying to get the consultants to give up their offices and start hot desking. It was getting more and more chaotic. Appointments are now largely outsourced to a separate appointment system that can be very hit and miss.
I am a full time patient now, attending a couple of different hospitals. On the one hand, the system of texts and reminders is pretty good, OTOH, the number of changes and cancellations is difficult to keep up with.
The only appointment I ever missed was one for which I had been told I would get a letter. Letter never came and my GP was informed I DNA. I explained and he just rolled his eyes and said it happened all the time.
That said, there are a lot of people who just take it for granted that they can just make another appointment. They are not paying at the point of care so they don't appreciate the cost.

SoShallINever · 13/12/2022 23:26

Absolutely agree with charging for missed appointments, a £40 fee would put most people off failing to attend. Vets, and dentists do this and my hairdresser demands a £20 deposit for every appointment.

MrsFinkelstein · 13/12/2022 23:26

Doesn't surprise me at all.
Happens all the time in our service.
People phone up that morning to book and DNA their appt that afternoon.
We've had 1 patient DNA 10 appts in the past 4 months, another who has made 12 online appts in the past 3 months and DNAd them all.
We're not allowed to refuse further appts, but it's frustrating when clinics are fully booked and you're trying to fit in an emergency to be seen.

JustLyra · 13/12/2022 23:26

If that many people are not showing there is a flaw in the system. That’s massively above normal no show levels.

My DD has “missed” 5 important appointments in the last six months.

2 she was in hospital already and I was assured that they’d let the relevant department know. Dept said they were never told.

1 letter arrived three days after the appointment.

1 letter simply never arrived.

1 she had Covid - we tested her the day before as requested (due to the type of ward she was going to). She tested positive. I rang the number on the letter 146 times that day and the next morning and never once got through. I tried the hospital switchboard, even asked the Secretary of her main specialist for advice. We finally managed to speak to someone the afternoon of when she was due in, sadly after a slot had been wasted.

Every other appointment she’s had in that hospital (which is many) has gone smoothly. Those 5 were all the same department…

antelopevalley · 13/12/2022 23:23

Buteverythingsfine · 13/12/2022 23:16

If 2/3rds don't show, that's way about average even for the NHS and needs investigating. Where's the communication going wrong? Are these people in hospital for something else, dead, got covid and can't attend? Do they have cognitive, memory problems, dementia? Are they reliant on public transport or hospital transport and can they get there? I agree there's a crappy minority of people who don't show, but I don't believe 2/3rds don't show for a heart procedure as they just can't be arsed, if that's the stats for that surgical team at that hospital, then they need to spend a lot more time reading about how others manage DNAs to minimise them. It is typical in the NHS that people keep going with inefficient systems for years when it would be better stopping for a week, assessing what's going on, and then implementing a better system, there's even been research on this.

As for letting people know, a lot of people with cognitive decline, who are elderly or hard of hearing or struggle mentally do much better if they can pop into GPs surgeries and talk to a real person. Having to negotiate complex phone systems or online passwords becomes a nightmare for them, this happened to one of my relatives and in the end I had to take over all care as they could not advocate for themselves to get proper care, appointments, prescriptions, because they couldn't understand what was being said on the telephone. This tendency to think more email, more texts is better does not apply to much of the population, indeed the end of the population that is the sickest. The current triage systems benefit the sharp-elbowed middle aged pushy people like me who insist on getting what they need from the system, a lot of older/less pushy/cognitively impaired/hard of hearing people can't do that.

This is an excellent post

EmmaAgain22 · 13/12/2022 23:19

Buteverythingsfine · 13/12/2022 23:16

If 2/3rds don't show, that's way about average even for the NHS and needs investigating. Where's the communication going wrong? Are these people in hospital for something else, dead, got covid and can't attend? Do they have cognitive, memory problems, dementia? Are they reliant on public transport or hospital transport and can they get there? I agree there's a crappy minority of people who don't show, but I don't believe 2/3rds don't show for a heart procedure as they just can't be arsed, if that's the stats for that surgical team at that hospital, then they need to spend a lot more time reading about how others manage DNAs to minimise them. It is typical in the NHS that people keep going with inefficient systems for years when it would be better stopping for a week, assessing what's going on, and then implementing a better system, there's even been research on this.

As for letting people know, a lot of people with cognitive decline, who are elderly or hard of hearing or struggle mentally do much better if they can pop into GPs surgeries and talk to a real person. Having to negotiate complex phone systems or online passwords becomes a nightmare for them, this happened to one of my relatives and in the end I had to take over all care as they could not advocate for themselves to get proper care, appointments, prescriptions, because they couldn't understand what was being said on the telephone. This tendency to think more email, more texts is better does not apply to much of the population, indeed the end of the population that is the sickest. The current triage systems benefit the sharp-elbowed middle aged pushy people like me who insist on getting what they need from the system, a lot of older/less pushy/cognitively impaired/hard of hearing people can't do that.

Hear hear!

OP, what do you mean by "standardised for all" please?